Reader #1 Comments

Name:______

Instructions: Before you leave today, you must have THREE of your peers read and score your lab report. Each of your readers will write their name below and reference a lab rubric to score your write up. Do not write on the lab rubric – mark your scores HERE. I MUST CHECK OFF ON THIS PAPER BEFORE YOU LEAVE FOR YOU TO RECEIVE PARTICIPATION CREDIT TODAY!

READER #1:
______ / READER #2:
______ / READER #3:
______
Is the Introduction Complete?
5 4 3 2 1 / Is the Introduction Complete?
5 4 3 2 1 / Is the Introduction Complete?
5 4 3 2 1
Is the Problem Clearly Stated?
3 2 1 / Is the Problem Clearly Stated?
3 2 1 / Is the Problem Clearly Stated?
3 2 1
Is the Hypothesis Clearly Stated?
3 2 1 / Is the Hypothesis Clearly Stated?
3 2 1 / Is the Hypothesis Clearly Stated?
3 2 1
Is the description of the procedure complete?
3 2 1 / Is the description of the procedure complete?
3 2 1 / Is the description of the procedure complete?
3 2 1
Is a list of materials included?
3 2 1 / Is a list of materials included?
3 2 1 / Is a list of materials included?
3 2 1
Are variables clearly recognized and defined? (FREE 3 POINTS)
3 2 1 / Are variables clearly recognized and defined? (FREE 3 POINTS)
3 2 1 / Are variables clearly recognized and defined? (FREE 3 POINTS)
3 2 1
Have appropriate safety precautions and/or steps for responsible use of organisms been taken?
1 0 / Have appropriate safety precautions and/or steps for responsible use of organisms been taken?
1 0 / Have appropriate safety precautions and/or steps for responsible use of organisms been taken?
1 0
Are the procedures described likely to result in the collection of meaningful data?
1 0 / Are the procedures described likely to result in the collection of meaningful data?
1 0 / Are the procedures described likely to result in the collection of meaningful data?
1 0
Are your results listed in a table and/or graph?
3 2 1 / Are your results listed in a table and/or graph?
3 2 1 / Are your results listed in a table and/or graph?
3 2 1
Is enough data presented to sufficiently address the problem and hypothesis?
1 0 / Is enough data presented to sufficiently address the problem and hypothesis?
1 0 / Is enough data presented to sufficiently address the problem and hypothesis?
1 0
Do you explain what your data means?
4 3 2 1 / Do you explain what your data means?
4 3 2 1 / Do you explain what your data means?
4 3 2 1
Are calculations and formulas included?
2 1 0 / Are calculations and formulas included?
2 1 0 / Are calculations and formulas included?
2 1 0
Do you trust your results? Have you explained any sources of error?
2 1 0 / Do you trust your results? Have you explained any sources of error?
2 1 0 / Do you trust your results? Have you explained any sources of error?
2 1 0
Are the conclusions valid?
4 3 2 1 0 / Are the conclusions valid?
4 3 2 1 0 / Are the conclusions valid?
4 3 2 1 0
Does the student offer any additional next steps or future questions?
1 0 / Does the student offer any additional next steps or future questions?
1 0 / Does the student offer any additional next steps or future questions?
1 0
Is the lab report typed?
5 0 / Is the lab report typed?
5 0 / Is the lab report typed?
5 0
Are the headings for each section clearly labeled?
2 1 0 / Are the headings for each section clearly labeled?
2 1 0 / Are the headings for each section clearly labeled?
2 1 0
Is the lab report written in third person passive voice?
2 1 0 / Is the lab report written in third person passive voice?
2 1 0 / Is the lab report written in third person passive voice?
2 1 0
Did you spell everything correctly and use proper grammar?
2 1 0 / Did you spell everything correctly and use proper grammar?
2 1 0 / Did you spell everything correctly and use proper grammar?
2 1 0
Did you appropriately cite your sources?
2 1 0 / Did you appropriately cite your sources?
2 1 0 / Did you appropriately cite your sources?
2 1 0
TOTAL POINTS OUT OF 50
(52 with extra)
______/ TOTAL POINTS OUT OF 50
(52 with extra)
______/ TOTAL POINTS OUT OF 50
(52 with extra)
______