English I Pre-AP Fall 2012
Drain, Robinson, Trujillo
Vignette ProjectRubric – Technology Portion
I. Title:
5(100%)“WOW”/ Thematic Connection/Superb Visual/ Creative Title/ Heading info
4(80%) Good Slide/Missing 1 of the above requirements
3(60%) Mediocre Slide/Missing 2 of the above requirements
2(40%) Weak Slide/ Missing 3 or more of the above requirements
1(20%) Irrelevant – Does not connect.
-5 pts missing slide Points received
II. Characterization:
5(100%)“WOW”/Strong quote (ATE)/Excellent Thematic Connection/Superb Visual/
Subtitle
4(80%) Quote Corresponds (ATE may be incorrect) /Relevant
Song/Visual may not be as strong
3(70%) Average Quote ATE/Average Song Visual/ May be missing 1
requirement
2(50%) Poor Quote, Song & Visual. Doesn’t thematically
connect/Missing 2+ requirements
1(20%) Irrelevant-Does not connect. OR missing significant
requirements
-5 pts for missing slide_____ Points received
III. Imagery:
5(100%) “WOW”/Strong quote (ATE)/Excellent Thematic Connection/Superb
Visual/ Subtitle
4(80%) Quote Corresponds (ATE may be incorrect) /Relevant
Song/Visual may not be as strong
3(70%) Average Quote ATE/Average Song & Visual/ May be missing 1
requirement
2(50%) Poor Quote, Song & Visual. Doesn’t thematically
connect/Missing 2+ requirements
1(20%) Irrelevant-Does not connect. OR missing significant
Requirements
-5 pts for missing slide_____ Points received
IV. Setting:
5(100%)“WOW”/Strong quote (ATE)/Excellent Thematic Connection/Superb Visual/
Subtitle
4(80%)Quote Corresponds (ATE may be incorrect) /Relevant
Song/Visual may not be as strong
3(60%)Average Quote ATE/Average Song & Visual/ May be missing 1
requirement
2(40%)Poor Quote, Song & Visual. Doesn’t thematically
connect/Missing 2+ requirements
1(20%)Irrelevant-Does not connect. OR missing significant
requirements
-5 pts missing slide _____ Points received
V. Symbolism:
5 (100%)“WOW”/Strong quote (ATE)/Excellent Thematic Connection/Superb
Visual/ Subtitle
4(80%) Quote Corresponds (ATE may be incorrect) /Relevant
Song/Visual may not be as strong
3(70%) Average Quote ATE/Average Song & Visual/ May be missing 1
requirement
2(50%) Poor Quote, Song & Visual. Doesn’t thematically
connect/Missing 2+ requirements
1(20%) Irrelevant-Does not connect. OR missing significant
requirements
-5 pts for each missing example Points received
VI. Irony:
5 (100%)“WOW”/Strong quote (ATE)/Excellent Thematic Connection/Superb Visual/ Subtitle
4(80%)Quote Corresponds (ATE may be incorrect) /Relevant
Song/Visual may not be as strong
3(70%)Average Quote ATE/Average Song & Visual/ May be missing 1
requirement
2(50%)Poor Quote, Song & Visual. Doesn’t thematically
connect/Missing 2+ requirements
1(20%)Irrelevant-Does not connect. OR missing significant
requirements
-5 pts for missing slide_____ Points received
VII. Motif:
5(100%)“WOW”/Strong quote (ATE)/Excellent Thematic
Connection/Superb Visual/ Subtitle/ Motif re-occurs, unique
4(80%) Quote Corresponds (ATE may be incorrect) /Relevant
Song/Visual may not be as strong/ Motif is re-occuring
3(60%) Average Quote ATE/Average Song & Visual/ May be missing 1
Requirement/ Motif re-occurs, doesn’t include a unique perspective
2(40%) Poor Quote, Song & Visual. Doesn’t thematically
connect/Missing 2+ requirements/ Does not show re-occurrence of motif
1(20%) Irrelevant-Does not connect. OR missing significant
requirements
-5 pts missing slide Points received
VIII. Tone:
8(100%)“WOW”/Strong quote (ATE)/Excellent Thematic
Connection/Superb Visual/ Subtitle/ Insightful Tone
7(85%) Quote Corresponds (ATE may be incorrect) /Relevant
Song/Visual may not be as strong/ Accurate Tone
6(75%) Average Quote ATE/Average Song & Visual/ May be missing 1
Requirement/ Weak Tone Choice
4(50%) Poor Quote, Song & Visual. Doesn’t thematically
connect/Missing 2+ requirements/ Inaccurate Tone
2(25%) Irrelevant-Does not connect. OR missing significant
Requirements/ Tone not present or explained
-8 pts missing slide Points received
IX. Theme:
7(100%) “WOW”/Strong quote (ATE)/Excellent Thematic
Connection/Superb Visual/ Subtitle/ Superb Thematic Explanation
6(85%) Quote Corresponds (ATE may be incorrect) /Relevant
Song/Visual may not be as strong/ Strong Thematic Explanation
5(70%) Average Quote ATE/Average Song & Visual/ May be missing 1
Requirement/ Theme somewhat explained
4(55%) Poor Quote, Song & Visual. Doesn’t thematically
connect/Missing 2+ requirements/ Theme not explained
2(25%) Irrelevant-Does not connect. OR missing significant
Requirements/ Missing thematic explanation
requirements
-7 pts missing slide Points received
____/50 possible
points
Vignette Project Rubric – Written Analysis Portion
Analysis—The analysis will be worth 50% of your individual grade. Each category is worth 10 points (10 being excellent----1 being poor) and must have commentary, concrete details/ATE to support what is being said. Properly cite the quotation within the paper following MLA style (imbedded ATE followed with page number in italics). This analysis should prove your understanding of THOMS and how elements are incorporated throughout the story.
_____CHARACTER
_____IMAGERY
_____SETTING
_____SYMBOLISM
_____IRONY
_____MOTIF
_____TONE - Required
_____THEME- Required
_____ 11 Sentence Paragraph/MLA Format (10 pts total)
10 – 100% mastery (follows the 11 sentence paragraph format, all quotes
imbedded, no errors in documentation)
8 – 80% mastery (follows the 11 sentence paragraph format, most quotes
imbedded, occasional documentation errors)
5 – 50% mastery (may or may not follow the 11 sentence paragraph
format, quotes not imbedded, more documentation
errors)
3 – 30% mastery (does not follow the 11 sentence paragraph format,
quotes not imbedded, abundant documentation errors)
_____/50 possible points
TOTAL TECHNOLOGY + TOTAL WRITTEN = ____
BONUS POINTS EARNED = _____
FINAL GRADE = ____
COMMENTARY: