PBL Grading Rubric
(25 point assignment)
Individual grade:Each member of the team will grade each other on their contributions to the team / Did not participate at all / Barely participated in the project; did nothing outside of class / Made minimal contributions to the team and to solving the problem / Aided in solving the problems and contributed to the success of the team / Important to the success of the team; involved in deriving a solution to the problem / Involved in all of the decisions and integral to the success of the team; intimately involved in deriving a solution to the problem
Organization: How is the solution to the problem organized / No apparent organization / Poorly organized appears to have been thrown together at the last minute / Mediocre organization, although may have major problems / Organized in an adequate manner, although the logic may be less evident / Good organization, logically put together / Completely clear, logically leading to the solution
Research: The amount of research that is used in solving the problem / No apparent research / Poor research, leading to a poor solution not based on research / Mediocre research which may or may not lead to an adequate solution / Adequate research which may or may not lead to an adequate solution / Good research, leading to a successful solution / Contains all the information needed for solving the problem
Handout: How thorough and well organized is the solution / No handout / Poor handout of little value; appears prepared at the last minute / Mediocre information which may or may not lead to a solution / Adequate information which may help in finding a solution / Good information organized well that could lead to a good solution / All of the necessary information clearly organized for easy use in solving the problem
Public Presentation: How did the team present the problem and the solution / Presentation not ready on time / Poor presentation, looks like put together in a hurry / Mediocre presentation which is unconvincing / Adequate presentation which is somewhat convincing. / Good presentation which convinces that the solution is appropriate. / Completely convincing presentation
0 1 2 3 4 5Grade