Draft Recommended Practice For

P929, Draft 11, November 1999

IEEE P929/D11

Draft Recommended Practice for

Utility Interface of

Photovoltaic (PV) Systems

Prepared by the Utility Working Group of

Standards Coordinating Committee 21,

On Fuel Cells, Photovoltaics, Dispersed Generation and Energy Storage

345 East 47th Street

New York, NY 10017, USA

This is an IEEE Standards Project, subject to change. Permission is hereby granted for IEEE Standards committee participants to reproduce this document for purposes of IEEE standardization activities, including balloting and coordination. If this document is to be submitted to ISO or IEC, notification shall be given to the IEEE Copyrights Administrator. Permission is also granted for member bodies and technical committees of ISO and IEC to reproduce this document for purposes of developing a national position. Other entities seeking permission to reproduce portions of this document for these or other uses must contact the IEEE Standards Department for the appropriate license. Use of information contained in the unapproved draft is at your own risk.

IEEE Standards Department

Copyrights and Permissions

445 Hoes Lane, P.O. Box 1331

Piscataway, NJ 08855-1331, USA

Introduction

(This introduction is not a part of P929, Draft Recommended Practice for Utility Interface of Photovoltaic (PV) Systems.)

This revision of IEEE Std 929 is in response to the maturing of the photovoltaic industry. That maturation has identified the critical need to have the interconnection of photovoltaic (PV) systems to the utility grid be covered under a comprehensive document that includes specific recommendations rather than general guidance. The intent of this document is to define the technical requirements of PV system interconnection in a manner that can be adopted as a PV system technical interconnection standard by individual utilities. This document also includes several annexes for tutorial and clarification purposes.

A significant effort has been made to coordinate this document with Underwriters Laboratories in the production of UL 1741, a test procedure that can be performed by an independent body to verify that an inverter intended for use with a utility-interconnected PV system meets the recommendations described in this recommended practice. This UL safety test procedure will, among other things, test the inverter for proper response, as detailed in this recommended practice, and as described in Annex G, to loss of utility or “out of bounds” utility conditions. One aspect of this testing is to ascertain that the inverter will not operate as a utility-independent island.

Participants

At the time this recommended practice was completed, Standards Coordinating Committee 21, on Fuel Cells, Photovoltaics, Dispersed Generation and Energy Storage, had the following membership:

Richard DeBlasio, Chair / A.J. Anderson, Secretary / S.Chalmers, Vice Chair

This is an unapproved IEEE Standards Draft, subject to change.

P929, Draft 11, November 1999

R.Addiss

J. Anderson

G. Atmaram

M. Azzam

T Basso

M. Behnke

R. Bonn

W. Bottenberg

W. Bower

B. Brooks

P. Butler

J. Bzura

J. Call

P. Capps

R. Cary

S. Chalmers

J. Chamberlin

J. Chau

D. Conover

G. Corey

R. D’Aiello

D. Dawson

R. DeBlasio

J. Drizos

T. Duffy

J. Dunlop

J. Emming

B. Farmer

W. Feero

M. Flis

C. Freitas

D. Garrett

R. Gonsiorawski

R. Hammond

K. Hecht

S. Hester

R. Hoffman

J. Hoffner

S. Hogan

B. Hornberger

T. Hund

M. Jackson

T. Jester

S. Jochums

B. Jones

W. Kanzer

W. Kaszeta

G. Kelly

G. Kern

J. Koepfinger

B. Kroposki

S. Kurtz

L. Libby

D. Loweberg

S. Macera

K. MacKamul

N. Magnani

A. Mikonowicz

J. Moriarty

D. Myers

C. Napikoski

A. Nilsson

U. Ortabasi

C. Osterwald

P. Overholt

J. Posbic

R. Rider

T. Ruhlmann

M. Russell

P. Russell

K. Sanders

R. Schmit

J. Smyth

J. Stevens

C. Sun

J. Sutherland

M. Thomas

J. Turner

J. Tuttle

S. Vechy

J. Ventre

C. Whitaker

K. Whitfield

J. Wiles

R. Wills

J. Wohlgemuth

T. Zgonena

This is an unapproved IEEE Standards Draft, subject to change.

P929, Draft 11, November 1999

At the time this recommended practice was completed, the Utility Working Group of Standards Coordinating Committee 21, on Fuel Cells, Photovoltaics, Dispersed Generation and Energy Storage, had the following membership who participated in the preparation of this recommended practice:

John Stevens, Chair Miles Russell, Secretary

This is an unapproved IEEE Standards Draft, subject to change.

P929, Draft 11, November 1999

Michael Behnke

Bill Brooks

John Bzura

Steve Chalmers

Joe Chau

Doug Dawson

Richard DeBlasio

Tom Duffy

Chris Freitas

D. Lane Garrett

Steve Hester

John Hoffner

Barry Hornberger

Bob Jones

Greg Kern

Leslie Libby

Don Loweberg

Tron Melzl

John Moriarty

Chester Napikoski

Jean Posbic

Jodi Smyth

Chase Sun

Rick West

Chuck Whitaker

Robert Wills

Tim Zgonena

This is an unapproved IEEE Standards Draft, subject to change.

P929, Draft 11, November 1999

The following people were on the balloting committee that approved this document for submission to the IEEE Standards Board:

This is an unapproved IEEE Standards Draft, subject to change.

P929, Draft 11, November 1999

Mike Behnke

John Bzura

Steve Chalmers

Jay Chamberlin

Doug Dawson

Richard DeBlasio

Tom Duffy

Bill Feero

D. Lane Garrett

Bob Hammond

John Hoffner

Stephen Hogan

Bob Jones

Greg Kern

Tron Melzl

John Moriarty

Miles Russell

John Stevens

Chase Sun

Chuck Whitaker

John Wiles

Robert Wills

This is an unapproved IEEE Standards Draft, subject to change.

P929, Draft 11, November 1999

Contents

Introduction 2

Participants 2

1. Overview 7

1.1 Scope 7

1.2 Purpose 8

2. References 8

3. Definitions 8

3.1 inverter: 8

3.2 islanding: 8

3.3 point of common coupling (PCC): 8

3.4 quality factor: 8

3.5 resonant frequency: 8

3.6 utility-interface disconnect switch: 8

4. Power quality 8

4.1 Normal voltage operating range. 8

4.2 Voltage flicker 8

4.3 Frequency 8

4.4 Waveform distortion 8

4.5 Power factor 8

5. Safety and protection functions 8

5.1 Response to abnormal utility conditions 8

5.2 Direct-current injection 8

5.3 Grounding 8

5.4 Utility-interface disconnect switch 8

Annex A - Bibliography 8

Annex B - PV inverters and the utility interface 8

Annex C - Disconnect switches & utility procedures 8

Annex D - Islanding as it applies to PV systems 8

Annex E - The PV inverter under utility fault conditions 8

Annex F - Dedicated distribution transformer 8

Annex G – Minimum test procedure for a non-islanding PV inverter 8

Recommended Practice for

Utility Interface of

Photovoltaic (PV) Systems

1. Overview

This recommended practice contains guidance regarding equipment and functions necessary to ensure compatible operation of photovoltaic systems which are connected in parallel with the electric utility. This includes factors relating to personnel safety, equipment protection, power quality and utility system operation

The document also includes seven annexes: (A) Bibliography, (B) PV inverters and the utility interface, (C) Disconnect switches and utility procedures, (D) Islanding as it applies to PV systems, (E) The PV inverter under utility fault conditions, (F) Dedicated distribution transformers, and (G) Minimum test procedure for a non-islanding PV inverter.

1.1 Scope

This recommended practice applies to utility-interconnected PV power systems operating in parallel with the utility and utilizing static (solid-state) inverters for the conversion of dc to ac. (This recommended practice does not apply to systems utilizing rotating inverters.) This document describes specific recommendations for small systems (rated at 10 kW or less), such as may be utilized on individual residences. These recommendations will provide greater standardization for these smaller systems, thereby reducing the engineering and design burden on both the PV system installer and the interconnecting utility.

Intermediate size applications, ranging from over 10 kW up to 500 kW, follow the same general guidelines as small systems. Options to have adjustable setpoints or other custom features may be required by the interconnecting utility, depending on the impact of the PV system on that portion of the utility system to which it is interconnected.

Large systems, greater than 500 kW, may combine various standardized features as well as custom requirements, depending on the impact of the PV system on that portion of the utility system to which it is interconnected. A greater degree of custom engineering of the utility interface is to be expected as the size of the PV system grows in relation to utility system capacity.

1.2 Purpose

This recommended practice will provide value to a wide spectrum of personnel involved with utility-interconnected PV systems including utility engineers, PV system designers/installers and PV system owners. The standardized interconnection recommendations included in this recommended practice will minimize custom engineering of many aspects of the interconnection. This document is focused on providing recommended practice for utility interconnection of PV systems in a manner that will allow the PV systems to perform as expected and be installed at a reasonable cost while not compromising safety or operational issues.

Small utility-interconnected photovoltaic systems, that is, those of 10 kW peak capacity or less, should use standardized, listed inverters (listed to test standards, such as Underwriters Laboratories Subject 1741-1999 (UL 1741), which include the testing requirements described in Annex G). The listing process assures that the inverter incorporates fixed voltage and frequency trip settings, and an integral anti-islanding scheme. It is the intent of this recommended practice that small systems designed and installed in accordance with this document and other applicable standards, such as the National Electrical Code® (NEC®) (NFPA 70-1999), will require no additional protection equipment.

2. References

This recommended practice shall be used in conjunction with the following publications. When the following standards are superseded by an approved revision, the revision shall apply.

Accredited Standards Committee C2-1997, National Electrical Safety Code® (NESC®).

ANSI C84.1-1995, Electric Power Systems and Equipment - Voltage Ratings (60Hertz)

IEEE Std 100-1996, IEEE Standard Dictionary of Electrical and Electronic Terms

IEEE Std 519-1992, Recommended Practices and Requirements for Harmonic Control in Electrical Power Systems

NFPA 70-1999, National Electrical Code® (NEC®).

UL Subject 1741, May, 1999, Standard for Static Inverters and Charge Controllers for use in Photovoltaic Power Systems

3. Definitions

For purposes of this recommended practice, the following terms and definitions apply. IEEE Std 100-1996 should be referenced for terms not defined in this clause.

3.1 inverter:

Equipment that converts direct current to alternating current.

Synonym: static power converter (SPC). Any static power converter with control, protection, and filtering functions used to interface an electric energy source with an electric utility system. Sometimes referred to as power conditioning subsystems, power conversion systems, solid-state converters, or power conditioning units.

Note: The term “inverter” is popularly used for the converter that serves as the interface device between the PV system dc output and the utility system. However, the definition for static power converter more accurately describes this interface device. Because of popular usage, the term “inverter” is used throughout this document. It should be born in mind that this inverter includes the control, protection, and filtering functions as described in the definition for static power converter.

Note: Because of its integrated nature, the inverter is only required to be totally disconnected from the utility for service or maintenance. At all other times, whether the inverter is transferring PV energy to the utility or not, the control circuits remain connected to the utility to monitor utility conditions. The phrase, “cease to energize the utility line” is used throughout this document. This is to acknowledge that the inverter does not become totally disconnected from the utility when a trip function occurs, such as an over-voltage trip. The inverter can be completely disconnected from the utility for inverter maintenance by opening the NEC-required ac-disconnect switch.

3.1.1 non-islanding inverter:

An inverter that will cease to energize the utility line in 10 cycles or less when subjected to a typical islanded load in which either of the following is true:

1. There is at least a 50% mismatch in real power load to inverter output (that is, real power load is less than 50% or greater than 150% of inverter power output) or,

2. The islanded-load power factor is less than 0.95 (lead or lag),

If the real power generation to load match is within 50% AND the islanded-load power factor is greater than 0.95, then a non-islanding inverter will cease to energize the utility line within 2 seconds whenever the connected line has a quality factor of 2.5 or less.

Note: See Annex G for a test procedure that identifies an inverter as a non-islanding inverter.

3.2 islanding:

A condition in which a portion of the utility system, which contains both load and distributed resources, is isolated from the remainder of the utility system.

3.2.1 distributed resource islanding:

An islanding condition in which the distributed resource(s) supplying the loads within the island is not within the direct control of the power system operator.

3.3 point of common coupling (PCC):

The point at which the electric utility and the customer interface occurs. Typically, this is the customer side of the utility revenue meter.

Note: In practice, for building-mounted PV systems (such as residential PV systems) the customer distribution panel may be considered the PCC. This is for convenience in making measurements and performing testing.

3.4 quality factor:

Two pi times the ratio of the maximum stored energy to the energy dissipated per cycle at a given frequency.

Note: In a parallel resonant circuit, such as a load on a power system:

Q = R

where

Q is quality factor

R is effective load resistance

C is effective load capacitance (including shunt capacitors)

L is effective load inductance.

Or, on a power system, where real power, P, and reactive powers, PqL for inductive load, and PqC for capacitive load are known:

Q = (1/P)

where

Q is quality factor

P is real power

PqL is inductive load

PqC is capacitive load.

3.5 resonant frequency:

The frequency, f, at which a parallel resonant RLC load has unity power factor.