April 23, 2015
WALWORTH COUNTY BOARD OF EQUALIZATION
WALWORTHCOUNTY CONSOLIDATED BOARD OF EQUALIZATION
MINUTES OF PROCEEDINGS
The Walworth County Consolidated Board of Equalization met at 8:30 a.m. on April 23, 2015 at the County Courthouse for the purpose of hearing appeals and equalizing the assessments of property. Members present were James Houck, Duane Martin,Scott Schillingand David Siemon. The meeting was called to order by Chairman Schilling. Also present were Auditor Rebecca Krein, States Attorney Jamie Hare and Director of Equalization Debbie Kahl.
Rose Henderson was present to represent the City of Mobridge and signed the Equalization Board Oath.
Houck moved and Siemon seconded to convene as a Consolidated Board/Selby. Voting Aye:5; Nay: 0. The motion was adopted.
The following appealswere heard and acted upon:
Appeal #3 – Record # 6094 – Mobridge NWTS Co’s 2nd Addn Lots 8 & S9 of Lot 9 Block 24 - Kenneth Rossow
Martin moved and Siemon seconded to lower the value from $131970 to $107230. Voting Aye: 5; Nay: 0. The motion was adopted.
Appeal #4 – Record #5512 – Mobridge Grand Crossing Lots 17A, 18A, 19A Block 61 - Loren Yates
Martin moved and Siemon seconded to lower the value from $26245 to $8040. Voting Aye:5; Nay: 0. The motion was adopted.
Appeal #5–Record #6418 – Mobridge Shor Acres Lot 107 - Darrell Bender
Martin moved and Siemon seconded to lower the value from $203450 to $127000. Voting Aye:5; Nay: 0. The motion was adopted.
Appeal #6 – Record #6027 – Mobridge NWTS 2nd Addn Lot 8 Block 17 - Daniel Merkel
Martin moved and Houck seconded to lower the value from $83410to $66000. Voting Aye: 5; Nay: 0. The motion was adopted.
Appeal #7 – Record #6037 – Mobridge NWTS Co’s 2nd Addn S 7’ of Lot 5 & all Lot 6 & N 17’ of Lot 7 Block 18 - Herman Hulm
Martin moved and Houck seconded to lower the value from $131580 to $107230. Voting Aye: 5; Nay: 0. The motion was adopted.
Appeal #8 – Record #6131 – Mobridge NWTS Co’s 3rd Addn Lot 7 & 8 - Kelly Armfield
Martin moved and Siemonseconded to lower the value from $108960 to $75000. Voting Aye: 5; Nay: 0. The motion was adopted.
Appeal #9– Record #5378 – Mobridge Grand Crossing Addn Lot 12 Block 49 - Dennis Naasz
Houck moved and Siemon seconded toleave as is $63690. Voting Aye: 5; Nay: 0. The motion was adopted.
Appeal #10 – Record #6047–Mobridge NWTS Co’s 2nd Addn Lot 6 & N 32’ of Lot 7 Block 19 - Robert Krumm
Houck moved and Martin seconded to lower the value from $119120 to $95000. Voting Aye: 5; Nay: 0. The motion was adopted.
Appeal #11 – Record #4697 – Mobridge Bel Aire 1st Addn Lot 2 Block 1 - Justin Jungwirth
Siemon moved and Houck seconded to lower the value from $124140 to $90000. Voting Aye:5; Nay: 0;. The motion was adopted.
Appeal #12 – Record #5908 – Mobridge NWTS Co’s 1st Addn Lots 9, 10 & 11 Block 1 - Leonard Linde
Siemon moved and Houck seconded to lower the value from $279090 to $210000. Voting Aye: 5; Nay: 0. The motion was adopted.
Appeal #14 – Record #4976 – Mobridge ELKO’s 2nd Addn Lot 12 - Joel Fischer
Siemon moved and Martin seconded to lower the value from $37480 to $34930. Voting Aye: 5; Nay: 0. The motion was adopted.
Appeal #13– Record #6050 – Mobridge NWTS Co’s 2nd Addn N 40’ of Lots 10 & S 26’ of Lot 11 Block 19 - Jason Peterson
Martin moved and Siemon seconded to lower the value from $107100 to $106000. Voting Aye:5; Nay: 0. The motion was adopted.
Appeal #15 – Record #4751 - Mobridge Bel Aire 2nd Addn 2nd Subd Lot 23 - Adeline Schmaltz
Houck moved and Siemon seconded to leave as is $105200. Voting Aye: 5; Nay: 0. The motion was adopted.
Appeal #16 – Record #6069 – Mobridge NWTS 2nd Addn Lot 12 & 13 - Steve Gasser
Houckmoved and Martinseconded to leave as is $210110. Voting Aye: 5; Nay: 0. The motion was adopted.
Appeal # 16 – Record 6576 – Mobridge Misc Lot 2 of Outlot 1 in SE4 24-124-80 - Lavonne Gemar
Siemon moved and Henderson seconded to lower the value from $136990 to $96460. Voting Aye: 5; Nay: 0. The motion was adopted.
Appeal #18 – Record 5540 – Mobridge Jay-Kraft 1st Addn N 20’ of Lot 10 & S 55’ of Lot 11 Block 3 - Evelyn Pleinis
Siemon moved and Houck seconded to lower the value from $126070 to $100000. Voting Aye: 5; Nay: 0. The motion was adopted.
Appeal #17 – Record #5951 – Mobridge NWTS 1st Addn Lot 3 & 4 Block 9 - James Schlekeway
Martin moved and Houck seconded to lower the value from $131400 to $114000. Voting Aye: 5; Nay: 0. The motion was adopted.
Appeal #18 – Record #4765 – Mobridge Brown’s 1st Addn Lot 7 Block 1 - Amy Hintz
Martin moved and Siemon seconded to lower the value from $149230 to $114000. Voting Aye: 5; Nay: 0. The motion was adopted.
Appeal #19 – Record #5267 – Mobridge Grand Crossing Addn Lot 5 Block 33 - Bruce Rinehart
Houck moved and Martin seconded to lower the value from $40090 to $30090. Voting Aye: 5; Nay: 0 The motion was adopted.
Appeal #19 – Record #5845 – Mobridge MILW Land Co’s 1st Addn Lot 11 Block 25 - Bruce Rinehart
Houck moved and Martin seconded to leave as is $36810. Voting Aye: 5; Nay: 0. The motion was adopted.
Appeal #19 – Record #5405 – Mobridge Grand Crossing Addn W ½ of Lot 6 Block 54 - Bruce Rinehart
Siemon moved and Martin seconded to lower the value from $22210 to $13000. Voting Aye: 5; Nay: 0. The motion was adopted.
Appeal #20 – Record #5542 – Mobridge Jay-Kraft 2nd Addn Lot 12A Block 3 - Derek Stewart
Martin moved and Houck seconded to lower the value from $265805 to $252000. Voting Aye: 5; Nay: 0. The motion was adopted.
Appeal # 21 – Record #4704 – Mobridge Bel Aire 1st Addn, S 10’ of Lot 24 and all of Lot 25 Block 1 - Ray Miklos
Siemon moved and Houck seconded to lower the value from $123850 to $114000. Voting Aye: 5; Nay: 0. The motion was adopted.
Appeal #22 – Record #6412–Mobridge Shor Acres S ½ of Lot 101 & Shor Acres Lot 102 - Gregg Simon
Martin moved and Henderson seconded to leave as is $253160. Voting Aye: 5; Nay: 0. The motion was adopted.
Appeal # 23 – Record #5377 – Mobridge Grand Crossing Addn, Lot 11, Block 49 - Chastity Spiry
Houck moved and Martin seconded to lower the value from $39910 to $25000. Voting Aye: 5; Nay: 0. The motion was adopted.
Appeal #24 – Record #4715 – Mobridge Bel Aire 1st Addn Lot 30 Block 2 & Bel Aire 2nd Addn 1 subd E 11’ of Lot 29 Block 2 - William Voller
Siemon moved and Martin seconded to lower the value from $113750 to $76000. Voting Aye: 5; Nay: 0. The motion was adopted.
Appeal #25 – Record #5283 – Mobridge Grand Crossing Addn Lot 1 Block 37 - John Dady
Houck moved and Siemon seconded to lower the value from $62850 to $58860. Voting Aye: 5; Nay: 0. The motion was adopted.
Appeal #27 – Record # 5532–Mobridge Jay-Kraft 1st Addn E 17’ of Lot 1 & W 56’ of Lot 2 Block 3 - Darroll Aas
Martin moved and Siemon seconded to lower the value from $131170 to $92000. Voting Aye: 5; Nay: 0. The motion was adopted.
Henderson left the meeting.
Appeal #26 – Record #6247 – Mobridge Original Lots 8 & ( Block 3 - Steven Schatz
Siemon moved and Martin seconded to leave as is $133020. Voting Aye: 5; Nay: 0. The motion was adopted.
Appeal #28 – Record #6092 – Mobridge NWTS Co’s 2nd Addn - Dwight Schmitt
Martin moved and Houck seconded to lower the value from $250710 to $234000. Voting Aye: 5; Nay: 0. The motion was adopted.
Appeal #29 – Record #6112 – Mobridge NWTS Co’s 3rd Addn Lots 6 & 7 Block 26 - Jeffrey Piatt
Siemon moved and Houck seconded to lower the value from $108330 to $80000. Voting Aye: 5; Nay: 0. The motion was adopted.
Appeal #26 – Record #6187 – Mobridge NWTS Co’s 3rd Addn W 94’ of N 33’ of Lot 9 & W 94’ of S 25’ of Lot 10 Block 36 - Jamie Brockamp
Martin moved and Siemon seconded to lower the value from $91000 to $65000. Voting Aye: 5; Nay: 0. The motion was adopted.
Appeal #31 – Record #5427 – Mobridge Grand Crossing Addn Lot 8 Block 56 - Sarah Howell
Martin moved and Houck seconded to leave as si $41970. Voting Aye: 5; Nay: 0. The motion was adopted.
Appeal #33 – Record #6246 – Mobridge Original Lots 6 & 7 Block 3 - Jon Olson
Martin would like to table due to not enough information on commercial property. Martin amended motion to table. Died for lack of second. Martin moved and Siemon seconded to leave as is $125000. Voting Aye: 5; Nay: 0. The motion was adopted.
Appeal #34 – Record #4754 – Mobridge Bel Aire 2nd Subd Lot 26 Block 2 - Faye Krone
Martin moved and Siemon seconded to lower the value from $129900 to $94000. Voting Aye: 5; Nay: 0. The motion was adopted.
Appeal #35 – Record #5980 – Mobridge NWTS 1st Addn E 70’ of Lots 7 & 8 Block 12 - Lynn Holzwarth
Martin moved and Siemon seconded to lower the value from $107450 to $87000. Voting Aye: 5; Nay: 0. The motion was adopted.
Appeal #30 – Record #4743–Mobridge Bel Aire 2nd Subd Lot 14 Ex the NE 10’ & A Tract 16’x25’ in SW Corner & Lot 17 Block 2 - Robert Keller
Siemon moved and Houck seconded to lower the value from $99510 to $95000. Voting Aye: 5; Nay: 0. The motion was adopted.
Appeal #32 – Record#5606 – Mobridge Main Park Lot 12 & S ½ of Lot 13 Block 10 - Harold Perman
Houck moved and Martin seconded to leave as is $86950. Voting Aye: 5; Nay: 0. The motion was adopted.
Appeal #39 – Record #6139 – Mobridge NWTS 3rd Addn Lot 6 Block 30 - Ruth Fischer
Martin moved and Houck seconded to lower the value from $110370 to $105000. Voting Aye: 5; Nay: 0. The motion was adopted.
Appeal #40 – Record #5917 – Mobridge NWTS 1st Addn N 22.5’ of Lot 10; All of Lot 11 & S 22 1/2’ Lot 12 Block 2 - Leland Berndt
Martin moved and Siemon seconded to lower the value from $168350 to $126000. Voting Aye: 5; Nay: 0. The motion was adopted.
Siemon left the meeting.
Appeal #42 – Record #5985/5986 – Mobridge NWTS 1st Addn Lot 5 & N 32’ of Lot 6 Block 13 - Alan Nelson
Martin moved and Houck seconded to lower the value from $96850 to $65000. Voting Aye: 5; Nay: 0. The motion was adopted.
Appeal #43 – Record #5960 – Mobridge NWTS 1st Addn Lots 1 & 2 Block 10 - Dennis Wheeler
Martin moved and Houck seconded to lower the value from $157650 to $145000. Voting Aye: 5; Nay: 0. The motion was adopted.
Appeal #44 – Record #6143 – Mobridge NWTS Co’s 3rd Addn S ½ Lot 2 & All of Lots 3 & 4 Block 31 - Robert Maisch
Martin moved and Houck seconded to lower the value from $140280 to $88000. Voting Aye: 5; Nay: 0. The motion was adopted.
Appeal #45 – Record #5848 – Mobridge MILW Land Co’s 1st Addn, Lot 2, Block 26 - Charles Sanger
Martin moved and Houck seconded to lower the value from $6360 to $2000. Voting Aye: 5; Nay: 0. The motion was adopted.
Appeal #45 – Record #5847 – Mobridge MILW Land Co’s 1st Addn Lot 1 Bloack 26 - Diane Sanger
Martin moved and Houck seconded to lower the value from $25380 to $20000. Voting Aye: 5; Nay: 0. The motion was adopted.
Appeal #46 – Record #6098 – Mobridge NWTS Co’s 2nd Addn N 17’ of Lot 13 & All Lot 14 Block 24 - Lane Goldsmith
Martin moved and Houck seconded to lower the value from $138710 to $90765. Voting Aye: 5; Nay: 0. The motion was adopted.
Appeal #47 – Record #4756 –Mobridge Broe’s Sub Lot 6 & S 20’ of Lot 7 Block 1 - Mary Ann Knudson
Martin moved and Houck seconded to lower the value from $183330 to $130000. Voting Aye: 5; Nay: 0. The motion was adopted.
Appeal #47 – Record #4757 – Mobridge Broe’s Sub In S W 4 NW 4 19-124-79 N 40’ - Mary Ann Knudson
Houck moved and Martin seconded to leave as is $10740. Voting Aye: 5; Nay: 0. The motion was adopted.
Appeal #36 – Record #6070 – Mobridge NWTS Co’s 2nd Addn Lot 14 Block 21 - Jack Perman
Houck moved and Martin seconded to lower the value from $99810 to $87550. Voting Aye: 5; Nay: 0. The motion was adopted.
Appeal #37 – Record #4740 – Moridge Bel Aire 2nd Addn 2nd Subd Lot 12 & S 25’ Lot 13 Block 2 -James Silbernagel
Martin moved and Houck seconded to lower the value from $193460 to $176000. Voting Aye: 5; Nay: 0. The motion was adopted.
Appeal #38 – Record #5918 – Mobridge NWTS 1st Addn N 22 ½’ of Lot 12 & all Lot 13 & S 7 ½’ of Lot 14 Block 2 - Raymond Quenzer
Martin moved and Houck seconded to leave as is $208770. Voting Aye: 5; Nay: 0. The motion was adopted.
Appeal #38 – Record #5676 – Mobridge Main Park Lots 13 & 14 Block 19 - Raymond Quenzer
Martin moved and Houck seconded to leave as is $36240. Voting Aye: 5; Nay: 0. The motion was adopted.
Appeal #41 – Record #6111 – Mobridge NWTS Co’s 3rd Addn Lots 3, 4 & 5 - Roger Heumiller
Martin moved and Houck seconded to lower the value from $246210 to $183000. Voting Aye: 5; Nay: 0. The motion was adopted.
Appeal #41 – Record #6113 – Mobridge NWts Co’s 3rd Addn Lots 8 thru 12 - Elizabeth Krause
Martin moved and Houck seconded to lower the value from $222240 to $152000. Voting Aye: 5; Nay: 0. The motion was adopted.
ADJOURN:
Martin moved and Siemon seconded that the Walworth County/Consolidated Board of Equalization adjourn. Voting Aye: 4; Nay: 00. The motion was adopted.
______
SCOTT SCHILLING, CHAIRMAN
ATTEST:
____________
REBECCA KREIN, AUDITOR