Performance Evaluation Table
PERFORMANCE EVALUATION TABLE
I. EDUCATIONA. Courses taught by the instructor (Maximum 10 including graduate courses) / Each course
(10 Points) / First-time course
(5 Points) / Compulsory course
(5 Points) / Course in English
(5 Points) / On-Line Course
(10 Points) / Tablet Course
(10 Points) / Use of Blackboard’s Advanced Tools (10 Points) / Number of students 50-100
(5 Points) / Number of students Over 100
(10 Points) / Summer school course (10 Points) / Average score of student evaluations / Total score
Syllabi of all courses must be included. Courses without syllabi will not be evaluated. / Over 4,5 (20 Points) / 4-4,5
(15 Points) / 3,5-4
(10 Points) / 3-3,5
(5 Points)
Private summer school, workshop, festival, certificate program organizer/director (10 points for each program) – Document shall be included.
Undergraduate student advising (Relevant department head’s letter shall be included) – At least 50 students (10 Points)
B. Graduate Thesis Supervision and Committee Membership / Maximum possible score / Number / Total points / HRC score
1. Graduate Thesis Supervision
Supervision of PhD dissertation completed within the year of evaluation (Maximum 5) / 30 POINTS
Supervision of Master’s thesis completed within the year of evaluation (Maximum 5) / 15 POINTS
Dissertation Monitoring Committee membership in progress / 5 POINTS
2. Graduate Thesis Defense Committee Membership (Only theses written at KHÜ shall be evaluated.)
PhD dissertation defense committee member / 5 POINTS
MA thesis defense committee member / 2 POINTS
GRUP I - TOTAL POINTS
II. RESEARCH-APPLIED STUDIES / Maximum possible score / Number / Total points / HRC
score
A. Publications and References
1) Publications in journals indexed in AHCI, SSCI, and SCI-EXP:
a) Full articles published / 50 POINTS
b) Short works, analyses, book reviews, letters to the editor, and related items. / 15 POINTS
2) International journals which are in indexes other than AHCI, SSCI, SCI-EXP and have been approved by the Senate / 30 POINTS
3) Articles published in other international refereed journals which do not meet the criteria in A.1 and A.2 / 20 POINTS
4) Articles published in other refereed scholarly journals / 15 POINTS
5) Articles published in other scholarly journals / 10 POINTS
6) Full-length articles published in other journals and encyclopedia entries / 5 POINTS
7) Article translations published in scholarly journals / 5 POINTS
8) Books and book chapters
a) Course books, scholarly and professional books published by acclaimed publishing houses or universities
International / 100 POINTS
Domestic / 70 POINTS
b) Chapters in course books, scholarly books and occupational books published by acclaimed publishing houses or by university publishing houses
International / 30 POINTS
Domestic / 15 POINTS
c) Course books, scholarly and professional books or chapters in such books published by other publishing houses
International book / 50 POINTS
Domestic book / 30 POINTS
Book chapter / 10 POINTS
d) Scholarly book translation / 30 POINTS
9. Paper presented at a scholarly conference and published in conference proceedings
International / 10 POINTS
Domestic / 5 POINTS
10. Each reference made by other writers to articles published in journals in A.1 and A.2 (maximum 10) / 2 POINTS
11. Each reference made by other writers to articles published in journals other than those in A.1 and A.2 / 1 POINT
B. Creative works and references in the fields of arts and design
1. Production/work which has been accepted into the permanent collections of museums/acclaimed art institutions
International / 100 POINTS
Domestic / 70 POINTS
2. Personal exhibitions and art/design events in acclaimed galleries, theatres, and other such locales.
International event / 50 POINTS
Domestic event / 30 POINTS
3. Works accepted into exhibitions and juried events (biennale, festivals, etc.)
International / 30 POINTS
Domestic / 20 POINTS
4. Works exhibited in art/design events in acclaimed galleries or theatres
International / 20 POINTS
Domestic / 15 POINTS
5. Other personal exhibitions and art/design events and works in these events
International event / 30 POINTS
Domestic event / 20 POINTS
Product/work in event / 10 POINTS
6. Writings and interviews by other authors about creative work, events and performances which are published in journals in the categories specified in A1, A2 and A3 / 10 POINTS
C. PROJECTS
1. Project Supervision
International (Points are earned on the project’s beginning/approval year) / 50 POINTS
National (Points are earned on the project’s beginning/approval year) / 25 POINTS
2. Project Researcher
International (Points are earned on the project’s beginning/approval year) / 20 POINTS
National (Points are earned on the project’s beginning/approval year) / 10 POINTS
GROUP II – TOTAL SCORE
III. DUTIES / Maximum possible score / Number / Total points / HRC score
A. University duties
1. Administrative duties
Vice dean, vice institute director / 15 POINTS
Department chair / 20 POINTS
Institute director, coordinator of program or administrative unit / 10 POINTS
2. Chair/member of permanent commission (For each) / 10/5 POINTS
3. Publicity duties (Maximum 30 points) – Corporate Communications Office will submit the lists to the HRC / 5 POINTS
4. Membership in a faculty/vocational school committee
(Letter from the Dean/Director shall be included) Maximum 30 points / 5 POINTS
B. Professional activities
1) Editorship/membership on editorial board
a. Editorship/membership on editorial board for journals in AHCI, SSCI or SCI-EXP / 75/30 POINTS
b. Editorship for international books published by acclaimed publishing houses or universities / 50 POINTS
c. Editorship for domestic books published by acclaimed publishing houses or universities / 35 POINTS
d. Editorship/membership on editorial board for international journals which are in indexes other than AHCI, SSCI, SCI-EXP and have been approved by the Senate / 30/15 POINTS
e. Editorship/membership on editorial board for other international refereed scholarly journals / 20/10 POINTS
f. Editorship/membership on editorial board for other domestic refereed scholarly journals / 15/5 POINTS
g. Special issue editorship of journals in AHCI, SSCI or SCI-EXP / 50 POINTS
h. Special issue editorship of international journals
which are in indexes other than AHCI, SSCI, SCI-EXP and have been approved by the Senate / 25 POINTS
i) Special issue editorship of other international refereed journals / 15 POINTS
j) Special issue editorship of other domestic refereed scholarly journals / 10 POINTS
2. Refereeing (maximum 5 for each)
a. For journals in AHCI, SSCI or SCI-EXP / 10 POINTS
b. For international journals which are in indexes other than AHCI, SSCI, SCI-EXP and have been approved by the Senate / 8 POINTS
c. For other international refereed journals / 5 POINTS
d. For other domestic refereed journals / 2 POINTS
3. Organization of scholarly event/Curatorship (maximum 3 for each)
a. Chair for the organization of international congress/symposium, curatorship for international event / 50 POINTS
b. Chair for the organization of domestic congress/symposium, curatorship for international event / 30 POINTS
c. Member of organizing board for international congress/symposium, art event organization committee / 15 POINTS
d. Member of organizing board for domestic congress/symposium, art event organization committee / 10 POINTS
e. Organization of other international event (conference, workshop, seminar, roundtable, art event, etc.) / 20 POINTS
f. Organization of other domestic event (conference, workshop, seminar, roundtable, art event, etc.) / 10 POINTS
g. Chair of international panel / 10 POINTS
h. Chair of domestic panel / 5 POINTS
i. Panelist at international scholarly event / 10 POINTS
j. Panelist at domestic scholarly event / 5 POINTS
k. Member of organizing board for international scholarly event or member of domestic art event advisory board / 10 POINTS
l. Member of organizing board for domestic scholarly event or member of domestic art event advisory board / 5 POINTS
4. Chair of professional organization/association
(maximum 3) / 20 POINTS
5. Off-campus professional consulting (maximum 3) / 15 POINTS
6. Media Events
a. Producer of a TV/Radio Program / 20 POINTS
b. Participation on TV/Radio Program (max. 10) / 5 POINTS
c. Column writing / 20 POINTS
d. Report, analysis, or review in newspaper or magazine (max. 10) / 5 POINTS
7. / Scholarships or Awards in Science, Arts and Design which have been selected by a committee, jury or curator
a. International scholarship/ post-doctoral research / 50 POINTS
b. Domestic scholarship/ post-doctoral research / 25 POINTS
c. Artist in residence invited by international institutions / 35 POINTS
d. Artist in residence invited by domestic institutions / 10 POINTS
e. International award in science, art, design, performance or architecture / 50 POINTS
f. Domestic award in domestic science, art, design, performance or architecture / 25 POINTS
8. Patents
a) International / 100 POINTS
b) Domestic / 50 POINTS
GROUP III. TOTAL POINTS
V. GENERAL EVALUATION (HRC)
Evaluator / Evaluation / Score / Signature
10
Kadir Has University Regulation for the Performance Evaluation of Academic Personnel (18.06.2014)