THE MEDICAL SOCIETIES
of the Counties of
ONEIDA, HERKIMER, MADISON, CHENANGO, OSWEGO & CAYUGA
4311 Middle Settlement Road, New Hartford, New York 13413-5317
Telephone (315) 735-2204 Fax (315) 735-1608
E-mail:
Kathleen E. Dyman
Executive Vice President
As medical practitioners, we write to bring toyour attention:
Primum, no nocere
First, do no harm.
Physicians care first and foremost about the health of our community. When an activity raises potential harm to human health, precautionary measures should be taken until cause and effect relationships are fully established scientifically.
The extraction of natural gas in the Marcellus and similar shales involves high-pressure injection of millions of gallons of water and chemicals per well into the shale formations to allow the release of natural gas. Some of these chemicals are known carcinogens and endocrine disruptors. While natural gas may be a cleaner fuel once it is refined for consumer use, extracting it is a process that pollutes the air with diesel fumes and volatile organic compounds and causes methane gas and other chemicals to migrate in unpredictable directions underground.
Hydraulic Fracturingtakes clean water and creates billions of gallons of toxic waste fluid for which there is no treatment. In addition to the chemical additives, this flowback contains brine, heavy metals, and radioactive materials. Given the vast scale of the proposed drilling, this amounts to an unprecedented level of toxins being released into the air and water. Extensive drilling activityhas already caused health problems, environmental disasters and irrevocable damage to water resources in other parts of the country. Accumulating incidents of explosions and spills, dead fish and cattle and contaminated water make Hydraulic Fracturing an unacceptable practice at this time
The effects of this process on human health, livestock and wildlife have not been subject to rigorous research by the medical, agricultural or forestry communities. The review reported by the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation in the draft Supplemental Generic Environmental Impact Statement does not include high quality medical data and lacks any analysis of the cumulative effects of thousands of wells.
We seek colleagues from professional and consumer communities to assist us in our support and advocacy for the EPA study and a moratorium on the process ofHigh Volume, Slick-water Hydraulic Fracturinguntil conclusive analysis of the health effects to humans, livestock and wildlife can be completed.
Respectfully,
Nameer Haider, MD. President Oneida County Medical Society
Suresh K. Sharma, MD President Herkimer County Medical Society
Jeffrey Kramer, MD President Chenango County Medical Society
Bashar Omarbasha, MD President Madison County Medical Society
Corliss Varnum, MD President Oswego County Medical Society
Muhammad Iqbal, MD President Cayuga County Medical Society