EVALUATION REPORT FOR THE PROCUREMENT OF EQUIPMENTFOR SINDHPOLICE DURING FINANCIAL YEAR 2011-12.

Evaluation report of the participating firms against the Tender Notice dated 20.10.2011 & 21.10.2011 (INF-KRY No.3778/11 & SPPRA ID No.5638) for the Procurement of Equipmentsfor Sindh Police.

2/-The following firms participated in response to this office Tender Notice The results of Evaluation of participated firms according to Evaluation Criteria are as under:-

  1. Vehicle Identification Number Investigation System Device

S.# / NAME OF FIRM / Make & Model / remarks
M/s Megaplus Pakistan / Complex Model 7505 Made by Regula Made in Belarus / ACCEPTED (meet to Departmental Specification)
M/s Global Science Co. / Complex Model 7505 Made by Regula Made in Belarus / ACCEPTED (meet to Departmental Specification)
M/s Noor Forensics / Complex Model 7505 Made by Regula Made in Belarus / ACCEPTED (meet to Departmental Specification)
  1. Light Sources for Crime Scene Unit

S.# / NAME OF FIRM / Make & Model / remarks
M/s Megaplus Pakistan / SPEX Forencis Model HandScope Xenon FLS HSX-5000 / ACCEPTED (meet to Departmental Specification)
M/s Surge Enterprises / LabinoTrac Finder / ACCEPTED (meet to Departmental Specification)
M/s Noor Forensics / FAL3000 Made by Sirchie Made in North Carolina / ACCEPTED (meet to Departmental Specification)
  1. Comparator for Handwriting Examination

S.# / NAME OF FIRM / Make & Model / remarks
M/s Megaplus Pakistan / Foster Freeman Model VSC400 / ACCEPTED (meet to Departmental Specification)
M/s Noor Forensics / Model 4305 M/MH Made by Regula Made in Belarus / ACCEPTED (meet to Departmental Specification)
M/s Forensic People Pakistan / Forensic XP-4010D / ACCEPTED (meet to Departmental Specification)
  1. Document Examination Accessories

S.# / NAME OF FIRM / Make & Model / remarks
M/s Global Science Co. / Stage Surface Projectina UCM Made in Switzerland / ACCEPTED (meet to Departmental Specification)
M/s Noor Forensics / Stage Surface Projectina UCM Made in Switzerland / ACCEPTED (meet to Departmental Specification)
  1. Explosive Detector

S.# / NAME OF FIRM / Make & Model / remarks
M/s Shirazi Trading / Model Hardened Mobile Trace Made by Morpho Detection Made in USA / ACCEPTED (meet to Departmental Specification)
M/s Defence Solutions System / Model MO-2M Made by Sibel Made in Russia / REJECTED (Not meet to Departmental Specification)
M/s Surge Enterprises / Model HEDD1 Manual 09v1 Made by Unival Group Made in Germany / REJECTED (Not meet to Departmental Specification)
  1. Portable X-Ray Machine

S.# / NAME OF FIRM / Make & Model / remarks
M/s Asian Consultant & Computer Services / Foxraylle with XR300 Made by SDS Group Made in UK / ACCEPTED (meet to Departmental Specification)
M/s Defence Solutions System / Model SXR-150 Made by Sibel Made in Russia / REJECTED (Not meet to Departmental Specification)
M/s Surge Enterprises / Model CR 35 SEC Made by DURR NDT Made in Germany / REJECTED (Not meet to Departmental Specification)
M/s Shirazi Trading / Model 2520 with Generator XR-150 Made by Scanna MSC Made in UK / REJECTED (Not meet to Departmental Specification)
  1. BD Technician Response Kit

S.# / NAME OF FIRM / Make & Model / remarks
M/s Asian Consultant & Computer Services / HK-0125 IED Made in Hongkong / ACCEPTED (meet to Departmental Specification)
  1. Emergency Light

S.# / NAME OF FIRM / Make & Model / remarks
M/s Asian Consultant & Computer Services / ACCEL Made in China / ACCEPTED (meet to Departmental Specification)
  1. Bomb Bin

S.# / NAME OF FIRM / Make & Model / remarks
M/s Asian Consultant & Computer Services / Suspect Postal Package Container Made by SDS Group Made in UK / ACCEPTED (meet to Departmental Specification)
M/s SIPKA Manufacturing (Pvt) Ltd. / Scanna Blast Container Made by Scanna Made in UK / REJECTED (Not meet to Departmental Specification)
M/s Surge Enterprises / Model Pluton -1 Made by ArliSpetstechnika Made in Russia / REJECTED (Not meet to Departmental Specification)
M/s Shirazi Trading / Suspect Package Containers Made by Scanna Made in UK / REJECTED (Not meet to Departmental Specification)
  1. Pocket Jammer (GSM)

S.# / NAME OF FIRM / Make & Model / remarks
M/s Asian Consultant & Computer Services / ACC-909SC Made in Taiwan / ACCEPTED (meet to Departmental Specification)
M/s SIPKA Manufacturing (Pvt) Ltd. / Model TG-120PRO Made by Tangreat Technology Co. Made in China / REJECTED (Not meet to Departmental Specification)
M/s Surge Enterprises / Model CPB-2000P-Plus Made by Winpower Made in Twain / REJECTED (Not meet to Departmental Specification)
M/s Shirazi Trading / CTS 1000 HA/B / REJECTED (Not meet to Departmental Specification)
M/s International Office Suppliers / TG-102A / REJECTED (Not meet to Departmental Specification)
M/s Azms & Co / GSM Jammer / REJECTED (Not meet to Departmental Specification)
  1. Conference Room Jammer (GSM)

S.# / NAME OF FIRM / Make & Model / remarks
M/s SIPKA Manufacturing (Pvt) Ltd. / Model TG5CA Made by Tangreat Technology Co. Made in China / REJECTED (Not meet to Departmental Specification)
M/s Asian Consultant & Computer Services / ACC-606 RJ Made in Taiwan / REJECTED (Not meet to Departmental Specification)
M/s Surge Enterprises / Model CPB-2000ATS Made by Winpower Made in Taiwan / REJECTED (Not meet to Departmental Specification)
M/s Shirazi Trading / CTS-VIP60 / REJECTED (Not meet to Departmental Specification)
M/s International Office Suppliers / TG-101A / ACCEPTED (meet to Departmental Specification)
  1. Portable Jammer (GSM) UHF/VHF

S.# / NAME OF FIRM / Make & Model / remarks
M/s International Office Suppliers / TG - 101A / ACCEPTED (meet to Departmental Specification)
M/s Shirazi Trading / CTS.UVX / REJECTED (Not meet to Departmental Specification)
M/s Surge Enterprises / CPB-2000 KP40 / REJECTED (Not meet to Departmental Specification)
M/s SIPKA Manufacturing (Pvt) Ltd. / Tangreat Technology Co. / China / REJECTED (Not meet to Departmental Specification)
  1. Generator 5-KV

S.# / NAME OF FIRM / Make & Model / remarks
M/s Shirazi Trading / Aksa AAP5500E / Turkey / REJECTED (Not meet to Departmental Specification)
M/s Azms & Co / Akulla AK /China / REJECTED (Not meet to Departmental Specification)
  1. Prodder Small & Large

S.# / NAME OF FIRM / Make & Model / remarks
M/s Asian Consultant & Computer Services / Prodder for Detecting Land Mines Explosive Devices & Trip Wires/Pakistan / ACCEPTED (meet to Departmental Specification)
  1. Luminal Cell

S.# / NAME OF FIRM / Make & Model / remarks
M/s Asian Consultant & Computer Services / Sensor E3500 P.No.D350538 Scintrex Trace / ACCEPTED (meet to Departmental Specification)
M/s Defence Solutions System / Scintrex Trace Corp P. NoD350548/ Canada / REJECTED (Not meet to Departmental Specification)
  1. Digital Camera (14.1 Mega Pixel)

S.# / NAME OF FIRM / Make & Model / remarks
M/s Gemco / Samsung ST-65 / ACCEPTED (meet to Departmental Specification)
M/s Azms & Co. / Summey / ACCEPTED (meet to Departmental Specification)
  1. Walk Through Gate

S.# / NAME OF FIRM / Make & Model / remarks
M/s Sage-Tech International / HI-PE Multi Zone / PNZ/ Ceia Italy / ACCEPTED (meet to Departmental Specification)
M/s Defence Solutions System / ThruScan S9 / Turkey / REJECTED (Not meet to Departmental Specification)
M/s SIPKA Manufacturing (Pvt) Ltd. / ThruScan S9 / Turkey / REJECTED (Not meet to Departmental Specification)
M/s Shirazi Trading / PD 6500i /USA / REJECTED (Not meet to Departmental Specification)
M/s Asian Consultant & Computer Services / Trough Scan S9 /Turkey / REJECTED (Not meet to Departmental Specification)
M/s Space Communication / M-Scope / USA / REJECTED (Not meet to Departmental Specification)

3/-Out of above firms, the following firms were declared qualified by the Evaluation Committee for the opening of Financial Bids. Financial proposals of qualified firms were opened on 27-02-2012. Its result is as follows:-

  1. Vehicle Identification Number Investigation System Device

S.# / NAME OF FIRM / Make & Model / Rate/Quoted
M/s Noor Forensics / Complex Model 7505 Made by Regula Made in Belarus / Rs. 4,698,000
M/s Megaplus Pakistan / Complex Model 7505 Made by Regula Made in Belarus / Rs. 4,988,000
M/s Global Science Co. / Complex Model 7505 Made by Regula Made in Belarus / Rs. 5,394,000
  1. Light Sources for Crime Scene Unit

S.# / NAME OF FIRM / Make & Model / Rate/Quoted
M/s Noor Forensics / FAL3000 Made by Sirchie Made in North Carolina / Rs. 1,189,000
M/s Surge Enterprises / LabinoTrac Finder / Rs. 2,290,000
M/s Megaplus Pakistan / SPEX Forencis Model HandScope Xenon FLS HSX-5000 / Rs. 3,480,000
  1. Comparator for Handwriting Examination

S.# / NAME OF FIRM / Make & Model / Rate/Quoted
M/s Noor Forensics / Model 4305 M/MH Made by Regula Made in Belarus / Rs. 4,553,000
M/s Forensic People Pakistan / Forensic XP-4010D / Rs. 5,500,000
M/s Megaplus Pakistan / Foster Freeman Model VSC400 / Rs. 10,208,000
  1. Document Examination Accessories

S.# / NAME OF FIRM / Make & Model / Rate/Quoted
M/s Noor Forensics / Stage Surface Projectina UCM Made in Switzerland / Rs. 3,886,000
M/s Global Science Co. / Stage Surface Projectina UCM Made in Switzerland / Rs. 4,700,000
  1. Explosive Detector

S.# / NAME OF FIRM / Make & Model / Rate/Quoted
M/s Shirazi Trading / Model Hardened Mobile Trace Made by Morpho Detection Made in USA / Rs. 5,435,000
  1. Portable X-Ray Machine

S.# / NAME OF FIRM / Make & Model / Rate/Quoted
M/s Asian Consultant & Computer Services / Foxraylle with XR300 Made by SDS Group Made in UK / Rs. 5,894,000
  1. BD Technician Response Kit

S.# / NAME OF FIRM / Make & Model / Rate/Quoted
M/s Asian Consultant & Computer Services / HK-0125 IED Made in Hongkong / Rs. 22,000
  1. Emergency Light

S.# / NAME OF FIRM / Make & Model / Rate/Quoted
M/s Asian Consultant & Computer Services / ACCEL Made in China / Rs. 2,200
  1. Bomb Bin

S.# / NAME OF FIRM / Make & Model / Rate/Quoted
M/s Asian Consultant & Computer Services / Suspect Postal Package Container Made by SDS Group Made in UK / Rs.3,96,000
  1. Pocket Jammer (GSM)

S.# / NAME OF FIRM / Make & Model / Rate/Quoted
M/s Asian Consultant & Computer Services / ACC-909SC Made in Taiwan / Rs. 22,000
  1. Conference Room Jammer (GSM)

S.# / NAME OF FIRM / Make & Model / Rate/Quoted
M/s International Office Suppliers / TG-101A / Rs. 66,317
  1. Portable Jammer (GSM) UHF/VHF

S.# / NAME OF FIRM / Make & Model / Rate/Quoted
M/s International Office Suppliers / TG - 101A / Rs. 2,47,183
  1. Prodder Small & Large

S.# / NAME OF FIRM / Make & Model / Rate/Quoted
M/s Asian Consultant & Computer Services / Prodder for Detecting Land Mines Explosive Devices & Trip Wires/Pakistan / Rs. 2,200
  1. Luminal Cell

S.# / NAME OF FIRM / Make & Model / Rate/Quoted
M/s Asian Consultant & Computer Services / Sensor E3500 P.No.D350538 Scintrex Trace / Rs. 243,000
(Per Packet)
  1. Digital Camera (14.1 Mega Pixel)

S.# / NAME OF FIRM / Make & Model / Rate/Quoted
M/s Gemco / Samsung ST-65 / Rs. 14,500
M/s Azms & Co. / Summey / Rs. 19,500
  1. Walk Through Gate

S.# / NAME OF FIRM / Make & Model / Rate/Quoted
M/s Sage-Tech International / HI-PE Multi Zone / PNZ/ Ceia Italy / Rs. 3,34,051

4/-In accordance with the PPRA Rules, which has been adopted by Sindh Police, The Committee recommended to approve the first lowest offered price by the Bidders as mentioned below:-

  1. Vehicle Identification Number Investigation System Device

S.# / NAME OF FIRM / Make & Model / Rate/Quoted
M/s Noor Forensics / Complex Model 7505 Made by Regula Made in Belarus / Rs. 4,698,000
  1. Light Sources for Crime Scene Unit

S.# / NAME OF FIRM / Make & Model / Rate/Quoted
M/s Noor Forensics / FAL3000 Made by Sirchie Made in North Carolina / Rs. 1,189,000
  1. Comparator for Handwriting Examination

S.# / NAME OF FIRM / Make & Model / Rate/Quoted
M/s Noor Forensics / Model 4305 M/MH Made by Regula Made in Belarus / Rs. 4,553,000
  1. Document Examination Accessories

S.# / NAME OF FIRM / Make & Model / Rate/Quoted
M/s Noor Forensics / Stage Surface Projectina UCM Made in Switzerland / Rs. 3,886,000
  1. Explosive Detector

S.# / NAME OF FIRM / Make & Model / Rate/Quoted
M/s Shirazi Trading / Model Hardened Mobile Trace Made by Morpho Detection Made in USA / Rs. 5,435,000
  1. Portable X-Ray Machine

S.# / NAME OF FIRM / Make & Model / Rate/Quoted
M/s Asian Consultant & Computer Services / Foxraylle with XR300 Made by SDS Group Made in UK / Rs. 5,894,000
  1. BD Technician Response Kit

S.# / NAME OF FIRM / Make & Model / Rate/Quoted
M/s Asian Consultant & Computer Services / HK-0125 IED Made in Hongkong / Rs. 22,000
  1. Emergency Light

S.# / NAME OF FIRM / Make & Model / Rate/Quoted
M/s Asian Consultant & Computer Services / ACCEL Made in China / Rs. 2,200
  1. Bomb Bin

S.# / NAME OF FIRM / Make & Model / Rate/Quoted
M/s Asian Consultant & Computer Services / Suspect Postal Package Container Made by SDS Group Made in UK / Rs.3,96,000
  1. Pocket Jammer (GSM)

S.# / NAME OF FIRM / Make & Model / Rate/Quoted
M/s Asian Consultant & Computer Services / ACC-909SC Made in Taiwan / Rs. 22,000
  1. Conference Room Jammer (GSM)

S.# / NAME OF FIRM / Make & Model / Rate/Quoted
M/s International Office Suppliers / TG-101A / Rs. 66,317
  1. Portable Jammer (GSM) UHF/VHF

S.# / NAME OF FIRM / Make & Model / Rate/Quoted
M/s International Office Suppliers / TG - 101A / Rs. 2,47,183
  1. Prodder Small & Large

S.# / NAME OF FIRM / Make & Model / Rate/Quoted
M/s Asian Consultant & Computer Services / Prodder for Detecting Land Mines Explosive Devices & Trip Wires/Pakistan / Rs. 2,200
  1. Luminal Cell

S.# / NAME OF FIRM / Make & Model / Rate/Quoted
M/s Asian Consultant & Computer Services / Sensor E3500 P.No.D350538 Scintrex Trace / Rs. 243,000
(Per Packet)
  1. Digital Camera (14.1 Mega Pixel)

S.# / NAME OF FIRM / Make & Model / Rate/Quoted
M/s Gemco / Samsung ST-65 / Rs. 14,500
  1. Walk Through Gate

S.# / NAME OF FIRM / Make & Model / Rate/Quoted
M/s Sage-Tech International / HI-PE Multi Zone / PNZ/ Ceia Italy / Rs. 3,34,051
Sd/-
Addl.igp/Special Branch Sindh
(Chairman)
Sd/-
DIGP/Admn. Karachi
(Member) / Sd/-
DIGP/HQtrs., Sindh Karachi
(Member)
Sd/-
DIGP/Special Branch Sindh Karachi
(Member) / Sd/-
AIGP /Logistics CPO Sindh Karachi
(Secretary)
Sd/-
Representative of Home Department
(Member) / Sd/-
Representative of IG Prison
(Member)