Asset Pooling
30 January 2017
PENSIONS COMMITTEE – 30 JANUARY 2017
Report of the Director of Finance and Resources
LOCAL GOVERNMENT PENSION SCHEME (LGPS) ASSET POOLING
Recommendations
- That the Pensions Committee recommend that the Audit and Standards Committee be requested to support the following recommendations to Full Council:
A. To enter into a shareholders agreement to become a joint shareholder of LGPS Central Ltd; a private company limited by shares, held solely by the participating funds, on a ‘one fund, one vote’ basis; incorporated for investment management purposes and regulated under the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000.
B.To approve the Staffordshire Pension Fund’s involvement in the governance and management arrangements for future Pension Fund investment management activity in accordance with the Governance Structure, shown at paragraph 11 and the Terms of Reference summarised in Appendix 3 of this report, more specifically:
(i)To appoint the Chair of the Staffordshire Pensions Committee or their nominatedrepresentative, to attend all Shareholder Forum meetings and to exercise the Council’s voting rights as a shareholder of LGPS Central Ltd.
(ii)To enter into an Inter- Authority Agreement with;
- Cheshire West and Chester Council
- Derbyshire County Council,
- Leicestershire County Council,
- Nottinghamshire County Council,
- Shropshire Council,
- Wolverhampton City Council and
- Worcestershire County Council
to regulate how the above authorities collaborate with each other in relation to the investment activities of LGPS Central Ltd.
(iii) To establish a joint pension fund investment pool, in accordance with the requirements of the Local Government Pension Scheme (Management and Investment of Funds) Regulations 2016.
(iv)To establish a Joint Committee under s102 of the Local Government Act 1972, to provide joint oversight of the pool and to suggest recommendations to the Practitioners Advisory Forum from time to time, in accordance with the terms of the Inter-Authority Agreement.
(v)To appoint the Chairof the Staffordshire Pensions Panel or their nominated representative, to attend all meetings of and act as the Council’s representative on the Joint Committee.
(vi)To agree in principle to any future request for the Council to act as lead authority to provide governance and administrative support to the Joint Committee on behalf of the participating Councils, subject to an appropriate cost sharing agreement in respect of officer time and other expenses.
(vii)To appoint the Director of Finance and Resources (and s151 Officer) or their nominated representative to represent the Council on a Practitioner Advisory Forum, providing joint officer support to the Joint Committee and support and decision making advice to the Shareholder Forum.
C.To authorise the Director of Strategy, Governance and Change and the Director of Finance and Resources to enter into the Shareholders Agreement and the Inter-Authority Agreement to establish a joint asset pool, and investment managementcompany and Joint Committee, as outlined in this report, and to implement the agreed recommendations.
Background
2.The LGPS is one of the largest funded pension schemes in the world, with combined assets of around £200 billion. These are managed by 89 local administering authorities who, historically, have maintained separate arrangements for the management of scheme assets, overseen by their respective Pension Fund Committees.
3.Between them, it is estimated that administering authorities incur total administrative and management costs of around £700 million per year, a significant proportion of which relates to investment management fees paid to external fund managers. Funds often use the same managers, offering the same or similar services but appointed under separate agreements and on different fee terms.
4.Funds also vary significantly in scale; large funds enjoy direct access to a wide range of investment markets and products and can often negotiate more competitive fees, whilst smaller funds have more restricted options due to lower levels of investable resources, and expertise and they often have less negotiating power in the market.
5.Over the past two and half years the government has explored a number of options for improving the efficiency and sustainability of the LGPS and has undertaken extensive consultation on the potential to deliver savings through greater investment management collaboration. A national cost benefit exercise, led by Hymans Robertson concluded that significant savings could be achieved through greater use of collective investment approaches, provided that certain regulatory restrictions around investment were removed.
6.Subsequently, the government announced its intention to introduce a new regulatory framework which would facilitate collective investing and issued guidance and criteria to help administering authorities to develop proposals for pooling aimed at reducing costs and improving efficiency. Initial proposals were required by February 2016, followed by more detailed business case submissions in July 2016, with a target implementation date of 1 April 2018. The government also announced that ‘backstop’ powers would be introduced to allow the Secretary of State to intervene where authorities failed to bring forward sufficiently ambitious proposals in accordance with the guidance and criteria issued.
7.Over the last 12 months, the Staffordshire Pensions Committee, Pensions Panel and Local Pensions Board have been kept informed of the progress being made in meeting the Government’s criteria. Legal workshops, presentations and reports have presented on the proposed governance structure, the business case and associated implications of the submission to Government in July 2016. The Chairs of the Pensions Committee and Pensions Panel together with the Director of Finance and Resources have attended regular joint meetings, and all interested parties were invited to a Stakeholder Day on 24 January 2017.
LGPS Central Ltd
8.Prior to the government’s announcement, the Staffordshire Pension Fund had already established close working links with a number of other funds in, and around, the Midlands area and had begun to explore the scope for wider collaboration. This began with a successful joint procurement exercise in 2015, which resulted in a substantial fee saving on the Funds’ passively managed assets. The collective fee reduction achieved was in excess of 50%; in cash terms around £560,000 per annum for the Staffordshire Fund.
9.These informal links became the starting point for wider discussions in the context of the formal requirement for pooling, resulting in a joint proposal from Cheshire, Derbyshire, Leicestershire, Nottinghamshire, Shropshire, Staffordshire, West Midlands and Worcestershire to create ‘LGPS Central’, with combined assets of £35 billion.
10.Following confirmation from the Minister that this proposal was acceptable, a joint working group of officers, supported by external advisors, developed a detailed business case setting out how LGPS Central will meet the four key assessment criteria laid down by the government :-
Criteria 1 – Asset pools that achieve the benefits of scale (>£25billion)
Criteria 2 – Strong governance and decision making
Criteria 3 – Reduced costs and value for money
Criteria 4 - Improved capacity and capability to invest in infrastructure
11.Detailed reports have been presented to this Pensions Committee in the last year explaining the key elements of the business case and seeking their approval for the proposed governance, oversight and management structure of the pool. The diagram below outlines the final Governance Structure of LGPS Central Ltd. A more detailed summary, prepared by the company’s legal advisors, Eversheds LLP, is attached at Appendix 2.
Governance Structure of LGPS Central Ltd
12.The structure will allow participating funds to exercise control (both individually, and collectively) over the new arrangements, not only as investors in the pooled fund, but also as shareholders of the operator company.
13.A Shareholder Forum, operating under company law, will have formal decision making powers. The Staffordshire Pension Fund, as a shareholder in LGPS Central Ltd, will have equal voting rights alongside the other participating funds, and unanimous decisions will be required on certain reserved matters before the actions can be implemented. These will be specified in the company’s Shareholders Agreement and Articles of Association and will include the appointment and dismissal of the company’s senior executives, the admission of new joiners, approving the company’s strategic plan, approving accounts and audits and decisions on any significant financial transactions, such as major acquisitions and lending or borrowing powers. Other matters, not directly related to the control of the company but to manage its operation are subject to a majority approval (75%) and these include such things as payments of dividends and entering into lease agreements / capital expenditure.
14.A Joint Committee, set up in accordance with provisions of the Local Government Act 1972, will be the forum for considering common investor issues, and for collective monitoring of the performance of the pool against the objectives set out in the LGPS Central business case submission. Whilst the Joint Committee will have no formal decision making powers it is able to suggest recommendations to the Practitioners Advisory Forum and in turn individual Pensions Committees for their consideration and approval, in accordance with their local constitutional arrangements.
15.In order to avoid potential conflicts of interest and to maintain clarity over the governance arrangements, it is recommended that the Council nominates different representatives to the Shareholder Forum and the Joint Committee.
16.To support the Joint Committee in its role, a Practitioners Advisory Forum (PAF) will be created consisting of officers from each of the 8 Funds. The PAF will support Joint Committee meetings and action any recommendations, including reporting back to Fund’s own Pensions Committees on matters requiring their attention. The expertise of the PAF will also be available to provide support, as required, to the Staffordshire Pension Fund’s representative on the Shareholders Forum.
17.The government has also made clear their expectation that pooled entities must be registered with the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) and regulated under the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000, to ensure appropriate safeguards over the management of client monies. As such, the new LGPS Central company will be subject to on-going oversight by the financial regulator and key management positions, including the company directors will need to be ‘approved persons’, able to demonstrate appropriate knowledge, expertise and track record in investment management.They will also carry significant legal, personal liability for their actions and decisions.
18.The Pensions Committee have already considered the relative merits of buying, or renting an established operator to manage the day to day running of the pool, against the benefits of setting up a jointly owned company, with associated shareholder rights. The Committees of all constituent Funds unanimously agreed that the latter option, whilst more expensive, offers significant advantages in terms of great flexibility and control, and this is the basis upon which the business case has been developed.
19.Whilst assets will be managed on a pooled basis, each Fund will be able to exercise their investor rights independently, although clearly, benefits of scale will be most effectively harnessed where parties work together, in a co-ordinated way to align their decision making. An important example being social, environmental and governance policies and policies on the exercise of voting rights, where cross-voting between funds within the same pool would be both costly to administer and counter-productive.
TUPE
20.It is expected that staff who are currently employed by the partner Funds to manage their investments or perform other related activities will transfer under the Transfer of Undertakings (Protection of Employment) regulations (TUPE) to the new company, subject to detailed consideration of current and future roles. As the Staffordshire Pension Fund does not currently have an in-house investment team, no staff transfer implications are anticipated for the Council, although the ability to access internal investment resources through the pool offers potential for additional future savings.
Location
21.It has been agreed that LGPS Central Ltd will initially be based at 2 locations. The headquarters will be in Wolverhampton with a satellite office in Matlock. This means that the teams at the West Midlands and Derbyshire Pension Funds, who manage their investments internally will not have to relocate to begin to manage assets in the pool.
Government Approval
22.The detailed business case has been reviewed by a joint Department of Communities and Local Government (DCLG) and Her Majesty’s Treasury (HMT) Review Panel in early September 2016. Representatives of the Pool met with the Minister for Local Government on 15 November to discuss the submission further and following this Ministerial consent to proceed was received by way of a letter, dated 18 November 2016, from Marcus Jones MP.
Impact on the role of the Staffordshire Pensions Committee and Pensions Panel
23.If approved, the proposals contained in this report will have an impact on the roles of the Staffordshire Pensions Committee and Staffordshire , Pensions Panel. However any changes will be gradual as the transfer of the management of investment activity to the new company progresses. Consequently the existing Terms of Reference need to run concurrently with new terms required to facilitate the changes.Appendix 3 details the existing Terms of Reference together with changes required.Those Terms of Reference which will eventually be deleted are shown in bold text.New Terms of reference required in connection with the proposals contained in this report are shown in red (italic) text.At an appropriate point in the future, when LGPS Central Ltd is fully operational, updated Terms of Reference will be reported to Members.
24.For the most part, the role of the Committee will be unaffected by the implementation of pooling and the creation of LGPS Central. The Committee will continue to be responsible for monitoring the overall management, performance and administration of the Fund, and for setting investment strategy, including the overall allocation of assets, which is the critical factor in determining investment performance.
25.Importantly, they will also continue to be responsible for communicating with individual scheme members, whose benefits are guaranteed in law, and are therefore not affected by the new pooling arrangements or investment performance.
26.Responsibility for appointing investment managers and overseeing their performance, including any decision to dismiss, will however transfer to the company, as will tactical decisions on the implementation of the overall investment strategy and the choice of specific investment vehicles.
27.The role of the Pensions Panel will be more fundamentally impacted by the pooling proposals, as its remit is focussed specifically on the review of investment manager performance and other service provider issues, which will increasingly become the responsibility of the pool operator. With reduced terms of reference it may be that the residual role of the Pensions Panel could be subsumed back in to the main Pensions Committee, thereby streamlining the overall governance arrangements and reducing the demands on Member time. It should be noted however, that the transition of assets into the pool is likely to be phased over a number of years, and that the Pensions Panel will have an important role in the interim in making sure that good governance is maintained over both transferred and non-transferred assets.
Costs and Savings
28.The estimated one-off cost of setting up the jointly owned company is £3m -£4m. This will be shared equally between the participating funds, with Staffordshire’s share being around £500,000. There will also be significant one-off transition costs as existing investment mandates are unwound and funds are transferred into new collective investment vehicles. It is not possible to accurately predict these costs, but the business case includes an estimate of £50m. Transition costs will also be shared between the Funds on an equitable basis; indicative transition costs for Staffordshire are estimated to be about £6m.
29.In addition, as the new company will be a regulated entity, under FCA rules, it will need to hold regulatory capital to guarantee its solvency. The regulatory capital requirement is expected to be in the region of £10m (£1.25m per Fund). The nature of the regulatory capital (i.e. debt or equity) is currently being reviewed in the context of tax implications by PricewaterhouseCoopers, one of the external advisors to the pool.
30.Staffordshire’s share of all costs (including the regulatory capital) will be met from the Pension Fund, and there will therefore be no direct impact on the Council’s revenue or capital budgets.
31.The July 2016 business case estimated net total savings for the pool in the region of £182m, over the period from 2018/19 to 2032/33, with annual savings of around £29m being achieved by the end of this period. Whilst the Staffordshire Pension Fund will eventually make savings of around £1.3m per annum by 2032/33, Pensions Committee Members are aware that in the short term there may be additional cost incurred by the Fund, in relation to the one-off set up and transition costs. However, it is important to re-iterate that the business case was based on a single set of prudent assumptions which factored in no increase in assets under management or investment outperformance. It was therefore considered to be a worst case scenario.
32.Officers from the 8 Funds will continue to work together, with the pool’s, and their own, Financial, Tax and Legal advisors, in establishing LGPS Central over the next 12 -15 months. All concerned are mindful of the fact that it is important to secure savings as early as possible in the process, whilst continuing to keep costs to a minimum. With this in mind, the project is being managed with ongoing review and challenge of assumptions and transition plans.
Legal Considerations
33.The Council as an administering authority, will enter in to the joint agreements forming LGPS Central Ltd, establishing a Joint Committee, representation on the relevant bodies described and modifying the terms of reference of the Staffordshire Pensions Committee, in reliance on the exclusive rights given to local authorities to undertake administrative arrangements of this nature in sections 101,102,112 and 113 of the Local Government Act 1972 and the regulations made under these Acts; together with the general power within section 2 of the Localism Act 2011 and the supporting provisions within section 111 of the Local Government Act 1972.