ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 29/WG 1 N2208
Date: 2001 July 06
ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 29/WG 1(ITU-T SG8)
Coding of Still Pictures
JBIG JPEG
Joint Bi-level Image Joint Photographic
Experts Group Experts Group
TITLE:24th ISO/IEC JTC1/SC29/WG1 Meeting, Stockholm, Sweden,
July 02-06, 2000, Resolutions
SOURCE:WG1
PROJECT:JPEG, JBIG
STATUS: Adopted Resolutions
REQUESTED
ACTION:Forward to SC29 Secretariat for appropriate action
DISTRIBUTION:WG1, SC29 Secretariat
Contact:
ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 29/WG 1 Convener - Dr. Daniel T. Lee
Yahoo!, Rm 2802, Sunning Plaza, 10 Hysan Avenue, Causeway Bay, Hong Kong
Tel: +1 408 349 7051/+852 2882 3898, Fax: +1 253 830 0372, E-mail:
1
1
Resolutions of 24th WG1 Stockholm Meeting
Title: Resolutions of the 24th ISO/IEC JTC1 SC29 WG1 Meeting, Stockholm, Sweden, 2000-07/03/07
Source: ISO/IEC JTC1 SC29/WG1
JBIG
See Appendix.
JPEG-LS
No Action, see Resolution 9.
JPEG 2000, Part 1 and Part 2
Resolution 1– Part 1 Corrigendum 1
WG1 approves the Part 1 Corrigendum 1 Final text contained in WG1N2211 and request editor to submit it to SC29 Secretariat for processing.
Resolution 2– Part 1 Corrigendum 2
WG1 approves the Part 1 Draft Corrigendum 2 contained in WG1N2212 and request editor to submit it to SC29 Secretariat for processing.
Resolution 3– Part 2 FDIS Balloting
WG1 approves the Part 2 FDIS study text contained in WG1N2215 and authorizes the editors to complete the final FDIS text by July 31, 2001 and circulate such text to all HODs for final inspection. Upon approval from HOD’s by August 6, 2001, the editor will submit the final text to SC29 Secretariat for balloting.
Resolution 4– Approval Part 2 FCD DOCR
WG1 approves the FCD DOCR contained in WG1N2214.
Core Experiments / Verification Model Ah Hoc Group
Resolution 5– Approval of the JPEG 2000 Core Experiments ad hoc group report
WG1 approves the report of the JPEG 2000 Core Experiment ad hoc group in WG1N2262.
File Format Sub-Group
Resolution 6– Approval of the JPEG 2000 File Format subgroup group report
WG1 approves the report of the JPEG 2000 File Format subgroup in WG1N2256.
Resolution 7– Registration Authority
WG1 requests the French NB and JURA consider taking care of the registration needs of the JPEG 2000 Part 1 and Part 2 file formats. Requirements and scope are described in JPEG 2000 Part 2 Annex M.7. WG1 requests the File Format Subgroup chair to contact the chair of JURA on this request.
Requirements Ad Hoc Group
Resolution 8– Approval of JPEG2000 Requirements and Profiles document
WG1 establishes an ad hoc group co-chaired by Dr. Touradj Ebrahimi (Swiss) and Mr. Eric Edwards (USA) to finalize and approve Version 7.0 of the Requirements and Profiles document (WG1N2263).
IPR Activities
Resolution 9– IPR related requests from Contributors
WG1 wishes to confirm that in order for the ITU to grant final approval in February 2002 on JPEG 2000 and JPEG LS Part 2 standards, the so called “Final Call” process in the new ITU approval mode, the ITU requires that the final official IPR declaration forms should be submitted for filing to the ITU TSB Director, Mr. H. Zhao, as soon as possible (desired by September 24, 2001 latest). The form of the statement can be found under under ITU-T, IPR-databases. The address is: ITU, TSB Director, Place de Nations, CH-2021 Geneve, Switzerland.
Please note, that currently it is still not sufficient to send the statements to ISO/IEC only. If the statements are not sent to the ITU-T, the names of the respective IPR contributors will be taken off from the relevant standards.
WG1 has identified the following IPR holders, who still need to send IPR statements to the ITU:
For JPEG 2000 – Part1 (T.800):
Sony
Lura Tech
Lizard Tech
Digital Accelerator Corp.
Canon
Prima Comp.
Sarnoff
Sharp
HP
IBM
For JPEG 2000 – Part2 (T.801):
Xerox
Motorola Australia
For JPEG-LS Extentions (Draft ITU-T T.870)
Canon
HP
JPEG 2000, Part 1 Amendment 1
Resolution 10– Part 1 Amendment 1 progression
WG1 establishes an ad hoc group chaired by Mr. Takahiro Fukuhara (Japan) to prepare final FDAM-1 text contained in WG1N2221 and final DOCR to FPDAM-1 contained in WG1N2222 and then submit the FDAM-1 text to all HODs for examination by July 15, 2001. Upon positive replies from HODs the editor will submit such text to the SC29 Secretariat for balloting.
JPEG 2000, Part 1 Amendment 2
Resolution 11– Part 1 Amendment 2 progression
WG1 approves the DOCR to PDAM-2 contained in WG1N2224 and the FPDAM-2 text contained in WG1N2223 and requests the SC29 Secretariat for balloting.
JPEG 2000, Part 2 Amendment 1
Resolution 12– Approval of Part II Amendment 1
WG1 requests that SC29 approve the establishment of AMD 1 to the JPEG 2000 image coding system Part 2 [JTC1 29.14.02 (15444-2) standard]. This enhancement is based on the requirement in remote sensing applications to specify quantization step sizes on a precinct-by-precinct basis, thus assuring accurate rate control in a low memory implementation.
Project No. JTC1 29.14
Target Dates: WD2001-6 / PDAM:2001-7 / FPDAM:2001-11 / FDAM:2002-3 / AMD 2002-5
Editor: Dr. Michael Marcellin (USA)
Co-Editor: Dr. Janet Rountree (USA)
Supporting National Bodies: USA, France, Japan, Sweden, UK.
Scope: Within the scope of JTC 29:14 (15444) JPEG 2000 image coding system
WG1 requests that SC29 circulate this for ballot as appropriate.
This amendment is supported by Core Experiment report WG1N2155, demonstrating a negligible loss in PSNR when the proposed methodology is adopted. The proposed PDAM text is contained in WG1N2175.
Resolution 13– Part 2 Amendment 1 progression
WG1 approves the PDAM1 to JPEG 2000 Part 2 as contained in WG1N2175R and request SC29 to start the PDAM ballot immediately. WG1 approves the establishment of standing ad hoc group chaired by Dr. Janet Rountree (USA) on Part 2 AMD 1.
JPEG 2000 Part 3: Motion JPEG 2000
Resolution 14– Approval of the Motion JPEG 2000 Meeting Report
WG1 approves the Motion JPEG 2000 Meeting Report contained in WG1N2253.
Resolution 15– Approval of AHG to update the FCD DOCR and Distribute the FDIS
WG1 appoints an AHG chaired by Mr. Eric Edwards (USA) to complete the DOCR (N2248) FCD 15444-3 by August 17, 2001 and to circulate to the HODs for one week for approval. WG1 appoints an AHG chaired by MR. Eric Edwards (USA) to complete the FDIS (N2250) by August 17, 2001 and to circulate the FDIS to the HODs for approval prior to forwarding to the SC29 secretariat to begin the balloting process.
Resolution 16– VM Technical Description 5.0
The MJP2 AHG requests WG1 distribute Motion JPEG 2000 VM Technical Description (WG1N2252) to the NB HOD for distribution to their members. Comments are requested to be submitted by 25th WG1 Sydney meeting where Motion JPEG 2000 VM Technical Description will be created.
Resolution 17– IP statement request for contributors
WG1 requests that companies claiming IP on technology in the JPEG 2000 Part 3 CD comply with WG1 request for IP statements including the terms and conditions of use. Further, WG1 requests that experts identify and report potential IP contained in the JPEG 2000 Part 3 CD.
Resolution 18- AHG to Study Electronic Cinema Capture and Editing Requirements
The AHG requests WG1 establish an AHG under Part 3 to study and report on the requirements for archiving and editing source content. Group to be chaired by Dr. Siegfried Foessel (Germany).
JPEG 2000 Part 4: Conformance testing
Resolution 19– Approval of the Conformance Testing ad hoc group report
WG1 approves the report of the Conformance Testing ad hoc group in WG1N2240.
Resolution 20– FCD Balloting
WG1 approves the FCD text contained in WG1N2236 and requests that the SC29 circulate for balloting by July 16, 2001.
Resolution 21– Approval CD DOCR
WG1 approves the CD DOCR contained in WG1N2239 and submit to SC29 Secretariat for processing.
JPEG 2000 Part 5: Reference Software
Resolution 22– Approval of the JPEG 2000 Part 5: Reference Software FDIS and DOCR
WG1 establishes an ad hoc group chaired by Mr. Richard Clark (UK) to finalize the JPEG 2000 Part 5 FDIS text as (which will be contained in WG1N2270) by August 1, 2001 and to circulate to all HODs for examination. Upon majority positive replies, the chair will submit such text to SC29 to start FDIS ballot process upon completion. Part 5 study text is available for National Body review in WG1N2269. WG1 approves the Part 5 FCD DOCR contained in WG1N2160R.
Resolution 23– Approval of Part 5 Amendment 1
WG1 requests that SC29 approve the establishment of AMD 1 to the JPEG 2000 image coding system Part V [JTC1 29.14.02 (15444-2) standard]. This enhancement will add support for the JPEG 2000 Part I file format.
Project No. JTC1 29.14
Target Dates: PDAM:2001-7 / FPDAM:2001-11 / FDAM:2002-3 / AMD 2002-5
Editor: Mr. Scott Houchin (USA)
Co-Editor: Mr. Greg Colyer (UK)
Supporting National Bodies: USA, UK, Sweden, Switzerland, Germany.
Scope: Within the scope of JTC 29:14 (15444) JPEG 2000 image coding system
This effort is described in WG1N2257.
Resolution 24– PDAM circulation of Part 5 AMD 1
WG1 approves Part V AMD 1 PDAM text contained in WG1N2258 and requests the SC29 secretariat circulate for balloting.
Resolution 25– File Format Reference Software Group
WG1 approves the the establishment of standing ad hoc group chaired by Mr. Scott Houchin (USA) on the development of file format reference software.
JPEG 2000 Part 6: Compound Image File Format
Resolution 26– Approval of the JPEG 2000 Part 6 ad hoc group report
WG1 approves the report of the Conformance Testing ad hoc group in WG1N2267.
Resolution 27– National Body comments on Study Document PRB of Part 6 FCD
WG1 requests National Body comments on WG1N2268, Study Document PRB of Part 6 FCD.
Resolution 28– Approval of Draft DOCR on Part 6 CD
WG1 approves the CD Draft DOCR contained in WG1N2237.
Resolution 29– Request for IPR statements
WG1 requests that WG1 participants review the Part VI CD text for IPR and comply with the WG1 request for IPR statements as appropriate. This additional review is requested even from those participants who have previously submitted IPR statements in conjunction with Part I and Part II.
Proposed JPEG 2000 New Subdivisions
Resolution 30– Proposed new subdivisions for JPEG 2000
WG1 requests that National Bodies to submit comments and indicate interest on the proposed new work relating to JPEG 2000 that is contained in WG1N2264 by the 25th WG1 Sydney Meeting.
JPEG 2000 Work Plan
Resolution 31– Approval of JPEG 2000 Work Plan
WG1 approves and re-affirms the following revised work plan for 15444 JPEG 2000:
Part / Title / CFP / WD / CD / FCD / FDIS / IS1 / JPEG 2000 Image Coding System: Core Coding System / 97/03 / 99/03 / 99/12 / 00/03 / 00/10 / 00/12
2 / JPEG 2000 Image Coding System: Extensions / 97/03 / 00/03 / 00/08 / 00/12 / 01/07 / 01/10
3 / Motion JPEG 2000 / 99/12 / 00/07 / 00/12 / 01/03 / 01/07 / 01/10
4 / Conformance Testing / 99/12 / 00/07 / 00/12 / 01/07 / 01/11 / 02/03
5 / Reference Software / 99/12 / 00/03 / 00/07 / 00/12 / 01/08 / 01/11
6 / Compound Image File Format / 97/03 / 00/12 / 01/03 / 01/11 / 02/03 / 02/05
Part / Title / WD / PDAM / FPDAM / FDAM / AMD
1 / JPEG 2000 Image Coding System: Core Coding System: Amendment 1 / 00/07 / 00/08 / 01/03 / 01/07 / 01/10
1 / JPEG 2000 Image Coding System: Core Coding System: Amendment 2 / 00/12 / 01/03 / 01/07 / 01/11 / 02/02
2 / JPEG 2000 Image Coding System: Extensions: Amendment 1 / 01/06 / 01/07 / 01/11 / 02/03 / 02/05
5 / JPEG 2000 Image Coding System: Reference Software Amendment 1 / 01/07 / 01/07 / 01/11 / 02/03 / 02/05
Liaisons/Response to Comments
Resolution 32– WG1 liaison to IEC TC100
WG1 approves the liaison to IEC TC100 contained in WG1N2255.
Resolution 33– IPR liaison to the ITU-T SG16
WG1 resolves to send a liaison statement back to ITU-T SG16 on the status of the JPEG2000 and JPEG LS Ext. IPR statements. The approved liaison statement is WG1N2246
Administration and Other Business
Resolution 34– Future Meetings of WG1
WG1 approves the following as its meeting plan.
25th / 2001 / Nov 12 -16 / Sydney, Australia26th / 2002 / Mar 18- 22 / Genoa, Italy (co-located with SC29 3/25-26)
27th / 2002 / July / Las Vegas, Nevada, USA (Tentative)
28th / 2002 / October 21-25 / Shanghai, China (co-located with WG11)
29th / 2003 / March / France (tentative) or Korea (tentative)
30th / 2003 / July / France (tentative) or Korea (tentative)
31st / 2003 / November / North America
32nd / 2004 / March / Asia
33rd / 2004 / July / Europe
34th / 2004 / November / North America
Resolution 35– Part 6 ad hoc meeting
WG1 approves an ad hoc meeting of the Part 6 ad hoc subgroup to be hosted by the German National Body. This meeting is tentatively planned for the end of September (September 29,30) in Berlin. The purpose of this meeting is to continue development of the FCD text. Results of this meeting will be ratified during the 25th WG1 Sydney meeting.
Resolution 36– Part 4 and Part 5 AMD 1 ad hoc meeting
WG1 approves an ad hoc meeting of the Part 4 and Part 5 AMD 1 ad hoc subgroups to be hosted by the French National Body. This meeting is tentatively planned for the first week of October (October 1,2,3) in Paris. The purpose of this meeting includes the development of test streams for Part IV and text/software for Part V AMD 1 (WG1N2259). Results of this meeting will be ratified during the 25th WG1 Sydney meeting.
Resolution 37– Web Master Report
WG1 approves the web master report contained in WG1N2162.
Resolution 38– Domain registration
WG1 requests the web master to register the following domains:
jp3g.org, jpsec.org, jpip.org, jp3d.org
Resolution 39– Document Consistency
WG1 adopts the following guidelines for SC29 documents within WG1, and suggests that the WG1 Webmaster assist the Editors in adhering to them
- Documents to be approved by resolution should be made available to WG1 (on the website or otherwise) before the resolution is passed.
- All revisions should be clearly indicated as such, using the website’s ‘revision’ option and preferably also by the inclusion of a strikeout or texts. (In the case of more than one revision, strikeouts from the original and from the immediately preceding revision may be helpful.)
- After circulation by SC29, the Editor should check that the SC29 output text corresponds exactly to the currently available WG1 document. If not, the SC29 text should be uploaded as a final revision to the WG1 document. Preferably, for verifiability by members, the two files should be bytewise identical. (Usually, a check of the files’ lengths in bytes would suffice to show up any discrepancy. UNIX users could easily run ‘cksum’ as well.) It should also be clear in the title that the WG1 document is an SC29 ballot text.
- Any post-ballot revision should be made using a new document number, and with a changed title that reflects the new status. For example, ‘PDAM ballot text’ could become ‘post-PDAM study text’ or ‘pre-FPDAM study text’, etc.
Resolution 40– WG1 affirmation of IP policy statement submission
WG1 re-affirms its support for its IP policy statement first approved at the 16th WG1 Seoul Meeting, March 1999.
“WG1 requires all participants within all National Bodies to disclose and identify any and all patent rights and the specific technologies within the Verification Model to which they apply. Further, WG1 requires this disclosure and identification at the time of submission of technology for VM consideration if submitted by the patent holder or no later than one meeting after submission of technology if the technology is not submitted by the patent holder. Further, WG1 requires that the form contained in WG1 N1267 be completed as part of this disclosure. This request is in accordance with ISO/IEC directives Part II, Annex A, Section A.2.a.”
The relevant ISO/IEC directives are contained in the integration group report, WG1 N1262.
Resolution 41— WG1 affirmation of SC29 Patent Policy
WG1 re-affirms its support for the SC29 IPR policy as approved in the Resolution 14 of the 11th SC29 Plenary meeting, 1998-07-13/15, Berlin Germany.
"SC 29 affirms and supports ISO policy that requires disclosure of the existence of Intellectual Property (IP) rights or pending rights (such as patents or pending patent applications), hereafter referred to as "IP rights", associated with any technology submitted to SC 29/WGs for consideration for inclusion in any ISO/IEC standard.
Specifically, SC 29 affirms the ISO policy of only considering technology that is free of "IP rights" or which is available on a royalty and license fee free basis or which is available under reasonable terms and conditions on a non-discriminatory basis.
In particular, SC 29 suggests to its WGs to implement, whenever possible, license-free "patent policy" as practiced by SC 29/WG 1.
Additionally, SC 29 encourages disclosure of the terms under which these "IP rights" will be made available for conforming implementations of ISO/IEC standards after final publication.
Further, SC 29 requires software and technology be available to all members of SC 29/WGs on a non-revocable, royalty and license fee free basis only for the purpose of standards development and until publication of the standard. This policy requires disclosure by any members of a WG having "IP rights" on each technology submitted for inclusion in the standard without regard to who makes the recommendations for inclusion. SC 29 requires this disclosure and agreement with this policy for future technology submissions prior to or at the time that the technology is recommended for inclusion in a standard."
Resolution 42— Re-nomination of the JPEG 2000 ad hoc group chairs
WG1 re-affirms the following ad hoc groups and chairs for JPEG 2000
Requirements & Profiles / Dr. Touradj Ebrahimi ( Switzerland)Core experiments / Dr. Jim Andrew (Australia)
Public Relations / Mr. Bernie Brower (acting chair) (USA)
Verification Model / Dr. Michael Marcellin (chair) (USA)
Mr. Mathias Larsson Carlander (doc editor) (Sweden)
File Format Sub-Group / Mr. Scott Houchin (USA)
Part 1 Editing Committee / Mr. Marty Boliek (Editor) (USA)
Dr. Eric Majani (co-editor) (France)
Dr. Charilaos Christopoulos (co-editor) (Sweden)
Part 2 Editing Committee / Mr. Marty Boliek (ISO Editor) (USA)
Dr. Eric Majani (France)
Mr. Scott Houchin (USA)
Dr. James Kasner (USA)
Mr. Mathias Larsson Carlander (Sweden)
Part 1 AMD 1 / Mr. Takahiro Fukuhara (Chair) (Japan)
Mr. Yasuyuki Nomizu (co-editor) (Japan)
Part 1 AMD 2 / Mr Takahiro Fukuhara (Japan)
Part 2 AMD 1 / Dr. Michael Marcellin (Editor) (USA)
Dr. Janet Rountree (co-editor, chair) (USA)
Part 3: Motion JPEG 2000 / Mr. Eric Edwards (USA)
Part 3 Editing Committee / Mr. David Singer (ISO Editor) (USA)
Mr. Takahiro Fukuhara (Japan)
Part 4: Conformance Testing / Mr. Bernie Brower (ISO Editor) (USA)
Dr. Michael Gormish (co-editor) (USA)
Part 5: Reference Software / Dr. Richard Clarke (ISO Editor) (UK)
Mr. Michael Adams (co-editor) (Canada)
Mr. Joel Askelof (co-editor) (Sweden)
Part 5 AMD 1: File Format Reference Software / Mr. Scott Houchin (editor, chair) (USA)
Mr. Greg Colyer (co-editor) (UK)
Part 6: Compound Image File Format / Dr. Robert Buckley (USA)
Mr. Louis Sharpe (co-chair) (USA)
JPEG 2000 License Pool AHG / Mr. Michael McCrodan (Canada)
JPEG 2000 Implementation Study Group / Mr. Robert Turney (USA)
Resolution 43– WG1 Committee chairs
WG1 affirms the following list of Committee chairs:
WG1 Webmaster / Mr. Richard Clark (UK)WG1 Resolution Drafting Committee / Dr. Scott Foshee (USA)
Resolution 44– WG1 Liaisons
WG1 nominated the following list of Liaisons:
SC 24 / Mr. Bernie Brower (USA)DICOM / Dr. Majid Rabbani (USA)
Resolution 45– Approval of WG1 Press Release
WG1 approves the JPEG 2000 press release contained in WG1N2207
Appreciation
Resolution 46– Appreciation to the resolution drafting committee
WG1 wishes to acknowledge the work of the resolution drafting committee, Dr. Scott Foshee (USA, chair), Mr. Ikuro Ueno (Japan), Dr. Eric Majani (France), Mr. Siegfried Foessel (Germany), Mr. Mathias Larsson Carlander (Sweden).
Resolution 47– Appreciation to the WG1 Webmaster
WG1 wishes to thank Mr. Richard Clark (UK) for his contribution to the operation of the WG1 website which is crucial to the success of WG1 activity.
Resolution 48– Appreciation to Mr.Tom Flohr
WG1 wishes to express its appreciation to Mr. Tom Flohr (USA) for his dedication and professionalism in maintaining the JPEG 2000 Verification Model and in his contribution to the editing of JPEG 2000 Part 2.