Determination of lower and upper boundaries for ScvO2: Data(n=203 initial values, two missing values for lactate) from 205 patients at time point h=0 hours were split at a ratio of 70:30into training (143 samples) and test (60 samples) sets as recommended [12].The definition of optimal lower and upper bounds for ScvO2 was solely based on the training set. The independent test set was used to assess the predictive power of the training results. We used 50 replications of 5-fold cross-validation to obtain estimators for the optimal lower and upper bounds for ScvO2. That is, the training set was split up into five random samples of nearly equal size (n=28 or 29, respectively). One of five sample sets was left aside (as the cross-validation test sample) and the remaining four parts were used for training of the classifier to predict the combined endpoint “death, need for veno-venous hemofiltration, or ventilation exceeding 24 hours”. This procedure was repeated for each of the five parts of the training set. To reduce the effect of this random split, 50 replications of 5-fold cross-validation overall leading to 250 random samples were used in addition. The initial use of numerical optimization procedures showed that there exist several local minima for the classification error. Hence, we switched to a more general procedure consisting of a grid search to find the global minimum of misclassification. A grid consisting of values ranging from 19 to 92% at agrid width of 0.1% was applied, as the minimum and maximum observed values were 19.8 and 91.5% for ScvO2, respectively. As a lower bound below 19.8% and a upper bound above 91.5% may be selected by our algorithm it also covers the case of a single cut-off. In each cross validation step the classification error for (731*730/2 =) 266815 pairs of grid points (i.e., all possible lower and upper bounds) was evaluated to define lower and upper bounds and the combination with the smallest misclassification chosen. Thus, this approach allowed to test all possible pairs of values simultaneously to calculate the minimal classification error for a pair of lower and upper limits of normal.The final lower and upper bounds based on the training set were then obtained as the median values of the 250 random replications.Thus, three groups were defined as ‘low’, ‘normal’, and ‘supranormal’ ScvO2, based on their immediate ScvO2 values upon admission to the ICU.
ESM Table 1: Vasoactive and inotropic drugs
low ScvO2-normal ScvO2-supranormal ScvO2-p-value
group group group
Epinephrine
0 hours after admission
No. of patients /total no. 4 / 27 37 / 115 42 / 63 *† < .001
dosage [µg/kg/min]0.33 [0.11 – 0.36]0.05 [0.03 – 0.08]0.06 [0.05 – 0.10] .011
3 hours after admission
No. of patients /total no. 8 / 26 38 / 115 44 / 63 *†< .001
dosage [µg/kg/min]0.11 [0.03 – 0.27]0.05 [0.03 – 0.08]0.07 [0.04 – 0.10] .067
6 hours after admission
No. of patients /total no. 7 / 56 36 / 115 41 / 63 *†< .001
dosage [µg/kg/min]0.07 [0.03 – 0.19] 0.05 [0.03 – 0.08] 0.07 [0.05 – 0.09] .098
9 hours after admission
No. of patients /total no. 7 / 26 38 / 115 39 / 63 *†< .001
dosage [µg/kg/min]0.07 [0.03 – 0.19]0.04 [0.03 – 0.07] 0.07 [0.04 – 0.09] * .044
12 hours after admission
No. of patients /total no. 7 / 26 37 / 115 36 / 63 *† .002
dosage [µg/kg/min]0.07 [0.03 – 0.29]0.04 [0.03 – 0.07]0.07 [0.04 – 0.09] * .027
24 hours after admission
No. of patients /total no. 6 / 26 35 / 115 31 / 63 * .002
dosage [µg/kg/min]0.13 [0.03 – 0.25] 0.04 [0.03 – 0.07] 0.06 [0.03 – 0.09] .128
Norepinephrine
0 hours after admission
No. of patients /total no. 21 / 27 87 / 115 50 / 63 .893
dosage [µg/kg/min]0.06 [0.02 – 0.15]0.06 [0.03 – 0.10]0.10 [0.05 – 0.17] * .004
3 hours after admission
No. of patients /total no. 20 / 26 74 / 115 45 / 63 .403
dosage [µg/kg/min]0.04 [0.02 – 0.11] 0.04 [0.03 – 0.10]0.10 [0.05 – 0.17] * .005
6 hours after admission
No. of patients /total no. 16 / 26 62 / 115 40 / 63 .466
dosage [µg/kg/min]0.06 [0.04 – 0.11]0.04 [0.02 – 0.10] ‡0.06 [0.04 – 0.11] ‡ .102
9 hours after admission
No. of patients /total no. 13 / 26 59 / 115 37 / 63 .594
dosage [µg/kg/min]0.07 [0.05 – 0.11] ‡0.05 [0.02 – 0.09] ‡0.06 [0.03 – 0.16] ‡ .156
12 hours after admission
No. of patients /total no. 12 / 26 53 / 115 31 / 63 .921
dosage [µg/kg/min]0.07 [0.05 – 0.17]0.04 [0.02 – 0.08] ‡0.09 [0.03 – 0.29] *‡ .009
24 hours after admission
No. of patients /total no. 11 / 26 49 / 115 27 / 63 .999
dosage [µg/kg/min]0.06 [0.03 – 0.14] ‡0.04 [0.02 – 0.08] ‡0.08 [0.04 – 0.24] *‡ .027
Dobutamine
0 hours after admission
No. of patients /total no. 3 / 27 * 0 / 115 2 / 63 .003
dosage [µg/kg/min]3.40 [2.90 – 4.50] -3.90 [3.80 – 4.00] .564
3 hours after admission
No. of patients /total no. 4 / 26 4 / 115 6 / 63 .042
dosage [µg/kg/min]4.00 [3.02 – 4.88]3.91 [3.61 – 6.23]3.65 [3.33 – 4.55] .611
6 hours after admission
No. of patients /total no. 6 / 26 12 / 115 7 / 63 .231
dosage [µg/kg/min]3.80 [3.20 – 4.63]4.20 [3.61 – 5.40] ‡4.00 [3.50 – 5.80] .675
9 hours after admission
No. of patients /total no. 6 / 26 19 / 115 8 / 63 .452
dosage [µg/kg/min]3.80 [3.20 – 4.63]4.20 [3.60 – 5.10] ‡4.00 [3.58 – 5.55] .595
12 hours after admission
No. of patients /total no. 6 / 26 19 / 115 10 / 63 .647
dosage [µg/kg/min]3.35 [2.98 – 4.28]4.20 [3.60 – 5.10] ‡4.00 [3.58 – 5.35] .196
24 hours after admission
No. of patients /total no. 9 / 26 22 / 115 13 / 63 .229
dosage [µg/kg/min]4.20 [3.15 – 4.40]4.20 [3.45 – 5.13] ‡4.06 [3.70 – 5.50] ‡ .593
Milrinone
0 hours after admission
No. of patients /total no. 0 / 27 0 / 115 0 / 63 -
dosage [µg/kg/min] - - - -
3 hours after admission
No. of patients /total no. 1 / 26 0 / 115 1 / 63 .098
dosage [µg/kg/min]0.19 [0.19 – 0.19] - 0.15 [0.15 – 0.15] .317
6 hours after admission
No. of patients /total no. 2 / 26 0 / 115 1 / 63 .018
dosage [µg/kg/min]0.36 [0.24 – 0.48] -0.15 [0.15 – 0.15] .221
9 hours after admission
No. of patients /total no. 2 / 26 0 / 115 2 / 63 .025
dosage [µg/kg/min]0.36 [0.24 – 0.48] -0.16 [0.15 – 0.16] .121
12 hours after admission
No. of patients /total no. 2 / 26 1 / 115 2 / 63 .081
dosage [µg/kg/min]0.36 [0.24 – 0.48]0.33[0.33 – 0.33]0.16 [0.15 – 0.16] .223
24 hours after admission
No. of patients /total no. 2 / 26 1 / 115 2 / 63 .081
dosage [µg/kg/min]0.36 [0.24 – 0.48]0.33[0.33 – 0.33]0.37 [0.31 – 0.42] .999
Data are medians and interquartile range and absolute values
* indicates p< .05 compared to normal ScvO2-group; † indicates p< .05 compared to low ScvO2 -group
‡ indicates p < .05 compared to baseline
ESM Table 2:
Intra- and postoperative heart rate, mean arterial pressure and volume therapy
low ScvO2- / normal ScvO2- / supranormal ScvO2- / p-valuegroup / group / group
n=27 / n=115 / n=63
Intraoperative values
heart rate [bpm]
after induction of anaesthesia / 63 [53 – 70] / 64 [54 – 74] / 62[55 - 73] / .849
after heparin bolus / 70.5 [59.8 - 83.5] / 70 [61 - 78.3] / 71 [60 – 83] / .850
after protamin bolus / 90 [88 - 99] / 92 [87.5 - 98] / 91 [87 – 97] / .914
mean arterial pressure [mmHg]
after induction of anaesthesia / 81 [65 - 88.8 ] / 80 [73 – 89] / 76.0 [66 - 84]* / .033
after heparin bolus / 70.5 [63.5 - 79.3] / 70 [64 – 78.3] / 66.0 [60 – 75] / .144
after protamin bolus / 72.5 [64.5 - 86.8] / 70 [64 - 75] / 67.0 [59 - 72] / .037
volume replacement
crystalloid solutions [ml/h] / 465.1 [384.6 - 606.1] / 512.8 [375 - 714.3] / 517.2 [370.2 - 714.3] / .689
colloid solutions [ml/h] / 0 [0 - 156.3] / 0 [0 - 116.3] / 0 [0 - 151.5] / .145
packed red cells [n] / 0 [0 - 1] / 0 [0 - 2] / 0 [0 - 2] / .406
fresh frozen plasma [n] / 0 [0 – 0] / 0 [0 – 0] / 0 [0 - 0] / .994
platelet concentrate [n] / 0 [0 - 1]* / 0 [0 – 0] / 0 [0 - 0] / .006
intensive care unit values
heart rate [bpm]
0 hours after admission / 94 [90 - 100] / 91 [84 - 99] / 91 [88 – 100] / .389
3 hours after admission / 93 [90 - 100.5] / 95 [90 - 100] / 92 [89 -100] / .602
6 hours after admission / 92.5 [90 - 102] / 94 [88 - 100] / 94 [90 - 101.5] / .329
9 hours after admission / 91.5 [90 - 100.5] / 92 [85 - 100] / 95 [90 - 100.3] / .270
12 hours after admission / 91.5 [90 - 100] / 92 [85 - 100] / 94 [89 – 100] / .594
24 hours after admission / 91 [90 - 100.5] / 92 [84 - 100] / 94 [89 - 99] / .679
mean arterial pressure [mmHg]
0 hours after admission / 75 [66 – 85] / 75 [66 - 82] / 75 [66 – 82] / .964
3 hours after admission / 72 [68.5 – 83.2] / 78.0 [72 - 85] / 74 [66 - 78]* / .005
6 hours after admission / 75 [69 - 84] / 76.0 [69 – 84] / 71 [67 - 77.3] / .051
9 hours after admission / 74.5 [65.8 – 78] / 77 [69 - 84] / 73 [67 – 80] / .063
12 hours after admission / 76 [70 - 79] / 77 [70 – 83] / 72 [68 - 78]* / .038
24 hours after admission / 76 [70 - 79.8] / 77 [70 – 83] / 73 [68 - 78] / .089
volume replacement
crystalloid solutions [ml/h] / 87 [58.8 - 166.7] / 125.0 [74.1 - 176.5] / 103.5 [71.4 - 166.7] / .561
colloid solutions [ml/h] / 125 [66.7 - 166.7] / 104.2 [71.4 - 172.4] / 100 [62.5 - 166.7] / .871
packed red cells [n] / 1 [0 – 2]* / 0 [0 – 0] / 0 [0 - 2] / <.001
fresh frozen plasma [n] / 0 [0 – 4] / 0 [0 - 0] / 0 [0 – 4] / .138
platelet concentrate [n] / 0 [0 - 1] / 0 [0 - 0] / 0 [0 – 0] / .078
aiDCO2
0 hours after admission / 0.5 [0.2 - 1.2] / 0.5 [0.2 - 0.9] / 0.4 [0.2 - 0.7] / .565
3 hours after admission / 0.5 [0.3 - 1.1] / 0.6 [0.4 - 1.1] / 0.6 [0.3 - 1.0] / .440
6 hours after admission / 1.2 [0.5 - 1.5] / 0.9 [0.5 - 1.3] ‡ / 0.6 [0.3 - 1.3] / .172
9 hours after admission / 0.9 [0.5 - 1.5] / 0.9 [0.5 - 1.2] ‡ / 0.8 [0.3 - 1.5] ‡ / .873
12 hours after admission / 1.2 [0.5 - 1.7] / 0.9 [0.5 - 1.2] / 0.9 [0.3 - 1.4] / .572
24 hours after admission / 1.2 [0.5 - 1.7] / 0.9 [0.5 - 1.2] / 0.9 [0.4 - 1.5] ‡ / .341
Data are medians and interquartile range and absolute values. * indicates p< .05 compared to normal ScvO2-group;† indicates p< .05 compared to low ScvO2-group, ‡ indicates p < .05 compared to baseline