Planning and Transportation Regulatory Panel

Planning and Transportation Regulatory Panel - 7th May, 2009

PLANNING AND TRANSPORTATION REGULATORY PANEL

7th May, 2009

Meeting commenced: 9.30 a.m.

" adjourned: 10.45 a.m.

" recommenced: 10.50 a.m.

“ adjourned: 11.20 a.m.

" recommenced: 11.35 a.m.

" ended: 12.50 p.m.

PRESENT: Councillor Clague - in the Chair

Councillors Drake, Ferrer, Karen Garrido, Heywood, Kean, B.J. Lea, McIntyre, Mashiter, Jane Murphy and Turner

Mr. J. Wheelton

ALSO IN ATTENDANCE: Councillors Davies , Lindley and Macdonald

155. APOLOGIES FOR ABSENCE

Apologies for absence were submitted on behalf of Councillors Antrobus, Potter and Tope.

156. MINUTES OF PROCEEDINGS

RESOLVED: THAT the minutes of the meeting of the Panel held on 16th April, 2009, be approved as a correct record.

157. APPLICATIONS FOR PLANNING PERMISSION

(Full details of the matters referred to in this Minute below are contained in the report of the Director of Sustainable Regeneration, as amended, in all cases in the supplementary report).

RESOLVED: THAT the recommendations of the Director of Sustainable Regeneration with regard to the undermentioned applications for planning permission be dealt with as indicated below:-

Application
Number/
Applicant / Site / Development / Decision
09/57413
Rossford Dental Laboratory / 78-80 Chorley Road, Swinton / Outline planning application to include layout and access in respect of four dwelling houses and nine apartments / Granted
09/57495
Dr. V. Joshi / 32 Roe Green, Worsley / Demolition of an existing, and erection of a new, dwelling and construction of a vehicular access / Refused , contrary to officer recommendation , as the large footprint, scale and mass of the proposal would amount to overdevelopment of the site and have a negative impact on the character of the Conservation Area and it’s overbearing nature have an unacceptable impact on the amenity of occupiers of the adjacent cottages
09/57486
A. Moulton / 13 Chatsworth Road, Eccles / Erection of a first floor side extension, a two storey side/ rear extension, a first and second floor rear extension, a single storey rear extension and a new hipped roof over an existing flat roof / Granted subject to the addition of a condition requiring the provision of obscure glazing in the window on the side elevation
09/57513
Mr. E. Burrows / Land at Quay Point, off Broadway, Salford Quays, Salford / Erection of two canopies, a single storey substation and a single storey office building for use in association with the Metrolink / Granted
09/57428
I. Iands Limited / 9 Park Road, Worsley / Erection of a three storey building comprising ten apartments with basement car parking (resubmission of planning application 08/5711?/FUL) / Refused , by a vote of eight to two and contrary to officer recommendation, on the grounds that the proposed development (a) would have an adverse impact upon the amenity of the adjacent neighbour by reason of overbearing and loss of light and (b) is contrary to the Council’s policy ,as set out in housing planning guidance, giving preference to housing rather than apartment development

158. PLANNING APPLICATIONS DETERMINED UNDER DELEGATED AUTHORITY

The Director of Sustainable Regeneration submitted a report containing details of planning applications, which had been determined by the Deputy Director of Housing and Planning, under delegated authority, during April, 2009, and were not, therefore, for consideration by the Panel.

RESOLVED: THAT the undermentioned applications be noted:-

Application
Number/
Applicant / Site / Development / Decision and Date of Decision
08/57232
The Community Health, Social Care Directorate, S.C.C. / Land behind indoor Market Hall, Corporation Road, Eccles / Change of use from a car park to a contractor’s compound and lay down storage / Approve
9th April, 2009
09/57404
Housing Services / Alleyway to rear of 9-27 Alexandra Road and 39 Stanley Road, Eccles / Erection of 2.2 metre high gates and 2.2 metre high railings to alleyway / Approve
9th April, 2009
09/57442
William Hill Organisation / 311 Liverpool Road, Eccles / Display of one externally illuminated fascia sign and one internally illuminated projecting sign / Approve
20th April, 2009
09/57489
M. Fish / Land adjacent to 375 Trafford Road, Eccles / Erection of a two storey attached dwelling, detached garage, new boundary wall and construction of new vehicular access (resubmission of planning application 08/57237/FUL) / Approve
22nd April, 2009
09/57405
M. Doyle / 170 Chaddock Lane, Worsley / Retention of use of two ground floor rooms and two first floor rooms as offices / Approve
9th April, 2009
09/57445
Mrs. L. Hall / 10 Waterdale Close, Worsley / Erection of a first floor side extension / Refuse
17th April, 2009
09/57458
Mr. Nigel Brown / 201 Leigh Road, Worsley / Erection of a single storey side and a single storey rear extension / Approve
20th April, 2009
09/57383
G. Merzeach / 38 Heaton Street, Salford / Erection of a single storey rear extension / Approve
6th April, 2009
09/57387
Joseph Holt Limited / Duke of York, 97 Marlborough Road, Salford / Erection of a spiral staircase to rear of public house / Approve
6th April, 2009
09/57389
Dr. D. Cohen / 8 Ashbourne Grove, Salford / Erection of a single storey side extension / Approve
6th April, 2009
09/57526
Contour Homes / The Priory, Salford / Reduce primary limb away from the building to leave a 3 metre clearance from the adjacent roof structure one ash (T1). Crown lift over grass area to leave a 3 metre clearance from the surrounding ground level one sycamore (T4). Fell four sycamore within (G2). Reduce lower branches to allow a 3 metre clearance from the adjacent building and 5% crown thin one alder (T16). Crown lift to leave a clear distance from the surrounding ground level two alder (G17) and one alder (T18). Crown clean and reduce tips of branches to leave a 2.5 metre clearance from the adjacent building one sycamore (T19) / Split decision
23rd April, 2009
09/57419
Varn Products Company Limited / Varn Products, Varn House, Brinell Drive, Irlam / Retention of a portable building and siting of two portable buildings / Approve
9th April, 2009
09/57441
P. Bower / 6 Woodbine Avenue, Cadishead / Erection of conservatory rear of dwelling / Refuse
17th April, 2009
09/57430
Lidl UK GMBH / Lidl, 2 Woodrow Way, Irlam / Retention of internally illuminated dual post sign / Approve
20th April, 2009
09/57065
Mr. P. Croden / 3 Ormonde Avenue, Salford / Erection of a part single/part two storey side/front/rear extension / Approve
24th April, 2009
09/57384
M. Burns / 37 Radcliffe Park Road, Salford / Erection of a first floor extension over existing garage including external access staircase / Refuse
20th April, 2009
09/57420
Mr. S. Ceglarek / 7 Overlinks Drive, Salford / Erection of a two storey rear extension including cellar at lower ground level (resubmission of 08/5658/HH) / Approve
9th April, 2009
09/57314
R. Butler / 100D Monton Road, Eccles / Construction of a new vehicular access / Approve
9th April, 2009
08/57241
Mrs. K. Sami / 3 Mather Road, Eccles / Change of use from shop to shop for the sale of hot food together with the retention of the extraction flue to the rear / Refuse
6th April, 2009
09/57369
Mr. Bhagwan Singh / 43 Stafford Road, Eccles / Erection of a part single/part first floor/part two storey front/side/rear extension. Demolition of existing conservatory and erection of a single storey rear extension. Construction of a dormer extension to front and both side of roof spaces. Construction of a pitched roof including accommodation in roof space. Erection of a detached outbuilding to the side of the dwelling / Refuse
20th April, 2009
09/57397
Mrs. Jean Dunmet / Clarendon Road Community Primary School, Clarendon Road, Eccles / Erection of a cycle shelter / Approve
6th April, 2009
09/57421
J. Evans / 1A Church Road, Eccles / Change of use of land for loading and car parking and erection of extension over existing yard area to form storage area / Refuse
21st April, 2009
09/57437
M. Butt / 3 Gladstone Road, Eccles / Erection of a part single/part two storey side/rear extension / Approve
16th April, 2009
09/57448
Mr. and Mrs. Williams / 50 Pine Grove, Eccles / Erection of single storey side and single storey rear extension / Approve
17th April, 2009
09/57435
S. Rogerson / 38 Queensway, Irlam / Demolition of existing extension and conservatory and erection of a part single/ part two storey side/rear extension / Approve
15th April, 2009
09/57444
Mr. and Mrs. M. Roberts / 106 Silver Street, Irlam / Erection of a two storey side extension / Approve
20th April, 2009
08/57175
Broadhurst Estates / 22-26 Blackfield Lane, Salford / Erection of a part five/part three storey building comprising eight apartments and a two storey detached dwelling together with associated car parking and construction of new vehicular and pedestrian accesses / Approve
20th April, 2009
08/57251
Mr. M. Green / 8 Castlefield Avenue, Salford / Demolition of existing garage, erection of a front porch, erection of a two storey side/rear extension and the erection of a part single/part first floor/part two storey rear extension / Approve
6th April, 2009
09/57402
Dr. Mann / 1 Norwood Avenue, Salford / Erection of a two storey side extension and single storey extension to front of dwelling / Approve
6th April, 2009
09/57438
Mr. Wolff / 2 Cheltenham Crescent, Salford / Erection of part single/part two storey side/front/rear extension with accommodation in roof space (resubmission of planning application 08/56884/HH) / Approve
6th April, 2009 `
09/57454
Mr. Silkin / 4 Deanery Gardens, Bury New Road, Salford / Construction of a second floor rear extension and roof alterations to existing main hipped roof to form a gable roof / Approve
21st April, 2009
09/57520
Mrs. Dixon / 1 Moorside Road, Salford / Prune back low lateral branches over the house to a suitable branch union to leave a 2 metre clearance from the building one lime (T1). Prune off low lateral branches over the street lamp and the adjacent property No. 30 Moor Lane one sycamore (T2) / Approve
20th April, 2009
09/57409
Housing Connections Partnership Limited / Alleyway to rear of 456-468 Liverpool Street and 49-61 Kara Street, Salford / Erection of 2.4 metre high gates and 2.2 metre high fencing to alleyway / Approve
9th April, 2009
09/57410
Housing Connections Partnership Limited / Alleyway to rear of 1-19 Langton Street and 143-161 Seedley Park Road, Salford / Erection of 2.4 metre high gates to alleyway / Approve
9th April, 2009
09/57411
Housing Connections Partnership Limited / Alleyway to rear of 52-76 Nansen Street and 133-157 Langworthy Road, Salford / Erection of 2.4 metre high gates and 2.2 metre high railings to alleyway / Approve
9th April, 2009
09/57426
AAH Plc / Lloyds Pharmacy,
Pendleton Health and Social Care Centre, 1 Broadwalk, Salford / Retention of one internally illuminated fascia sign and one internally illuminated projecting sign / Approve
9th April, 2009
09/57431
Co-operative Group / 17 Hulton District Centre, Worsley / Display of two externally illuminated fascia signs and ten window graphics / Approve
15th April, 2009
09/57361
Mr. G. Howard / 30 Dell Avenue, Pendlebury, Swinton / Construction of a new pitched roof to existing garage / Approve
6th April, 2009
09/57385
Mr. and Mrs. R. Shaw / 16 Walnut Close, Clifton, Swinton / Erection of a single storey side extension including dormer and accommodation in roof space / Approve
6th April, 2009
09/57429
Co-operative Group / 580 Bolton Road, Pendlebury, Swinton / Display of two externally illuminated fascia signs and one internally illuminated projecting sign / Approve
6th April, 2009
09/57401
Mr. J. Davenport / 27 Alder Drive, Wardley, Swinton / Erection of a two storey side extension, the erection of a part single/part two storey side/rear extension, the erection of a front porch and the erection of a canopy roof above the ground floor front elevation / Approve
17th April, 2009
09/57472
Mr. Nigel Pilling / Stax Trade Centre (formerly Convoys), Wardley Industrial Estate, Holloway Drive, Worsley / Display of six internally illuminated box fascia signs and one internally/externally illuminated gantry sign / Approve
17th April, 2009
09/57519
Joseph Holt Limited / Morning Star, 520 Manchester Road, Worsley / Erection of covered area on west elevation over existing external drinking area / Approve
17th April, 2009
09/57368
Mr. John McNeive / 40 Thorn Road, Swinton / Demolition of existing utility room and erection of single storey side and rear extension / Approve
6th April, 2009
09/57382
A. Laffin / 27 Folly Lane, Swinton / Erection of a single storey rear extension / Approve
6th April, 2009
09/57427
Boots The Chemist / Boots The Chemists Limited, 24-28 The Parade, Swinton / Display of three internally illuminated fascia signs and one internally illuminated projecting sign / Approve
9th April, 2009
09/57440
Mr. and Mrs. Milan / 2 Oakville Drive, Salford / Erection of single storey front/side/rear extension / Approve
17th April, 2009
09/57462
P.K. Brookes / 26 Blantyre Street, Eccles / Erection of conservatory at rear of dwelling / Refuse
22nd April, 2009
09/57471
Bolton Council / Land at rear of Exide Batteries, off Salford Road, Bolton / Article 10 Consultation in respect of the erection of an in-vessel composting (IVC) facility building and site office including 26 metre high stack, together with the formation of new access road / No objections
20th April, 2009
09/57299
Derwent Holdings Limited / Tesco Store, Unit 60 Ellesmere Shopping Centre, Bolton Road, Worsley / Demolition of units 57-63 Bolton Road, erection of four new two storey retail units fronting Bolton Road together with new internal atrium to the Ellesmere Shopping Centre (atrium element amendment to planning approval 08/56280/FUL) / Approve
21st April, 2009
09/57465
T-Mobile (UK) Limited / Ellesmere Retail Park, New Ellesmere Approach, Worsley / Prior notification for the installation of a 15 metre high monopole and two equipment cabinets / Refuse
14th April, 2009
09/57466
J. Condron / 232 Manchester Road, Worsley / Erection of a single storey rear extension and construction of new roof over existing single storey rear element / Approve
22nd April, 2009
09/57396
Mr. Robert Taylor / 35 Ashford Avenue, Swinton / Erection of single storey rear extension and steps / Approve
9th April, 2009
09/57398
Mrs. B. Jones / 27 The Coppice, Swinton / Erection of a three storey rear extension and a single storey front extension / Approve
6th April, 2009
09/57417
Mr. Ian Blease / 49 Glen Avenue, Worsley / Demolition of existing single storey side and rear extensions and erection of a part single/part two storey side/rear extension, front canopy and porch and erection of conservatory at rear / Approve
9th April, 2009
09/57467
Mr. Christensen / 11 Ewhurst Avenue, Swinton / Erection of conservatory at rear of dwelling / Approve
17th April, 2009
09/57504
Turris Limited / The Lime Kilns, Worsley / Fell two ash (1232 and 1233) and three sycamores (1234, 1235 and 1236) / No objections
16th April, 2009
09/57323
Mr. Carl Whitehead / 4 Parrfold Avenue, Worsley / Demolition of existing single storey rear extension and erection of a part single/part two storey side/rear extension / Approve
17th April, 2009
09/57349
Mr. Michael Pollard / 44 Rydal Crescent, Worsley / Erection of a single storey side/rear extension / Approve
20th April, 2009
09/57450
Dr. E. Vasanth / 10 Hyde Drive, Worsley / Erection of a single storey rear extension / Approve
6th April, 2009
09/57455
Mr. and Mrs. Hodgkinson / 77 Bridgewater Road, Worsley / Erection of a two storey side extension / Approve
22nd April, 2009

159. CONFIRMATION OF THE CITY OF SALFORD TREE PRESERVATION ORDER NO. (NO. 391) 2008 TO THE REAR OF HAZELHURST ROAD AND CHAPEL ROAD, SWINTON