Robinson V. Bates

Robinson v. Bates

The following are some of the cases holding that Robinson v. Bates is superseded by R.C. §2315.20 and that evidence of set-offs/reductions/write-offs is not admissible in cases arising after April 7, 2005, the effective date of the statute:

Cuyahoga County

Pride v. Ortez, CV-07-630869, (May 15, 2008) (Judge Dick Ambrose):

Rock v. Richard E. Siegfried Architects, Inc., CV-07-623550 (August 18, 2008) (Judge Nancy Furest);

Daugherty v. Grange, CV-08-655032 (Judge Bridget McCafferty);

Kral v. Hren, CV-07-642068, (August 26, 2008) (Judge Peter Corrigan);

Mendenis v. Cinadar, CV-07-632215 (September 26, 2008) (Judge Stuart Friedman);

Gati v. Moore, 652662 (Judge Kathleen Ann Sutula).

Lee v. Gilbert, CV-08-678630 (May 26, 2008) (Judge Nancy R. McDonnell);

Lococo v. Loprich, CV-07-629522 (September 26, 2008) (Judge Joan Synenberg);

Mariani v. Garcia, CV-08-646292 (October 17, 2008) (Judge David Matia);

Jackson v. Buckland, CV-07-629572 (November 20, 2008) (Judge Eileen T. Gallagher);

Simonelli v. Deceola, CV-08-651314 (October 2, 2008) (Judge Janet Burnside);

Williams v. Poleman, CV-07-635466 (February 18, 2009) (Judge Carolyn B. Friedland);

Shapiro v. Goodman, CV-08-662432 (July 22, 2009) (Judge Timothy E. McMonagle).

Edge v. Fairview Hospital, CV-08-670975 (September 28, 2009) (Judge John D. Sutula).

Summit County

Herron v. Anderson, CV-2007-04-2600 (March 18, 2008) (Judge Judy Hunter);

Blinter v. Waste Management of Ohio, 2007-09-6769 (April 30, 2008) (Judge Thomas A. Teodosio);

McNutty v. Morgan, CV-2007-06-4518 (March 3, 2009) (Judge Alison McCarty);

Kress v. Hamuro, CV-2008-04-3422 (May 5, 2009) (Judge Mary Margret Rowlands)

Perrot v. Baughman, CV 2009 04 2564 (May 29, 2009) (Judge Burnham Unruh).

Stark County

Stewart v. Fitness Quest, Inc., 2007-CV-00233 (2007) (Judge Charles E. Brown, Jr.);

Allen County

Verhoff v. Diller, CV-2007-1278 (March 24, 2009) (Judge Jeffrey L. Reed);

Columbiana County

Laughlin v. Zoraida Mendez, M.D., 07-CV-409 (August 17, 2009) (Judge David Tobin).

Erie County

Hilyard v. Rodford, 07-CV-358 (January 6, 2009) (Judge Tygh M. Tone);

Highland County

Attard v. Williamson, 07-CV-257 (June 18, 2008) (Judge Jeffrey J. Haskins);

Fulton County

Clausen v. Lester, 06-CV-000268 (November 30, 2007) (Judge James E. Barber);

Gutierrez v. Kure, 07-CV-000123 (January 17, 2008) (Judge James E. Barber);

Caidill v. Lemaster, 07-CV-847 (October 8, 2008) (Judge Richard E. Berons);

Franklin County

Clark v. Fuddruckers, Inc., 08CVH02-1905 (July 31, 2009) (Judge Timothy P. McCarthy);

Dimitroff v. Grishcow, 07-CVA-01-103 (January 5, 2009) (Judge John A. Conner).

Guernsay Coutny

Furbee v. Dubois, 07-MM-607 (May 7, 2009) (David A. Ellwood).

Lucas County

Palm V. Burmeister, CI 06-3579, (July 31, 2007) (Judge Denise Ann Dartt);

Almaguer v. King, G-4801-CI-200605776-000 (Judge Fredrick H. McDonald);

Kissinger v. Hollosi, G-4801-CI-200703285-000 (November 1, 2007) (Judge James D. Bates);

Chang v. Uzunel, CI0200706325, (Mach 12, 2008) (Judge James D. Jensen);

Neumeyer v. Ziegler, CI0200706643 (November 18, 2008) (Judge Charles J. Donaghy).

Lorain County

Rivera v. Urbansky, 08CV154436 (August 26, 2008) (Judge Miraldi).

Hohman v. Metlife Auto and Home, 08CV159471 (July 31, 2009) (Judge Edward M. Zaleski).

Court of Appeals

Jacques v. Manton, 2009 Ohio 1468; 2009 Ohio App. LEXIS 1273 (Lucas Cty).