BC Timber Sales
Appraisal Data Submission Peer Review Checklist
License Number: ECAS Id: XML upload date:
Submission Prepared by: Reviewed by:
Correct / Fixed / Correct / FixedECAS60 Reference Info / ECAS63 Cruise Information / Tree to Truck
Timber Mark / Required Cruise Compilation reports and files attached
(as per Cruise Manual 5.10.1)
TSA/TSB / Compilation “for appraisal purposes”?
Point of Appraisal as per TRDEV calc? / Compilation used current version of compiler?
Comparative Cruise? / Net Merch area matches compilation
GSA >= NMA?
Stand Rate Eligibility codes / Cruise Info on ADS matches compilation?
Appraisal Map (IAM Appendix IV) / Sampling error <=15% or 1 plot/ha and at least 4 trees/plot average?
Cutting authority boundaries clearly marked? / Selling Price Zone
Retention areas identified? / BEC zones as per appraisal map and prorated by area?
Biogeoclimatic zones identified and delineated? / Basic Silviculture toggle set to NO
Different Harvest Methods delineated? / Root Disease toggleset to NO
Geographic centre of each cutblock and common junction marked? / Tree to Truck on ADS matches compilation?
Existing roads shown? / Partial cut indicated? Is the calculation correct? Does it qualify?
New tabular roads shown and identified by type? Sections to be gravelled identified? / ECAS66 Culverts
All ECE road sections and structures identified? / Applicable volume match compilation
Other developments identified and shown (ie. Fencing, cattleguards, etc.) / Number or culverts and sizes match the appraisal map?
Appropriate map scale? / ECAS68 Other Development
ECAS67 Tabular Roads / Other structures consistent with that shown on Appraisal Map?
Applicable volume match compilation / Is there supporting information attached for every Engineered Development entry?
Road Group correct? / Are the attached calculations for Engineered Development correct and match the ADS?
BEC zone correct for each section? / Applicable volume match compilation
Road identifier matches appraisal map / ECAS64 Log Transportation / Administration
Road type consistent with IAM / Cycle time calculated to closest mill at Point of Appraisal?
Length, moisture, side slope and rock % correct? / Primary Haul method correct?
(Highway vs Off-Highway)
Is stabilization required? Is length, material type and haul distance correct? / Was district approved road speed ledger (or equivalent) used for calculating cycle time?
Are all tabular road sections at least 100m in length (unrounded)? / Water / Special Transportation info correct?
Tabular roads less than 50% side slope / If road use charges are being claimed, is supporting documentation attached
Rock % calculations as per IAM? / Road management toggle set to NO
Camp toggle?
ECAS65 Specified Operations / ECAS70 Attachments
Does it qualify for a High Development Cost? / Are all required attachments attached?
If HDC, is calculation attached and correct? / Appraisal Map
ECAS69 BC Timber Sales / Cruise Compilation (pdf, dat, & csv)
Have dates, values, and toggles been filled in where required, and are they correct? / Detailed cycle time calculation
ECAS61 Acknowledgements / Other potentially required files
Reduced cruise compilation?
ECE calculations and associated files?
High Dev Cost calculation?
Road Use Charge documentation?
VCU calculation?
TSM/Exec Dir approval of rate?
Submitters name and contact info complete and correct? / ECAS62 Control
Professional certification toggle / TOA toggled to NO?
Licensee Representative filled in where appropriate?
Comments:
Reviewers SignatureDate
Page 1 of 2