Hyattgrandchampion, Indianwells, California

May2011 IEEEP802. 15-11-0437-02-0006

IEEEP802.15

WirelessPersonalAreaNetworks

Project / TG6 BodyAreaNetworks
Title / TG6 PalmSpringsInterimMeetingMinutes
DateSubmitted / 19/May/2011
Source / [IgorDotlić]
[NICT]
[Yokosuka, Japan] / Voice:[+81-46-847-5066]
Fax:[+81-46-847-5431]
E-mail:[
Re: / TG 6 PalmSpringsMeetingMinutes
Abstract / MinutesofTG6 inPalmSprings 2011
Purpose / MinutesofTG6 sessions
Notice / ThisdocumenthasbeenpreparedtoassisttheIEEEP802.15. Itisofferedasabasisfordiscussionandisnotbindingonthecontributingindividual(s) ororganization(s). Thematerialinthisdocumentissubjecttochangeinformandcontentafterfurtherstudy. Thecontributor(s) reserve(s) therighttoadd, amendorwithdrawmaterialcontainedherein.
Release / ThecontributoracknowledgesandacceptsthatthiscontributionbecomesthepropertyofIEEEandmaybemadepubliclyavailablebyP802.15.

HyattGrandChampion, IndianWells, California.

May 9-12, 2011

Monday, May 9th, 2011– Session 1

13:30 Meetingwascalledtoorderbythechair.

Thechairaskedforapprovalofthepreviousmeetingminutes (11-0314-01).

Meetingminuteswereapprovedunanimously.

Thechairwentthrough “IEEE-SAPatentPolicy”.

Nooneansweredasawareofanypatentsessentialfortheimplementationofthestandard.

Thechairpresented “TG6 openingreportMay 2011” (11-0366-00).

ChuckFarlowgavereportaboutHBCPHYconf. calls.ThreeteleconferenceshavebeenheldtodatewithAdvaMedmembers: March 1, March 8, andMay 3. Minutesfromthesecondteleconferencearepostedindocument -0326. Samsung’sresponseisindocument -0344. Overall, thegroupisnotmakinggoodprogress. Theindustryaskedmanydetailedquestions, andverylittleadditionaltechnicalinformationhasbeenprovidedbyHBCsupporters. Inareflectorpostinglastweek, IrequestedadditionalHBCinformationbemadeavailableontheIEEEserver.

DavidDavenport: Wheredoesthisalllead? Howisthisinteractionconcluded?

ChuckFarlow: TheconcernsvoicedbyAdvaMedmembersarereflectedinmyLetterBallotcomments. Ifnotresolvedduringthisphase, thesecommentswillbecarriedforwardintotheSponsorBallotstage.

Bob: Wewillneedonemorere-circulationballotfortheresolutionsofthenewnegativecomments.

DanielLewisgavetheeditors’ reportforthedraftofthestandardd03, LB71.

Thegroupdividedinsubgroupsforcommentsresolution.

Thesessionwasrecessedbythechair.

Monday, May 9th, 2011– Session 2

16:00 Meetingwascalledtoorderbythechair.

Thegroupdividedinsubgroupsforcommentsresolution.

Thesessionwasrecessedbythechair.

Tuesday, May 10th, 2011– Session 3

08:00 Meetingwascalledtoorderbythechair.

Thegroupdividedinsubgroupsforcommentsresolution.

Thesessionwasrecessedbythechair.

Tuesday, May 10th, 2011– Session 4

10:30 Meetingwascalledtoorderbythechair.

Approvaloftheclause 9 commentsresolutions; commentsresolutionswereapprovedwithoutobjections.

Thegroupdividedinsubgroupsforcommentsresolution.

Thesessionwasrecessedbythechair.

Tuesday, May 10th, 2011– Session 5

13:30 Meetingwascalledtoorderbythechair.

Thesessioncontinuedwiththecommentsresolution.

Thesessionwasrecessedbythechair.

Tuesday, May 10th, 2011– Session 6

16:00 Meetingwascalledtoorderbythechair.

Approvaloftheclause 10 commentsresolutions; commentsresolutionswereapprovedunanimously.

Thesessioncontinuedwiththecommentsresolution.

Thesessionwasrecessedbythechair.

Wednesday, May 11th, 2011– Session 7

13:30 Meetingwascalledtoorderbythechair.

Thechair: CommentresolutionforClauses 6 and 7 isfinished.

Thechair: WewillcombineallspreadsheetsintooneandvoteonitonPM2.

Chuck: ThreeofmycommentsforHBCPHYwererejectedasnon-actionable. WeneedtomakesubstantialimprovementsinClause 11 andSamsungneedstoprovideenoughinformationtoaddressindustryconcerns.

Anuj: WeneedtoaddresspointinMICSbandaboutduty-cycleinacertainband; wewillchangethetextandbringittothegroupinPM2 tovoteon.

Thesessionwasrecessedbythechair.

Wednesday, May 11th, 2011– Session 8

16:00 Meetingwascalledtoorderbythechair.

PaulStadnikpresented “ProposedchangetotextforMICSLP-LDCsupport” (11-0410-00).

PaulStadnikpresented “ProposedchangetotextforMICSLP-LDCsupport” (11-0410-01).

TG6 Motion 1:

Approvethecontentsof: 15-11-0363-05-0006-lb71-d03p802-15-6-comment-registerandpresentation 15-11-0410-01-0006-proposed-change-to-text-for-mics-lp-ldc-supportasresolvingcommentsond03P802-15-6_Draft_Standard.

Moved: DanielLewis

Second: AnujBatra

Vote: Unanimous

Thesessionwasrecessedbythechair.

Thursday, May 12th, 2011– Session 9

13:30 Meetingwascalledtoorderbythechair.

Danielgavethecurrentstatusofincorporatingthecommentsinthestandarddraft.

Thechairpresentedthetimelineforletterballotre-circandsponsorballot (11-0432-00) p.8.

Anuj: Iurgepeopletokeeptheirtechnicalcommentsforthesponsorballot. WecancertainlydiscusstheminadvanceinSanFrancisco.

Thechairpresented “TG6 ClosingReportMay 2011”(11-0432-00).

Thesessionwasrecessedbythechair.

Thursday, May 12th, 2011– Session 10

16:00 Meetingwascalledtoorderbythechair.

ThechairpresentedtheliaisonletterfromETSIincludingtwoconcerns:

1. AlignmentoftheIEEE 802.15.6 standardwithprovisionsoftheHarmonizedETSIstandards
2. PotentialEMIproblemofHBCtoimplantedmedicaldevices. Thechairremarkedthisisanotherexampleofindustryconcern.

Thechair: IwanttoaskreportofHBC - implantedmedicaldevicesindustrymeetingupdate.

ChuckFarlow: Noprogresswasmadeduringthisweek’ssession. HBCproponentsandAdvaMedmemberswillconsideraface-to-facemeetingimmediatelybeforetheJulyPlenarySessionorsometimeduringthesameweek.

Thesessionwasrecessedbythechair.

Themeetingwasadjournedbythechair.

TG6 submission Page1 IgorDotlić, NICT