Date: 2007-07-06
ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 29/WG 1
(ITU-T SG16)
Coding of Still Pictures
JBIG JPEG
Joint Bi-level Image Joint Photographic
Experts Group Experts Group
TITLE:Resolutions of the 42nd ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 29/WG1 Meeting,
2007-07-02/06, Lausanne, Switzerland
SOURCE:WG1 Convener
PROJECT:JPEG, JBIG
STATUS: Resolutions adopted at the 42nd WG1 Lausanne Meeting
REQUESTED
ACTION:Forward to SC 29 Secretariat for appropriate action
DISTRIBUTION:WG 1, SC 29 Secretariat
Contact:
ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 29/WG 1 Convener - Dr. Daniel T. Lee
eBay Inc., 2145 Hamilton Avenue, San Jose, California95125
eBay China Development Center, Shanghai German Center, 88 Keyuan Road, Zhangjiang Hi-Tech Park, Pudong, Shanghai 201203, China
Tel: +1 408 219 4709 Fax: +1 253 830 0372, E-mail:
1
Resolutions of 42nd WG1 Lausanne Meeting
Title: Resolutions of the 42nd ISO/IEC JTC1/SC29/WG1 Meeting,
2007-07-02/06, Lausanne, Switzerland
Source: ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 29/WG 1
Date: 2007-07-06
JPEG Part 1 (10918-1)
No action.
JBIG-2 (14492)
Resolution 1– Request for National Bodies to participate in mailing list
The JBIG group requests National Bodies to inform their members that an email reflector should be created by July 15, 2007. The address is . To subscribe, JPEG/JBIG members may send an email to .
Resolution 2– Request for participation at 43rd WG1 Kobe Meeting
The JBIG group requests that interested contributors attend the 43rd WG1 Kobe meeting, The JBIG group will arrange for its meeting to start one day early, on Sunday, November 11 in Kobe. Logistical details will be posted to the mailing list.
JPEG 2000 Part 1: Core Coding System
Resolution 3– Approval of ISO/IEC 15444-1:2006 Defect Report
WG 1 approves ISO/IEC 15444-1:2004 Defect Report (WG1N4308).
JPEG 2000 Part 2: Extensions
No action.
JPEG 2000 Ad Hoc Group on Digital Cinema
Resolution 4–Approval of the Digital Cinema AHG meeting report
WG1 approves the Digital Cinema AHG Meeting Report in WG1N4314.
Resolution 5– Approval of call for information for Broadcast Applications
WG1 approves the Call for Information for Broadcast Applications (WG1N4309).
Resolution 6- Approval of Call for Proposals for Film Archive Applications
WG1 approves the Call for Proposals for Film Archive Applications in document WG1N4303 and approves the submission of the document to SMPTE DC28, SC29/WG11 and interested parties for appropriate distribution.
.
JPEG 2000 Part 3: Motion JPEG 2000
See Part 12.
JPEG 2000 Part 4: Conformance testing
No action.
JPEG 2000 Part 5: Reference Software
No action.
JPEG 2000 Part 6: Compound Image File Format
No action.
JPEG 2000 Part 8: JPSEC
Resolution 7- Approval of JPSEC AHG meeting report
WG1 approves the JPSEC Ad Hoc Group Lausanne meeting report contained in WG1N4311.
Resolution 8 – Approval of ISO/IEC 15444-8/FPDAM1
WG1 authorizes JPSEC AMD 1 editors to finalize and submit the FPDAM document WG1N4313 before July 10, 2007 and requests the SC29 Secretariat to start balloting. The current study text is available in document WG1 N4312.
JPEG 2000 Part 9: JPIP
Resolution 9– Approval of the JPIP AHG meeting report
WG1 approves the JPIP AHG Meeting report from the Lausanne WG1 meeting, contained in document WG1N4297.
Resolution 10– Approval of ISO/IEC 15444-9:2005/PDAM4
WG 1 approves ISO/IEC 15444-9:2005/PDAM4 in document WG1N4298 and request the SC29 Secretariat to start balloting.
JPEG 2000 Part 10: JP3D
Resolution 11– Approval of JPEG2000 Part 10 JP3D AHG meeting report
WG1 approves the Part 10 (JP3D) Ad Hoc meeting report contained in WG1N4321.
Resolution 12– Approval of JPEG2000 Part 10 JP3D Core Experiments 5.0
WG1 approves the ISO/IEC 15444-10 Core Experiments 5.0 contained in WG1N4322.
JPEG 2000 Part 11: JPWL
Resolution 13– Approval of JPWL AHG Meeting Report
WG1 approves JPWL AHG meeting report in WG1N4316.
Resolution 14– Request for minor enhancement (AMD1) to JPWL
WG1 approves the request for minor enhancement (AMD1) to JPWL as contained in WG1N4317.
Resolution 15– Call for Proposals for JPWL AMD 1 – JPWL for IP Based Wireless Networks Technologies
WG1 approves the JPWL Call for Proposals for JPWL AMD 1 – IP Based Wireless Networks as contained in WG1N4320.
JPEG 2000 Part 12: ISO Media base format
No Action
JPEG 2000 Part 13: An Entry Level Encoder
Resolution 16–Request of action on patent declarations
WG 1 requests the NBs, including those not attending the 41st WG1 San Jose meeting, to report what actions were taken to confirm that no organizations in each NB, other than those listed in document WG 1 N 3869R, do own the related patents to JPEG 2000 Part 13, if not reported yet. Also WG 1 will continue the effort to receive 2.1 conditions from the organizations holding class-A patents.
JPEG 2000 Part 14: JPEG 2000 XML Structure (JPXML)
Resolution 17– Common Text with ITU-T SG 16
WG 1 recommends ISO/IEC 15444-14 be published as common text as a mode of cooperation with ITU-T.
Resolution 18- Call for contribution for ISO/IEC 15444-14
WG1 approves the Call for contribution (WG1N4334) for ISO/IEC 15444-14 and encourages National Bodies and experts to distribute it to interested parties.
Resolution 19- Approval of JPXML meeting report
WG1 approves the report of JPXML AHG meeting held at the 42nd WG1 Lausanne Meeting, as contained in WG1N4323.
JPEG 2000 Requirements and Profile AHG
See Advanced Image Coding.
JPEG 2000 Work Plan
Resolution 20– Approval of JPEG 2000 Work Plan
WG1 approves and re-affirms the following revised work plan for 15444 JPEG 2000:
Part / Title / CFP / WD / CD / FCD / FDIS / IS1 / JPEG 2000 Image Coding System: Core Coding System / 97/03 / 99/03 / 99/12 / 00/03 / 00/10 / 00/12
Cons.04/09
2 / JPEG 2000 Image Coding System: Extensions / 97/03 / 00/03 / 00/08 / 00/12 / 01/07 / 01/11
Cons.04/05
3 / Motion JPEG 2000 / 99/12 / 00/07 / 00/12 / 01/03 / 01/07 / 01/11
4 / Conformance Testing / 99/12 / 00/07 / 00/12 / 01/07 / 02/02 / 02/05
5 / Reference Software / 99/12 / 00/03 / 00/07 / 00/12 / 01/08 / 01/11
6 / JPM: Compound Image File Format / 97/03 / 00/12 / 01/03 / 01/11 / 02/11 / 03/04
7 / --withdrawn--
8 / JPSEC: Secure JPEG 2000 / 02/03 / 02/10 / 04/04 / 04/11 / 05/11 / 06/07
9 / JPIP: Interactivity tools, APIs and protocols / 02/03 / 02/07 / 03/03 / 03/07 / 04/04 / 04/10
10 / JP3D: Extensions for three dimensional data / 02/03 / 02/10 / 06/07 / 06/11 / 07/04 / 07/11
11 / JPWL: Wireless / 02/07 / 03/07 / 04/07 / 05/03 / 05/11 / 07/04
12 / ISO Media File Format / 02/10 / 02/10 / 02/10 / 02/10 / 03/03 / 03/07
13 / An entry level JPEG 2000 encoder / 04/07 / 04/07 / 05/03 / 06/09 / 07/04 / 07/06
14 / XML Structure Representation and Reference / 07/07 / 07/11 / 08/03 / 08/07 / 08/11 / 09/03
Part-AMD / Title / WD / PDAM / FPDAM / FDAM / AMD
1-AMD1
(2000) / JPEG 2000 Image Coding System: Part1 AMD1 / 00/07 / 00/08 / 01/03 / 01/07 / 01/11
1-AMD2
(2000) / JPEG 2000 Image Coding System: Part1 AMD2 / 00/12 / 01/03 / 01/07 / 02/05 / 02/07
1-AMD1 (2004) / JPEG 2000 Image Coding System: Part1 AMD1: Profile for digital cinema applications / 04/11 / 04/11 / 05/03 / 05/07 / 05/11
1-AMD2 (2004) / JPEG 2000 Image Coding System: Part1 AMD2: Extended profiles for digital cinema applications / 07/11 / 08/03 / 08/07 / 08/11 / 09/03
2-AMD1
(2002) / JPEG 2000 Image Coding System: Part2 AMD1: Enhancement to quantization method / 01/06 / 01/07 / 01/11 / 02/03 / 02/05
2-AMD2
(2002) / JPEG 2000 Image Coding System: Part2 AMD2 : Extended capabilities marker segment / 03/07 / 03/12 / 04/07 / 04/11 / 05/02
3-AMD1 / JPEG 2000 Image Coding System: Part3 AMD1: (Moved To Part12) / 01/10 / 01/11 / 02/03 / 02/10 / 02/12
3-AMD2 / JPEG 2000 Image Coding System: Part3 AMD2: Motion JPEG 2000 derived from ISO base media file format / 01/10 / 01/11 / 02/03 / 02/10 / 02/12
3-AMD3 / JPEG 2000 Image Coding System: Part3 AMD3: Definition of compliance points and testing for Motion JPEG 2000 / 02/03 / 02/07 / 02/11 / 03/12 / 04/07
5-AMD1 / JPEG 2000 Image Coding System: Part5 AMD 1:Reference software for the JP2 file format / 01/07 / 01/07 / 01/11 / 03/03 / 03/05
6-AMD1 / JPEG 2000 Image Coding System: Part6
AMD 1: Hidden text metadata / 04/07 / 05/03 / 06/07 / 06/11 / 07/07
8-AMD1 / JPEG 2000 Image Coding System: Part8 AMD1: File Format Security / 05/07 / 07/04 / 07/07 / 07/11 / 08/03
8-AMD2 / JPEG 2000 Image Coding System: Part8 AMD2: JPSEC conformance tests and bitstreams / 05/11 / 07/11 / 08/03 / 08/07 / 08/11
9-AMD1 / JPEG 2000 Image Coding System: Part9
AMD1: API's, metadata, and editing / 04/11 / 05/03 / 05/07 / 06/01 / 06/07
9-AMD2 / JPEG 2000 Image Coding System: Part9
AMD2: JPIP server and client profiles / 05/07 / 07/11 / 08/03 / 08/07 / 08/11
9-AMD3 / JPEG 2000 Image Coding System: Part9
AMD3: JPIP Extensions / 06/03 / 06/07 / 06/11 / 07/03 / 07/07
9-AMD4 / JPEG 2000 Image Coding System: Part9
AMD4: Extensions for 3-Dimensional and higher dimensional images / 07/04 / 07/07 / 07/11 / 08/03 / 08/07
11-AMD1 / JPEG 2000 Image Coding System: Part11 AMD1 / 07/11 / 08/03 / 08/07 / 08/11 / 09/03
12-AMD1 / JPEG 2000 Image Coding System: Part12 AMD1 / 05/11 / 05/11 / 06/03 / 06/07 / 06/11
12-AMD2 / JPEG 2000 Image Coding System: Part12 AMD2 / 05/11 / 06/03 / 06/06 / 06/11 / 07/03
JPSearch (ISO/IEC 24800)
Resolution 21– Approval of JPSearch meeting report
WG1 approves the JPSearch meeting report in 42nd WG1 Lausanne Meeting as contained in document WG1N4318.
Resolution 22– Liaison response to SC29/WG11
WG1 approves the liaison document from WG1 to WG11 concerning the MPEG-7 Query Format as contained in WG1N4319.
Resolution 23– Replacement of JPSearch Co-Chair
WG1 thanks Wo Chang (USA) for his efforts and contributions as he steps down as Co-Chair of JPSearch.
JPSearch nominates Dr. Frederic Dufaux (Switzerland) to succeed Wo Chang in the position.
JPSearch Work Plan
Resolution 24– Approval of JPSearch Work plan
WG1 approves and re-affirms the following work plan for ISO/IEC 24800 JPSearch:
Part / Title / WD / PDTR / DTR / TR1 / System framework and components / 05/07 / 06/07 / 07/04 / 07/07
Part / Title / CFP / WD / CD / FCD / FDIS / IS
2 / Schema and ontology registration and identification / 06/11 / 07/11 / 08/03 / 08/07 / 08/11 / 09/03
3 / JPSearch Query Format / 06/11 / 07/11 / 08/03 / 08/07 / 08/11 / 09/03
4 / Metadata embedded in image data (JPEG and JPEG 2000) file format / 06/11 / 07/11 / 08/03 / 08/07 / 08/11 / 09/03
5 / Data interchange format between image repositories / 06/11 / 07/11 / 08/03 / 08/07 / 08/11 / 09/03
JPEG HD Photo Ad-hoc Group
Resolution 25– Approval of HD Photo AHG Report
WG1 approves the report of the HD Photo evaluation AHG reports contained in WG1N4300 and WG1N4302. WG1 also recommends that the work on quantitative testing and its correlation with subjective testing be continued through the AIC AHG.
Resolution 26– Test Image Collection
WG1 appreciates the efforts made by the HD Photo AHG to collect and collate useful test imagery, and thanks Tim Bruylants and Dr. Peter Schelkens for their kind offer to host an ftp server for its distribution. It recognizes the need to collect 'difficult' or otherwise important test items, and recommends that (subject to a recognition of the source), a freely distributable collection of such items should be started, together with as much relevant metadata on each image as possible, in order to bring WG1's collection up to date. WG1 requests contributions, particularly from working photographers, and of collections of textures to the test image collection.
Resolution 27– New work item – JPEG Suite
WG1 acknowledges the conclusions and proposals from the HD Photo AHG contained in WG1N4301 and WG1N4302, to start a new work item under the general banner of the 'JPEG Suite'. This will comprise of two parts as described in WG1N4301, containing as first part a Technical Report and a second part defining a normative version of the proposals presented by Microsoft in their HD Photo submission at the 41st WG1 San Jose Meeting. WG1 submits WG1N4301 to SC29 for immediate letter ballot as a new work item. WG1 members are encouraged to invite their membership and contacts to participate actively in this new work item, and the PR AHG andWG1 webmaster are requested to prepare appropriate information for public release.
Resolution 28– New Work Item - JPEG Suite - Part 1, Imaging Systems Integration, Technical Report
WG1 appoints Lou Sharpe (USA) as the editor and Robert Rossi (USA) and Richard Clark (UK) as co-editors, subject to the agreement of their respective organizations. Contributions and input are requested from WG1 members.
Resolution 29– New Work Item - JPEG Suite - Part 2, JPEG-XR - Photographic coding for digital camera applications
WG1 appoints Dr. Sridhar Srinivasan (USA) as the editor and Richard Clark (UK) and Aharon Gill (IL) as co-editors, subject to the agreement of their respective organizations. WG1 agrees to use Microsoft's proposed technology (HD Photo) as presented in 41st WG1 San Jose Meeting as a basis and starting point for this part, and requests the JPEG PR chairs and Microsoft to give this a high level of co-ordinated publicity in order to increase participation and industry feedback for the 43rd WG1 Kobe Meeting and the 44th WG1 Hollywood Meeting.
Resolution 30 – Liaison Statement to ISO TC42, ITU-T SG-16, JTC1/SC24, IEC TC100, IPTC, IFRA
WG1 approves the liaison statement template given in WG1N4333 concerning JPEG Suite and JPEG-XR proposed new work item as a basis for liaison statements to ISO TC42, ITU-T SG-16, JTC1/SC24, IEC TC100, IPTC and IFRA and appoints the WG1 webmaster to finalize and distribute these liaison statements via SC29 secretariat.
Resolution 31– Approval of JPEG-Suite Workplan
WG1 approves and re-affirms the following work plan for JPEG Suite:
Part / Title / WD / PDTR / DTR / TR1 / JPEG Suite / 07/11 / 08/03 / 08/07 / 08/11
Part / Title / CFP / WD / CD / FCD / FDIS / IS
2 / JPEG-XR / -- / -- / 07/11 / 08/03 / 08/07 / 08/11
Resolution 32– JPEG and JPEG Suite presentation at 43rd WG1 Kobe MeetingWG1 requests the JNB to provide time and facilities (preferably on Tuesday or Thursday pm) at the 43rd WG1 Kobe Meeting for an open meeting and general presentation on JPEG skills and technologies. Robert Rossi (USA) is requested to be the organizer for this event, WG1 members are requested to consider positive and informative presentations of technology, offers for which should be forwarded to Robert Rossi by 15th September for potential inclusion in the program. The intent is to provide an introduction to JPEG for potential new members and liaison organizations, and to allow for valuable debate on what features and methods should be profiled or standardized within the JPEG Suite initiative.
Resolution 33– Closure of HD Photo AHG and creation of JPEG Suite and JPEG-XR AHGs
WG1 thanks Richard Clark (UK) for leading the discussion on HD Photo through the AHG, and closes this activity. Two new AHGs are to be set up to progress the work program planned, with appropriate closed email reflectors requested from the WG1 Webmaster. These will have the email addresses and . The Webmaster is requested to transfer membership of the HD Photo email list to the jpegxr reflector. Richard Clark (UK) is appointed as Chair of the Suite AHG in preparation for 43rd WG1 Kobe Meeting, and Dr. Sridhar Srinivasan (USA) as the Chair of the JPEG-XR AHG.
Advanced image coding (AIC)
Resolution 34– Approval of AIC scope and evaluation document
WG1 approves the document on AIC scope and evaluation in WG1N4326 and invites National Bodies and delegates to provide comments and feedback on this document by 43rd WG1Kobe Meeting.
Resolution 35– Approval of AIC call for evidence and potential technologies (working document)
WG1 approves the document AIC call for evidence and potential technologies in WG1N4325 and invites National Bodies to distribute it through appropriate channels.
Resolution 36– Approval of Call for Advanced Image Coding (AIC) evaluation methodologies and technology examples for validation
WG1 approves the document AIC call for contributions in WG1N4324 and invites National Bodies to distribute it through appropriate channels.
Resolution 37–Approval of AIC meeting report
WG1 approves the meeting report of AIC as in document WG1N4328.
Liaisons/Responses
Resolution 38– Approval of the liaison response to SMPTE
WG1 approves the liaison document from WG1 to SMPTE concerning Digital Cinema as contained in WG1N4307.
Resolution 39– Approval of liaison statement to WG 11
WG1 approves the Liaison Statement from SC29/WG1 to WG11 on Film Archive Applications as contained in WG1N4315.
Resolution 40– Approval of establishment of a category C liaison with IFRA
WG1 approves the establishment of a category C Liaison with IFRA as described in document WG1N4335.
JPEG Historical Archive Group
Resolution 41– Request for support of Historical Archive AHG
WG1 requests NB’s to nominate individuals willing to assist in the creation of metadata records for historical archive documents waiting for upload.
Administration and Other Business
Resolution 42– Webmaster's report and WG1 web site
WG1 thanks the Webmaster (and Elysium Ltd) for the verbal report and their maintenance of the JPEG web site, which is a key factor in JPEG's work processes. WG1 also thanks the US NB for their generous contribution to the expenses of running the web site, following the 41st WG1 San Jose meeting, and requests that other NBs organizing JPEG meetings also consider an appropriate levy on the meeting fee to be used for supporting the web site development. WG1 members are requested to consider additional sponsorship of the web site in order to improve its quality and timeliness. WG1 requests that since non-English languages content on the site appears to be significantly out of date, the Webmaster should disable these language variants unless active participants are found to maintain page content. WG1 also requests web contributions from its members, and for AHG members to provide adequate and up to date content to the Webmaster, particularly in the light of the likely interest to be generated through the new standardization work on the JPEG Suite.
Resolution 43– Approval of website maintenance fee
WG1 approves a facilities fee of 5,000 Yen to be collected at the 43rd WG1 Kobe meeting for the purpose of the maintenance of WG1 website.
Resolution 44– WG1 Registration Authority Selection
WG1 thanks Intellectual Resources Initiative (IRI), Japan, for their interest to serve as the Registration Authority for ISO/IEC 15444-8 and providing a detailed response to WG1 (WG1 N4287). After careful review WG1 has determined that IRI is suited to perform the task. WG 1 therefore requests the SC 29 secretariat to issue the ballot asking for IRI to be appointed Registration Authority for ISO/IEC 15444-8.
Resolution 45– WG 1 affirmation of IP guideline statement submission
WG 1 re-affirms its support for its IP guideline statement first approved at the 16th WG 1 Seoul Meeting, March 1999.
“WG 1 requires all participants within all National Bodies to disclose and identify any and all patent rights and the specific technologies within the Verification Model to which they apply. Further, WG 1 requires this disclosure and identification at the time of submission of technology for VM consideration if submitted by the patent holder or no later than one meeting after submission of technology if the technology is not submitted by the patent holder. Further, WG 1 requires that the form contained in WG 1 N1267 be completed as part of this disclosure. This request is in accordance with Common Patent Policy for ITU-T/ITU-R/ISO/IEC, clause 3.”
The relevant ISO/IEC directives are contained in the integration group report, WG1N1262.
Resolution 46– WG1 affirmation of SC 29 resolution on IPR guidelines
WG1 complies with the Resolution 8: “SC 29 IPR Guidelines” of the 16th SC 29 Plenary Meeting, 2003-07-28/30, Trondheim, Norway
“SC 29 affirms and supports Common Patent Policy for ITU-T/ITU-R/ISO/IEC that requires a party that submits a technology contribution for proposed inclusion in any SC 29 standard to disclose to the WG the existence of patents or published pending patent applications, hereafter referred to as "IP rights", of which the party is personally aware and which the party considers to cover any item of its contribution.
"[Clause 3, Guidelines for Implementation of the Common Patent Policy for ITU-T/ITU-R/ISO/IEC]
“any party participating in the work of the Organizations should, from the outset, draw their attention to any known patent or to any known pending patent application, either their own or of other organizations.”
SC 29 affirms Common Patent Policy for ITU-T/ITU-R/ISO/IEC of only considering for inclusion in a standard (unless the ISO Council authorizes an exception) technology that is either 1) free of IP rights, or 2) available to all implementers of the standard without a royalty or license fee and under other reasonable and non-discriminatory ("RAND") terms and conditions, or 3) available to all implementers of the standard for a reasonable royalty/license fee and under other RAND terms and conditions.
Although royalty-bearing patented technologies may be included in SC 29 standards, SC 29 suggests to its WGs to promote, whenever possible, the inclusion of technologies that either do not require a patent license, or that only require a RAND license without a royalty or license fee. Additionally, SC 29 encourages disclosure by the IP rights holder of the type of licensing under which these IP rights will be made available for conforming implementations of ISO/IEC standards after final publication -- that is either 1) royalty/license fee-free and under other RAND terms and conditions, or 2) reasonable royalty/license fee and under other RAND terms and conditions. Negotiations regarding specific licensing terms and conditions are left to the parties concerned and are performed outside of SC 29. Further, SC 29 requires software and technology contained in any party's contribution to an SC 29 standard to be made available by such party to all members of the SC 29 WG developing such standard, on a royalty- and license fee-free basis, solely for the purpose of testing and developing such standard and only until publication of the standard.”