June 2004doc.: IEEE802.11-04/0670-00
IEEE P802.11
Wireless LANs
Conference Call Minutes Task Group K June 16, 2004
Date:
June16, 2004
Author:
Paul Gray
AirWave Wireless, Inc.
1700 El Camino Real Suite 500
San Mateo, CA94025
Phone: 650-286-6107
Fax: 650-286-6101
e-Mail:
Abstract
Teleconference Minutes for Task Group K.
Detailed minutes follow:
Wednesday, June 16, 2004 – 8:30 AM Pacific
- Chair calls the conference call to order at8:30AM
- AttendancePaine, Gray, Kwak, McGovern, Black, Qi
- Trouble with Webex, so we are going to work without Web conferencing software.
- We are working off of Revision 12 of comment resolution.
- Editorial Comment Resolution
Comment #169 – Clause 7.3.2.25- Johnson
Problem - Missing description of Element ID
Remedy –Mirror after definition from 7.3.2.26 Site Report Element
Comment – P28, L10
Comment – The element ID text has not been incorporated from 11h. The suggestion is not to include element ID text.
Comment – It is included on PG28, L10.
New Remedy – modify PG28, L10 as appropriate
Resolution – accept – instruct editor make change as described above in New Remedy
Comment #170 – Clause 7.3.2.26 – Black
Problem - P28, L6 broken reference
Remedy - Fix reference.
Question – wasn’t Simon Black cleaning up Site Report including changing the Site Report? Is Simon intending on bringing forth a presentation at the next meeting.
Comment – Tim Olson volunteered to rework this section.
Resolution – accept – instruct editor to make change as described above.
Comment #171 – Clause7.3.2.26 - Black
Problem - P28, L8 Figure 0-2- there are five fields in the quadruplet
Remedy - Make a quintuplet, of define a site report entry and have zero or more of those in the site report element.
New Remedy - Make a quintuplet, or define a site report entry and have zero of more of those in the site report element
Resolution –accept – instruct editor to make change as described
Comment #174 – Clause 7.3.2.26 - Black
Problem - P29, L10 Reference to channel band table.
Remedy - Correct the reference
Resolution –decline – Already fixed in D 0.16
Comment #175 – Clause 7.3.2.26 – Black
Problem P29, L13 BSSID rather than BSSgID and 'The PHY type is encoded' rather than 'will be encoded'
Remedy - Fix editorials
Resolution – accept – instruct editor to make change as described above.
Comment #177 – Clause 7.3.2.26 – Johnson
Problem - Better Wording on p28, l5-6
Remedy - Replace "canidates to which STAs can roam to." with "roaming canidates for a STA." or "BSS transistion canidates for a STA."
New Remedy – Replace "candidates to which STAs can roam to." with "roaming candidates for a STA." or "BSS transition candidates for a STA."
Resolution – accept – instruct editor to make change as described above
Comment #178 – Clause 7.3.2.26 - Johnson
Problem - Replace all "quadruplets" with "quituples" - 3 occurences on p28, l 11-12
Remedy - Replace all "quadruplets" with "quintuplet"
Resolution – accept – instruct editor to make change as described above
Comment #179 – Clause 7.3.2.26 - Johnson
Problem - Correct Figure Reference
Remedy - Correct Figure Reference
Resolution – decline – already fixed in D 0.16.
Comment #180 – Clause 7.3.2.26 – Johnson
Problem - Add Channel Band to the list
Remedy - Add Channel Band after Current Channel on p28, l10 and p28, l13
New Remedy – Replace current channel and PHY type with current channel, channel band, and PHY type on P28 L13 and P28 L16
Resolution –accept – instruct editor to make change as described in New Remedy.
Comment #181 – Clause 7.3.2.26 – Johnson
Problem - p28, l15 - replace “;”with“:”
Remedy - replace semicolonwithcolon
Comment – 802.11 Editor will have a mandated style
Resolution –accept – instruct editor to make change as described above
Comment #183 – Clause
Problem - p 29, l8 - delete line
Remedy – delete blank line
Resolution – accept –instruct editor to make change describe above.
Comment #184 – Clause 7.3.2.26 – Johnson
Problem - p 29, l10 - Define editor TBD
Remedy – Should be Figure 0-2
Resolution – accept – same as Comment #174
Comment #185 – Clause 7.3.2.26 - Johnson
Problem - p 29, l13 - Fix BSSID
Remedy - Replace BSSIgD with BSSID
Resolution – accept – addressed with Comment #175
Comment #187 – Clause 7.3.2.26 - Olson
Problem –Table and length description says quadriplets when there are five fields.
Remedy - Update to be quintuplets.
Resolution – accept – no action needed because addressed with Comment #171
Comment #188–Clause 7.3.2.26 - Olson
Problem - Some APs support multiple SSIDs so the ESS match bit should be true if the AP supports the SSID and not just advertised it.
Remedy - Change the word "advertises" to "supports"
Comment – there are 2 paragraphs with advertises in it
Comment – P28 L20 and is only taking about the ESS.
New Remedy – Replace the word “advertise” to “supports” on P28 L20.
Resolution – accept – instruct editor to make change as described in New Remedy
Comment #189 – Clause 7.3.2.26 – Olson
Problem - The BSSID match status field table does not specify bits 2, 5 and 6.
Remedy - Indicate that bits 2, 5 and 6 are reserved.
Comment – should be 0,1,2
Resolution – accept – instruct editor to make change as described above
Comment #190 – Clause 7.3.2.26 - Kracz
Problem –page 29, line 13 "BSSIgD" typo
Remedy – edit
Resolution – accept – no action needed same as Comment #175
Comment #195 – Clause 7.4.2 - Johnson
Problem – Change Five to Several p30, l11 and remove five p30, l12
Remedy - Change Five to Several p30, l11 and remove five p30, l12
Resolution – accept – instruct editor to make change as described above
Comment #196 – Clause 7.4.2 – Olson
Problem - Eliminate Disassociation Imminent from Table 20f since no longer part of specification
Remedy - Eliminate Disassociation Imminent from Table 20f
Resolution – accept – already changed in D 0.16
Comment #197 – Clause 7.4.2 – Olson
Problem - Eliminate Disassociation Imminent from Table 20f since no longer part of specification
Remedy - Eliminate Disassociation Imminent from Table 20f
Resolution – accept – already changed in D 0.16
Comment #199 – Clause 7.4.2.3 – Black
Problem - Various editorials: P31, L9 Table 1 should be Table 19a P31, L11 Table 5 in 7.4.1 should be Table 20f in 7.4.2 P31, L9, L11, L13 remove 'equal'
Remedy - Fix editorials
Resolution – accept – instruct editor to make change as described above.
Comment #200 – Clause 7.4.2.3 – Black
Problem – P31 L7 Figure 0-4 SSID IE should be SSID P31, L15 first sentence of the final paragraph of 7.4.2.3 is badly written.
Remedy - Correct figure and replace indicated sentence with: The SSID element may be included to request a site report for a specific ESS.
Resolution – accept – already fixed in the D 0.16
Chair officially ends the meeting at 9:30 AM.
Minutes TGk page 1Paul Gray, AirWave Wireless, Inc.