COMMISSION OF INQUIRY
INTO THE CONDUCT OF
HIS WORSHIP, VERNON A. CHANG ALLOY
A JUSTICE OF THE PEACE
STATEMENT OF AGREED FACTS
I. APPOINTMENT OF COMMISSION OF INQUIRY
1. By Order in Council dated May 28, 2008, the Honourable Justice William Gorewich of the Ontario Court of Justice was appointed pursuant to section 12(1) of the Justices of the Peace Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. J.4, as it read immediately before January 1, 2007, to inquire into the question of whether there has been misconduct by His Worship Vernon A. Chang Alloy, a Justice of the Peace, and to recommend whether the Lieutenant-Governor in Council should remove the Justice of the Peace from office, or to recommend that the Justices of the Peace Review Council implement a disposition to:
(a)warn the Justice of the Peace;
(b)reprimand the Justice of the Peace;
(c) order the Justice of the Peace to apologize to the complainant or to any other person;
(d) order the Justice of the Peace to take specified measures, such as receiving education or treatment as a condition of continuing to sit as a Justice of the Peace;
(e) suspend the Justice of the Peace with pay for any period; or
(f) suspend the Justice of the Peace without pay, but with benefits for a period up to thirty days.
2. The Commission of Inquiry was appointed on the recommendation of the Justices of the Peace Review Council upon the completion of investigations certain complaints, the details of which are provided below.
3. The Order in Council dated May 28, 2008 is under Tab 1.
4. The Report of the Opinion of the Justices of the Peace Review Council respecting its investigations into the complaints described below is under Tab 2.
5. A Notice of Public Hearing was published in the Brampton Guardian, Mississauga News, and Ontario Reports. A copy of the Public Notice is under Tab 3.
II. BACKGROUND CONCERNING JUSTICE OF THE PEACE VERNON A. CHANG ALLOY
6. Vernon A. Chang Alloy was appointed Justice of the Peace on April 20, 1990. At all relevant times, he presided in the Central West Region in Brampton.
IV. ISSUES
7. The following issues, as set forth in the Notice of Public Hearing attached hereto under Tab 3 are raised for determination by this Commission of Inquiry:
(i) Whether, on or around June 30 2006, Justice of the Peace Chang Alloy made unwanted physical contact with another Justice of the Peace by inappropriately touching her in a sexual manner, and later told her that he checks his work schedule to see when she is working and that he had never checked his schedule like that before?
(ii) Whether, on or about July 20 2006, Justice of the Peace Chang Alloy made unwanted physical contact with the other Justice of the Peace by inappropriately touching her in a sexual manner?
8. In the event that either or both of these questions is answered affirmatively, the Commission of Inquiry will be called upon to decide whether such conduct constitutes misconduct and, if so, whether a recommendation should be made that the Lieutenant¬ Governor in Council should remove Justice of the Peace Chang Alloy from office, or whether a recommendation should be made that the Justices of the Peace Review Council implement a decision to impose one of the sanctions listed in paragraph 1.
V. ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
11. Justice of the Peace Chang Alloy acknowledges that, before signing below, he reviewed this Statement of Agreed Facts carefully and obtained the advice of his counsel, Eugene Bhattacharya, about its contents.
DATED at Toronto this 8th day of May 2009
______(Signed)______(Signed)______
Gavin MacKenzieJustice of the Peace Vernon A. Chang Alloy
Commission of Inquiry
Counsel Heenan Blaikie LLP
P.O. Box 185, Suite 2600
South Tower, Royal Bank Plaza
Toronto ON M5J 2J4