Evaluation of Qualifications

Evaluation of Qualifications

PRIMARY AGRICULTURESTANDARD GENERATING BODY

PRIVATE BAG X 6008

HILTON

3245

CELL: 082 731 3314

TO: ALL AGRICULTURAL SERVICE PROVIDERS

RE: QUESTIONAIRE FOR THE REVIEW OF UNIT STANDARD AND QUALIFICATIONS

As Chairperson of the Standard Generating Body (SGB) for Primary Agriculture that was responsible for the development of the unit standard and qualifications that were registered in November 2004, and who are responsible for the view and re registration process that has to be completed by November 2007, I would like to request that you take time to read the covering letter and complete the attached questionnaire.

The completion of this questionnaire will give you the Service Providers an ideal opportunity to give valuable feedback to the SGB for the review and revision of the unit standard and qualifications in 2007. Any feedback regarding the unit standard and qualifications will be welcomed, both positive and negative.

All Service Providers that have made use of any of the qualifications listed on the questionnaire must please complete a questionnaire for each qualification and return to the e-mail or postal address supplied. An evaluation of individual unit standard that have been used as part of the qualification on the relevant questionnaire would be welcomed. Additional comments regarding the qualifications and any specific unit standard are very welcome and can be attached to the questionnaire.

Any Service Provider that has not used the qualifications but has used unit standard part of skills programmes or short courses are welcomed to complete the relevant questionnaire for unit standard or submit general comments regarding the unit standards. This feedback will be valuable in reviewing unit standard and ensuring they are a product that can be used in by providers.

The feedback that is received will form the basis of the review workshop to be held at the end of March 2007. The review process will be completed by August 2007.

The closing date for the submission of questionnaire is Monday 12 March 2007. All complete questionnaires and comments must be submitted electronically via the website or emailed to or posted to The Chairperson, Private Bag X 6008, HILTON, 3245.

Your time and support for this process is much appreciated by the SGB and the Agricultural Sector.

Yours faithfully

Grant Kobus

Chairperson Standard Generating Body Primary Agriculture

SGB for Primary Agricultural

Evaluation of Qualifications and Unit Standards

Invitation To Submit Input

On The Qualifications And Unit Standards For Primary Agriculture

The sixteen qualifications developed by the Standards Generating Body (SGB) for Primary Agriculture had been registered by SAQA on 13 October 2004. The revision date is 13 October 2007. The SGB has taken a decision to embark on a formal process to obtain comments and input on the qualifications and the unit standards to be in a position to revise the qualifications and unit standards and provide SAQA with informed advice.

The sixteen qualifications listed below and all the core unit standards which form part of these qualifications are up for revision:

Title / NQF level / SAQA ID
National Certificate: Animal Production / 1 / 48970
National Certificate: Mixed Farming Systems / 1 / 48971
National Certificate: Plant Production / 1 / 48972
National Certificate: Farming / 1 / 20287
National Certificate: Animal Production / 2 / 48976
National Certificate: Mixed Farming Systems / 2 / 48977
National Certificate: Plant Production / 2 / 48975
National Certificate: Farming / 2 / 20288
National Certificate: Animal Production / 3 / 49048
National Certificate: Plant Production / 3 / 49052
National Certificate: Animal Production / 4 / 48979
National Certificate: Plant Production / 4 / 49009
National Certificate: Farming / 4 / 20290
National Diploma: Animal Production / 5 / 49011
National Diploma: Plant Production / 5 / 49010
National Certificate: Landcare Facilitation / 5 / 49626

You are invited to submit your comments / input on the qualifications and unit standards by completing the attached appropriate questionnaire electronically, by fax or e-mail for attention:

Ms Beatrice Enslin

Fax: 012 325 1624

Email:

Please complete a separate questionnaire for each qualification and/or unit standard. Answer the questions on the qualification/unit standard by ticking YES/NO. Use the space provided on the last page to submit your comment on each “NO” tick.

This questionnaire could be completed and submitted anonymously. However, should you prefer so, please supply your personal details:

Surname and initials:
Company:
Tel no.
Cell no:
Qualification Title: / SAQA ID:
Section 1: General
ASPECT / YES / NO
1 / Language: Is the language:
1.1 / Understandable at the level of qualification?
1.2 / Clear and understandable?
2 / Title: Is the title:
2.1 / Clear and unique?
3 / Rationale: Does the rationale clearly and accurately state the:
3.1 / Typical learners?
3.2 / Areas of employment?
3.3 / Demand/need for qualification?
3.4 / Added value for learner?
3.5 / Benefit to society and economy?
3.6 / Position of qualification in relation to overall structure of the qualification?
3.7 / Further learning possibilities (career path)?
4 / Level: Is the level of the qualification:
4.1 / In relation to outcomes?
5 / Credits: Is the credit allocation:
5.1 / In relation to the exit level outcomes and unit standard matrix?
6 / Purpose: Does the purpose clearly define the:
6.1 / Expected knowledge and skills of successful learners
7 / Learning assumed to be in place:
7.1 / Is the LAP valid and appropriate?
8 / Exit level outcomes: Do the exit level outcomes:
8.1 / Encompass the specific outcomes?
8.2 / Encompass the cross-field outcomes?
8.3 / Encompass the implied competence of learners?
8.4 / Allow for an integrated approach?
8.5 / Provide for learners who do not complete the qualification?
9 / International comparability:
9.1 / Benchmarks are identified and relevant.
9.2 / Specific qualifications are identified and relevant.
10 / Articulation: Is clearly provided for in the:
10.1 / Matrix?
10.2 / Career path?
Section 2: Generic nature of the qualification
ASPECT / YES / NO
11 / The qualification has been designed to reflect a generic nature so that it can be applied in diverse agricultural contexts and commodities.
11.1 / Did you find it difficult to contextualise the qualification?
11.2 / Did you find it difficult to adapt the qualification to include the specifications of the commodity?
Section 3: Core section – skills areas
ASPECT / YES / NO
12 / The core section of the qualification include unit standards in the following skills areas:
Agri Business; Generic Agricultural Practices; Natural Resource Management.
12.1 / The credit value of skills areas is realistic in relation to each other in terms of weighting.
12.2 / The credit value of the skills area is realistic in relation to the overall credit value of the qualification.
13 / Articulation between Plant Production and Animal Production
13.1 / The composition of the qualifications makes articulation easy.

Page 1 of 7

Unit Standard Title: / SAQA ID:
Section 1: General
ASPECT / YES / NO
1 / Language: Is the language
1.1 / Understandable at the level of the unit?
1.2 / Clear and immediately understandable?
2 / Title:
2.1 / Is the title clear and unique?
3 / Level:
3.1 / Is the level of the unit standard in relation to the specific outcomes?
4 / Credits: Are the credits
4.1 / Appropriate to level?
4.2 / Appropriate to the competencies?
4.3 / Appropriate in relation to the other unit standards?
5 / Purpose: Does the purpose clearly define the
5.1 / Expected knowledge and skills of successful learners?
6 / Learning assumed to be in place: Is
6.1 / Valid?
6.2 / Appropriate?
7 / Specific outcomes: Are the SO’s
7.1 / Appropriate in relation to purpose?
7.2 / Measurable and verifiable?
7.3 / Stating the implied competence clearly?
8 / Assessment criteria: Are the AC’s
8.1 / Specific?
8.2 / Measurable?
8.3 / Potential to develop assessment procedures?
9 / Range statement: Do the range specify the
9.1 / Scope?
9.2 / Context?
9.3 / Relationship to outcomes and assessment criteria?
9.4 / Limits for inclusion/exclusion?
10 / Articulation: Is articulation possible
10.1 / To next level?
11 / Notes: Are the
11.1 / Critical cross-field identified?
11.2 / Embedded knowledge statement in relation to abilities and competence of learner?
11.3 / Relationship of cross-field outcomes to purpose, outcomes and embedded knowledge of unit clear?
Section 2: Generic nature of the unit standard
ASPECT / YES / NO
12 / The unit standard has been designed to reflect a generic nature so that it can be applied in all agricultural contexts and commodities.
12.1 / Did you find it difficult to contextualise the unit standard?
12.2 / Did you find it difficult to adapt the unit standard to include the specifications of the commodity?
Section 3: Core section – skills areas
ASPECT / YES / NO
13 / Overlap: Do the SO’s and AC’s of this unit standard
13.1 / Overlap with other unit standards (at the same level)? (Please identify)
13.2 / If yes, is the overlap justified?
13.3 / Should the overlapping unit standards be merged?

Page 1 of 7

Qualification Title: / SAQA ID:
Aspect Nr /

Problem

/ Suggestion
Unit Standard Title: / SAQA ID:
Aspect Nr /

Problem

/ Suggestion

Page 1 of 7