Jordan Journal of Mathematics
& Statistics
Manuscript Review Form
Information for the Editors: (Information to be withheld from authors)
Manuscript No: ( )Author(S):
Þ Hidden to the Reviewer but open to Editors
Title:
Reviewer’s Information (The following required to our financial department to be able to issue the nominal remuneration ):
1. Full name:
2. Nationality:
3. Birthday Date:
4. Passport No. :
5. Full address:
Reviewer’s Recommendation: (Please select þ one of the following items)
¨ Accepted for publication without any modifications as :
¨ Full Text ¨ Short note
¨ Accepted for publication after minor modifications
¨ Review again after major modifications
¨ Rejected
Comments to the Editors: (Information to be withheld from authors)
Overall Assessment: (To be returned to authors)
Manuscript No: ( )Author(S):
Þ Hidden to the Reviewer but open to Editors
Title:
Please check scores from 1 to 4 on each item indicated below, According to the following scale:
4: Strongly Accept (Excellent quality, cutting edge ideas)3: Accept (Good quality, sound and interesting results)
2: Weakly Accept (I vote acceptance, but will not argue for it)
1: Strongly Reject (Unsuitable for publication in this journal)
Aspects (Please check þ the appropriate score):
Originality: 1. ¨ 2. ¨ 3. ¨ 4. ¨
Methodology: 1. ¨ 2. ¨ 3. ¨ 4. ¨
Novelty of Approach 1. ¨ 2. ¨ 3. ¨ 4. ¨
Adequacy of Documentation 1. ¨ 2. ¨ 3. ¨ 4. ¨
Significance: 1. ¨ 2. ¨ 3. ¨ 4. ¨
Clarity and organization: 1. ¨ 2. ¨ 3. ¨ 4. ¨
Language 1. ¨ 2. ¨ 3. ¨ 4. ¨
Addition to knowledge in the field 1. ¨ 2. ¨ 3. ¨ 4. ¨
Overall Rating: 1. ¨ 2. ¨ 3. ¨ 4. ¨
Detailed Comments and Suggestions to the Author(s):
On the following page(s), please provide specific comments on the research contribution, in addition to suggestions you deem relevant and may help authors to improve the overall quality of the manuscript.
Comments and Suggestions to the authors: (You may add more pages, if necessary)