Minutes of the 138th meeting of the Committee Constituted for Deciding the Consent under Orange Category, held on 16.04.2010 in the Conference Room of Chairman, DPCC.
The following persons attended the meeting:
Sh. Dharmendra, Chairman, DPCC
Dr. A.K.Ambasht, Member Secretary, DPCC
Prof. S. K. Gupta, IIT-Delhi.
EEs of CMC – I, II, III & IV.
AEEs of CMC – I, II, III & IV.
Sh. M. Dwarakanth, SSO, Dept. of Env,. GNCTD and Sh. B. Kumar, SEE, DPCC could not attend the meeting.
Following decisions were taken in the said meeting:-
Agenda Item No. 1- Consent to Establish cases in non industrial areas w.e.f. 15.01.2008 considered by Scrutinizing Committee on 04.03.20210/05.03.2010/08.03.2010/09.03.2010.
Decisions taken with respect to this agenda are tabulated and annexed as Annexure – 1.
Agenda Item No. 2- Cases of non industrial area in which SIT has conducted inspection considered by Scrutinizing Committeeon 04.03.20210/05.03.2010/08.03.2010/09.03.2010.
Decisions taken with respect to this agenda are tabulated and annexed as Annexure – 2.
Agenda Item No. 3- Review of ATR w.r.t Fresh Consent to Establish cases w.e.f. 29.09.2009 considered in the CMC meeting dated 13.11.2009 and reviewed by Scrutinizing Committee meeting dated 31.03.2010/01.04.2010 : during the Scrutinizing meeting, ATR w.r.t. 36 number of cases in which consent has been granted was apprised. The agenda for the CMC(Orange) consist the cases other than those in which consent has been granted.
Decisions taken with respect to this agenda are tabulated and annexed as Annexure – 3. In 08 number of cases, the Scrutinizing Committee decided to expedite the inspection. These cases will be considered in next CMC.
Agenda Item No. 4- Review of ATR w.r.t. Fresh Consent to Operate / Renewal cases w.e.f. 29.09.2009 considered in the CMC meeting dated 21.12.2009 / 22.12.2009 and reviewed by Scrutinizing Committee meeting dated 31.03.2010/01.04.2010 : during the Scrutinizing meeting, ATR w.r.t. 37 number of cases in which consent has been granted was apprised. The agenda for the CMC(Orange) consist the cases other than those in which consent has been granted.
Decisions taken with respect to this agenda are tabulated and annexed as Annexure – 4. In 09 number of cases, the Scrutinizing Committee decided to expedite the inspection. These cases will be considered in next CMC.
Agenda Item No. 5- Review of ATR w.r.t. Fresh Consent to Establish cases under Orange category w.e.f. 03.11.2009 considered in CMC meeting dated 21.12.2009 / 22.12.2009 and reviewed by Scrutinizing Committee meeting dated 31.03.2010/01.04.2010 : during the Scrutinizing meeting, ATR w.r.t. 46 number of cases in which consent has been granted was apprised. The agenda for the CMC(Orange) consist the cases other than those in which consent has been granted.
.
Decisions taken with respect to this agenda are tabulated and annexed as Annexure – 5. In 12 number of cases, the Scrutinizing Committee decided to expedite the inspection. These cases will be considered in next CMC.
Agenda Item No. 6- Review of ATR w.r.t. Fresh Consent to Operate/ Renewal cases under Orange category w.e.f. 03.11.2009 considered in CMC meeting dated 21.12.2009 / 22.12.2009 and reviewed by Scrutinizing Committee meeting dated 31.03.2010/01.04.2010 : during the Scrutinizing meeting, ATR w.r.t. 44 number of cases in which consent has been granted was apprised. The agenda for the CMC(Orange) consist the cases other than those in which consent has been granted.
.
This agenda could not be taken up by the Committee, due to paucity of time, and it was decided to take up the same in the next meeting.
Agenda Item No. 7- Review of ATR w.r.t. Fresh Consent to Establish cases under Orange category w.e.f. 01.12.2009 considered in CMC meeting dated 25.01.2010 and reviewed by Scrutinizing Committee meeting dated 31.03.2010/01.04.2010 : during the Scrutinizing meeting, ATR w.r.t. 50 number of cases in which consent has been granted was apprised. The agenda for the CMC(Orange) consist the cases other than those in which consent has been granted.
This agenda could not be taken up by the Committee, due to paucity of time, and it was decided to take up the same in the next meeting.
Agenda Item No. 8- Review of ATR w.r.t. Fresh Consent to Operate/ Renewal cases under Orange category w.e.f. 01.12.2009 considered in CMC meting dated 25.01.2010 and reviewed by Scrutinizing Committee meeting dated 31.03.2010/01.04.2010 : during the Scrutinizing meeting, ATR w.r.t. 34 number of cases in which consent has been granted was apprised. The agenda for the CMC(Orange) consist the cases other than those in which consent has been granted.
This agenda could not be taken up by the Committee, due to paucity of time, and it was decided to take up the same in the next meeting.
Agenda Item No. 9- Table Agenda Items considered by Scrutinizing Committee meeting dated 31.03.2010/01.04.2010.
This agenda could not be taken up by the Committee, due to paucity of time, and it was decided to take up the same in the next meeting.
Table Agenda Item No 1:
05 number of cases were considered as a table agenda. The decision w.r.t. these cases are tabulated at Annexure-6.
Meeting ended with thanks to the chair.
Sl. No / ID No / appl_dt / firm_name / firm_address / area_name / Proposed Activity/ Product / Project Details / Earlier CMC Decisions / Environmental Damages (ED ) / Bank Guarantee (BG) / ATR / Remarks / Recommendations of Scrutinizing Committee on 04.03.2010 / 05.03.2010/08.03.2010/09.03.2010 / Decision on 16.04.20101 / 24743 / 15-01-2008 / G & S. SAROVER PARK PLAZA HOSPITALITY PVT. LTD / 14, DSTRICT CENTRE, LAXMI NAGAR / NC-E / BUA : 20000 sq ft.
EC : Not submitted
Water Consumption :
10 KLD
Waste Water generation :
(a) Domestic effluent: 3 KLD
(b) Trade effluent: 3 KLD
Total Project Cost : 70 Lakh
Date of Commissioning: Feb, 2008 / 06.11.2008
MS to write to MD, DSIDC. Call on 23.12.2008
23.12.2008
6th reminder be issued through Chairman, DPCC to MD, DSIIDC with a copy to Chief Secretary. Call on 28.01.2009
28.01.2009
MS to talk to MD, DSIIDC and get the report. Call on 12.03.2009
12.03.2009
MS to talk to MD, DSIIDC to resolve it. Call on 22.04.2009
23.04.2009
Issue final reminder. Call on 03.06.2009
03.06.2009
MS to speak to DSIDC and to sort out. Call on 22.07.2009 / Environmental Damages:Nil
Bank Guarantee : Nil / Source of water:
Ground water: 10 KLD
Letter issued to MD, DSIIDC on 20.01.09 and final reminder issued on 11.05.09 regarding the submission of NMR and ETP report.
No reply received / Call for personal hearing. / Call for personal hearing.
2 / 24937 / 14-02-2008 / VINGO ICE CREAM / PLOT NO-12, KEWAL PARK, AZADPUR / NC-NW / Ice cream making / BUA : 20 sqm
EC : NA
Water Consumption :600l/d
Waste Water generation :
(a) Domestic effluent:400l/d
(b) Trade effluent:500l/d
Total Project Cost :Rs 10,12,261.00
Date of Commissioning:operating since 2002 / Environmental Damages:NA
Bank Guarantee :NA / Trade effluent-500l/day
DG Set (proposed).
CTO refused on 25.10.04
CTO applied on 24.11.04 / File be put up administratively. / Case be considered after implementation of decision of Scrutinizing Committee.
3 / 24938 / 14-02-2008 / DORLIP ICE CREAM / PLOT NO 9, KEWAL PARK, AZADPUR / NC-NW / Ice cream making / BUA : 45 sqm
EC : NA
Water Consumption :600L/D
Waste Water generation :
(a) Domestic effluent:200L/D
(b) Trade effluent:400l/d
Total Project Cost :Not mentioned clearly
Date of Commissioning:operating since 2002 / Environmental Damages:NA
Bank Guarantee :NA / Trade effluent-400l/day
CTO refused on 25.10.04
CTO applied on 24.11.04 / File be put up administratively. / Case be considered after implementation of decision of Scrutinizing Committee.
4 / 24954 / 18-02-2008 / KITCHNER ROAD SERVICE STATION / ROAD NO-41, SAHEED LALA JAGAT NARAYAN MARG, NEAR T.V. TOWER PITAMPURA / NC-NW / Service station for vehicles / BUA : 800sqm
EC : NA
Water Consumption :500l/day
Waste Water generation :
(a) Domestic effluent:200l/day
(b) Trade effluent:300l/day
Total Project Cost :Rs 2.46Lacs
Date of Commissioning:Jan 2008 / Environmental Damages:NA
Bank Guarantee :NA / Applied for CTO on 25.06.09
Trade effluent-300l/day
Adequacy report of ETP is submitted.
One DG Set of 125KVA. / Recommended for grant of consent to establish. Subsequently, inspection be conducted. / Issue consent to establish. Subsequently, inspection be conducted.
5 / 24973 / 19-02-2008 / KAKAJI CORNER / J-39, DOUBLE STOREY, LAJPAT NAGAR, NIRMAL PURI / NC-S / Mfg of food products / Comencement-2008, DG-nil, GW-nil,
Trade effluent-nil
MCD license-Yes
Police license-Yes
CTO not applied / Recommended for grant of consent to establish. / Issue consent to establish.
6 / 25010 / 25-02-2008 / PARSVNATH DEVELOPERS LTD / GAMES VILLAGE, NEAR AKSHARDHAM TEMPLE, / NC-E / Commercial Complex / BUA : 29,642.57 sqm
EC : Not Submitted
Water Consumption : 212.5 KLD
Waste Water generation :
(a) Domestic effluent: 49.5 KLD
(b) Trade effluent: Nil
Total Project Cost : 153.67 Crores
Date of Commissioning: June 2009 / 21.08.2008
The unit came for personal hearing today. It claims that it had submitted an application to the MOEF for withdrawal of the Environmental Clearance application on the ground that DMRC is the parent company building this integrated station-cum-commercial complex. Their proposal for withdrawal has been accepted by the MOEF without assigning any reason. In the personal hearing today, the unit repeatedly emphasized that the DMRC is above all environmental laws and it has such a mandate from the Govt. of India. It does not stand to reason that DMRC, which is the promoter of the metro rail and moves trains for the welfare of the people, can exercise power under EPA to exempt itself from Environmental Clearance for a commercial project being undertaken within its premises, attracting the basic provisions of the EIA notification. The Committee feels that this is not an appropriate way of exempting the unit which is likely to create air, water and noise emissions substantially on a built-up area of nearly 29000 sqm. Since the State EIA Committee has been notified by the MOEF, this matter be placed as a first item on the agenda in the first meeting of State EIA Committee. The SIT inspection report must be placed before the State EIA Committee and the Committee may be requested to visit the site since the unit claims that no construction has been done on the commercial complex, whereas SIT report says that the entire 29000 sqm which includes the commercial complex ,has been constructed.
The unit has filed Consent to Establish application which will be considered only after the matter of Environmental Clearance, will be decided by the State EIA Committee. Call on 17.09.2008.
28.08.2008
This will be agenda item no 1 in the SEIAA
in its first meeting. / Environmental Damages: Nil
Bank Guarantee : Nil / Source of water:
Municipal Authority: 55 KLD
Ground water/ Tankers: 113 KLD
No Environmental Clearance provided by unit. / Issue reminder for enviornmental clearance. / Case be considered after implementation of decision of Scrutinizing Committee.
7 / 25037 / 27-02-2008 / VIKRANT CAFÉ / 13-A, KAMLA NAGAR / NC-N / Restaurant / BUA : 100 s yards
EC : Not Required
Water Consumption :1000 lit/day
Waste Water generation :
(a) Domestic effluent: 300 lit/day
(b) Trade effluent: 400lit/day
Total Project Cost : 3.55 lakh
Date of Commissioning: Operating since 1975 / Environmental Damages: Nil
Bank Guarantee : Nil / Source of water:
Municipal Authority:600lit/day
Ground water: 400lit/day
Applied for CTO on 31.01.2005
Applied for CTE on 27.02.2008 (for the seating capacity of 70 Nos.)
(No police license and MCD license provided)
However unit has informed regarding installation of Oil & Grease Trap. / Recommended for grant of consent to establish with the condition to install ETP to meet the prescribed standards. Ask the unit to submit valid MCD and Delhi Police licences. / Ask the unit to install ETP to meet the prescribed standards and submit valid MCD and Delhi Police licences.
8 / 25171 / 13-03-2008 / HOTEL QUEEN ROAD PVT. LTD / 19, ASHOK ROAD / NC-ND / Hotel Industry / BUA :
EC :
Water Consumption :
Waste Water generation :
(a) Domestic effluent:
(b) Trade effluent:
Total Project Cost :
Date of Commissioning: / 09.04.2009- Ask the unit to file an affidavit on the following points:-
(i) Installation of solar water heating system
(ii) Conversion of oil fired burner into gas burner
(iii) Stack height of the D.G. Set atleast 5 meter above the building height
(iv) Compliance of building code of BEE
(v) Apply for permission for ground water drawl from DJB.
Call on 19.05.2009.
11.05.2009-Ask the unit to explain why it has started operations without submitting DJB permission for ground water extraction. Also ask the unit to explain why it has started operations without full compliance of earlier CMC decisions where it was asked to file an affidavit on five points. Let it be clear to the unit that operating without Consent to Establish and Consent to Operate it will be liable for causing damage to the environment.
03.06.2009-Issue final reminder for full compliance asked vide letter dated 13.05.2009 til then unit should operate. Call on 22.07.2009 / Environmental Damages: