Ohio Elections Commission s8
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION
CASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO: 2008R-101
RESPONDENT: RONNIE RIMBERT
RE-ELECT RONNIE J. RIMBERT
RONNIE RIMBERT, TREASURER
331 S. PLEASANT ST.
OBERLIN, OH 44074
REFERRED BY: LORAIN COUNTY
ALLEGATION: 3517.13(C)(LATE FILING OF A 2007 POST-GENERAL REPORT)
OFFICE: OBERLIN COUNCIL AT LARGE
ELECTION DATE: 11/6/07
PRIOR CASES:
DISPOSITION: 6/26/2008 THE COMMISSION FOUND A VIOLATION OF R.C. §3517.13(C), BUT FOR GOOD CAUSE SHOWN DID NOT IMPOSE A FINE OR REFER THE MATTER FOR PROSECUTION.
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION
CASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO: 2008R-102
RESPONDENT: GLENN LOUGHRIE
47567 MIDDLE RIDGE RD.
AMHERST, OH 44001
COMMITTEE TO ELECT GLENN LOUGHRIE FOR COUNCIL
R. J. BUDWAY, TREASURER
4201 FAIRBANKS CT.
LORAIN, OH 44053
REFERRED BY: LORAIN COUNTY
ALLEGATION: 3517.13(C)(LATE FILING OF A 2007 POST-GENERAL REPORT)
OFFICE: LORAIN COUNCIL WARD 2
ELECTION DATE: 11/6/07
PRIOR CASES:
DISPOSITION: 6/26/2008 THE COMMISSION FOUND A VIOLATION OF R.C. §3517.13(C), BUT FOR GOOD CAUSE SHOWN DID NOT IMPOSE A FINE OR REFER THE MATTER FOR PROSECUTION.
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION
CASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO: 2008R-103
RESPONDENT: ANDREW RAY WINEMILLER
WINEMILLER FOR PRESIDENT OF CITY COUNCIL
ANDREW WINEMILLER, TREASURER
517 BAYBERRY RD.
LORAIN, OH 44053
REFERRED BY: LORAIN COUNTY
ALLEGATION: 3517.13(C)(LATE FILING OF A 2007 POST-GENERAL REPORT)
OFFICE: LORAIN COUNCIL PRESIDENT
ELECTION DATE: 11/6/07
PRIOR CASES:
DISPOSITION: 6/26/2008 THE COMMISSION FOUND A VIOLATION OF R.C. §3517.13(C), BUT FOR GOOD CAUSE SHOWN DID NOT IMPOSE A FINE OR REFER THE MATTER FOR PROSECUTION.
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION
CASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO: 2008R-104
RESPONDENT: SAMUEL SPICER
COMMITTEE TO ELECT SAMUEL SPICER
SAMUEL SPICER, TREASURER
911 HARTFORD DR.
ELYRIA, OH 44035
REFERRED BY: LORAIN COUNTY
ALLEGATION: 3517.13(C)(LATE FILING OF A 2007 POST-GENERAL REPORT)
OFFICE: ELYRIA COUNCIL AT LARGE
ELECTION DATE: 11/6/07
PRIOR CASES:
DISPOSITION: 6/26/2008 THE COMMISSION FOUND A VIOLATION OF R.C. §3517.13(C) AND IMPOSED A FINE OF $50.00.
8/28/08 RECEIVED CHECK #1170 IN THE AMOUNT OF $50.00
FROM SAMUEL SPICER FOR PAYMENT OF FINE.
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION
CASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO: 2008R-105
RESPONDENT: BRYAN JENSEN
COMMITTEE TO ELECT BRYAN JENSEN
BRYAN JENSEN, TREASURER
37101 HUNTERS TRAIL
AVON, OH 44011
REFERRED BY: LORAIN COUNTY
ALLEGATION: 3517.13(C)(LATE FILING OF A 2007 POST-GENERAL REPORT)
OFFICE: AVON COUNCIL WARD 1
ELECTION DATE: 11/6/07
PRIOR CASES: 2006R-547, 2006R-587
DISPOSITION: 6/26/2008 THE COMMISSION FOUND A VIOLATION OF R.C. §3517.13(C) AND IMPOSED A FINE OF $100.00.
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION
CASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO: 2008R-106
RESPONDENT: TIMOTHY NICKUM
NICKUM FOR A CHANGE
TIMOTHY NICKUM, TREASURER
2935 CENTER RD.
AVON, OH 44011
REFERRED BY: LORAIN COUNTY
ALLEGATION: 3517.13(B) AND (C)(FAILURE TO FILE A 2007 PRE AND POST-GENERAL REPORT)
OFFICE: AVON COUNCIL
ELECTION DATE: 11/6/07
PRIOR CASES: 2002R-006
DISPOSITION: 6/26/2008 THE COMMISSION DISMISSED THE MATTER AND DECLARED THE COMMITTEE TERMINATED PURSUANT TO COMMISSION ADVISORY OPINION 97ELC-04.
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION
CASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO: 2008R-107
RESPONDENT: CITIZENS FOR CHEVIOT
RYAN T. ZECH, TREASURER
3620 HOMELAWN AVE.
CINCINNATI, OH 45211
REFERRED BY: HAMILTON COUNTY
ALLEGATION: 3517.13(E)(FAILURE TO FILE A 2007 ANNUAL REPORT)
OFFICE:
ELECTION DATE:
PRIOR CASES: 2006R-750, 2007R-433
DISPOSITION: 3/5/2009 THE COMMISSION CONSOLIDATED CASE NOS. 2008R-107 AND 2008R-366, FOUND A VIOLATION OF R.C. §3517.13(D) AND (E) AND IMPOSED A FINE OF $25 PER DAY COMMENCING ON THE DATE THAT THE FILING WAS DUE UNTIL SUCH TIME AS IT IS FILED. THE COMMISSION MAY RECONSIDER THE MATTER IF THE REPORT IS FILED WITH THE APPROPRIATE FILING OFFICE AND A PROPERLY NOTARIZED AFFIDAVIT ALONG WITH A PAYMENT OF $200 IS RECEIVED BY THE COMMISSION WITHIN 30 DAYS OF THE NOTIFICATION OF THE DISPOSITION.
8/20/2009 ELC-1559- REFERRED TO THE ATTORNEY GENERAL’S OFFICE FOR COLLECTION OF FINE IN CASE NOS. 2006R-750, 2007R-433, 2008R-107, AND 2008R-366, FOR A COMBINED TOTAL OF $38,725.00.
9/2/2010 THE COMMISSION RECONSIDERED CASE NOS. 2006R-750, 2007R-433, 2008R-108, 2008R-366 AND 2009R-141 AND VACATED THE PREVIOUS FINDINGS. THE COMMISSION THEN CONSOLIDATED CASE NOS. 2006R-750, 2007R-433, 2008R-107, 2008R-366, 2009R-141, 2009R-402 AND 2010R-044, FOUND A VIOLATION AND IMPOSED A TOTAL JOINT FINE OF $600.
2/17/2011 THE COMMISSION RECEIVED CHECK #528 IN THE AMOUNT OF $600 FROM RYAN T ZECH FOR PAYMENT OF THE FINE IMPOSED.
CASE CLOSED
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION
CASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO: 2008R-108
RESPONDENT: CITIZENS FOR THE PRESERVATION OF A SAFE
CLEAN GREEN TOWNSHIP
LANGDON G. GUENTHER, TREASURER
4612 NATHANIEL GLEN DR.
CINCINNATI, OH 45248
REFERRED BY: HAMILTON COUNTY
ALLEGATION: 3517.13(E)(FAILURE TO FILE A 2007 ANNUAL REPORT)
OFFICE:
ELECTION DATE:
PRIOR CASES:
DISPOSITION: 6/26/2008 THE COMMISSION FOUND A VIOLATION OF R.C. §3517.13(E), BUT FOR GOOD CAUSE SHOWN DID NOT IMPOSE A FINE OR REFER THE MATTER FOR PROSECUTION.
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION
CASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO: 2008R-109
RESPONDENT: MELANIE BATES
3937 ROSE HILL AVE.
CINCINNATI, OH 45229
CAMPAIGN TO ELECT MELANIE BATES
PAUL A. KITZMILLER, TREASURER
2741 MINOT AVE., APT. 1
CINCINNATI, OH 45209
REFERRED BY: HAMILTON COUNTY
ALLEGATION: 3517.11(C)(FAILURE TO FILE A COMPLETE AMENDED 2007 ANNUAL REPORT)
OFFICE: CINCINNATI CITY COUNCIL MEMBER
ELECTION DATE: 11/6/07
PRIOR CASES:
DISPOSITION: 6/26/2008 THE COMMISSION FOUND A VIOLATION OF R.C. §3517.11(C) AND IMPOSED A FINE OF $25.00 PER DAY COMMENCING ON THE DATE THE FILING WAS DUE UNTIL SUCH TIME AS THE FILING IS MADE. THE COMMISSION MAY RECONSIDER THE MATTER IF THE FILING IS MADE WITH THE APPROPRIATE FILING OFFICE AND A PROPERLY NOTARIZED AFFIDAVIT IS FILED WITH THE COMMISSION WITHIN 30 DAYS OF NOTICE OF THE DISPOSITION.
6/25/2009 THE COMMISSION RECONSIDERED CASE NO. 2008R-109, VACATED THE PREVIOUS IMPOSITION OF OF A PER DIEM FINE, CONSOLIDATED WITH CASE NO. 2009R-157, FOUND A VIOLATION AND IMPOSED A JOINT FINE OF $100.
8/19/2009 RECEIVED CHECK #7094 IN THE AMOUNT OF $100 FOR THE PAYMENT OF THE FINE.
CASE CLOSED
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION
CASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO: 2008R-110
RESPONDENT: BRIAN GARRY
178 WOOLPER
CINCINNATI, OH 45220
BRIAN GARRY FOR ONE CINCINNATI
STEPHANIE KUZMA, DEPUTY TREASURER
3409 MIDDLETON AVE.
CINCINNATI, OH 45220
REFERRED BY: HAMILTON COUNTY
ALLEGATION: 3517.11(C)(FAILURE TO FILE A COMPLETE AMENDED 2007 SEMI-ANNUAL REPORT)
OFFICE: CINCINNATI CITY COUNCIL MEMBER
ELECTION DATE: 11/6/07
PRIOR CASES: 2004R-010, 2004R-665, 2006R-075, 2006R-801
DISPOSITION: 7/16/2009 THE COMMISSION FOUND A VIOLATION OF R.C. §3517.11(C) AND IMPOSED A FINE OF $250.
12/8/2009 RECEIVED CHECK #7615 IN THE AMOUNT OF $50 DOLLARS FROM BRIAN GARRY TO BE PAID TOWARD THE FINE IMPOSED. A BALANCE OF $200 IS STILL OUTSTANDING.
3/18/2010 THE COMMISSION RECONSIDERED CASE NO. 2008R-110, CONSOLIDATED ALL OUTSTANDING CASES, FOUND A VIOLATION AND IMPOSED A JOINT FINE OF $400.
08/09/2010 CLAIM NO. ELC-1591/ELC-1591 COMBINED CASE NOS. 2008R-110 AND 2009R-447, AND REFERRED THESE CASES TO THE ATTORNEY GENERAL’S OFFICE FOR COLLECTION OF A FINE IN THE AMOUNT OF $400.00.
9/8/2010 RECEIVED CHECK # 8399 IN THE AMOUNT OF $50 FROM BRIAN GARRY AS PAYMENT TOWARD THE FINE IMPOSED.
9/28/2010 RECEIVED FROM THE AG CHECK #000780622 IN THE AMT. OF $1385.10 IN WHICH $100.10 IS APPLIED TO THIS ACCT.
10/13/2010 RECEIVED CHECK #8505 IN THE AMOUNT OF $50 FROM GREEN CITY ECOSTRUCTION FOR PAYMENT OF THE FINE IMPOSED.
11/29/2010 RECEIVED CHECK #8125 IN THE AMOUNT OF $200 FROM GREEN CITY ECOSTRUCTION FOR PAYMENT OF THE FINE IMPOSED.
CLOSED CASE
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION
CASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO: 2008R-111
RESPONDENT: ANDRE HARPER
7848 BANWOOD LANE
CINCINNATI, OH 45224
HARPER FOR CITY COUNCIL
ALAN D. TUCKER, TREASURER
11431 FLAGLER LANE
CINCINNATI, OH 45240
REFERRED BY: HAMILTON COUNTY
ALLEGATION: 3517.13(C)(FAILURE TO FILE A 2007 POST-GENERAL REPORT)
OFFICE: CINCINNATI COUNCIL
ELECTION DATE: 11/6/07
PRIOR CASES:
DISPOSITION: 6/26/2008 THE COMMISSION CONSOLIDATED CASE NUMBERS 2008R-111 AND 2008R-216. THE COMMISSION FOUND A VIOLATION OF R.C. §3517.13(C) FOR CASE NUMBER 2008R-111 AND A VIOLATION OF R.C. §3517.11(C) FOR CASE NUMBER 2008R-216, BUT FOR GOOD CAUSE SHOWN DID NOT IMPOSE A FINE OR REFER THE MATTER FOR PROSECUTION.
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION
CASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO: 2008R-112
RESPONDENT: ROBERT B. GEUY
ROBERT B. GEUY FOR COUNTY ENGINEER
ROBERT B. GEUY, TREASURER
100 BULLE RD.
PIQUA, OH 45356
REFERRED BY: SHELBY COUNTY
ALLEGATION: 3517.13(B)(LATE FILING OF A 2008 PRE-PRIMARY REPORT)
OFFICE: SHELBY ENGINEER
ELECTION DATE: 3/4/08
PRIOR CASES:
DISPOSITION: 6/26/2008 THE COMMISSION FOUND NO VIOLATION OF R.C. §3517.13(B).
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION
CASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO: 2008R-113
RESPONDENT: DOUG SCHLAGETTER
DOUG SCHLAGETTER FOR SHELBY COUNTY SHERIFF COMMITTEE
KAREN J. SCHLAGETTER, TREASURER
441 LUNAR ST.
SIDNEY, OH 45365
REFERRED BY: SJHELBY COUNTY
ALLEGATION: 3517.13(B)(LATE FILING OF A 2008 PRE-PRIMARY REPORT)
OFFICE: SHELBY SHERIFF
ELECTION DATE: 3/4/08
PRIOR CASES:
DISPOSITION: 6/26/2008 THE COMMISSION FOUND NO VIOLATION OF R.C. §3517.13(B).
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION
CASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO: 2008R-114
RESPONDENT: TRUDY WHIPPLE
WHIPPLE FOR COUNCIL
TRUDY WHIPPLE, TREASURER
1384 BYRD ST.
CINCINNATI, OH 45215
REFERRED BY: HAMILTON COUNTY
ALLEGATION: 3517.13(C)(FAILURE TO FILE A 2007 POST-GENERAL REPORT)
OFFICE: LINCOLN HTS. VLG. COUNCIL
ELECTION DATE: 11/6/07
PRIOR CASES:
DISPOSITION: 6/26/2008 THE COMMISSION FOUND A VIOLATION OF R.C. §3517.13(C), BUT FOR GOOD CAUSE SHOWN DID NOT IMPOSE A FINE OR REFER THE MATTER FOR PROSECUTION.
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION
CASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO: 2008R-115
RESPONDENT: GREGORY L. STROLE
STROLE FOR LOCKLAND
GREGORY L. STROLE, TREASURER
307 N. COOPER AVE.
LOCKLAND, OH 45215
REFERRED BY: HAMILTON COUNTY
ALLEGATION: 3517.13(C)(FAILURE TO FILE A 2007 POST-GENERAL REPORT)
OFFICE: LOCKLAND VLG. COUNCIL
ELECTION DATE: 11/6/07
PRIOR CASES:
DISPOSITION: 6/26/2008 THE COMMISSION FOUND A VIOLATION OF R.C. §3517.13(C) AND IMPOSED A FINE OF $25.00 PER DAY COMMENCING ON THE DATE THE FILING WAS DUE UNTIL SUCH TIME AS THE FILING IS MADE. THE COMMISSION MAY RECONSIDER THE MATTER IF THE FILING IS MADE WITH THE APPROPRIATE FILING OFFICE AND A PROPERLY NOTARIZED AFFIDAVIT IS FILED WITH THE COMMISSION WITHIN 30 DAYS OF NOTICE OF THE DISPOSITION.
2/11/2008 THE COMMISSION RECONSIDERED THE MATTER, VACATED THE PREVIOUS IMPOSITION OF PER DIEM FINE AND INSTEAD IMPOSED A FINE OF $100.00.
2/18/09 RECEIVED FROM GREGORY L STROLE MONEY ORDER #57546757191 IN THE AMOUNT OF $100.00 FOR FINE.
CASE CLOSED
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION
CASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO: 2008R-116
RESPONDENT: VICKIE HOPPE
3431 HARBORWAY
SHARONVILLE, OH 45241
FRIENDS TO ELECT VICKIE HOPPE
CYNDI BROWN, TREASURER
10889 WENGATE LANE
CINCINNATI, OH 45241
REFERRED BY: HAMILTON COUNTY
ALLEGATION: 3517.13(C)(FAILURE TO FILE A 2007 POST-GENERAL REPORT)
OFFICE: SHARONVILLE CITY COUNCIL
ELECTION DATE: 11/6/07
PRIOR CASES:
DISPOSITION: 6/26/2008 THE COMMISSION FOUND A VIOLATION OF R.C. §3517.13(C), BUT FOR GOOD CAUSE SHOWN DID NOT IMPOSE A FINE OR REFER THE MATTER FOR PROSECUTION.
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION
CASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO: 2008R-117
RESPONDENT: JOSEPH T. BRICKLER
BRICKLER FOR WARD 4
MARY L. BRICKLER, TREASURER
4617 VINE ST.
CINCINNATI, OH 45217
REFERRED BY: HAMILTON COUNTY
ALLEGATION: 3517.13(C)(FAILURE TO FILE A 2007 POST-GENERAL REPORT)
OFFICE: ST. BERNARD CITY COUNCIL WARD 4
ELECTION DATE: 11/6/07
PRIOR CASES:
DISPOSITION: 7/10/08 THE COMMISSION FOUND A VIOLATION OF R.C. §3517.13(C) AND IMPOSED A FINE OF $25.00 PER DAY COMMENCING ON THE DATE THE FILING WAS DUE UNTIL SUCH TIME AS THE FILING IS MADE. THE COMMISSION MAY RECONSIDER THE MATTER IF THE FILING IS MADE WITH THE APPROPRIATE FILING OFFICE AND A PROPERLY NOTARIZED AFFIDAVIT IS FILED WITH THE COMMISSION WITHIN 30 DAYS OF NOTICE OF THE DISPOSITION.
9/18/2008 THE COMMISSION RECONSIDERED THE MATTER, VACATED THE PREVIOUS FINE AMOUNT AND FOUND GOOD CAUSE PRESENT NOT TO IMPOSE A FINE OR REFER THE MATTER FOR FURTHER PROSECUTION.
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION
CASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO: 2008R-118
RESPONDENT: STEVE GALSTER
COMMITTEE TO ELECT STEVE GALSTER TO
SPRINGDALE CITY COUNCIL
NANCY GALSTER, TREASURER
11821 GLENFALLS CT.
CINCINNATI, OH 45246
REFERRED BY: HAMILTON COUNTY
ALLEGATION: 3517.13(C)(FAILURE TO FILE A 2007 POST-GENERAL REPORT)
OFFICE: SPRINDALE CITY COUNCIL
ELECTION DATE: 11/6/07
PRIOR CASES:
DISPOSITION: 7/10/2008 THE COMMISSION FOUND A VIOLATION OF R.C. §3517.13(C), BUT FOR GOOD CAUSE SHOWN DID NOT IMPOSE A FINE OR REFER THE MATTER FOR PROSECUTION.
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION
CASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO: 2008R-119
RESPONDENT: EDITH THROWER
EDITH E. THROWER COMMITTEE
EDITH THROWER, TREASURER
2628 CLEINVIEW AVE
CINCINNATI, OH 45206
REFERRED BY: HAMILTON COUNTY
ALLEGATION: 3517.13(D)(FAILURE TO FILE A 2007 ANNUAL REPORT)
OFFICE: BOARD OF EDUCATION
ELECTION DATE: 11/4/07
PRIOR CASES: 98R-034, 98R-364, 98R-456, 99R-261, 2000R-737, 2001R-185, 2003R-173, 2005R-038, 2006R-071, 2007R-102, 2007R-357
DISPOSITION: 12/11/2008 THE COMMISSION FOUND A VIOLATION OF R.C. §3517.13(D) AND IMPOSED A FINE OF $31,500 PLUS $100.00 PER DAY COMMENCING ON THE DATE THE REPORT WAS DUE UNTIL SUCH TIME AS THE REPORT IS FILED. THE COMMISSION MAY RECONSIDER THE MATTER IF THE REPORT IS FILED AND A PROPERLY NOTARIZED AFFIDAVIT IS RECEIVED ALONG WITH A PAYMENT OF $15,000.00 WITHIN 30 DAYS OF THE NOTIFICATION OF THE DISPOSITION.
04/01/2010 THE COMMISSION RECONSIDERED THE MATTER AND VACATED THE PER DIEM FINE, CONSOLIDATED CASE NOS. 2006R-071, 2007R-102, 2007R-357, 2009R-119 AND 2009R-173, AND IMPOSED A JOINT FINE OF $1,000.
7/19/2010 RECEIVED CHECK # 2040 IN THE AMOUNT OF $100 FROM EDITH THROWER.
8/24/2010 RECEIVED MONEY ORDER #127693 IN THE AMOUNT OF $100 FROM EDITH THROWER.
03/02/2011 ELC-1704 COMBINED CASE NOS. 206R-071, 2007R-102, 2007R-357, 2008R-119 AND 2009R-173, AND REFERRED THESE CASES TO THE ATTORNEY GENERAL’S OFFICE FOR COLLECTION OF A TOTAL FINE IN THE AMOUNT OF $700.00. – CANCELLED 3/5/2011
03/04/2011 RECEIVED MONEY ORDER #212428 IN THE AMOUNT OF $500 FROM EDITH THROWER --BALANCE DUE $200.00
06/28/2011 CASE CLOSED PER PCR
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION
CASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO: 2008R-120
RESPONDENT: JAY SLAUGHTER
20455 PACKARD ST.
DETROIT, MI 48234
SLAUGHTER'S COMMITTEE
YVONDA HOARD GASTON, TREASURER
5452 BETTMAN DR
CINCINNATI, OH 45232
REFERRED BY: HAMILTON COUNTY
ALLEGATION: 3517.13(D)(FAILURE TO FILE A 2007 ANNUAL REPORT)
OFFICE: CINCINNATI CITY COUNCIL
ELECTION DATE: 11/6/01
PRIOR CASES: 2002R-261, 2003R-169, 2004R-312, 2005R-045, 2006R-076, 2007R-084
DISPOSITION: 11/3/2011 THE COMMISSION RECONSIDERED THE MATTER, VACATED THE PREVIOUS IMPOSITION AND ALLOWED THE MATTER TO BE WITHDRAWN BY THE BOARD OF ELECTIONS.
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSION
CASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO: 2008R-121
RESPONDENT: VICTOR MONROE PHILLIPS
15 E 8TH ST. #2
CINCINNATI, OH 45202