Having a ‘Bird Brain’ Is Actually a Compliment
ByNathaniel Scharping| June 13, 2016 2:00 pm
202
Calling a person a birdbrain isn’t the insult to intelligence it used to be. Sure, bird brains aresmall, but, according to a new study, their surprising intellect mightarisefrom packing more neuralconnections intoa smaller package.
Some birds excelat tasks believed to require “higher thought,” such as planning for the future, using toolsand recognizing themselves in mirrors. Birds accomplish these challenges at a level that matches or exceeds primates’ problem-solving skills,despite having brains that areseveral times smaller. Researchers in the pastsuggested thatbird brains are wiredin a completely different way than primates’, a theory that was disproved two years ago in a study examining pigeon brains. Instead, birds might be living proof that big things come in small packages.
Doing More With Less
Rather than working with brains that are organized differently, researchers from Vanderbilt University believe birds simply pack more neurons into a smaller space than primates. The researchers analyzed brains from 28 different bird species and found that parrot and songbird brains are especially dense in the forebrain region, which is typically associated with more complex activities.Compared to primate brains of similar size, these birds have twice as many neurons and display more connectivity between them.In other words, researchers suggest that bird brains may provide “much higher ‘cognitive power’ per unit mass than do mammalian brains.”
The collection of avian brains that the scientists analyzed. For each species, the total number of neurons (in millions) in their brains is shown in yellow, the number of neurons (in millions) in their forebrains (pallium) is shown in blue and their brain mass (in grams) is shown in red. The scale bar in the lower right is 10 mm.(Credit: SuzanaHerculano-Houzel/Vanderbilt University)
Smaller Neurons Get More Done
In their investigation, researchers targeted the pallium, a structure in bird brains that’s analogous to the mammalian cerebral cortex. In mammals, larger neurons help connectfar-away brain regions, but at the cost of density. Birds get around this trade-off by keeping most of their neurons close together, and growing a select number of larger neurons to handle long-distance communication.
“In designing brains, nature has two parameters it can play with: the size and number of neurons and the distribution of neurons across different brain centers,” lead author SuzanaHerculano-Houzel said in anewsrelease.“And in birds we find that nature has used both of them.” Theypublished their findingsMondayin the journalProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.
While a direct link between neuron count and cognitive ability has not been established, this study provides a plausible explanation for some birds’ uncanny intelligence. The evolutionary roots of birds’ denser brains, though, remain unclear — it could have been a way for birds to keep their weight down so they could fly better, or simply an example of divergent evolution.