INTERNATIONAL ORGANISATION FOR STANDARDISATION
ORGANISATION INTERNATIONALE DE NORMALISATION
ISO/IEC JTC1/SC29/WG1
CODING OF STILL PICTURES
ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 29/WG 1 N1669
Date: 2000 March 17
Title:Draft Meeting Report, 19th Meeting of ISO/IEC JTC
1/SC 29/WG 1
2000-03-13/17, Tokyo, Japan
Source: Daniel T. Lee, WG1 Convener
1.Open meeting
The 18th Meeting of ISO/IEC JTC1/SC29/WG1 meeting was opened at 9:15am, Monday, December 6, 1999, at the Outrigger Maui Hotel, Maui, Hawaii, USA. The meeting was hosted and organized by the American National Standards Institute (ANSI) and the member organizations of NCITS L3, with financial support from IBM Content Solutions Division and Microsoft Corporation.
1.1Roll call
One Hundred and five delegates attended the meeting representation 17 national bodies. The attendance list is contained below.
N1418 / WG1 Convener / 18th WG1 Hawaii Meeting, Attendant List2.Approval of agenda
The draft agenda was approved.
N1413 / WG1 Convener / 18th WG1 Hawaii Meeting, Draft Meeting Agenda3.Organisation of this meeting
3.1Registration and allocation of contributions
N1417 / WG1 Convener / 18th WG1 Hawaii Meeting, Document Register3.2Finalize meeting time allocation
N1413 / WG1 Convener / 18th WG1 Hawaii Meeting, Draft Meeting Agenda3.3Nomination of Resolutions/Liaisons Drafting Committee
The committee was appointed:
US / Scott Foshee (chair)Japan / Ikuro Ueno
France / Jean Barda
Switzerland / Benoit Duc
Australia / Andrew Dorrell
4.Report on the previous meeting and interim period
4.1Approval of 17th WG1 Vancouver meeting report
The following meeting reports were approved:
N1414 / WG1 Convener / 17th WG1 Vancouver Meeting, Draft Meeting ReportN1443 / Kathleen Rattell, Booz, Allen & Hamilton / Core Experiments AHG Interim Meeting Chair Report /St. Malo, France, September 29 - October 1, 1999
N1460 / File format subgroup/J. Scott Houchin / File format subgroup report, St. Malo, France, 29 Sep - 1 Oct 1999
1
- Liaisons, correspondences, etc.
The following liaisons and correspondences were received and disposed of:
N1483 / Lambert/CNES / CCSDS and Space Requirements
N1490 / Stokes/Microsoft / Feedback on JPEG2000
N1509 / DICOM / DICOM comments on IPR for Part I
N1501 / SC29 / Summary of voting CD 11492
N1502 / USNB / USNB position to WG1
N1507 / Swiss NB / Swiss NB Comment on JPEG 2000 CD Progress
N1518 / JTC1 / Ballot result ISO/IEC 16485 Mixed Raster Content
N1514 / Chinese NB / Chinese NB comment on IPR Statement of JPEG 2000
N1555 / WG1 / WG1 Programme of Work
N1565 / Digital Imaging Group / DIG35 General Metadata Requirements
N1563 / JBIG / Liaison to ITU-T SG8 on draft ITU-T T.89
N1561 / WG1 / Response to comments to Microsoft
- Project JTC 1.29.04.03 (10918-3) JPEG Part 3: Extensions
6.1Report from AHG on FDAM 10918-3
The following result from SC29 on FDAM 1 was review:
7.Project JTC 1.29.04.04 (10918-4) JPEG Part 4: Registration Procedure
for JPEG Profile, APPn Marker, and SPIFF Profile ID Marker
7.1Report from JURA (jura.jpeg.org)
The following report was presented by Mr. Jean Bards (France) on status of JURA.
8.Project JTC 1.29.12 (14495) JPEG - LS : Lossless Compression of Continuous-tone Still Pictures
8.1Report on results from Vancouver meeting
The following meeting was issued:
8.2Report from AHG on CD 14495-2
The JPEG-LS Part 2 CD was published:
8.3Plan for further development
The CD was forwarded to SC29 for processing with ballot closing on 3/10/00.
9.Project JTC 1.29.10 (14492) JBIG2 (Lossy/Lossless Coding of Bi-level Images)
9.1 Final results from Vancouver meeting.
The summary of voting of FCD was review:
N1501 / SC29 / Summary of voting FCD 144929.2Liaison Matters, FDIS discussions, Plan for further development
Results are summarized in the JBIG meeting report:
9.3Patent issues
The following patent statements were received:
N1548 / Xerox / Xerox Patent Statement related to JBIG2
9.4 Resolution of Vancouver meeting
The JBIG resolutions were contained in the JBIG Meeting Report:
N1544 / JBIG / DOCR to FCD 14492
N1567 / WG1 / JBIG2 Press Release
10. Project JTC 1.29.9 (14493) Image Compression Across Multiple Components
There was no activity at this meeting.
11.Project JTC 1.29.14 (15444) JPEG 2000 Image Coding System
11.1 Report on results from Vancouver meeting
The following national bodies comments were reviewed and disposed of.
National BodiesComments
N1424 / AFNOR France / French national body recommandation about JPEG2000N1436 / FNB / FNB comments on JPEG2000 WD3.0 PR A
N1442 / A. Gill/Israel NB / Some observations of original JPEG which are relevant to JPEG 2000
N1447 / Japan NB / JNB comments on Resolution-9 9n WG1N1414
N1449 / French National Body / FNB comments on JPEG-2000 WD3.0 PR B
N1481 / German NB / GNB comment on Motion JPEG2000
N1486 / UBC / Comments on MJP2
N1488 / Boliek/JPEG2000 Editor / DOCR to French NB comments
N1492 / Japan NB / Japan NB Comments to subdivision of JPEG2000
N1493 / Swedish NB / Swedish NB comments to MJP2
N1499 / Belgium NB / BNB comments on MJP2
N1502 / USNB / USNB position to WG1
N1510 / USNB / USNB statement on SSODWT
N1509 / DICOM / DICOM comments on IPR for Part I
N1511 / FNB / French NB comments on WD3.1
N1514 / Chinese NB / Chinese NB comment on IPR Statement of JPEG 2000
N1520 / Canadian NB / Comments on the WD3.1
IPR Statements
The following IPR statements were received and reviewed.
N1445 / LizardTech / LizardTech's Patent on MrSID technology
N1500 / Sony / Sony patent Statement for JPEG2000
N1505 / Mitsubishi / ROI Licenses related to JPEG 2000 Part 1
N1508 / Algo Vision / IP Statement
N1521 / K. Jung/Germany / LuraTech’s Patent on Linebased DWT
N1524 / TeraLogic / TeraLogic Patent Position on JPEG 2000
Liaisons, correspondences, etc
The following liaisons, correspondences were reviewed and displosed of.
N1454 / DICOM / DICOM comments on JPEG 2000 Part 1 Working Draft V3.0, particularly the minimal file format
N1477 / JJ2000/EPFL / JJ2000 Status Report
N1478 / JJ2000/EPFL / JJ2000 Presentation
N1483 / Lambert/CNES / CCSDS and Space Requirements
N1490 / Stokes/Microsoft / Feedback on JPEG2000
N1473 / Li/Microsoft / A Virtual File Media Access Mechanism for JPEG2000 Image Delivery over the Internet
N1513 / Peking University / Verification of Vfile
N1485 / UBC / Performance by an independent implementation of JPEG 2000 VM
N1496 / Lu/Apple / Quicktime decoder for JP2
N1497 / Lu/Apple / Photographic compression using JPEG2000
N1465 / Alan Chien, Kodak / Visual Evaluation of Medical Imagery using JPEG2000
N1559 / Marcellin / Hyperspectral image compression in JPEG 2000
11.2 Reports from Ad Hoc Groups on JPEG 2000
The Ad Hoc Group conducted their work and documents were reviewed.
Editing Group
N1421 / JPEG 2000 Editor / JPEG 2000 (PI WDV3.0 PRA, PII Pre-WD)N1426 / JPEG 2000 Editor / Addendum to WDV3.0 PRA (Annex D)
N1444 / JPEG 2000 Editor / JPEG 2000 (PI WDV3.0 PRB, PII Pre-WD)
N1457 / JPEG 2000 Editor / JPEG 2000 Part I Working Draft Version 3.0 and PII Pre-WD
N1461 / JPEG 2000 Editor / JPEG 2000 Working Draft: Comparison between V3.0 and V3.0PRB
N1482 / JPEG 2000 Editor / JPEG 2000 Part I Working Draft Version 3.1 and PII Pre-WD
N1488 / JPEG2000 Editor / DOCR to French NB comments
N1519 / JPEG2000 Editor / JPEG 2000 CD 1.0 PRA
N1522 / JPEG2000 Editor / CD V1.0 versus WD V3.1
N1523 / JPEG2000 Editor / JPEG 2000 Part I CD V.1.0 (CD 15444-1)
N1549 / JPEG2000 Editor / DOCR for FNB and Canadian NB on WD V.3.1
N1550 / JPEG2000 Editor / CD V.1.0 versus CD V.1.0 PRA
N1554 / JPEG 2000 Editor / JPEG 2000 Part 2 Pre WD
Requirements AHG
N1419 / DICOM / DICOM request for JPEG2000 Part I to require support for >8bit decompressed imageN1434 / Requirements AHG / Requirements and features in JPEG2000 part I
N1483 / Lambert/CNES / CCSDS and Space Requirements
N1507 / Requirements AHG / Requirements and profiles progress report
N1565 / Requirements AHG / JPEG 2000 Requirements and Profiles Ver. 6.1
N1566 / Requirements AHG / Report of JPEG 2000 Requirements & Profiles AHG
VM AHG
N1420 / Tom Flohr, SAIC / VM5.1 SoftwareN1422 / Christopoulos/
Ericsson / JPEG2000 VM 5.2
N1423 / Tom Flohr, SAIC / VM5.2 Software
N1439 / Marcellin/VM AHG / Verification Model 5 Status Report
N1450 / Christopoulos/
Ericsson / JPEG2000 Verification Model 5.3 (technical description)
N1559 / VM AHG / VM AHG Meeting Report
Architecture Subgroup/File Format Subgroup
N1427 / DIG (Scott Houchin) / DIG contribution to the minimal file formatN1428 / DIG (Scott Houchin) / Resolving Conflicts in Metadata Storage
N1429 / Borden, Chebil, Sezan/Sharp and Nokia / Proposal for discussion in the file format group
N1430 / J. Scott Houchin/Eastman Kodak Company / Dividing the codestream: Report on methods B-D
N1437 / Eastman Kodak Company/J. Scott Houchin / Contribution for Component ordering & Definition for Minimal File Format
N1438 / David Singer and Peter Hoddie, US National Body, Apple Computer / Experiment for simple divided codestream support using an index
N1440 / David Singer and Peter Hoddie, Apple Computer / Report on divided codestream support using an index (Method F)
N1442 / A. Gill/Israel NB / Some observations of original JPEG which are relevant to JPEG 2000
N1455 / Andrew Dorrell, CISRA / Codestream layout: comments and proposals
N1460 / File format subgroup/J. Scott Houchin / File format subgroup report, St. Malo, France, 29 Sep - 1 Oct 1999
N1473 / Li/Microsoft / A Virtual File Media Access Mechanism for JPEG2000 Image Delivery over the Internet
N1474 / Houchin/Eastman Kodak / Presentation on JP2 file format
N1490 / Stokes/Microsoft / Feedback on JPEG2000
N1496 / Lu/Apple / Quicktime decoder for JP2
N1512 / Microsoft Research China / Verification of SHIRCT
N1513 / Peking University / Verification of Vfile
N1517 / CISRA / Proposal for multi-layer image support at the file format level
N1552 / File Format Subgroup / File Format Subgroup Report – Maui Meeting
Core Experiments AHG
N1540 / CE AHG / CE AHG Chair ReportN1541 / CE AHG / CE AHG VM 6 Recommendations
N1542 / CE AHG / CE AHG WD Part 2 Recommendations
N1543 / CE AHG / New Core Experiements for 19th WG1 Tokyo Meeting
Coding Efficiency Subgroup
N1443 / Kathleen Rattell, Booz, Allen & Hamilton / Core Experiments AHG Interim Meeting Chair Report /St. Malo, France, September 29 - October 1, 1999N1432 / Canon Research France: P. Onno, G. Mozelle, B. Berthelot and F. Henry / Testing report: Low-pass/high-pass filtering convention and uniform
N1433 / I. Moccagatta and M. Coban, Rockwell / Results of the Core Experiment "Study of the VM Complexity for Cost Efficient Implementation" (revised)
N1456 / Tom Flohr, SAIC / CodEff07, Reduced Complexity TCQ
N1459 / Janet Rountree, SAIC / Core Experiment CodeEff04, Optimum Block Size
N1462 / Lepley/Mitre / Report on CE Interim 1: Effect of Repetitive Encoding and Decoding
N1466 / B. Berthelot, Canon Research Centre France (CRF) / Report on Core Experiment CodEff_Interim2: Memory benefits of SSOWT
N1468 / Peter John, Motorola Australia / Evaluation of point symmetric extension (PSE) for multi-frame applications
N1469 / L. Nachtergaele (IMEC) / Study of the VM5.2 Memory Complexity for Cost Efficient Implementation
N1471 / Donald Pian, STMicroelectronics / Report on The CE on "Study of the VM Complexity for Cost Efficient Implementation"
N1472 / Troy T. Chinen, Fujifilm Software California / Report on Core Experiment CodEff08 "Comparison of TCQ & Visual Coding Methods"
N1475 / Wheeler & Pearlman/RPI / Report on Coding Efficiency Core Experiment 11: EBCOT and SPIHT in Small Tiles
N1476 / Canon Research France / Report of Core Experiment “Improved Tiling Mode”
N1485 / UBC / Performance by an independent implementation of JPEG2000 VM
N1487 / Tim Wilkinson/The Aerospace Corporation / Post-processing Approach to Tile Boundary Removal
N1494 / Onno/CRF / Report on Canvas and Geometric processing
N1495 / Rabbani/Coding Efficiency / Coding Efficiency Subgroup report
N1516 / Los Alamos Lab/USA / Report on Coding Efficiency Core Exp. 09 Tiles and Cells
N1453 / Wenjun Zeng, Sharp Labs. of America / Option of JPEG2000 for Coding Palletized Images-a Proposal
N1564 / Rabbanni / Coding Efficiency SubGroup Meeting Report
Color Subgroup
N1479 / Hao/China / Integer Color Transform for JPEG2000N1491 / Gromish/Ricoh / Color Subgroup Core Experiment Report
Error Resilience Subgroup
N1431 / Michael Gormish, Ricoh Silicon Valley / Report on Core Experiment ER 2: Packed Packet HeadersN1480 / David Taubman, UNSW / Elimination of Byte Stuffing for Error Resilience
N1484 / UBC / Mixed FLC/VLC …..
N1489 / Liang / Error Resilience Group report
Region of Interest Subgroup
N1556 / ROI SubGroup / ROI Subgroup Report Maui MeetingVisual Subgroup
N1452 / Wenjun Zeng, Sharp Labs. of America / Report on CE V1 (Improve Visual Quality by Making Use of Both Self-Contrast-Masking and Neighborhood-Masking)N1458 / Margaret Lepley, MITRE / Report on Core Experiment V3: Visual Testing on SAR
N1497 / Lu/Apple / Photographic compression using JPEG2000
N1470 / EPFL Switzerland / Report on CE V2 (Performance analysis of csf-filtering compared to fixed weighting using recommended parameter set)
N1536 / Visual Subgroup / Visual Subgroup Maui Meeting Report
Testing Subgroup
N1435 / Alan Chien, Eastman Kodak Company / Testing Sub-Group Results for St. MaloN1464 / Alan Chien, Kodak / Testing Sub-Group Report for Maui
N1465 / Alan Chien, Kodak / Visual Evaluation of Medical Imagery using JPEG2000
PR AHG
N1526 / PR AHG / Report of PR AHGN1528 / PR AHG / Maui Meeting Press Release
N1558 / PR AHG / Proposal for self-sustained WG1 Web-site
11.3JPEG 2000: Part 3: Motion JPEG2000 (MJ2) AHG
A new subdivision of JPEG 2000 into Part 3, Motion JPEG 2000 was formed.
The following documents were reviewed and disposed of.
N1451 / French National Body / FNB comments on MotionJPEG2000
N1481 / German NB / GNB comment on Motion JPEG2000
N1486 / UBC / Comments on MJP2
N1492 / Japan NB / Japan NB Comments to subdivision of JPEG2000
N1499 / Belgium NB / BNB comments on MJP2
N1503 / Sony / Distinction between MPEG-4 Studio profile and Motion JPEG 2000
N1535 / Motion JPEG 2000 AHG / Motion JPEG 2000 AHG Meeting Report
N1538 / Motion JPEG 2000 AHG / Motion JPEG 2000 Requirements and Profile, V.0.1
N1562 / Motion JPEG 2000 AHG / Joint WG1-WG11 meeting on MJP2
11.4JPEG 2000 Part 4: Conformance Testing AHG
A new subdivision of JPEG 2000 into Part 4, Conformance Testing was formed.
The following documents were reviewed and disposed of.
11.5JPEG 2000 Part 5: Reference Software AHG
A new subdivision of JPEG 2000 into Part 5, Reference Software was formed.
The following documents were reviewed and disposed of.
N1551 / WG1 / JPEG Software Copyright Statement
11.6Re-nomination of the JPEG 2000 ad hoc group chairs
The following officers were nominated/re-nominated:
Requirements & Profiles / Dr. Touradj Ebrahimi (chair) SwitzerlandCore experiments / Ms. Kathleen Rattell (chair) USA
Public Relations / Mr. Jean Barda (chair) France
Verification Model / Dr. Michael Marcellin (chair) USA
Dr. Charilaos Christopoulos (doc editor) Sweden
Integration Sub-Group / Dr. Scott Foshee (chair) USA
Architecture Sub-Group / Mr. Bernie Brower (chair) USA
Editing Committee / Mr. Marty Boliek (chair and ISO Editor) USA
Dr. Eric Majani (co-editor) France
Dr. Charilaos Christopoulos (co-editor) Sweden
Motion JPEG 2000, Part 3 / Mr. Eric Edwards (chair) USA
Conformance Testing, Part 4 / Mr. Bernie Brower (chair) USA
Reference Software, Part 5 / Dr. Faouzi Kossentini (chair) Canada
- Report on WG1 web-site administration
The following reports were issued by the WG1 Webmaster, Mr. Richard Clark (UK).
A fee of USD50 was collected from all members that attended the meeting for the suppor
of the WG1 Web-site
A steering committee to agree to develop guidelines for financial sponsorship of the JPEG Web sites in line with the recommended proposal in WG1N1558. Mr. Jean Barda (France) as chair of the PR AHG is appointed to chair this committee, which should make proposals in time for the Tokyo meeting of WG1. National bodies were also asked to consider changing the file name extension of JPEG 2000 as stated in the Resolution 29.
N1504 / WG1 Web-Master / WG1 Web-Master’s ReportN1558 / Web-Master and PR AHG / Proposal for self-sustaining WG1 web-site operation
13. Identify hosts and specify dates for future meetings
The host and dates for future WG1 meeting were specified:
2000 / March 13-17 / Tokyo, Japan
2000 / July 3-7 / Arles, France
2000 / December 3-8 / New Orleans, Louisiana, USA
2001 / March 5-9 / Singapore (co-located with WG11, SC29 Plenary)
2001 / July / Stockholm, Sweden
2001 / November / Rochester, New York, USA
2002 / March / TBD
2002 / July / TBD
2002 / November / TBD
14.Any other business
HODs meeting were held on Tuesday (12/07), Thursday (12/09) and Friday (12/10) were held.
WG1 Officers’ Meetings were held on Sunday (12/05) and Wednesday (12/08).
15.Resolutions
The meeting resolutions were adopted in
- Close of meeting
The meeting closed at 4:30pm, 12/10.
1