Minutes of the 78th meeting of the Committee Constituted for Deciding the Consent under Orange Category, held on 19.09.2008 in the Conference Room of Chairman, DPCC.
The following persons attended the meeting:
1. Sh. J. K Dadoo, Chairman DPCC
2. Sh. Anil Kumar, Member Secretary, DPCC
3. Sh. S.K.Gupta, Head Chemical Engineering Deptt. ,IIT Delhi
4. Sh. B. Kumar, SEE, DPCC
5. Sh. M. Dwarakanth, SSO, Dept. of Env,. GNCTD.
6. EEs of CMC – I, II & III.
7. AEEs of PGRC.
8. AEEs and JEE of CMC – I, II & III.
Following decisions were taken in the said meeting:-
Agenda Item No.1- CBI reference cases.
Decisions taken with respect to this agenda are tabulated and annexed as Annexure – 1.
Agenda Item No.2- Cases of Friends Colony Industrial Area
Decisions taken with respect to this agenda are tabulated and annexed as Annexure – 2.
Agenda Item No.3- Cases of Okhla Industrial Area
Decisions taken with respect to this agenda are tabulated and annexed as Annexure – 3.
Agenda Item No.4- Cases of Naraina Industrial Area, Phase-I
Decisions taken with respect to this agenda are tabulated and annexed as Annexure – 4. In all theses cases, letter be issued without waiting for the minutes.
Table Agenda Item No. 01 - Letter received from Delhi Gymkhana Club Ltd., 2, Safdarjung Road, New Delhi-110011 regarding advertisement in the souvenir.
Copies of advertisements released by DPCC relating to industries may be put up on the file so that a careful selection may be done of advertisements, which can reach the target audience of Delhi Gymkhana Club members.
Table Agenda Item No. 02 - Prominent Hotel, Connaught Place, New Delhi -110001
The unit has filed a letter seeking renewal of consent. Ask the unit to apply for Consent to Establish. SIT may inspect and report by 20.10.2008. Call on 20.10.2008.
Meeting ended with thanks to the Chair.
Annexure : 04
Decisions w.r.t. 12 cases of Naraina Industrial Area, Phase-I in CMC meeting held on 19.09.2008
S.NO. / NAME AND ADDRESS OF THE UNIT / ACTIVITY / CTE Status / REMARKS / Decision on 19.09.20081. / R.K.KHULLAR & CO., C-203, Nariana Industrial Area, Phase-1, New Delhi / Medical and Surgical Equipments / No / Applied for CTO under Green category on 30-4-2005. / Shift to Green Committee.
2. / Jayanti Tools,A-23/2, Naraina Industrial Area / Engineering work with Heat Treatment and Plating / No / CTO was valid up to23-7-2005. / Ask the unit to apply for Consent to Establish. Call on 20.10.2008.
3. / Lord’s Homeopathic Lab.Pvt. Limited, C-106/5, NIA / Homeopathic Medicine and Cosmetic / No / Applied for CTO(R) on 12-7-2005. / Ask the unit to apply for Consent to Establish. Call on 20.10.2008.
4. / Parkash candles, C-151, NIA / Candles / No / Applied for CTO on 21-02-2006 / Ask the unit to apply for Consent to Establish. Call on 20.10.2008.
5. / Sangat Printers Pvt. Limited, C-115, NIA / Offset printing / No / Applied for CTO on 31-5-2006. / Ask the unit to apply for Consent to Establish. Call on 20.10.2008.
6. / Pankaj Plastics, A-31A, Mayapuri Industrial Area / PVC canvas Footwear / No / Applied for CTO on 23-02-2007 / Ask the unit to apply for Consent to Establish. Call on 20.10.2008.
7. / Parkash Brothers,C-193, Phase-1, NIA / PVC Footwear / No / Applied for CTO on 19-03-2007. / Ask the unit to apply for Consent to Establish. Call on 20.10.2008.
8. / Speedway Industries Pvt. Limited, B-96/4, NIA / Speaker grill, Metal Lable, Injection Moulding, Anodizing, Pickling and Powder Coating / No / Applied for CTO on 30-5-2008 / Ask the unit to apply for Consent to Establish. Call on 20.10.2008.
9. / S.B.B. Crafts, C-109, Phase-1, NIA / Candle / No / Applied for CTO on 22-06-2007. / Ask the unit to apply for Consent to Establish. Call on 20.10.2008.
10. / Roxon Trading company, B-96/4, NIA, Phase-1, / Mould and Dice(Light Engg. Without Trade Effluent) / No / Applied for CTO on 27-06-2007. As per CMC decision on 5-3-2008 letter was sent on 24-3-2008 wherein they were requested to Submit CTE along with other documents. Reply awaited.
CTE granted under Green Category / Shift to Green Committee.
11. / Alankar Global Pvt. Ltd, B-102/2, NIA / Readymade garments / No / Applied for CTE on 27-2-2008 and granted under Green category. / Shift to Green Committee.
12. / Alankar International, B-102/3, Phase-1, NIA / Readymade garments / No / Applied for CTE on 27-2-2008 and granted under Green category. / Shift to Green Committee.
S. No. / Name of Industry / Address / Activity / Earlier decisions / ATR FOR 19.9.8 / DECISION ON 19.9.08
1 / M/s New O.K. Electroplating, / K-31/S-1, Anand Parbat Industrial Area Delhi / Zn Plating (with Cr. passivation) / 27.09.2007
New OK electroplating has stopped his electroplating activity another unit M/s Sarla Engg. Works was found operating involved in cutting of steel sheets. Power connection found intact. Ask for compliance report for power disconnection both for this unit and for the substitute unit in whatever it may be.
24.10.2007
Take up on 20.11.07.
20.11.2007
To be taken up on 27.12.2007 since compliance report by BSES has not come yet.
30.01.2008
Seek the compliance report from BSES. / Reminder issued to BSES on 20.03.2008
No compliance report received. / Issue reminder for compliance report. Call on 20.10.2008
2 / M/s Alipur Pipe & Steel Tubing Industries (P) Ltd., / M- 6, Phase I, Badli Industrial Area, Delhi – 42. / Manufacturing of Copper sheets involving pickling. / 27.09.2007
While he has corrected his deficiencies accordng to latest inspection reports. His documents of production may be analysed to confirm his claims. Put up in next month CMC.
24.10.2007
Analysis on file. Case to be decided on 20.11.07.
20.11.2007
The case to be taken on 27.12.2007
30.01.2008
Since this is highly polluting activity and the Bank Guarantee was taken only for six months which period is over now, the Bank Guarantee may be taken afresh for one year beginning January, 2008. / Letter issued.
Responded and BG revalidated upto 10.02.2009. / SIT to inspect and report. Call on 20.10.2008.
3 / M/s Rakhi Export, / S- 76, Phase I, Badli Industrial Area, Delhi – 42. / Fabrication of M.S. engineering goods (involving cutting, shearing and welding) / 27.09.2007
Put up in next CMC with all their applications and documents.
24.10.2007
No action pending.
30.01.2008
Since the Bank Guarantee was taken only for six months which period is over now, the Bank Guarantee may be taken afresh for one year beginning January, 2008. / Letter issued.
Responded and BG revalidated for one year i.e. 03.01.2009. / SIT to inspect and report. Call on 20.10.2008.
4 / M/s Ideal Udyog, / Plot No. 102, Phase II, Badli Industrial Area, Delhi – 42. / Manufacturing of Cu and brass sheets/ circles involving annealing and pickling. / 27.09.2007
Put up in next CMC with the Appellate Authority orders.
24.10.2007
Wait for order.
20.11.2007
In this case Applleate Authority namely Financial Commissioner has completed the hearing on 10.07.07 and reserved the order. Wait for orders
30.01.2008
It does not stand to reason that the polluting unit continues to violate the Air / Water Acts and HWM Rules on account of a long date given by Appellate Authority under Water Act, which harms public interest. Therefore the Committee felt to file immediate application for early hearing.
Since the unit has been ordered closure u/s 5 of the EP Act, 1986 which covers the HWM Rules also and immediate inspection must be done by the concerned CMC and reported by 11th February, 2008 on the status of the unit and whether it is operating in violation of the directions under EP Act. / Matter is subjudice before Hon'ble High Court. / Call on 20.10.2008 with High Court order.
5 / M/s C.V. Mathur & M. K. Unithan/ Swastic Aluminum, / Plot No. 103, Phase II, Badli Industrial Area, Delhi – 42. / Manufacturing of aluminum sheets and circles. / 27.09.2007
Put up in next CMC for want of time.
24.10.2007
Ask him to apply for consent to establish.
20.11.2007
Issue letter for applying for Consent to Establish.
30.01.2008
Before his consent application is considered, let him file a fresh Bank Guarantee valid for one year. / Letter issued.
Unit had responded and BG revalidated for one year i.e. 20.02.2009. / Let the unit file 2nd Bank Guarantee valid for one year. Call on 20.10.2008.
6 / M/s Maruti Industries, / Plot No. 83, Phase II, Badli Industrial Area, Delhi – 42. / Pickling of SS sheets / 27.09.2007
Not applied for consent to establish. Put up in next CMC.
Applied for consent to establish on 14.9.07 with ID No. 13497
24.10.2007
Call such cases next month on 20.11.07.
20.11.2007
Let the CMC study the project report submitted with the Consent to Establish. The case will be taken up on 27.12.2007
30.01.2008
Before his consent application is considered, let him file a fresh Bank Guarantee valid upto 06.02.2010. / Letter issued.
Unit had submitted a reply wherein it is stated that the unit was closed for a period of 7 months hence suffering a great loss so we are not capable to furnish this BG. Moreover a BG of Rs. One Lakh is already with DPCC. If this BG returned, the same can be renewed and will be submitted to DPCC. Unit has no furnace and D.G. Set. / The plea of the unit cannot be accepted. Let him file fresh Bank Guarantee of Rs. One Lakh valid upto 06.02.2010 and confirm by 20.10.2008. Call on 20.10.2008.
7 / M/s Powercon Industries, / Plot No. 45, Phase II, Badli Industrial Area, Delhi – 42. / Annealing, re-rolling and pickling of SS sheets. / 27.09.2007
Video graphy to be seen by Prof. Gupta, after refernce of reasons of videography are given to him. Take up in next CMC.
24.10.2007
Call such cases next month on 20.11.07.
20.11.2007
A fresh CD to be provided to Prof. S K Gupta.
30.01.2008
Based on the videography CD seen by Prof. Gupta, the unit appears to be big but having sloppy operations. Since the unit is highly polluting it can not run on sloppy lines and create adverse public interest. The unit may be asked to file Bank Guarantee of Rupees One Lakh under three acts valid upto 06.02.2010. It must also be directed to have efficient ETP, ECS & HWM systems. Let the unit file an affidavit to this effect along with the Bank Guarantee. / Letter issued.
Unit submitted its reply wherein it is stated following
(i) unit was closed from May, 2006 to Jan. 2007.
(ii) unit was reopened in Jan. 2007 and in compliance of DPCC instruction, we had submitted BG of Rs. One Lakh at that time itself.
(iii) Because of closure, unit had to go through very tough period, not able to collect old business and customers and proudction is also much lower than before. Market conditions are very tough. So, it would be tough to submit any further BG. Earlier filed of BG of Rs. One Lakh has been expired on 29.12.2007. / The plea of the unit cannot be accepted. Let him file fresh Bank Guarantee of Rs. One Lakh valid upto 06.02.2010 and confirm by 20.10.2008. Call on 20.10.2008.
8 / M/s Jwell Electroplating, / K-31-5, Anand Parbat Industrial Area Delhi / Ni Plating (with Cr. dip) with buffing (1 machine) / 27.09.2007
Inspection report indicates that unit has stopped the activity machinery of electroplating and buffing found removed and premises is empty. Therefore no action pending with this orange CMC.
24.10.2007
No action pending.
20.11.2007
No action pending
30.01.2008
No action by this Committee. / No action.
9 / M/s Asrani Steel Industries, / A-4, Wazirpur Industrial Area / Pickling, Annealing, Re-rolling, Circle Cutting / 27.09.2007
Same team to inspect and report for next month CMC.
24.10.2007
Ask him to apply for consent to establish.
20.11.2007
Issue letter for applying for Consent to Establish.
30.01.2008
Since this is the highly polluting activity and the Bank Guarantee was taken only for six months which period is over now, the Bank Guarantee may be taken afresh valid upto 06.02.2010. / Letter issued to unit on 07.02.2008
Unit submitted copy of earlier Bank Guarantee expired on 04.01.2008 along with affidavit informed that they have closed down the pickling, annealing & re-rolling from 31.01.2008 and only engaged in circle cutting. Hence, no fresh Bank Guarantee submitted. / SIT to inspect and report. Call on 20.10.2008.
10 / M/s Manish Industries, / A-83, Wazirpur Industrial Area / Pickling, cold rolling, Circle Cutting / 27.09.2007
Same team to inspect and report for next month CMC.
24.10.2007
Let him correct the deficiencies and ask him to apply for consent to establish.
20.11.2007
Let him correct the deficiencies and ask him to apply for Consent to Establish.
30.01.2008
Since this is the highly polluting activity and the Bank Guarantee was taken only for six months which period is over now, the Bank Guarantee may be taken afresh valid upto 06.02.2010. / Letter issued on 06.02.2008.
Unit submitted a letter from bank regarding extension of Bank Guarantee upto 06.02.2010. / SIT to inspect and report. Call on 20.10.2008.
11 / M/s Jai Paras Steel, / A-16, Wazirpur Indl. Area / Pickling, / 27.09.2007
Same team to inspect and report for next month CMC.
24.10.2007
Ask him to apply for consent to establish.
20.11.2007
Issue letter for applying for Consent to Establish.
30.01.2008
Since this is the highly polluting activity and the Bank Guarantee was taken only for six months which period is over now, the Bank Guarantee may be taken afresh valid upto 06.02.2010. / Letter issued on 06.02.2008.