Earth-Kind Shrub Trials in the Upper Midwest

Earth-Kind Shrub Trials in the Upper Midwest

Earth-Kind® Shrub Trials in the Upper Midwest


In the U.S., three of the largest environmental concerns regarding American landscapes are: (1) the depletion of limited water resources through irrigation practices, (2) inappropriate fertilizer and pesticide use and their impacts on environmental quality and ecosystem health and (3) the large amounts of yard waste deposited in landfills. At the individual level, gardeners struggle with (1) growing plants in poor quality soils created by disturbance during urban construction and (2) maintaining plants that are poorly adapted to the pests and growing conditions in their region of the U.S. In particular, we are all experiencing changes in rainfall patterns: heavier, larger rainfalls with longer and more frequent periods of drought in between.

In the early 1990’s, Dr. Steve George at Texas AgriLife Extension Service at Texas A&M University initiated the Earth-Kind® program, which addresses all of these concerns by providing research-based information on environmentally responsible cultural practices and wise plant selection in the ornamental landscape.

As individual gardeners, our impact on the environment may be minimal but collectively we have a large and sometimes negative impact. If we as individuals change our practices, we can collectively reduce or eliminate our negative impact. That is what Earth-Kind is about: changing our practices to create effectiveness and efficiency in the creation and maintenance of beautiful, productive landscapes and gardens. Earth-Kind changes “aesthetics vs. sustainability” to “aesthetics and sustainability”.

Key components of program are:

  1. identifying and teaching landscape practices focused on:

 nutrient management without inorganic fertilizer applications

 improving overall soil health with compost & organic mulch

 water conservation (selecting drought-tolerant plants, use of drip irrigation)

 minimizing pesticide use

  1. identifying plant cultivars & species that perform well over multiple years & over a regional basis when:

 inorganic fertilizer and pesticide use are eliminated

 compost and organic mulch are used as nutrient sources

 supplemental irrigation is minimized

How Earth-Kind Works

  • Pick cultivars to be trialed and multiple evaluation sites across a region
  • Pick a cultivar currently in the trade and known for its good performance to use as a standard to compare trial plants to.
  • Prepare 4 beds or “blocks” by killing existing vegetation.
  • Add 3” of compost and incorporate it in to a 6-8” depth.
  • Plant each cultivar in each of the 4 blocks in a randomized design.
  • Apply 3” of wood chips or other organic mulch to the bed. This 3” is maintained throughout the 4 year study by reapplying mulch as needed.
  • Irrigate plants regularly throughout year 1 as plants establish. After year 1, plants are irrigated only under drought conditions when plants begin to wilt.
  • No pesticides, fertilizer, or winter protection throughout the 4-year trial.
  • In years 2-4, evaluate monthly during the growing season for pest and stress tolerance and ornamental traits
  • Earth-Kind designation is given to plants that perform well across all sites
  • Evaluation results are made available through journal articles (refereed journals, trade magazines, gardening magazines), websites, and presentations

Earth-Kind Hydrangea Trials

24 cultivars at 5 locations:

  1. Minnesota Landscape Arboretum, Chaska, MN
  2. Iowa State University Research Farm, Ames Iowa
  3. Cottonwood Park, Dilworth, MN
  4. North Central Research and Outreach Station, Grand, MN
  5. Boerner Botanic Garden, Hales Corner, WI

Results from Texas:

Resource and labor savings:

  1. 50-70% reduction in water use
  2. 98% reduction of pesticides
  3. 20% reduction of yard wastes from entering landfills
  4. 50% labor savings in Addison, TX through reduced watering, replanting, weeding, and pesticide applications

Designation of 23 Earth-Kind® shrub roses that thrive under low-maintenance

Gussie Field Watterworth Park,TX Myers Park, McKinney, TX

Farmers Branch, TX

2.5 acre Earth-Kind trial ofE-K trials: Kordes roses, herbaceous

100 shrub rose cultivars (400 plants)perennials, annuals, crape myrtle


feb 22 2008 birds eye 5 jpg

myers park garden sign 116 jpgjune 17 2008 076 1 jpgfigure 1 large pngEK perennial garden jpg