Agenda Item No

AREA COMMITTEESMeeting:

PLANNING APPEAL STATISTICS 2012/2013

Report of The Service Director (Legal & Property)

  1. MATTER FOR CONSIDERATION

Appeal statistics for 2012/2013

  1. INFORMATION

The appeal decisions for the Area Committee and of the Borough as a whole are appended to this report. Information is also provided on success according to the maker of each decision, application for costs and the amount received or paid.

The figures inbrackets/red are for 2011/2012.

The Council performance on appeals against the refusal of planning permission or conditions attached to a grant of planning permission (Section 78 appeals) has slipped for officer determined applications from 2011/2012 by 2%. The appeal statistics for Area Committee applications have improved by 60% and Planning & Highways Committee improved by 50%.

  1. RECOMMENDATION

That the report be noted

BACKGROUND PAPERS

Decision letters issued by the Planning Inspectorate for each of the appeals reported. Anyone wishing to inspect the background papers should contact Joy Morton on 474 3219

Planning Appeals Annual Statistics Report

1st April 2012 – 31st March 2013

Planning & Highways Regulation Committee / 50% dismissed (0) / Means that they have improved by 50%
Area Committees / 100% dismissed (40) / Means that they have improved by 60%
Planning Services / 75% dismissed (77) / Means that they have slipped by 2%
Key to Abbreviations used within the report
AC / Area Committee
PS / Planning Services
PH / Planning & Highways Regulation Committee
DSV / Deferred for site visit

BRAMHALL & CHEADLE HULME SOUTH AREA COMMITTEE

Planning Appeal Decisions 1st April 2012 to 31st March 2013

Section 78 Appeals

Application No. / Address /

Determined by

/ Decision / Recommendation / Date
DC045656 / 5 Roundway, Bramhall /

PH

/ Allowed / Grant / 01.05.12
DC049060 / 83 Hulme Hall Road, Cheadle Hulme / PS / Dismissed / N/A / 20.09.12
DC050247 / 12a Carrwood Avenue, Bramhall / PS / Dismissed / N/A / 08.02.13
Determined by / No. appeals: /

Dismissed

/

% Dismissed

/

SMBC % Dismissed

P&H Committee / 1(1) / 0 (0) / 0(0) / 50(0)
Area Committee / 0(2) / n/a(1) / n/a (50%) / 100(40)
Planning Services / 2(3) / 2(1) / 100 (33%) / 75 (77)
Total / 3(6) / 2(2) / 66 (33%) / 76 (67)
Withdrawn (not counted) / 0(0) / n/a(N/A) / n/a(0%) / 0 (N/A)

Enforcement Appeals

Address

/ Development / Decision / Date

5 Roundway, Bramhall

/ Unauthorised construction of a dwelling / Notice quashed, appeal allowed and planning permission granted / 01.05.12

5 Walmer Drive, Bramhall

/ Construction of a balcony / Notice quashed on legal grounds / 05.11.12

High Hedge Appeal

Application No.

/

Address

/ Decision / Date

Number of planning applications determined

Number of planning applications determined in the area between 1st April 2012 and 31st March 2013 is 327

Costs Applications

Address

/ Application by / Decision / Date /

Reason

/

Amount

83 Hulme Hall Road, Cheadle Hulme /

Appellant

/ Refused / 19/12/12 / Unreasonable behaviour not demonstrated / n/a

CHEADLE AREA COMMITTEE

Planning Appeal Decisions 1st April 2012 to 31st March 2013

Section 78 Appeals

Application No. / Address /

Determined by

/ Decision / Recommendation / Date
DC049470 / 8 Nansen Road, Gatley / PS / Allowed / n/a / 29.08.12
DC048704 / 2 Oakfield Avenue, Cheadle / PS / Dismissed / n/a / 19.06.12
DC049580 / 25 Daylesford Road, Cheadle / PS / Dismissed / n/a / 23.10.12
DC050068 / 1-4 The Elms, Gatley Road, Gatley / PS / Dismissed / n/a / 06.02.13
Determined by / No. appeals: /

Dismissed

/

% Dismissed

/

SMBC % Dismissed

P&H Committee / 0 (0) /

n/a (N/A)

/

n/a (N/A)

/ 50 (0)
Area Committee / 0 (0) / n/a (N/A) / n/a (N/A) / 100 (40)
Planning Services / 4 (8) / 3 (6) / 75 (75) / 75 (77)
Total / 4 (8) / 3 (6) / 75 (75) / 76 (67)
Withdrawn (not counted) / 0 (0) / n/a (N/A) / n/a (N/A) / 0 (N/A)

Enforcement Appeals

Address

/ Development / Decision / Date

8 Nansen Road, Gatley

/ Without planning permission the construction of a two storey rear extension / withdrawn / 04/10/12

Number of planning applications determined

Number of planning applications determined in the area between 1st April 2012 and 31st March 2013 is 276

Costs Applications

Address

/ Application by / Decision / Date /

Reason

/

Amount

HEATONSREDDISH AREA COMMITTEE

Planning Appeal Decisions 1st April 2012 to 31st March 2013

Section 78 Appeals

Application No. / Address / Determined by / Decision / Recommendation / Date
DC048195 / Land at Cranford Golf Centre, Harwood Road / PS / Dismissed / n/a / 12/06/12
DC048215 / 17 Shaw Road, Heaton Moor, / PS / Dismissed / n/a / 25/07/12
DC049878 / The Bakers Basket, 28 Reddish Road / PS / Dismissed / n/a / 28/11/12
DC049371 / Land to the rear of 35-47 David Street / PS / Dismissed / n/a / 30/11/12
DC049240 / 1 Didsbury Road / PS / Allowed / n/a / 14/03/12
DC049325 / 5 Cedarwood Avenue / PS / Dismissed / n/a / 29/08/12
Determined by / No. appeals: /

Dismissed

/

% Dismissed

/

SMBC % Dismissed

P&H Committee / 0 (1) / n/a (0) / n/a (N/A) / 50 (0)
Area Committee / 0 (0) / n/a (N/A) / n/a (N/A) / 100 (40)
Planning Services / 6 (7) / 5 (6) / 83(85) / 75 (77)
Total / 6 (8) / 5 (6) / 83 (75) / 76 (67)
Withdrawn (not counted) / 0 (0) / n/a (N/A) / n/a (N/A) / 0 (N/A)

Enforcement Appeals

Address

/ Development / Decision / Date

Number of planning applications determined

Number of planning applications determined in the area between 1st April 2012 and 31st March 2013 is316.

Costs Applications

Address

/ Application by / Decision / Date / Reason / Amount

MARPLE AREA COMMITTEE

Planning Appeal Decisions 1st April 2011 to 31st March 2012

Section 78 Appeals

Application No. / Address /

Determined by

/ Decision / Recommendation / Date
DC048466 / 83 Cote Green Road /

PS

/ Dismissed / n/a / 24.04.12
DC048614 / The Homestead, Sandhill Lane /

PS

/ Allowed / n/a / 07.06.12
DC048399 / 91 Stockport Road /

PS

/ Dismissed / n/a / 25.07.12
Determined by / No. appeals: /

Dismissed

/

% Dismissed

/

SMBC % Dismissed

P&H Committee / 0 (0) / n/a (N/A) / n/a (N/A) / 50 (0)
Area Committee / 0 (1) / n/a (1) / n/a (100) / 100 (40)
Planning Services / 3 (3) / 2 (2) / 66 (66) / 75 (77)
Total / 3 (4) / 2 (3) / 66 (75) / 76 (67)
Withdrawn (not counted) / 0 (0) / n/a (N/A) / n/a (N/A) / 0 (N/A)

Enforcement Appeals

Address

/ Development / Decision / Date
Lomber Hey Farm, 74 Andrew Lane, High Lane, / Without the benefit of planningpermission the material change in the use of the land from agricultural land within the
Green Belt to a residential use involving the stationing of a mobile home on the land. / Appeal dismissed and notice upheld / 12/09/12

Tree Replacement Notice Appeals

Address / Development / Decision / Date

Number of planning applications determined

Number of planning applications determined in the area between 1st April 2012 and 31st March 2013 is254

Costs Applications

Address

/ Application by / Decision / Date / Reason / Amount
Lomber Hey Farm, 74 Andrew Lane, High Lane, / SMBC / Refused / 12/09/12 / Unreasonable behaviour not demonstrated / n/a

STEPPING HILL AREA COMMITTEE

Planning Appeal Decisions 1st April 2011 to 31st March 2012

Section 78 Appeals

Application No. / Address /

Determined by

/ Decision / Recommendation / Date
DC048426 / 81 Torkington Road / PS / Dismissed / n/a / 23.04.12
DC044674 / 171 Dialstone Lane / AC / Dismissed / Grant / 10.10.12
Determined by / No. appeals: /

Dismissed

/

% Dismissed

/

SMBC % Dismissed

P&H Committee / 0 (0) / n/a (N/A) / n/a (N/A) / 50 (0)
Area Committee / 1 (2) / 1 (1) / 100 (50) / 100 (40)
Planning Services / 1 (2) / 1 (2) / 100 (100) / 75 (77)
Total / 2 (4) / 2 (2) / 100 (50) / 76 (67)
Withdrawn (not counted) / 0 (0) / n/a (N/A) / n/a (N/A) / 0 (N/A)

Enforcement Appeals

Address

/ Development / Decision / Date

Costs Applications

Address

/ Application by / Decision / Date / Reason / Amount

Number of planning applications determined

Number of planning applications determined in the area between 1st April 2012 and 31st March 2013 is206.

CENTRAL AREA COMMITTEE

Planning Appeal Decisions 1st April 2012 to 31st March 2013

Section 78 Appeals

Application No. / Address /

Determined by

/ Decision / Recommendation / Date
DC046648 / National House, 80-82 Wellington Road North, Heaton Norris, / AC / Dismissed / Grant / 16/11/12
DC048810 / Land To The Rear Of 26 To 56 Cunliffe Street, Edgeley / AC / Dismissed / Grant / 13/02/13
Determined by / No. appeals: /

Dismissed

/

% Dismissed

/

SMBC % Dismissed

P&H Committee / 0 (0) / 0 (N/A) / n/a (N/A) / 50 (0)
Area Committee / 2 (0) / 2 (N/A) / 100 (N/A) / 100 (40)
Planning Services / 0 (2) / 0 (2) / n/a (100) / 75 (77)
Total / 2 (2) / 2 (2) / 100 (100) / 76 (67)
Withdrawn (not counted) / 0 (0) / n/a (N/A) / n/a (N/A) / 0 (N/A)

Advertisement Appeals

Application No.

/

Address

/ Determined by / Decision / Recommendation / Date

Enforcement Appeals

Address

/ Development / Decision / Date

Number of planning applications determined

Number of planning applications determined in the area between 1st April 2012 and 31st March 2013 is263.

Costs Applications

Address

/ Application by / Decision / Date /

Reason

/

Amount

WERNETH AREA COMMITTEE

Planning Appeal Decisions 1st April 2012 to 31st March 2013

Section 78 Appeals

Application No. / Address /

Determined by

/ Decision / Recommendation / Date
DC048428 / 34 High Meadows, Romiley /

PS

/ Split / n/a / 01/05/12
DC048289 / Land Between 13 &15 Berrycroft Lane, Bredbury /

PH

/ Dismissed / Grant / 30/11/12
DC048384 / 18 Bunkers Hill, Romiley /

PS

/ Allowed / n/a / 13/12/12
Determined by / No. appeals: /

Dismissed

/

% Dismissed

/

SMBC % Dismissed

P&H Committee / 1 (0) / 1 (N/A) / 100 (N/A) / 50 (0)
Area Committee / 0 (0) / 0 (N/A) / n/a (N/A) / 100 (40)
Planning Services / 2 (2) / 0.5 (2) / 25 (100) / 75 (77)
Total / 3 (2) / 1.5 (2) / 50 (100) / 76 (67)
Withdrawn (not counted) / 0 (0) / n/a (N/A) / n/a (N/A) / 0 (N/A)

Enforcement Appeals

Address

/ Development / Decision / Date

Number of planning applications determined

Number of planning applications determined in the area between 1st April 2012 and 31st March 2013 is165.

Costs Applications

Address

/ Application by / Decision / Date / Reason / Amount

COMBINED TOTALS FOR WHOLE OF STOCKPORT

Section 78 Planning Appeals

Determined by / No. appeals: /

Dismissed

/

% Dismissed

P&H Committee / 2(2) / 1(0) / 50%(0)
Area Committee / 3(5) / 3(2) / 100%(40)
Planning Services / 18(27) / 13 + 1 split decision(21) / 75%(77)
Not Determined / n/a (N/A) / n/a (N/A) / n/a (N/A)
Total / 23(34) / 17 + 1 split decision(23) / 76%(67)
Withdrawn (not counted) / 0 (0) / n/a(N/A) / n/a (N/A)

Enforcement Appeals

No. appeals: /

Dismissed

/

% Dismissed

/

Withdrawn

4(5) / 1(3) / 25%(100) / 0(2)

High Hedge Appeals

Determined by / No. appeals: /

Dismissed

/

% Dismissed

------/ ------(0) /

----- (0)

/

----- (0)

Advertisement Appeals

Determined by / No. appeals: /

Dismissed

/

% Dismissed

Area Committee / 0 (0) /

n/a(N/A)

/

n/a (N/A)

CRE / 0 (2) / n/a (2) / n/a (100)
Total / 0 (2) / n/a(2) / n/a(100)
Withdrawn (not counted) / 0 (0) / n/a(N/A) / n/a(N/A)

Lawful Development Certificate Appeals

Determined by / No. appeals: /

Dismissed

/

% Dismissed

/

Withdrawn

n/a / 0(0) / 0(0) / 0(n/a) / 0 (n/a)

Listed Buildings /Conservation Areas

Determined by / No. appeals: /

Dismissed

/

% Dismissed

/

Withdrawn

n/a / 0(0) / 0(0) / 0(n/a) / 0 (n/a)

Listed Buildings /Conservation Areas Enforcement Appeals

Determined by / No. appeals: /

Dismissed

/

% Dismissed

/

Withdrawn

n/a / 0 (0) / 0(0) / 0(n/a) / 0 (n/a)

Costs Applications

Application by
/

No Applications

/

No. Successful

/

Partial

Appellant / 1(3) / 0(2) / 0(0)
SMBC / 1(1) / 0(1) / 0(0)