Late Payment: Challenging Grossly Unfair Terms and Practices

Discussion Paper Response Form

The Department may, in accordance with the Code of Practice on Access to Government Information, make available, on public request, individual responses.

The closing date for this consultation is 9 March 2015.

Please return completed forms to:

Natalie Sterman

3rd Floor, Piccadilly Gate

Store Street

Manchester

M1 2WD

Or

Name:

Organisation (if applicable):

Address:

Telephone:

email:

Business representative organisation/trade body
Central government
Charity or social enterprise
Individual
Large business (over 250 staff)
Legal representative
Local Government
Medium business (50 to 250 staff)
Micro business (up to 9 staff)
Small business (10 to 49 staff)
Trade union or staff association
Other (please describe)

Giving powers to representative bodies to challenge “grossly unfair” terms and practices

The current situation

1)[If you are an SME, or a representative organisation for SMEs] How often do you think SMEs have suffered from being exposed to grossly unfair payment terms in the last 12 months, as a percentage of their contracts?

Comments:

2)[If you are a large business or a representative organisation for large businesses] How often do you think large businesses have suffered from being exposed to grossly unfair payment terms in the last 12 months, as percentage of their contracts?

Comments:

3)Have you noticed an increase in the use of terms and practices that could be considered grossly unfair in the last 12 months?

Yes NoNot sure

If yes, what tend to be the circumstances?

Comments:

4)[For businesses] Would you classify yourself as a micro, small, medium or large business?

MicroSmallMediumLarge

Comments:

5)[For businesses] Have you ever approached a representative body for help to resolve disputes about terms and practices that oust or vary your right to statutory interest following a late payment?

Yes NoContinue to sub questions

  1. If yes, under what circumstances and, what was the outcome?

Comments:

  1. If no, why?

Comments:

6)[For businesses] Would you every approach a representative body for help to resolve disputes about grossly unfair payment terms and practices above and beyond those related to statutory interest?

Yes NoContinue to sub questions

  1. If yes, under what circumstances?

Comments:

  1. If no, why?

Comments:

7)[For representative bodies] Have you ever been approached to challenge grossly unfair late payment terms and practices, i.e. terms that oust or vary the right to statutory interest, on behalf of a business?

Yes No

If yes, please go to sub questions below. If no, continue to question 8.

  1. How many times have you been called upon to help in this way in the last 12 months?

Comments:

  1. Was the business a SME or a large business?

Comments:

  1. What were the circumstances?

Comments:

  1. What was the outcome?

Comments:

  1. If applicable, which court did this end up in?

Comments:

  1. What was the average cost of the cases taken to court on behalf of an SME or large business in the last 12 months?

Comments:

  1. What is a rough breakdown of the cost for example legal cost staff costs etc?

Comments:

  1. Does this differ between a case representing a SME or representing a large firm?

Comments:

8)[For representative bodies] Have you been made aware of any cases where the contract terms and practices could be deemed grossly unfair but have not been able to do anything about it?

Yes No

If yes, please go to sub questions below.If no, continue to question 9.

  1. How many cases were there in the last 12 months?

Comments:

  1. Were they a large business or a SME?

Comments:

9)Do you think the cost or resources needed will be significantly different if required to act on behalf of a business for grossly unfair payment terms?

Yes NoNot sure

Comments:

Representative claims

10)Should representative bodies be able to take action on behalf of

a) individual businesses

b) groups of individual businesses

c) both

Comments:

11)Do you agree that representative bodies should only be able to take action on behalf of members rather than non-members as well?

Yes No

Comments:

How to define “representative bodies”

12)Do you agree with our proposal to have an indicative list of representative bodies?

Yes No

Comments:

13)As a representative body, would you self-nominate yourself to represent businesses in this way?

Yes No Not sure

Comments:

14)Do you agree with our proposal that the list should be regularly reviewed?

Yes No

Comments:

Representing members without going to Court

15)[For representative bodies] Would you be more likely to use the threat of taking a company to court than actually take them to court?

Yes NoNot sure

If yes, please go to sub questions below, if no, continue to question 16.

  1. How often might you do this? What would your decision be based on?

Comments:

  1. Are you able to give an indication of the financial benefits of doing so for you and the members you are representing?

Comments:

Court hearings

16)Do you have any comments on our proposals regarding court hearings?

Comments:

Winning and Losing a Case

17)[For representative bodies]How often might you take a case to court? What would the decision be based on?

Comments:

18)[For representative bodies]What do you think would be the resource requirement of representing a business in terms of grossly unfair terms? How would this change in terms of representing a large firm or a SME?

Comments:

19)[For representative bodies]How do you think the resource requirement may differ with the different options of where a case can be heard?

Comments:

20)[For representative bodies]Do youhave the necessary resources to handle these cases?

Yes NoNot sure

Comments:

21)[For representative bodies]Would you consider increasing your membership fees to reflect the provision of this service? If so, by how much would the membership fees increase?

Yes NoNot sure

Comments:

Definition of grossly unfair payment contractual terms and practices

22)Do you think we should follow the Irish approach, and add additional indicative criteria to the UK definition of grossly unfair?

Yes NoNot sure

Comments:

23)If we adopt such criteria, should consideration be given to “the strength of the bargaining positions of the supplier and the purchaser”? Are there any other criteria that are particularly important?

Comments:

Do you have any other comments that might aid the consultation process as a whole?

Please use this space for any general comments that you may have, comments on the layout of this consultation would also be welcomed.

Thank you for taking the time to let us have your views.

At BIS we carry out our research on many different topics and consultations. As your views are valuable to us, would it be okay if we were to contact you again from time to time either for research or to send through consultation documents?

Yes No

© Crown copyright 2015

You may re-use this information (not including logos) free of charge in any format or medium, under the terms of the Open Government Licence. To view this licence, visit publication is also available on our website at

URN BIS/15/68RF