January 2015 IEEE 802.11-15/0158r0

IEEE P802.11
Wireless LANs

January 2015 TGah Minutes
Date: 2015-01-13
Author(s):
Name / Affiliation / Address / Phone / Email
Kaiying Lv / ZTE / #9 XIFENG ROAD, XI’AN, CHINA /

Abstract

This document contains the meeting minutes for the 802.11 TGah meeting, January 2015.

January 2015 IEEE 802.11 TGah Sessions Overview

Monday / Tuesday / Wednesday / Thursday
AM 1
AM 2 / TGah
PM 1 / TGah
PM 2 / TGah / TGah / TGah / TGah
EVE

January 12, 2015 (Monday) PM2 16:00 – 18:00

  1. Yongho Seok (chair) calls the meeting to order at 4:00pm
  2. Call for secretary
  3. Kaiying Lv (ZTE) volunteers to take minutes
  4. Review of Proposed Agenda
  5. No one speaks up about Potentially Essential Patent Claims.
  6. Approval of meeting minutes
  7. November F2F (11-14/1548r0)
  8. Conference call (11-14/1566r1, 11-14/1592r1, 11-14/1606r0, 11-14/1619r0, 11-14/0024r0, 11-14/0036r0)
  9. TGah LB205 comment resolution status:
  10. Resolved CIDs: 297
  11. Unresolved CIDs: 209
  12. Call for additions to agenda:
  13. LB205 Comment Resolutions for TWT SST CIDs not group TWT (11-15/0083r0)
  14. Matthew Fischer presents the document
  15. There are some editorial comments in nature during the presentation and all changes are made in 11-15/0083r1.
  16. Premotion: Do you accept the comment resolutions for CID 5002, 5003, 5023, 5024, 5037, 5038, 5039, 5040, 5041, 5042, 5043, 5044, 5045, 5046, 5071, 5072, 5073, 5104, 5185, 5186, 5187, 5190, 5191, 5258, 5259, 5260, 5261, 5262, 5263, 5264, 5272, 5302, 5303, 5304, 5305, 5306, 5307, 5317, 5318, 5319, 5447, 5448, 5449, 5453, 5482 (45 CIDs) as shown in 11-15/0083r1?
  17. Unanimously passed
  18. LB205 Comment Resolutions (11-15/ 0118r0)
  19. Matthew Fischer presents the document
  20. There are some discussions and no changes are made
  21. LB205 Comment Resolutions (11-15/ 01603r2)
  22. Liwen presents the comment resolution for CID 5247
  23. There are some editorial changes.
  24. Do you accept the comment resolution for CID 5247 as shown in 11-14/1603r3?
  25. Unanimously passed
  1. Adjourn

January 13, 2015 (Tuesday) PM1 13:30-15:30

  1. Yongho Seok (chair) calls the meeting to order at 13:30pm
  2. Kaiying Lv (ZTE) volunteers to be the secretary for this session
  3. No one speaks up about Potentially Essential Patent Claims.
  4. Add one document on agenda for this session.

a. 11-/15/1604r3

  1. LB205 Comment Resolutions (11-15/ 0060r0)

a. Euguine presents the document

  1. Some editorial changes.

b. Do you accept the comment resolution in 11-14/0060r1?

  1. Unanimously passed
  1. LB205 Comment Resolutions (11-15/ 0119r0)

a. George presents the document

  1. There are some changes about editor instruction during the presentation and all changes are made in 0119r1

b. Do you accept the comment resolution in 11-14/0119r1?

  1. Unanimously passed
  1. LB205 Comment Resolutions (1604r3)

a. Liwen presents the document

  1. The previous version has already been discussed in conference call. Only CID 5202 is remained to discuss here. No discussion.

b. Do you accept the comment resolution in 11-14/1604r1?

  1. Unanimously passed
  1. LB205 Comment Resolutions(11-15/0106r0)

a. Kaiying presents the document

  1. Some editorial changes are made in 0106r1.

b. Do you accept the comment resolution in 11-15/0106r1?

  1. Unanimously passed
  1. LB205 Comment Resolutions(11-15/0107r0)

a. Kaiying presents the document

  1. Some changes are made for CID 5429 in 0107r1.

b. Do you accept the comment resolution in 11-15/0107r1?

  1. Unanimously passed
  1. LB205 Comment Resolutions(11-15/0108r0)

a. Kaiying presents the document

  1. Some editorial changes are made in 0108r1.

b. Do you accept the comment resolution in 11-15/0108r1?

  1. Unanimously passed
  1. LB205 Comment Resolutions(11-15/0067r0)

a. Mingguang presents the document

  1. Some editorial changes are made in 0067r1.

b. Do you accept the comment resolution in 11-15/0067r1?

  1. Unanimously passed
  1. Adjourn

January 14, 2015 (Tuesday) PM2 16:00-18:00pm

  1. Yongho Seok (chair) calls the meeting to order at 16:05pm
  2. Kaiying (ZTE) volunteers to be the secretary for this session
  3. IPR Call: No one speaks up about Potentially Essential Patent Claims.
  4. LB205 Comment Resolutions for 9.3.2.7 (11-15/0100r0)
  5. Liwen presents the document

No discussion.

  1. Premotion: Do you accept the comment resolutions for the CIDs listed in the discussed document (revision R1)?
  2. No objections to pre-motion the resolved CIDs
  1. LB205 Comment Resolutions for Annex B (11-15/0102r0)
  2. Liwen presents the document
  3. Comments by Yongho
  4. CID 5122: modify the reason for rejecting the comment. “VHT Single MPDU is a MPDU format by using A-MPDU. As A-MPDU is optional MAC feature in S1G band, VHT Single MPDU is mandatory feature in S1G band for MPDU length longer than 512 bytes. ”
  5. Premotion: Do you accept the comment resolutions for the CIDs listed in the discussed document (revision R1)?
  6. No objections to pre-motion the resolved CIDs
  7. LB205 Comment Resolutions for CIDs 5006, 5300, 5344 (11-15/0134r0)
  8. Liwen presents the document
  9. No discussion
  10. Premotion: Do you accept the comment resolutions for the CIDs listed in the discussed document (revision R1)?
  11. No objections to pre-motion the resolved CIDs
  12. LB205 Comment Resolutions for 10.1.3.10.2, 10.1.4.3.4b, and 10.1.4.3.4c (11-15/0135r0)
  13. Jae Seung Lee presents the document
  14. Some editorial changes are needed.
  15. LB205 Comment Resolutions for 8.4.2.170t and 8.8.5.3 (11-15/0136r0)
  16. Jae Seung Lee presents the document
  17. Comments on resolutions for CID 5076, 5077. Alfred commented that there are many cases where “It is set to 0 to indicate” are used in 11ac.
  18. Some editorial modifications
  19. LB205 Comment Resolutions for 9.42b (11-15/0137r0)
  20. Jae Seung Lee presents the document
  21. Some editorial modifications
  22. Premotion: Do you accept the comment resolutions for the CIDs listed in the discussed document (revision R1)?
  23. No objections to pre-motion the resolved CIDs
  24. LB205 Comment Resolutions for 10.4.2, 9.42d.2 (11-15/0120r0)
  25. Chaochun Wang presents the document
  26. Some editorial modifications
  27. Premotion: Do you accept the comment resolutions for the CIDs listed in the discussed document (revision R1)?
  28. No objections to pre-motion the resolved CIDs
  29. Adjourn

1