July 2013doc.: IEEE 802.11-13/0762r0

IEEE P802.11
Wireless LANs

July 2013 Berlin Ad-hoc Session Minutes
Date: 2013-07-12
Author(s):
Name / Affiliation / Address / Phone / email
Hitoshi Morioka / Allied Telesis R&D Center / 2-14-38 Tenjin, Chuo-ku, Fukuoka 810-0001 JAPAN / +81 92 771 7630 /

TGaiJuly 2013 Berlin Ad-hoc Meeting Minutes

Wednesday AM Session:

  1. Attendees
  2. Marc Emmelmann (Fraunhofer FOKUS)
  3. Lee Armstrong (US DoT)
  4. Ping Fang (Huawei)
  5. Hitoshi Morioka (Allied Telesis R&D Center)
  6. Lei Wang (InterDigital)
  7. Lin Cai (Huawei)
  8. Jarkko Kneckt (Nokia)
  9. Giwon Park (LGE)
  10. Marc called the meeting to order at 9:17.
  11. Agenda 11-13/0724r0
  12. Marc reminder on meeting and patent policy.
  13. Comment Resolutions
  14. Lin Cai
  15. 11-13/733r0 (spread sheet)
  16. 11-13/732r0 (normative text)
  17. Continue discussion about
  18. UP related CID1112, 1114, 1115 and 1147
  19. Vendor Specific related CID1116, 1117 and 1118
  20. All other comments are resolved.
  21. Recessed at 12:18.

Wednesday PM Session:

  1. Attendees
  2. Marc Emmelmann (Fraunhofer FOKUS)
  3. Lee Armstrong (US DoT)
  4. Ping Fang (Huawei)
  5. Hitoshi Morioka (Allied Telesis R&D Center)
  6. Lei Wang (InterDigital)
  7. Lin Cai (Huawei)
  8. Jarkko Kneckt (Nokia)
  9. Giwon Park (LGE)
  10. Resumed at 13:30
  11. Comment Resolutions
  12. Lin Cai on behalf of George Calcev
  13. 11-13/0725r0 (normative text)
  14. Will be revised as r1 and revisit next day.
  15. Hitoshi Morioka
  16. 11-13/714r0 (normative text)
  17. 11-13/735r0 (spread sheet)
  18. Documents are live edited as r1.
  19. Lei Wang
  20. 11-13/699r0 (normative text)
  21. Straw poll or motion in Geneva
  22. FD frame should be transmitted in 6Mbps or higher rate or not.
  23. 11-13/698r0 (normative text)
  24. Revisit next day.
  25. Jarkko Kneckt
  26. 11-13/721r0 (spread sheet)
  27. 11-13/573r2 (normative text)
  28. New revisions will be on the server.
  29. All done.
  30. 11-13/718r0 (normative text)
  31. Revisit next day.
  32. Recessed at 16:50.

Thursday AM Session:

  1. Attendees
  2. Marc Emmelmann (Fraunhofer FOKUS)
  3. Lee Armstrong (US DoT)
  4. Ping Fang (Huawei)
  5. Hitoshi Morioka (Allied Telesis R&D Center)
  6. Lei Wang (InterDigital)
  7. Lin Cai (Huawei)
  8. Jarkko Kneckt (Nokia)
  9. Giwon Park (LGE)
  10. George Cherian (Qualcomm)
  11. Resumed at 9:07.
  12. Discussion about Supported Minimum Rate subfield in FILS Indication IE in Beacon/Probe Response and FD frame.
  13. By defining FILS Minimum Rate which is higher than PHY minimum rate, robustness may be getting worse but the coverage area will be shrink with desired rate.
  14. Lei will revise her proposal.
  15. Giwon Park
  16. 11-13/736r0 (spread sheet)
  17. 11-13/708r0 (normative text)
  18. AP CCC discussion.
  19. Marc Emmelmann on behalf of Dan Harkins
  20. Resolution from Dan is directly e-mailed to Marc and not uploaded on the server.
  21. CID1401
  22. Instruct editor to confirm.
  23. CID1406
  24. Accepted.
  25. CID1340
  26. Reassigned to Ping Fang.
  27. CID1313
  28. Reassigned to George Cherian.
  29. Lei Wang
  30. Re-ordering Table 8-28.
  31. New order.
  32. FILS authentication type
  33. FILS nonce
  34. FILS session
  35. FILS identity
  36. FILS wrapped data
  37. Recessed at 12:30.

Thursday PM Session:

  1. Attendees
  2. Marc Emmelmann (Fraunhofer FOKUS)
  3. Lee Armstrong (US DoT)
  4. Ping Fang (Huawei)
  5. Hitoshi Morioka (Allied Telesis R&D Center)
  6. Lei Wang (InterDigital)
  7. Lin Cai (Huawei)
  8. Jarkko Kneckt (Nokia)
  9. Giwon Park (LGE)
  10. George Cherian (Qualcomm)
  11. Hiroki Nakano (Trans New Technology)
  12. Resumed at 13:20.
  13. Continue Dan’s resolution
  14. CID1382
  15. Reassigned to George Cherian.
  16. CID1391
  17. Reassigned to Rene Struik.
  18. Lei Wang on behalf of Rob Sun
  19. 11-13/742r0 (normative text)
  20. Revisit in Geneva meeting.
  21. Lei Wang
  22. 11-13/698r1
  23. Revised version.
  24. Incorporates “FILS Minimum Rate”.
  25. Giwon Park
  26. 11-13/708r1
  27. Revised version
  28. Live edit and revised as r2.
  29. Lin Cai
  30. 11-13/725r1
  31. Recessed at 17:18.

Friday AM Session:

  1. Attendees
  2. Marc Emmelmann (Fraunhofer FOKUS)
  3. Lee Armstrong (US DoT)
  4. Ping Fang (Huawei)
  5. Hitoshi Morioka (Allied Telesis R&D Center)
  6. Lei Wang (InterDigital)
  7. Lin Cai (Huawei)
  8. Jarkko Kneckt (Nokia)
  9. Giwon Park (LGE)
  10. George Cherian (Qualcomm)
  11. Hiroki Nakano (Trans New Technology)
  12. Giwon Park
  13. 11-13/736r0
  14. Ready for motion
  15. Lei Wang on behalf of Rob Sun
  16. 11-13/742r2
  17. Live edit and revised as r3
  18. George Cherian
  19. 11-13/759r0
  20. About CID1009
  21. Will be revised as r1
  22. 11-13/751r0
  23. CID1413, 1313, 1314 and 1347
  24. Will be revised as r1
  25. Remaining open comments
  26. CID261
  27. Commenter (Jarkko) withdraw
  28. CID1008
  29. Resolved by George Cherian
  30. CID1028
  31. Title has been added
  32. CID1038
  33. Rejected. (Jarkko)
  34. CID1054
  35. Resolved
  36. CID1064
  37. Accepted
  38. CID1066
  39. Rejected (Lei)
  40. CID1067
  41. Rejected (Lei)
  42. CID1079
  43. Keep open
  44. CID1081
  45. Resolved by George Cherian
  46. CID1083
  47. Accepted
  48. CID1100
  49. Resolved
  50. CID1101
  51. Accepted
  52. CID1120
  53. Accepted
  54. CID1142
  55. Assigned to Jarkko
  56. CID1181
  57. Acceped
  58. CID1222
  59. Accepted
  60. CID1223
  61. Resolved
  62. CID1236
  63. Resolved
  64. Straw poll
  65. Do you support approving the comment resolutions as contained in the “2013-07-AdHoc” Tab contained in 11-13/495r12 ?
  66. Result (Y/N/A): 10/0/0
  67. Adjourned at 12:44.

Submissionpage 1Hitoshi Morioka, Allied Telesis R&D