Yakub Abdul Razak Memon Vs. The State of Maharashtra, through CBI Bombay
[Criminal Appeal No. 1728 of 2007]
[Criminal Appeal No. 609-610 of 2008]
[Criminal Appeal No. 628-629 of 2008]
[Criminal Appeal No. 637-638 of 2008]
[Criminal Appeal No. 365 of 2008]
[Criminal Appeal No. 864-865 of 2008]
[Criminal Appeal No. 897 of 2008]
[Criminal Appeal No. 941-942 of 2008]
[Death Reference Case No. 1 of 2011]
Yakub Abdul Razak Memon Versus State of Maharashtra Thr., CBI, Bombay
[Criminal Appeal No. 1728 of 2007]
P. Sathasivam, J.
1) This appeal and the connected matters have been directed against thefinal orders and judgments of conviction and sentence passed on variousdates by the Presiding Officer of the Designated Court under Terrorist andDisruptive Activities (Prevention) Act, 1987 (in short 'the TADA') forBombay Bomb Blast Case, Greater Bombay in BBC No. 1 of 1993. These appealshave been filed under Section 19 of the TADA by the accused against theirconviction and sentence and by the CBI for confirmation of the deathsentence and against the acquittal of some of the accused persons.
2) Brief facts:The case of the prosecution is as follows:
(a) Babri Masjid at Ayodhya was demolished on 06.12.1992. After itsdemolition, violence broke out throughout the country. In order to takerevenge of the said demolition, Tiger Memon (AA) and Dawood Ibrahim, aresident of Dubai, formulated a conspiracy to commit a terrorist act in thecity of Bombay. In pursuance of the said object, Dawood Ibrahim agreed tosend arms and ammunitions from abroad. Tiger Memon, in association withhis men, particularly, the accused persons, received those arms andammunitions through sea-coasts of Bombay. In continuation of the saidconspiracy, Tiger Memon sent some of the accused persons to Dubai and fromthere to Pakistan for training and handling in arms and ammunitions.
(b) On 12.03.1993, the commercial hub of the country, the city of Bombay,witnessed an unprecedented terrorist act sending shock waves throughout theworld. In a span of about two hours i.e., between 13:33 to 15:40 hours, aseries of 12 bomb explosions took place one after the other at thefollowing twelve places in Bombay, namely, Bombay Stock Exchange, KathaBazaar, Sena Bhavan, Century Bazaar, Mahim Causeway, Air India Building,Zaveri Bazaar, Hotel Sea Rock, Plaza Theatre, Juhu Centaur Hotel, Air PortBay-54 and Air Port Centaur Hotel. In the abovesaid incident of serialbombings, 257 human lives were lost, 713 persons were seriously injured andproperties worth about Rs. 27 crores were destroyed. This was the firstever terrorist attack in the world where RDX (Research DepartmentExplosive) was used on a large scale basis after the World War II.
c) The aforesaid calculated act of terror was carried out with utterdisregard to human life and dignity. The object of the crime was to incitecommunal violence and to overawe and weaken the government, disturb socialharmony and to break up the social, political and economic order of thecountry. This overt act of violence not only caused physical and mentaldamage but also left a psychological impact on society as a whole as thelives of several citizens were completely destroyed.
(d) The conspiratorial acts leading to one of the aforesaid object beganon or before 06.01.1993 at a meeting in Hotel Persian Darbar, Panvel,wherein the following accused persons, viz., Md. Ahmed Dosa (AA), Md. SalimMira Moiddin Shaikh @ Salim Kutta (A-134), Md. Kasam Lajpuria (A-136), Ranjitkumar Singh Baleshwar Prasad (A-102) and Md. Sultan Sayyed (A-90) metand organized the landing of fire arms and ammunitions and hand grenadeswhich was to take place on the coast of Dighi Jetty in Raigad District ofState of Maharashtra on 09.01.1993. On the said date, Md. Dossa (AA)smuggled and sent a consignment of arms and ammunitions at Dighi Jetty,Raigad in connivance with Md. Sultan Sayeed (A-90), who received illegalgratification for the same. The following persons were also involved inthe landing at Dighi Jetty, namely, Uttam Shantaram Poddar (A-30), AbdullaIbrahim Surti (A-66), Ashok Narayan Muneshwar (A-70), Faki Ali Faki AhmedSubedar (A-74), Janardhan Pandurang Gambas (A-81), Jaywant Keshav Gurav (A-82), Krishna Sadanand Mokal (A-83), Krishna Tukaram Pingle (A-84), ManoharMahadeo More (A-87), Md. Sultan Sayyed (A-90), Pandharinath MadhukarMahadik (A-99), Ramesh Dattatray Mali (A-101), Ranjitkumar Singh BaleshwarPrasad (A-102), Sayed @ Mujju Ismail Ibrahim Kadri (A-104), Sayed IsmailSayed Ali Kadri (A-105), Srikrishna Yeshwant Pashilkar (A-110), SomnathKakaram Thapa (A-112), Sudhanwa Sadashiv Talwadekar (A-113), VijayKrishnaji Patil (A-116), Jamir Sayyed Ismail Kadri (A-133), Md. Salim MiraMoiddin Shaikh @ Salim Kutta (A-134) and Md. Kasam Lajpuria (A-136). Thesaid meeting dated 06.01.1993 was not a sudden meeting but was pre-arrangedand pre-planned.
(e) On 19.01.1993, another meeting was held at Dubai wherein Dawood @Dawood Taklya Mohammed Phanse @ Phanasmiyan (A-14), Dawood Ibrahim andTiger Memon (both absconding) were present and detailed discussions wereheld whereafter Tiger Memon agreed to arrange for landing of arms andammunitions and explosives which were to be sent to India by sea route forthe purpose of committing the aforesaid terrorist act. Pursuant to theabove, between 02-08.02.1993, two more such landings of arms andammunitions, detonators, hand grenades and explosives like RDX took placeat Shekhadi Coast under Taluka Shrivardhan in Raigad District throughlanding agent A-14, Sharif Abdul Gafoor Parkar @ Dadabhai (A-17) (deceased)and Rahim Abbas Karambelkar @ Rahim Laundrywala. In the said landing, thefollowing persons also played an active role, namely, Md. Shoaib MohammedKasam Ghansar (A-9), Asgar Yusuf Mukadam (A-10), Abdul Gani Ismail Turk (A-11), Parvez Nazir Ahmed Shaikh (A-12), Dawood @ Dawood Taklya MohammedPhanse @ Phanasmiyan (A-14), Imtiyaz Yunusmiya Ghavte (A-15), Md. FarooqMohammed Yusuf Pawale (A-16), Sharif Abdul Gafoor Parkar @ Dadabhai (A-17),Suleman Mohammed Kasam Ghavate (A-18), Yeshwant Nago Bhoinkar (A-19), Munna@ Mohammed Ali Khan @ Manojkumar Bhavarlal Gupta (A-24), Muzammil UmarKadri (A-25), Raju Laxmichand Jain @ Raju Kodi (A-26), Rashid Umar Alware(A-27), Sayyed Abdul Rehman Shaikh (A-28), Shahnawaz Abdul Kadar Qureshi (A-29), Abdul Aziz Haji Gharatkar (A-34), Ashfaq Kasim Havaldar (A-38), KhalilAhmed Sayed Ali Nasir (A-42), Mohammed Rafiq @ Rafiq Madi Musa Biyariwala(A-46), Sardar Shahwali Khan (A-54), Sarfaraz Dawood Phanse (A-55),Shahjahan Ibrahim Shaikhdare (A-56), Shaikh Ali Shaikh Umar (A-57), ShaikhMohammed Ethesham Haji Gulam Rasool Shaikh (A-58), Sharif Khan AbbasAdhikar (A-60), Sajjad Alam @ Iqbal Abdul Hakim Nazir (A-61), TulsiramDhondu Surve (A-62), Abu Asim Azmi (A-63), Nasir Abdul Kader Kewal @ NasirDakhla (A-64), Gulam Hafiz Shaikh @ Baba (A-73), Jaywant Keshave Gurav (A-82), Liyakat Ali Habib Khan (A-85), Mohmmed Sultan Sayyed (A-90), ParvezMohammed Parvez Zulfikar Qureshi (A-100), Ranjitkumar Singh BaleshwarPrasad (A-102), Somnath Kakaram Thapa (A-112), Sudhanwa Sadashiv Talwadekar(A-113), Shahnawaz Khan s/o Faiz Mohammed Khan (A-128), Mujib Sharif Parkar(A-131), Mohammed Shahid Nizamuddin Quresh (A-135) and Eijaz MohammedSharif @ Eijaz Pathan @ Sayyed Zakir (A-137).
(f) Between February to March 1993, the following persons were sent toPakistan via Dubai by Tiger Memon (AA) and Dawood Ibrahim (AA) forreceiving training in handling of fire arms, use of rocket launchers andexplosives, in particular, RDX for achieving the common object of theconspiracy, namely, Farooq Mohammed Yusuf Pawale (A-16), Shahnawaz AbdulKadar Qureshi (A-29), Zakir Hussain Noor Mohammed Shaikh (A-32), Abdul Khan@ Yakub Khan Akhtar Khan (A-36), Firoz @ Akram Amani Malik (A-39),Nasim Ashraf Shaikh Ali Barmare (A-49), Salim Rahim Shaikh (A-52), NasirAbdul Kader Kewal @ Nasir Dakhla (A-64), Salim Bismilla Khan @ Salim Kurla(Dead) (A-65), Faroow Iliyas Motorwala (A-75), Fazal Rehman Abdul Khan (A-76), Gul Mohammed @ Gullu Noor Mohammed Shaikh (A-77), Mohammed HanifMohammed Usman Shaikh (A-92), Mohammed Rafiq Usman Shaikh (A-94), MohammedSayeed Mohammed Issaq (A-95), Niyaz Mohammed @ Islam Iqbal Ahmed Shaikh (A-98), Parvez Mohammed Parvez Zulfikar Qureshi (A-100), Shaikh Ibrahim ShaikhHussain (A-108), Sayed Ismail Sayed Ali Kadri (A-105) and Usman Man KhanShaikh (A-115). All the above said accused persons were received at DubaiAirport by Ayub Abdul Razak Memon (AA) and Tahir Mohammed Merchant @ TahirTaklya (recently deported to India and arrested by the CBI in the casebeing No. RC 1(s)/1993).
(g) Another batch, comprising of the following accused persons, namely,Shaikh Mohammed Ethesham Haji Gulam Rasool Shaikh (A-58), Manzoor AhmedMohammed Qureshi (A-88), Shaikh Kasam @ Babulal Ismail Shaikh (A-109),Sultan-E-Rome Sardar Ali Gul (A-114), Abdul Aziz Abdul Kader (A-126),Mohammed Iqbal Ibrahim s/o Shaikh Ibrahim (A-127), Shahnawaz Khan s/o FairMohammed Khan (A-128), Murad Ibrahim Khan (A-130) and Mohammed ShahidNizammudin Qureshi (A-135) went to Pakistan for a similar training,however, the said training programme was aborted and they had to returnfrom Dubai.
(h) In March 1993, a weapons training programme was also conducted atSandheri and Borghat at the behest of Tiger Memon (AA). In the said camp,training was imparted by Tiger Memon (AA), Anwar Theba (AA) and JavedTailor @ Javed Chikna (AA) to the following persons, namely, Abdul GaniIsmail Turk (A-11), Parvez Nazir Ahmed Shaikh (A-12), Bashir Ahmed UsmanGani Khairulla (A-13), Sharif Abdul Gafoor Parkar @ Dadabhai (A-17),Suleman Mohammed Kasam Ghavate (A-18), Mohammed Iqbal Mohammed Yusuf Shaikh(A-23), Munna @ Mohammed Ali Khan @ Manojkumar Bhavarlal Gupta (A-24),Mohammed Moin Faridulla Qureshi (A-43), Sardar Shahwali Khan (A-54), ShaikhAli Shaikh Umar (A-57), Issaq Mohammed Hajwani (A-79), Shahnawaz @Shahjahan Dadamiya Hajwani (A-106) and Sikander Issaq Hajwani (A-111).After completing the said training programme, A-17 and A-79 attempted todestroy the evidence by disposing off the hand grenades in the Sandhericreek on or about 8th March 1993 to aid and abet the above offenders.
(i) On 04.03.1993, Tiger Memon called for a preparatory meeting at theTaj Mahal Hotel which was attended by Javed Chikna (AA), Mohammed MushtaqMoosa Tarani (A-44), Sardar Shahwali Khan (A-54), Shaikh Ali Shaikh Umar (A-57), Niyaz Mohammed @ Islam Iqbal Ahmed Shaikh (A-98) and Mohammed UsmanJan Khan (PW-2) (Approver). They conducted reconnaissance of some of thetargets on 04.03.1993 as well as on 05.03.1993.
(j) In order to achieve the said object, vehicles were purchased forplanting explosives by Tiger Memon, Mohammed Shafi Zariwala and MunafHalari (all three absconding). Three scooters were purchased through MunafHalari (AA) who was a close friend of Tiger Memon (AA). Three Commanderjeeps were also purchased through Mohammed Shafi Zariwala (AA) and he alsobought two Maruti Vans and one Ambassador Car. Mohammed Shafi Zariwalaarranged all these vehicles through Suleman Mohammed Lakdawala (PW-365). Two Maruti vans of Blue and Red colour were also purchased through PW-365.
(k) On 07.03.1993, another meeting was held at the house of Shafi whereTiger Memon formed separate groups for reconnaissance of the targets. PW-2, A-64 and A-100 were in one group which was assigned the task to surveyShiv Sena Bhawan and Sahar Airport.
(l) On 08.03.1993, another meeting was held at the residence of Babloowhere Tiger Memon called Javed Chikna, Irfan Chougule, Salim Mujahid,Bashir Khan, Babloo and PW-2 in the flat and selected the following placesas targets, namely, Air India Building, Nariman Point, Bharat PetroleumRefinery, Chembur, Share Market near Fountain, Zaveri Bazaar near MohammedAli Road and Pydhonie, Five Star Hotels, Cinema Theatres, Shiv Sena Bhavan,Shivaji Park, Dadar, Bombay Municipal Corporation Building, V.T., SaharAirport, Passport Office, Worli, Mantralaya and others places.
(m) Again, on 10.03.1993, a meeting was held at the house of Mobina @Bayamoosa Bhiwandiwala (A-96) where PW-2 met Tiger Memon, Javed Chikna,Salim Rahim Shaikh (A-52), Bashir Khan, Zakir Hussain Noor Mohammed Shaikh(A-32), Nasir Abdul Kader Kewal @ Nasir Dakhla (A-64), Parvez MohammedParvez Zulfikar Qureshi (A-100), Mohammed Moin Faridulla Qureshi (A-43),Mohammed Iqbal Mohammed Yusuf Shaikh (A-23), Sardar Shahwali Khan (A-54),Bashir Ahmed Usman Gani Khairulla (A-13) and Nasim Ashraf Shaikh AliBarmare (A-49). In the second meeting, Tiger Memon distributed Rs. 5,000/-to each one of them and again formed the groups. PW-2 also told TigerMemon about the survey of Chembur Refinery. The following persons alsoparticipated in the said meeting, namely, Yakub Abdul Razak Memon (A-1),Essa @ Anjum Abdul Razak Memon (A-3), Yusuf Abdul Razak Memon (A-4), AbdulRazak Suleman Memon (dead) (A-5), Hanifa Abdul Razak Memon (A-6), RahinYakub Memon (A-7), Rubeena Suleman @ Arif Memon (A-8), Mohammed ShoaibMohammed Kasam Ghansar (A-9), Asgar Yusuf Mukadam (A-10), Abdul Gani IsmailTurk (A-11), Parvez Nazir Ahmed Shaikh (A-12), Bashir Ahmed Usman GaniKhairulla (A-13), Md. Farooq Mohammed Yusuf Pawale (A-16), Mohammed IqbalMohammed Yusuf Shaikh (A-23), Shahnawaz Abdul Kadar Qureshi (A-29), ZakirHussain Noor Mohammed Shaikh (A-32), Firoz @ Akram Amani Malik (A-39),Mohammed Moin Faridulla Qureshi (A-43), Nasim Ashraf Shaikh Ali Barmare (A-49), Sardar Shahwali Khan (A-54), Shaikh Ali Shaikh Umar (A-57), NasirAbdul Kader Kewal @ Nasir Dakhla (A-64), Mohammed Rafiq Usman Shaikh (A-94), Mobina @ Bayamoosa Bhiwandiwala (A-96), Niyaz Mohammed @ Islam IqbalAhmed Shaikh (A-98) and Parvez Mohammed Parvez Zulfikar Qureshi (A-100).
(n) Another meeting had taken place in the intervening night between11/12.03.1993 at Al-Hussaini Building, Dargah Street, Mahim, in which afinal touch to the proposed plan of serial bomb blasts was given. The co-conspirators stored explosives like RDX and fire arms in the garages ownedby the Memons' and their relatives at Al-Hussaini Building and utilizedthese garages and open places outside the same for making bombs during thesaid night. The following persons were also present there at that time andhad actively participated in the work of filling of RDX in the vehicles andsuitcases for the said purpose, namely, A-9, A-10, A-11, A-12, A-13, A-16,A-23, A-32, A-36, A-43, A-49, A-52, A-54, A-57, A-64 and A-100.
(o) On 12.03.1993, bombs and other explosive substances were planted atvarious places by the following persons in the following sequence:Firstly, Mohammed Farooq Mohammed Yusuf Pawale (A-16), Mohammed TainurPhansopkar (AA) and Irfan Chougule planted bomb and caused explosion atBombay Stock Exchange at 13:30 hrs. wherein 84 persons were killed and 218persons were injured;Secondly, Parvez Nazir Ahmed Shaikh (A-12) planted bomb and causedexplosion at Katha Bazaar at 14:15 hrs. wherein 4 persons were killed and21 persons were injured;Thirdly, Mohammed Usman Jan Khan (PW-2) and Mohammed Farooq Mohammed YusufPawale (A-16) planted bomb and caused explosion at Lucky Petrol Pump nearShiv Sena Bhavan wherein 4 persons were killed and 50 persons were injured;Fourthly, Abdul Gani Ismail Turk (A-11) planted bomb and caused explosionat Century Bazaar at 14:45 hrs wherein 88 persons were killed and 160persons were injured;Fifthly, Bashir Ahmed Usman Gani Khairulla (A-13), Zakir Hussain NoorMohammed Shaikh (A-32), Abdul Khan @ Yakub Khan Akhtar Khan (A-36), Firoz @Akram Amani Malik (A-39), Mohammed Moin Faridulla Qureshi (A-43), SalimRahim Shaikh (A-52) and Ehsan Mohammed Tufel Mohammed Qureshi (A-122) threwhand grenades and caused explosions at Fishermen's colony at Mahim at 14:45hrs. wherein 3 persons were killed and 6 persons were injured;Sixthly, Mohammed Farooq Mohammed Yusuf Pawale (A-16), Mohammed Tainur (AA)and Irfan Chougule planted bomb and caused explosion at Air India Buildingat 15:00 hrs wherein 20 persons were killed and 84 persons were injured;Seventhly, Md. Shoaib Mohammed Kasam Ghansar (A-9) planted bomb and causedexplosion at Zaveri Bazaar at 15:05 hrs. wherein 17 persons were killed and57 were injured;Eighthly, Parvez Nazir Ahmed Shaikh (A-12) planted bomb and causedexplosion at Hotel Sea Rock at 15:10 hrs.Ninthly, Asgar Yusuf Mukadam (A-10) and Shahnawaz Abdul Kadar Qureshi (A-29) planted explosives and caused explosion at 15:13 hrs at Plaza Cinemawherein 10 persons were killed and 37 were injured;Tenthly, Mohammed Mustaq Moosa Tarani (A-44) planted bomb and causedexplosion at Hotel Centaur, Juhu at 15:20 hrs. which resulted in injury tothree persons.Eleventhly, Mohammed Iqbal Mohammed Yusuf Sheikh (A-23) and Nasim AshrafShaikh Ali Barmare (A-49) planted bomb and caused explosion at SaharAirport at 15:30 hrs and;Twelfthly, Anwar Theba (AA) caused explosion at 15:40 hrs at Centaur Hotel,Airport wherein 2 persons were killed and 8 persons were injured. In addition to the above, at various other places, viz., Naigan CrossRoad, Dhanji Street and Sheikh Memon Street etc., bombs were planted byaccused persons which were defused in time on the basis of informationreceived by the police. Thus the object behind the said conspiracy wasachieved and commercial hub of the country, Bombay was rocked by a seriesof blasts.
(p) Thereafter, a First Information Report (FIR) was lodged and pursuantthereto several arrests were made. After the arrest of Altaf Ali MustaqAli Sayed (A-67), he made a disclosure under Section 27 of the EvidenceAct, 1872 and led Mr. Anil Prabhakar Mahabole (PW-506), Police Officer andpancha Suresh Jagaganath Satam (PW-37) to the residence of Mohammed Haniffrom where the following articles were recovered and taken into possessionvide Panchnama Exh. 109. A suit case (Article 42) was found containing 65hand grenades and 100 electronic detonators. In addition, one VIP suitcase (Article 43) was found containing 40 hand grenades and 50 electronicdetonators. During the examination, only 85 grenades were found in the twosuit cases which were marked as Article 44 (1-84) and one hand grenadewhich was sent to the FSL was marked as Article 45.
(q) Further, on 12.03.1993, one maroon coloured Maruti van was found inabandoned condition near Siemens Factory, Worli bearing No. MFC 1972. Whenthe Police party came to know about the abandoned vehicle, a search wasconducted and it was seized by the Police Officer, Dinesh P. Kadam (PW-371)in the presence of Narayan Dattaram More (PW-46) vide Panchnama Exh. 190.The seizure included 7 AK-56 rifles, a plastic bag and 14 magazines whichwere forwarded to the FSL. One more plastic bag and four hand grenadeswere also recovered from the Van and were sent to the FSL. The FSL reportExh. 2439-A establishes that these hand grenades were capable of causingexplosion. During investigation, it was found that in the above said van,the following persons were sitting, viz., A-57, Javed Chikna (AA), BashirKhan and Nasir @ Babloo and were proceeding towards BMC office near V.T.for the purpose of killing BJP and Shiv Sena Corporators but they left thevehicle because of the damage caused to the car during the explosion atCentury Bazaar.
(r) On 26.03.1993, the following items were recovered from Khalil AhmedSayed Ali Nasir (A-42), namely, a single 7.62 mm pistol without magazine(Article 87), a single 7.65 mm pistol without magazine having body No.352468 made in Czechoslovakia marked as Article 88, four empty magazines,13 cartridges, 7 cartridges of 7.65 mm pistol, 4 KF 7.65 mm cartridges, 2SBP 7.65 mm cartridges and 8 cartridges of 7.62 mm pistol.
(s) On 26.03.1993, Investigating Officer (PW-506), in the presence ofLakshan Loka Karkare (PW-45) searched the house of accused Mujammil UmarKadri (A-25) at village Mhasala, Tal. Shrivardhan and seized certainaricles vide Exh. 158, namely, 13 AK-56 rifles, 26 empty magazines and 3gunny bags (Article 86).
(t) During the investigation, on 27.03.1993, at the instance of accusedAshrafur Rehman Azimulla Shaikh @ Lallu, Shivaji Shankar Sawant (PW-524)and Abdul Kadar A. Khan (PW-323) prepared the disclosure Panchanama Exh.439 in the presence of Sayyed Badshah Gaus Mohiuddin (PW-85). In pursuanceof the said disclosure Panchanama, the police recovered hand grenades,white tubes, detonators tied together and live cartridges