Minutes of the 139th meeting of the Committee Constituted for Deciding the Consent under Orange Category, held on 27.04.2010 in the Conference Room of Chairman, DPCC.

The following persons attended the meeting:

Sh. Dharmendra, Chairman, DPCC

Dr. A.K.Ambasht, Member Secretary, DPCC

Sh. B. Kumar, SEE, DPCC

EEs of CMC – I, II, III & IV.

AEEs of CMC – I, II, III & IV.

Prof. S. K. Gupta, IIT-Delhi and Sh. M. Dwarakanth, SSO, Dept. of Env,. GNCTD could not attend the meeting.

Following decisions were taken in the said meeting:-

Agenda Item No. 1- Fresh Consent to Establish cases w.e.f. 29.09.2009 in which inspection was decided in CMC meeting dated 13.11.2009 and inspection was yet to be conducted as apprised in Scrutinizing Committee.

Decisions taken with respect to this agenda are tabulated and annexed as Annexure – 1.

Agenda Item No. 2- Fresh Consent to Operate / Renewal cases w.e.f. 29.09.2009 in which inspection was decided in CMC meeting dated 21.12.2009 / 22.12.2009 and inspection was yet to be conducted as apprised in Scrutinizing Committee.

Decisions taken with respect to this agenda are tabulated and annexed as Annexure – 2.

Agenda Item No. 3- Fresh CTE cases under Orange category w.e.f. 03.11.2009 in which inspection was decided in CMC meeting dated 21.12.09 / 22.12.09 and inspection was yet to be conducted as apprised in Scrutinizing Committee.

Decisions taken with respect to this agenda are tabulated and annexed as Annexure – 3.

Agenda Item No. 4- (i) Review of ATR w.r.t. Fresh Consent to Operate/ Renewal cases under Orange category w.e.f. 03.11.2009 considered in CMC meeting dated 21.12.2009 / 22.12.2009 and reviewed by Scrutinizing Committee meeting dated 31.03.2010/01.04.2010 : during the Scrutinizing meeting, ATR w.r.t. 44 number of cases in which consent has been granted was apprised. The agenda for the CMC(Orange) consist the cases other than those in which consent has been granted and (ii) the cases in which inspection was yet to be conducted as apprised in Scrutinizing Committee.

Decisions taken with respect to this agenda are tabulated and annexed as Annexure – 4.

Agenda Item No. 5- (i) Review of ATR w.r.t. Fresh Consent to Establish cases under Orange category w.e.f. 01.12.2009 considered in CMC meeting dated 25.01.2010 and reviewed by Scrutinizing Committee meeting dated 31.03.2010/01.04.2010 : during the Scrutinizing meeting, ATR w.r.t. 50 number of cases in which consent has been granted was apprised. The agenda for the CMC(Orange) consist the cases other than those in which consent has been granted and (ii) the cases in which inspection was yet to be conducted as apprised in Scrutinizing Committee.

Decisions taken with respect to this agenda are tabulated and annexed as Annexure – 5.

Agenda Item No. 6- (i) Review of ATR w.r.t. Fresh Consent to Operate/ Renewal cases under Orange category w.e.f. 01.12.2009 considered in CMC meting dated 25.01.2010 and reviewed by Scrutinizing Committee meeting dated 31.03.2010/01.04.2010 : during the Scrutinizing meeting, ATR w.r.t. 34 number of cases in which consent has been granted was apprised. The agenda for the CMC(Orange) consist the cases other than those in which consent has been granted and (ii) the cases in which inspection was yet to be conducted as apprised in Scrutinizing Committee.

Decisions taken with respect to this agenda are tabulated and annexed as Annexure – 6.

Agenda Item No. 7- Table Agenda Items considered by Scrutinizing Committee meeting dated 31.03.2010/01.04.2010.

Decisions taken with respect to this agenda are tabulated and annexed as Annexure – 7.

Agenda Item No. 8- Case of M/s Bentex Control & Switchgear Co. for which the CMC decided to seek legal opinion in its meeting dated 12.02.2010/15.02.2010.

Decisions taken with respect to this agenda are tabulated and annexed as Annexure – 8.

Table Agenda Item No 1: M/s Negolice India Ltd. Construction of Residential Complex named "Victoria Gardens" at Ring Road, Azadpur, New Delhi

The unit came for personal hearing today. The representative of the unit stated that they have filed an appeal in view of the provision of section 27 (2) which prescribes that the Committee has powered to review any of the condition imposed during the course of exercise of powers under section 25/26. Committee deliberated on the issue and decided to defer for next CMC.

Table Agenda Item No 2: Two Table Agenda were considered, the decision taken is annexed as Annexure-9.

Meeting ended with thanks to the chair.

Sl. No / ID No / appl_dt / firm_name / firm_address / area_name / Proposed Activity/ Product / Earlier CMC Decisions / ATR / Remarks / Latest ATR / Remarks / Recommendations of Scrutinizing Committee on 31.03.2010 / 01.04.2010 / Decision on 27.04.2010
1 / 31588 / 30-09-2009 / GUGAR MARKETING PRIVATE LIMITED / PLOT NO 358, KOHAT ENCLAVE, PITAMPURA / NC-NW / Sweet shop and restaurant. / 13.11.2009
Issue Consent to Establish. Subsequently, inspection be conducted. / Trade effluent-350l/day
Production-150kg/day
Oil & grease trap proposed / Consent issued. Inspection yet to be conducted. / Inspection be expedited. / Inspection done. Issue SCN for not applying consent to operate and for non installation of ETP.
2 / 31606 / 01-10-2009 / ALKA FOODS PVT. LTD. / 26 / SSI INDUSTRIAL AREA / Mfg of confectionery and ayurvedic products. / 13.11.2009
Issue Consent to Establish. Subsequently, inspection be conducted. / Trade effluent-NIL
No air & water pollution proposed.
No D.G set. / Consent issued. Inspection yet to be conducted. / Inspection be expedited. / Inspection done. Ask the unit to apply for consent to operate immediately. Inform to DJB regarding extraction of ground water.
3 / 31618 / 05-10-2009 / THE BELLE LABORATORIES (P) LTD. / 1/562, STREET NO. 8 / FRIENDS COLONY INDUSTRIAL AREA / Mfg of Silicon of Detergent. / 17.06.2009
Issue SCN u/s 21 of the Air Act and u/s 25/26 for not obtaining consent to establish and consent to operate. Call on 19.08.2009.
13.11.2009
Issue Consent to Establish without trade effluent discharge. Subsequently, inspection be conducted. / Inspection by SIT on 05.02.2009 and it was observed that waste water is generated from floor washing & mixture washing. However, as per CTE application unit claimed that no trade effluent discharge. / Consent issued.
Inspection report discussed and the case was considered in CMC where it was decided to re-inspect the unit.
Re-inspection yet to be done / Inspection be expedited. / Inspection be expedited.
4 / 31619 / 05-10-2009 / SPEED PRINTERS / PLOT NO. 28, BLOCK-A / GTK ROAD INDUSTRIAL AREA / Printing of calender, pictures on offset machine. / 13.11.2009
Issue Consent to Establish. Subsequently, inspection be conducted. / Trade effluent- NIL / Consent issued. Inspection yet to be conducted. / Inspection be expedited. / Inspection done. Ask the unit to apply for consent to operate immediately. Issue SCN u/s 5 of the EPA on the basis of deficiencies w.r.t. HWM Rules.
5 / 31665 / 09-10-2009 / PURI ENTERPRISES / C-89, SECTOR-2, DSIDC / BAWANA INDUSTRIAL AREA / Mfg of iron foundaries. / 13.11.2009
Inspection be conducted to find out the type of furnace.. / No D.G set.
Regarding air pollution unit has proposed that unit will provide proper channelization systems with stack to be installed to control air emission. / Inspection yet to be conducted. / Inspection be expedited. / Inspection done. Decision deferred till clarification from DDA.
6 / 31723 / 23-10-2009 / AMIT METAL COMPANY / E-168, PHASE-II / MAYAPURI INDUSTRIAL AREA / Trading & dismentaling of electronic and electrical waste / Decision on 13.11.2009
Ask the unit to provide method of disposal of e-waste and documentary evidence w.r.t. disposal of e-waste to recylcer approved by CPCB/MOEF. / Earlier the case was considered in CMC w.r.t a public complaint . As per CMC(O) dated 06.08.02, closure directions were issued on 19.09.09 due to non submission of CTE application . Now unit has applied for CTE. / Letter issued.
Unit submitted its reply stating that unit is engaged in trading & dismantling of Electronic and electrical waste and after dismentalling and separeation it is send for segregation through transport to recycler M/S Kaysons Pigments Pvt. Ltd at G-24 , Industrial area Odella Road, Rllco Dhdpur 328001, Rajasthan, which is approved by CPCB. ( Copy of Certificate enclosed) / Inspection be conducted. / Inspection be expedited.
7 / 31741 / 27-10-2009 / SOHAIL INDUSTRIES / C-60/5 / WAZIRPUR INDUSTRIAL AREA / Electroplating job work / 13.11.2009
Issue Consent to Establish. Subsequently, inspection be conducted. / Trade effluent-400l/day
D.G set-NIL
ETP proposed / Consent issued. Inspection yet to be conducted. / Inspection be expedited. / Inspection done. Ask the unit to apply for consent to operate immediately.
8 / 31753 / 28-10-2009 / STAIN LAY ISPAAT PVT. LTD. / 39 / SSI INDUSTRIAL AREA / Annealing, Cold re-rolling and cleaning of S.S Sheetsby electrocleaning process. / Decision on 13.11.2009
Case be shifted to BMW Cell. / Proposed Dec, 2009 / Inspection yet to be conducted. / Inspection be expedited. / Inspection done. Issue SCN for removal of facilities of pickling activity.
Sl. No / ID No / appl_dt / firm_name / firm_address / area_name / Proposed Activity/ Product / Category / Earlier CMC Decisions / Quantity of Ground water extraction / ATR / Remarks / Latest ATR / Remarks / Recommendations of Scrutinizing Committee on 31.03.2010 / 01.04.2010 / Decision on 27.04.2010
1 / 31605 / 01-10-2009 / SUNRISE PLASTIC / A-186, DSIDC / NARELA INDUSTRIAL AREA / Mfg of plastic without reprocessing / OPERATE / 21.12.2009/22.12.2009
Inspection be conducted. Refer to DJB for ground water extraction. Also file be put up administratively along with old file. / 150l/day / No D.G set
CTO applied on 26.07.02
CTO refused on 03.09.2004 / Inspection yet to be done. / Inspection be expedited. / Inspection be expedited.
2 / 31608 / 01-10-2009 / R.S. AJIT & CO. / C-91/10B / WAZIRPUR INDUSTRIAL AREA / Servicing(worhshop cum service station of tools) / OPERATE / 21.12.2009/22.12.2009
Ask the unit to apply for Consent to Establish and inspection be carried out. Also refer to DJB for ground water extraction. / 2KLD / unit has never applied for CTE & CTO earlier.It is operating since, 2006.
Trade effluent-1500KLD/day
D.G set-62.5KVA / Inspection yet to be done. / Inspection be expedited. / Inspection done. Ask the unit to submit fresh adequacy report of ETP from empanelled consultant of DPCC and to correct the deficiencies noted during inspection and submit an affidavit in this regard.
3 / 31634 / 07-10-2009 / ESTOCORP (INDIA) PVT. LTD / B-56, PHASE-I / OKHLA INDUSTRIAL AREA / Mfg. of readymade garments & home furnishing items with washing / OPERATE / 21.12.2009 / 22.12.2009
Ask the unit to apply for Consent to Establish. Also inspection be carried out to check source of water. / nil / 1.CTE not applied.
2.Comencement-1991.
3.DG-125Kva & 110 Kva, NMR Submitted & SMR submitted
4.Trade effluent- 8000 Lt/day, adequacy report & effluent analysis report submitted. / CTE applied on 12.03.10 Inspection yet to be done. / Inspection be expedited. / Inspection done. Inform to DJB regarding extraction of ground water. Issue consent to operate and consent to esablish with the condition to obtain the permission from DJB for ground water extraction.
4 / 31649 / 08-10-2009 / SUPERMAX DRUGS & PHARMACEUTICALS PVT LTD. / H-1231, DSIDC / NARELA INDUSTRIAL AREA / Mfg of pharmesutical products / OPERATE / 21.12.2009/22.12.2009
Ask the unit to apply for Consent to Establilsh. Also inspection be condcuted. / NIL / Trade effluent-50l/day
D.G set-15KVA
AR& NMR report submitted / Letter issued.
Applied for CTE on 23.02.2010
Also Inspection yet to be conducted.. / Inspection be expedited. / Inspection done. Issue consent to operate. Ask the unit to apply for authorization under HWM Rules.
5 / 31660 / 09-10-2009 / AUTO INDUSTRIES / A-108 / WAZIRPUR INDUSTRIAL AREA / Forging of Non Ferrous alloys mainly auto parts / OPERATE / 21.12.2009/22.12.2009
Inspection be conducted. / _ / CTO refused on 03.09.2004 / Inspection yet to be conducted. / Inspection be expedited. / Inspection done. Ask the unit to apply for consent to establish.
6 / 31704 / 15-10-2009 / R.K. METAL INDUSTRIES / A-99/3 / WAZIRPUR INDUSTRIAL AREA / Mfg copper & brass sheets with casting, melting & wasing etc. / OPERATE / 07.01.2009
Ask the unit to install Effluent Treatment Plant (ETP) as per the previous adequacy report. Call on 25.02.2009
25.02.09
Ask the unit to install flow meter as advised in the adequacy report. Call on 15.04.2009
29.04.09
Issue renewal of conent. Call on 28.05.2009
21.12.2009/22.12.2009
Inspection be conducted. / _ / CTE granted & valid upto 14.04.09
CTR granted & valid upto 11.10.09
Submitted affidavit is contradictory, on one hand unit stated that there is discharged of 200 lt/day in sewer and in another column unit states that there is no trade effluent discharge.
Submitted copy of AR & MR of ETP & ECS. Parameters are within limit. NMR of D.G. Set also submitted.
Authorization under HWM was issued on 13.07.2009 for five years period.
Unit is using oil fired furnace for melting of copper scrap. Source of purchase of scrap not mentioned. / Inspection yet to be conducted. / Inspection be expedited. / Inspection done. Issue SCN for refusal of consent on the basis of deficiencies noted during the inspection.