IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

(CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION)

I.A. No. of 2016

In

CIVIL APPEAL NO. 4347 OF 2014

IN THE MATTER OF

State of Uttar Pradesh & Ors. ………...PETITIONERS

VERSUS

Shiv Kumar Pathak .…….RESPONDENTS

AND

IN THE MATTER OF:

1. Satya Kumar S/o Parasu Ram R/o Village- Siraichnow Post- Jarauli Newada, District- Hardoi- 241403, U.P.

2. Murli Dhar Sharma S/o Munnalal Sharma R/o 2, Shubash Nagar, Panchampurawa Road, District- Sitapur, U.P.

3. Vipin Kumar Mishra S/o Shiv Kumar Mishra R/o 137 Narayan Nagar, Shahjahanpur Road, Hempurwa, District- Sitapur, U.P.

4. Alka Srivastava D/o Pankaj Kumar Srivastava, R/o 114, Lohar Bagh, District- Sitapur, U.P.

5. Praveen Kumar Mishra S/o Ram Chandra Mishra R/o Village- Bhat Purwa, Post- Bachhawal, District- Sitapur, U.P.

6. Amit Banswar S/o Ram Nath Verma R/o 24, Kathali Bagh, Sitapur, U.P.

7. Komal Shukla D/o Badshah Shukla R/o Agnihotri Nagar, Garhi near Idea Tower Post- Midania District- Lakhimpur Khiri, U.P.

8. Mohammad Aroon S/o Mubarak Ali R/o Village Lodhpurwa, Post- Bawdhiya Kalan District- Sitapur, U.P.

9. Brijesh Kumar Shukla S/o Bangali Prasad R/o Village- Allipur, Post- Jar, District- Sitapur, U.P.

10. Rajesh Kumar Mishra S/o Ramesh Chandra Mishra R/o M.N. 106, Police Line Paraid, Jail Road, District- Sitapur, U.P.

11. Rishi Mishra S/o Sudhir Mishra R/o Naimishpuram, Naipalpur, District- Sitapur, U.P.

12. Rachna Bajpai D/o Arvind Kumar Bajpai R/o Naimishpuram, Naipalpur, District- Sitapur, U.P.

13. Priya Mishra D/o Karuna Sankar Mishra R/o Sandhya Sadan, Baragaon Moholi, District- Sitapur, U.P.

14. Om Prakash Singh S/o Chhavi Nath Singh R/o Village- Kamalpur, Post- Kutubnagar, District- Sitapur, U.P.

15. Rajesh Kumar Dixit S/o Krishna Dutt Dixti R/o Village- Harni Post- Keshavpur District- Sitapur, U.P.

16. Ram Pratap Singh S/o Shatrohan Prasad R/o Village Takela Post- Karsyora, District- Sitapur, U.P.

17. Anil Kumar S/o Than Singh R/o Village- Baghulyai Post- Mohammadabad, District- Auraiya-206241, U.P.

18. Lalit Kumar Verma S/o Pramod Kumar R/o Village Takela Post- Karsewra, District- Sitapur, U.P.

19. Pankaj Kumar Sharma S/o Sarvesh Kumar Sharma R/o Village and Post- Miaun District- Baddun, U.P.

20. Dileep Kumar Singh S/o Ram Narayan Singh R/o Village- Baherava, Post- Arthapur, District- Sitapur, U.P.

21. Amit Mishra S/o Umesh Mishra R/o Sardar form Durga Purva, District- Sitapur, U.P.

22. Lalit Mohan Gupta S/o Rajendra Prasad Gupta R/o Village and Post- Talgaon District- Sitapur, U.P.

23. Savitri Singh D/o Surendra Singh R/o 124, Adda Nurakhan Sirajamao, District- Etwah, U.P.

24. Ashok Kumar Shukla S/o Ram Kanth Shukla R/o 334, Budhnagar, Hussainganj, District- Sitapur, U.P.

25. Alok Kumar Shukla S/o Ram Kanth Shukla R/o 334, Budhnagar, Hussainganj, District- Sitapur, U.P.

26. Sandeep Kumar S/o Sewak Ram R/o Village- Kureli Post- Pipargaon, District- Farrukkabad, U.P.

27. Alok Tiwari S/o Baikunth Nath Tiwari R/o Village- Kureli Post- Pipargaon, District- Farrukabad, U.P.

28. Rama Singh D/o Ravi Pratap Singh R/o 538 K 1444 Shri Puram Triveni Nagar-3, Lucknow, U.P.

29. Ram Babu Mishra S/o Ashok Kumar Mishra R/o Village and post- Daranagar, District- Sitapur, U.P.

30. Rajneesh Pratap S/o Munna Lal Rathor R/o 294, Durga Purwa, Sitapur, U.P.

31. Seema Singh D/o Arvind Kumar Singh R/o Village- Babauna, Post- Mitauli, District- Lakhimpur Kheri, U.P.

32. Abbas Zaidi S/o Mohd. Abbas Zaidi R/o Village and Post- Vadhaiya, District- Lakhimpur Khiri, U.P.

33. Ram Singh Yadav S/o Chhatra Pal Yadav R/o Village- Periya Kodar, Post- Machhreath, District- Sitapur, U.P.

34. Niharika Pandey D/o Pankaj Pandey R/o H.N. 97 A Moh. Shbash Nag District- Shajahanpur, U.P.

35. Praveen Kumar S/o Arun Kumar R/o Village Shabajpur, Post- Hanumanganj, District- Allahabad, U.P.

36. Saroj Singh S/o Lallu Singh R/o Village- Prayagpur Chhapra, Sohnag Salempur, District- Deoria, U.P.

37. Ajay Kumar Srivastava S/o Anil Kumar Srivastva R/o Moh. Bhikhpura Post- Sikandarpur, District- Ballia-277303, U.P.

38. Amresh Kumar Verma S/o Hira Lal Verma R/o Village- Ganj Kishor, Post- Chetankishor, District- Ballia- 277303, U.P.

39. Rajneesh Verma S/o Hans Nath Verma R/o Village- Duha, Post- Dudhabihara, District- Ballia, 221717, U.P.

40. Pritam Baboo Chauhan S/o Jay Ram Chauhan R/o Village- Manikpur, Post- Gahami, District- Mau- 221705, U.P.

41. Bhuwal S/o Shyama Yadav R/o Village- Nausemar, Post- Kopaganj, District- Mau- 275305, U.P.

42. Dinesh Kumar Singh S/o Ram Kailash Singh R/o Village- Sarai Mahmajiya, Post- Bhopatpur, District- Allahabad, U.P.

43. Kaushlesh Singh S/o Raj Bahadur R/o Village and Post- Jagatpur, District- Allahabad, U.P.

44. Abhishek Kumar Srivastava S/o Ram Kumar Srivastava R/o Dwarikapuri Oppsite Krishna Takij, Post- Lakhimpur, District- Lakhimpur, PIN-262701, U.P.

45. Rajni Mishra D/o R.D. Mishra R/o 210 Santoshnagar Colony Post-Lakhimpur, District- Lakhimpur, PIN 262701, U.P.

46. Jaya shukla D/o Vinod Shankar Shukla R/o Village and Post Khamaila District- Kanpur Dehat, PIN-209302 U.P.

47. Kamal Kant S/o Brij Mohan Verma R/o Yogendra Vihar Khandepur Naubasta District-Kanpur, PIN-208021, U.P.

48. Ajay Kumar Hans S/o Chet Ram Hans R/o H. No. 220, B- Block Ambedkar Nagar Loharbagh, District- Sitapur, PIN-261001, U.P.

49. Mahfooz Alam S/o Mohd. Habib R/o Islam Bagh Sekh Sarai Near Sitapur City Station District- Sitapur PIN-261001.

50. Mohd. Ishaq S/o Ali Ahamad R/o 346 Butts Ganj Near Bandh, District- Sitapur, PIN 261001, U.P.

51. Priyanka Singh D/o Shiv Kumar Singh R/o 109 New Gwal Mandi Post- Sitapur, District- Sitapur, PIN- 261001, U.P.

52. Rehan Ahmad Khan S/o Irfan Ahmad Khan R/o 211, Mirdahi Tola City Station Road District- Sitapur, PIN- 261001, U.P.

53. Sajid Ali S/o Waris Ali R/o Hazi Ready Made Moh- Katra Laharpur District- Sitapur PIN-261135, U.P.

54. Ram Das S/o Ram Swaroop R/o V-Khandheriya Post- Bansa District- Hardoi, PIN 241303, U.P.

55. Mamta Mishra D/o Raj Kumar Mishra R/o Moh- Krishna Nagar District- Sitapur, PIN-261001, U.P.

56. Vikas Mishra S/o Raj Kumar Mishra R/o Moh- Krishna Nagar District- Sitapur, PIN-261001, U.P.

57. Parvej Ekbal S/o Liyakat Hussain R/o 64, Fattan Sarain Manni Chauraha District- Sitapur, PIN-261001, U.P.

58. Abhishek Mishra S/o Karuna Shanker Mishra R/o 509, Sanjay Nagar District- Sitapur PIN-261001, U.P.

59. Madhu Shanker Mishra S/o Ajay Kumar Mishra R/o 148/10 Narrottam Nagar Pani Tanki Road Sidhuli District- Sitapur, U.P.

60. Sanjai Kumar S/o Shitala Prasad R/o H.N. 83/164 A, Juhi Param Purwa Post- Juhi District – Kanpur, PIN 208014, U.P.

61. Kalpana Singh D/o Ram Naresh Singh R/o Azad Nagar Colony, District- Sitapur, U.P.

62. Priti Pandey D/o Anil Kumar Pandey R/o M. No. 788 Narmal Tiraha Pandey Hatha Road, Turkmanpur, District- Gorakhpur, U.P.

63. Atul Kumar S/o Ram Kumar R/o 243, Ghuramou Bangla District- Sitapur, PIN 261001, U.P.

64. Dharmendra Kumar S/o Sankta Prasad R/o Vill- Kaima Bujurg Post- Karanpur, District- Lakhimpur Kheri, U.P.

65. Sanjay Gupta S/o Bicharan Lal Gupta R/o Village Gondhiya Post- Parariya Tola District- Lakhimpur Kheri PIN-262901, U.P.

66. Devendra Kumar S/o Chandra Bhal R/o Vill-Jaitapur Post- Kaimahra District- Lakhimpur Kheri, PIN- 262701, U.P.

67. Dinesh Kumar Gautam S/o Sunder Lal R/o Moh-Hathipur Koriyana, H. No. 2042, District- Lakhimpur Khiri PIN-262701, U.P.

68. Jag Jiwan Ram S/o Ram Lal R/o Moh- Gomti Nagar Ward-2, Ramnagar District- Lakhimpur Khiri, PIN-262701, U.P.

69. Vijay Prakesh S/o Hajaree Lal R/o Village- Phool Behar, District- Lakhimpur Kheri PIN- 261506, U.P.

70. Mohammad Afzaal S/o Mohammad Ayyub R/o Moh-Katra Azadnagar, Post- Laharpur District- Sitapur, U.P.

71. Mukesh Kumar S/o Hetpal Singh R/o Village Nagla Gariba Post- Barat Kalyanpur, Awagarh, District – Etah, PIN-207301, U.P.

72. Anil Kumar S/o Deen Dayal R/o H.No. 192 Prem Nagar Etah District- Etah PIN-207001, U.P.

73. Amitosh Tiwari S/o Banvir Prasad R/o Veer Prasad Ashok Nagar, Nidholi Road Etah District- Etah, PIN-207001, U.P.

74. Naveen Chhauhan S/o Ravendra Singh Chauhan R/o 10-Shrinagar Gali No-2, Nidholi Road District- Etah, PIN- 207001, U.P.

75. Prashant Gupta S/o Suresh Chandra Gupta R/o H.No. 199, Prem Nagar, Behind of Chaprai House, Etah, District- Etah, PIN – 207001, U.P.

76. Girish Chandra Verma S/o Tara Chandra Verma R/o H. No. 36 Nai Basti City Kotwali Etah District- Etah PIN-207001, U.P.

77. Ramesh Chandra S/o Duryodhan Singh R/o Village- Dattapur Post- Ishara District- Etah, PIN-207001, U.P.

78. Sachin Kumar Gupta S/o Mahesh Chandra Gupta R/o Village and Post- Bhagipur Etah, PIN-207001, U.P.

79. Jai Prakash S/o Ganpati Singh R/o Village- Post – Bhagipur Thana- City Kotwali District- Etah- PIN- 207001, U.P.

80. Brajesh Kumar S/o Sujan Singh R/o Village-Post Akbarpur Aunchha District- Mainpuri, PIN-205263, U.P.

81. Tejendra Kumar S/o Thakur Das R/o Village & Post- Rarpatti District- Etah, PIN-207001, U.P.

82. Sunil Kumar S/o Ranveer Singh R/o Moh-Yadav Nagar Soron Gate Kasganj District- Kasganj PIN-207123, U.P.

83. Ashok Kumar S/o Tej Singh R/o Village- Post Neorai District- Etah, PIN-207001, U.P.

84. Reena Kumari D/o Roop Kishor R/o Village- Bakshipur Post- Rajpur, District- Etah, PIN-207001, U.P.

85. Balbeer Singh S/o Sobran Singh R/o Village Bakshipur, Post- Rajpur, District- Etah, PIN-207001, U.P.

86. Manish Tomar S/o Dharmendra Tomar R/o 331 Mayur Vihar, Sahawar Road, Etah, District- Etah, PIN 207001, U.P.

87. Asheesh Gupta S/o Dinesh Chandra Gupta R/o 242, Sunder Lal Street, Patiyali Gate, District- Etah, PIN-207001, U.P.

88. Hasan Imam S/o Naushad Husain R/o 17/128, Ram Narain Bazar, District- Kanpur Nagar, PIN-208001, U.P.

89. Akhilesh Agrahari S/o Jiyalal Agrahari R/o 57/1, Sirki Mohal Chauraha, District- Kanpur, PIN 208001, U.P.

90. Sandeep Kumar Yadav S/o Arvind Kumar Yadav R/o 139, Adarsh Vihar, 80 Feet Road, Infront of Sundari Nath Mandir, Post- New Pac District- Kanpur, PIN- 208015, U.P.

91. Ritu Rani D/o Hari Krishan Gupta R/o Khajuri, Akbarpur, Post-Khas Saharanpur, District- Saharanpur, PIN-247001, U.P.

92. Priyana D/o Brahmpal Singh R/o Village- Sadiyapur, Post- Agri, District-Bijnor, PIN-246701, U.P.

93. Prerna D/o Madan Singh R/o Village- Faridpur Uddu Near Chandpur Ki Chungi, Post- Bijnor, District- Bijnor, PIN-246701, U.P.

94. Deepika Shakya D/o Om Prakesh Shakya R/o Moh. Lukari Darwaja Post- Aliganj, District- Etah, PIN- 207247, U.P.

95. Netrapal Singh S/o Lakshman Singh R/o Village- Mohanpur, Post- Barnahal District- Mainpuri, PIN-205261, U.P.

96. Suchi Pandey S/o Anil Kumar Pandey R/o Village-Dhirauli Pandey, Post- Shankapur, District- Basti, PIN-272129, U.P.

97. Abhishek Pandey S/o Rajesh Kumar Pandey R/o Moh-Mevatiyan, Gonda, District- Gonda, PIN-271001, U.P.

98. Rama Verma D/o Siyaram Verma R/o Village- Post Hardaspur, District-Bar, PIN-243303, U.P.

99. Rajesh Kumar S/o Ashok Kumar Pal R/o Kishanpur Rama Nursingh Home Ramghat Road, District- Aligarh, PIN-202001, U.P.

100. Anoop Verma S/o Suresh Chandra Verma R/o Village and Post- Basara District- Sitapur, U.P.

101. Satyam Verma S/o Shravan Kumar Verma R/o 607, Holinagar Post- Sitapur, District- Sitapur, PIN-261001, U.P.

102. Sarita Yadav S/o Vijay Pal Singh R/o Kakaji Ki Gali Post- Gokul District-Mathura, PIN- 281303, U.P.

103. Neetu Chaudhary S/o Gajendra Singh Chaudhary R/o 495 Atal Vihar Dhauli Pvau District- Mathura, PIN- 281001, U.P.

104. Brij Mohan S/o Nekram R/o Village- Thana, Post- Sonkh Khera District- Mathura, PIN-281308, U.P.

105. Hari Om S/o Durga Prasad R/o Village- Ram Nagla, Post- Gangchaoli District- Hathras, PIN-204101, U.P.

106. Ramhari Singh S/o Devki Nandan Singh R/o Village and Post- Neemgaon Via Raya, District- Mathura, PIN-281204, U.P.

107. Kamlesh Kumar S/o Shyamlal Maurya R/o Village- Bhanipur Post- Balolpur District- Pratapgarh, PIN-230131, U.P.

108. Preeti Singh S/o Durgesh Kumar Singh R/o Village and Post- Vishnoharpur District- Gonda, PIN-271203, U.P.

109. Pramod Kumar S/o Chandra Mani Prasad R/o Village- Belwa Bujurg Post- Belwa Babu District- Gorakhpur, U.P.

110. Naveen Kumar S/o Suresh Chandra Gupta R/o 46, Motiganj, Bharthana District- Etawah, PIN-206242, U.P.

111. Jitendra Singh S/o Prakash Chandra R/o 20, Bajpai Nagar Near Railway Bridge Bharthana, Distirct- Etawah PIN-206242, U.P.

112. Devesh Kumar S/o Om Prakash Yadav R/o Village- Mudaina Post- Baghaipur, District Etawah, PIN-206241, U.P.

113. Aradhana Shukla D/o Deep Chandra Shukla R/o 89 ‘C’ Block Shyam Nagar, District- Kanpur, PIN- 208013, U.P.

114. Ranjeet Singh S/o Surendra Pratap Singh R/o Village- Bawanpura, Post- Merhan District- Chandauli, PIN-232106, U.P.

115. Khushboo Jaiswal D/o Jagdamba Prasad Jaiswal R/o C 539 Teliyana Varanasi PIN-221001, U.P.

116. Arshad Ali S/o Nusrat Ali R/o Durgapuri, District- Barabanki, PIN- 225001, U.P.

117. Pooja D/o Harpal Singh R/o Village and Post- Peepli Nayak District- Rampur, PIN-244925, U.P.

118. Kuldeep Singh S/o Vijay Singh R/o Village Mahamdpur, Post- Peepli Nayak District- Rampur, PIN-244925, U.P.

119. Rajesh Singh S/o Chandra Pal R/o Village Roopapur, Post-Darayal, District- Rampur, PIN 244925, U.P.

120. Gresh Kumar S/o Mohan Singh R/o Village- Seekampur Post- Ramnagar Latipupur District- Rampur, PIN- 244925, U.P.

121. Ghan Shyam Singh S/o Rampal Singh R/o Village- Hasanpur, Post- Dhanupura, District- Rampur, PIN-244925, U.P.

122. Vinod Kumar S/o Mukhram Singh R/o Village Roopaur, Post- Dariyal District- Rampur PIN- 244925, U.P.

123. Yashoda Devi S/o Kishan Swaroop R/o Village and Post- Piplinayak District- Rampur, PIN- 244925, U.P.

124. Bhavna S/o Balbeer Singh R/o Village- Chandupura Post- Lambakhera District- Rampur, PIN-244925, U.P.

125. Tej Ram S/o Teekam Singh R/o Village- Muvana Post- Darhiyal District- Rampur, PIN- 244925, U.P.

126. Dhirendra Singh Yadav S/o Sundar Lal Yadav R/o Village – Narayan Purwa, Post- Shahabda Madhoganj, District- Hardoi, PIN-243102, U.P.

127. Pankaj Trivedi S/o Chandra Narayan Trivedi R/o Moh- Krishna Nagariya Near Baba Mandir, District- Hardoit, PIN-241001, U.P.

128. Amit Kumar Sharma S/o Shripal Sharma R/o Village- Itara Post- Pihani, District- Hardoi, PIN- 241406, U.P.

129. Krishna Kumar Tiwari S/o Ramanivas Tiwari R/o Village- Natthanpur, Post- Parsada, District- Sitapur, PIN-261001, U.P.

130. Pawan Kumar Rai S/o Devi Prasad Rai R/o Moh. Buddhanagar Post- Hussainganj, District- Sitapur, PIN 261001, U.P.

131. Rohit Singh S/o Sravan Kumar Singh R/o Village- Narsohi Post-Shahmoholi District- Sitapur, PIN-261001, U.P.

132. Pratibha Sharma S/o Prem Chandra Sharma R/o D-59-198-K-3-C-5 Bank Colony Yognaga R. Shivpurva, District- Varanasi, PIN-221010, U.P.

133. Sushil Kumar Yadav S/o Raja Ram Yadav R/o Village- Akhtyarpur Post- Pasaner District- Hardoi, PIN- 241201, U.P.

134. Sunil Kumar Seth S/o Sanhaiya Lal R/o Kanhaiya Lal R/o CK 65155A Badi Piyari District- Varanasi, PIN 221001, U.P.

135. Narendra Pal Singh S/o Chanan Singh R/o Village and Post- Hathwant District- Firozabad, PIN-205145, U.P.

136. Shashi Kant Maurya S/o Nanda Lal R/o Village and Post Dhanapur, District- Chandauli, 232105 U.P.

137. Suryanath Maurya S/o Ram Nayan R/o Village- Shahdeeh Post- Dewara Khas Raja District- Azamgarh, PIN-277122, U.P.

138. Geeta Varma D/o Bhoodev Singh Verma R/o Vill+Post- Kutubpur, District- Firozabad, U.P.