WIRRAL TENNIS LEAGUE
Problem and Action Catalogue 2012
Blue=to be resolved/ratified by next WTL CM Red=waiting for response Purple=Correction/change after WTL CM
Nbr
/Problems
/Action / Decision / Penalty
MIXED WEEK 1/ INCORRECT CARD: Oxton1 v Pinewood1: Both incomplete sets recorded and incomplete rubbers recorded and added in to total. Could lead to extra points being given if both on original and rearranged cards. / CM1: Oxton1 pen 1pt Pinewood1 pen 1pt
/ REARRANGED DATE NOT ADVISED BY AWAY CLUB: Oxton1 v Pinewood1: 3 dates on card. 2 unfinished rubbers awarded to Oxton1 6/0 6/0. Result card changed from 10-2 (originally noted as 12-3) to 14-2 / CM1: Pinewood1 pen 1pt
MIXED WEEK 2
/ LATE CARD: Ladies: Heswall1 v Oxton1: Match 29 Apr. Received 9 May. Match postponed / CM1: Heswall1 ladies pen 1pt
/ DID NOT FULFIL FIXTURE: Men: WallaseyM2 could not raise team. Match awarded to Oxton1 8-0. / CM1: WallaseyM2 Men pen 4pts
/ PLAYER PLAYING TWICE IN SAME WEEK: NCheshire2 v P Sunlight3: Helen Lees played 4th for PSunlight2 and was specified 1st in PSunlight3 team in postponed match. HL not eligible for rearranged match. / CM1: PSunlight3 pen 1pt
/ DID NOT FULFIL PART FIXTURE: WallaseyM3 were 2 ladies short at Hoylake4. 3 rubbers awarded to Hoylake4 6/0 6/0 / CM1: WallaseyM3 pen 3pts
MIXED WEEK 3
/ PLAYER NOT REGISTERED: Birkenhead4 v PSunlight3: Nathan Slade won 3 sets. Rubbers in which NS played awarded to Birkenhead4 6/0 6/0. / CM1: PSunlight3 pen 2pts. Result card changed from 3-15 to 5-12
/ DID NOT FULFIL PART FIXTURE: Heswall4 v Thorndale2. 1st man (Steve McEvoy) did not turn up. Rubbers in which SM should have played awarded to Thorndale2 6/0 6/0 / CM1: Heswall4 pen 2pts
/ INCORRECT CARD: Men: Prenton2 v WallaseyM1: No date and No forenames for Prenton2 / CM1: Prenton2 Men pen 1pt WallaseyM1 Men pen 1pt
9A / INCORRECT CARD: Alderley2 v Hoylake3: Not signed by home captain. / CM1: Alderley2 pen 1pt Hoylake3 pen 1pt
MIXED WEEK 4
/ DID NOT FULFIL FIXTURE: Ladies: Oxton1 v Neston1: Neston1 could not raise team. Match awarded to Oxton1 8-0. / CM1: Neston1 Ladies pen 4pts
/ DID NOT FULFIL PART FIXTURE: Upton3 v Birkenhead4. Birkenhead4 were 1 lady short. Rubbers awarded to Upton3 6/0 6/0 / CM1: Birkenhead4 pen 2pts
/ DID NOT FULFIL PART FIXTURE: NCheshire2 v PSunlight3 Rearranged. NCheshire2 were 2 ladies short. Rubbers awarded to PSunlight3 6/0 6/0 / CM1: NCheshire2 pen 3pts
/ PLAYER PLAYING TWICE IN SAME WEEK: Men: Thorndale2 v Hooton2: Roy Finney played for Thorndale1 on Sun 13 May and then for Thorndale2 on Mon 14 May. RF won 3 sets. Rubbers in which RF played awarded to Hooton2 6/0 6/0. / CM1: Thorndale2 Men pen 2pts. Result card changed from 5-4 to 2-6
/ PLAYER NOT REGISTERED: Men: NCheshire1 v Upton1: Jon Maddocks won 3 sets. Rubbers in which JM played awarded to NCheshire1 6/0 6/0. / CM1: Upton1 Men pen 2pts. Result card changed from 5-4 to 8-0
14A / LONG SET PLAYED: Upton2 v Thorndale3: 3rd set resulted in 8-6 rather than tie-break at 6-6. No penalty applied because it took longer than a tie-break set. / CM1: No penalty
MIXED WEEK 5
/ DID NOT FULFIL FIXTURE: Men: Alderley3 v WallaseyM2: WallaseyM2 could not raise team. Match awarded to Alderley3 8-0. / CM1: WallaseyM2 Men pen 4pts
/ DID NOT FULFIL PART FIXTURE: Birkenhead4 v Pinewood2: Birkenhead4 were 2 ladies short. Rubbers awarded to Pinewood2 6/0 6/0 / CM1: Birkenhead4 pen 3pts
/ INCORRECT CARD: Thorndale3 v Neston5: No Match number, No Division, No date / CM1: Thorndale3 pen 1pt Neston5 pen 1pt
/ PLAYER NOT REGISTERED: Alderley2 v Neston4: Frankie Street won 4 sets. Rubbers in which FS played awarded to Alderley2 6/0 6/0. / CM1: Neston4 pen 2pts. Result card changed from 9-9 to 13-5
MIXED WEEK 6
/ DID NOT FULFIL PART FIXTURE: WallaseyM3: Upton2. WallaseyM3 were 2 ladies short. Rubbers awarded to Upton2 6/0 6/0 / CM1: WallaseyM3 pen 3pts
/ DID NOT FULFIL PART FIXTURE: Pinewood2 v NCheshire2. NCheshire2 were 2 ladies short. Rubbers awarded to Pinewood2 6/0 6/0 / CM1: NCheshire2 pen 3pts
/ RANKING (playing out of position): Prenton4 v Thorndale4: June Dawson(20) played 2 positions below Jill Troxler(21). JD won 2 sets. Rubbers in which JD played awarded to Thorndale4 2 6-0 6-0 / CM1: Prenton4 pen 2pts. Result card changed from 13-5 to 11-7
/ PLAYER NOT REGISTERED: WallaseyM3 v Upton2: Dave Chee won 2 sets. Rubbers in which DC played awarded to Upton2 6/0 6/0. / CM1: WallaseyM3 pen 2pts. Result card changed from 2-15 to 0-16
/ LATE CARD: Neston2 v Hoylake2: Match 27 May. Card received 30 May PM 29 May. / CM1: Neston2 pen 1pt
MIXED WEEK 7
/ DID NOT FULFIL PART FIXTURE: Prenton2 v WallaseyM2. WallaseyM2 were 1 lady short. Rubbers awarded to Prenton2 6/0 6/0 / CM1: WallaseyM2 pen 2pts
/ DID NOT FULFIL FIXTURE: Neston5 v WallaseyM3. Match awarded to Neston5 16-0 / CM1: WallaseyM3 pen 8pts
/ PLAYER NOT REGISTERED: Oxton2 v Birkenhead4: Karen McCartney won 2 sets. Rubbers in which KM played awarded to Oxton2 6/0 6/0. / CM1: Birkenhead4 pen 2pts. Result card changed from 13-4 to 14-2
/ PLAYER PLAYING TWICE IN SAME WEEK: Heswall3 v NCheshire1: Sue A Davies on result card for Neston3 v Heswall2 also on result card for Heswall3 v NCheshire1. SAD won 0 sets. Rubbers in which SAD on card awarded to NCheshire1 6/0 6/0. / CM1: Heswall3 pen 2pts. Result card unchanged at 6-11
/ UNFINISHED MENS DOUBLES – MIXED RECORDED: PSunlight3 v Pinewood2. Debate on validity of mixed which was conceded. / CM1: PSunlight3 pen 1pt. Pinewood2 pen 1pt
MIXED WEEK 8
/ DID NOT FULFIL PART FIXTURE: Neston4 v PSunlight2. P Sunlight2 were 2 men short. Rubbers awarded to Neston4 6/0 6/0 / CM1: PSunlight2 pen 3pts
/ LOWER TEAM FULFILLED FIXTURE WHILE HIGHER TEAM WERE SHORT: Oxton3 v PSunlight3. See problem 28. PSunlight2 were 2 men short. / CM1: No further penalty
/ INCORRECT CARD: Oxton3 v PSunlight3: Specifies PSunlight2 / CM1: Oxton3 pen 1pt PSunlight3 pen 1pt
MIXED WEEK 9
/ DID NOT FULFIL PART FIXTURE: WallaseyM3 v Hoylake4. WallaseyM3 were 2 ladies short. Rubbers awarded to Hoylake4 6/0 6/0 / CM2: WallaseyM2 pen 3pts
/ DID NOT FULFIL FIXTURE: Men: Helsby1 v Prenton1: Helsby1 could not raise team. Match awarded to Prenton1 8-0. / CM2: Helsby1 Men pen 4pts
MIXED WEEK 10
/ INCORRECT CARD: Men: WallaseyM1 v Prenton2: Result card total stated rubbers instead of sets. / CM2: Result card changed from 2-2 to 4-4. WallaseyM1 pen 2pts Prenton2 Men pen 2pts (2nd time)
/ DID NOT FULFIL PART FIXTURE: WallaseyM3 v Thorndale4. WallaseyM3 were 1 lady short. Rubbers awarded to Thorndale4 6/0 6/0 / CM2: WallaseyM3 pen 2pts
/ RANKING (playing out of position): Thorndale2 v Heswall4: Mike Hedderick(15) played 2 positions below Graham Daley(17). MH won 2 sets. Rubbers in which MH played awarded to Thorndale2 6-0 6-0 / CM2: Heswall4 pen 2pts. Result card changed from 13-8 to 13-6
/ RANKING (playing out of position): Hoylake4 v Thorndale3: Lucinda Mercer(17) played 3 positions below Julie Hunter(18). LM won 1 set. Rubbers in which LM played awarded to Thorndale3 6-0 6-0 / CM2: Hoylake4 pen 2pts. Result card changed from 5-14 to 4-14
MIXED WEEK 11
/ DID NOT FULFIL FIXTURE: Birkenhead3 v WallaseyM3. WallaseyM3 could not raise team. Rubbers awarded to Birkenhead3 6/0 6/0 / CM2: WallaseyM3 pen 8pts
/ DID NOT FULFIL PART FIXTURE: Oxton2 v NCheshire2. NCheshire2 were 4 ladies short. Rubbers awarded to Oxton2 6/0 6/0 / CM2: NCheshire2 pen 6pts
/ DID NOT FULFIL PART FIXTURE: Oxton3 v Pinewood2. Pinewood2 were 1 lady short. Rubbers awarded to Oxton3 6/0 6/0 / CM2: Pinewood2 pen 2pts
/ RANKING (playing out of position): Oxton3 v Pinewood2: Andy Minnis(9) played 2 positions below Ian Peters(12). AM won 0 sets. Rubbers in which AM played awarded to Oxton3 6-0 6-0 / CM2: Pinewood2 pen 2pts. Result card unchanged at 11-7
/ LATE CARD: Neston2 v Heswall2: Match 3 Jul. Card received on Friday, posted late. / CM2: Neston2 pen 2pts (2nd time)
/ PLAYER PLAYING TWICE IN SAME WEEK: Men: Alderley2 v Thorndale2: Roger Chester played for Alderley3 on Sun 1 Jul and then for Alderley2 on Wed 4 Jul. RC won 1 set. Rubbers in which RC played awarded to Thorndale2 6/0 6/0. / CM2: Alderley2 Men pen 2pts. Result card changed from 4-6 to 3-6
/ INCORRECT CARD: Men: Hoylake1 v Oxton1: Specifies Oxton2 / CM2: Hoylake1 Men pen 1pt Oxton1 Men pen 1pt
44A / PLAYING OUT OF POSITION (treated as ranking): Heswall4 v Neston4: Ali Smith contravened Rule 7.1 Order: Players must be played in order of doubles ability. AS won 4 sets. Rubbers in which AS played awarded to Heswall4 6-0 6-0 / CM2: Neston4 pen 2pts. Result card changed from 10-9 to 13-5
MIXED WEEK 12
/ INCORRECT CARD: COaks1 v Heswall3: No Match number / CM2: COaks1 pen 1pt Heswall3 pen 1pt
/ RANKING (playing out of position): Oxton1 v Bertram1: Jonathan Monks(3) played 2 positions below Andy Turner(5). JM won 1 set. Rubbers in which JM played awarded to Oxton1 6-0 6-0 / CM2: Bertram1 pen 2pts. Result card changed from 8-10 to 8-9
/ PLAYER PLAYING TWICE IN SAME WEEK: Upton3 v Oxton3: Barbara Ayres on result card for Upton2 v Thorndale4 also on result card for Upton3 v Oxton3. BA won 0 sets. Rubbers in which BA on card awarded to Oxton 3 6/0 6/0. / CM2: Upton3 pen 2pts. Result card changed from 12-5 to 8-8. Appeal not upheld
/ DID NOT FULFIL FIXTURE: Men: WallaseyM1 could not raise team. Match awarded to Hooton1 8-0. / CM2: WallaseyM1 Men pen 4pts
MIXED WEEK 13
/ DID NOT FULFIL FIXTURE: Upton2 v WallaseyM3. WallaseyM3 could not raise team. Rubbers awarded to Upton2 6/0 6/0 / CM2: WallaseyM3 pen 8pts
/ DID NOT FULFIL PART FIXTURE: NCheshire2 v Pinewood2. NCheshire2 were 4 ladies short. Rubbers awarded to Pinewood2 6/0 6/0 / CM2: NCheshire2 pen 6pts
/ DID NOT FULFIL PART FIXTURE: Hoylake1 v Neston1. Neston1 4th man did not show. Rubbers awarded to Hoylake1 6/0 6/0 / CM2: Neston1 pen 2pts
51A / HIGHER TEAM SHORT WHILE LOWER TEAM FULL COMPLEMENT: See 51. Decision: Neston1 were aware at mid day that player was not available but did not adjust teams accordingly. Tom Vojtak should have played for Neston1 (see P51 above). / CM2: Neston2 pen 4pts to be applied in season 2013.
MIXED WEEK 14
/ DID NOT FULFIL PART FIXTURE: Neston1 v WallaseyM1. WallaseyM1 4th lady did not show. Rubbers awarded to Neston1 6/0 6/0 / CM2: WallaseyM1 pen 2pts Appeal not upheld
/ DID NOT FULFIL PART FIXTURE: Neston2 v Upton1. Neston2 2nd man did not show. Rubbers awarded to Upton1 6/0 6/0 / CM2: Neston2 pen 2pts Appeal not upheld
/ DID NOT FULFIL PART FIXTURE: Birkenhead4 v Oxton2. Birkenhead4 were 4 ladies short. Rubbers awarded to Oxton2 6/0 6/0 / CM2: Birkenhead4 pen 6pts
/ DID NOT FULFIL PART FIXTURE: WallaseyM3 v Neston5. Neston5 were 2 ladies short. Rubbers awarded to WallaseyM3 6/0 6/0 / CM2: Neston5 pen 3 pts
/ DID NOT FULFIL PART FIXTURE: Upton3 v NCheshire2. NCheshire2 were 1 lady short. Rubbers awarded to Upton3 6/0 6/0 / CM2: NCheshire2 pen 2pts
/ PLAYER NOT REGISTERED: Thorndale1 v COaks1: Jan Lyons won 2 sets. Rubbers in which JL played awarded to Thorndale1 6/0 6/0. / CM2: COaks1 pen 2pts. Result card changed from 12-6 to 13-4
/ RANKING (playing out of position): Pinewood2 v PSunlight3: Andy Minnis(11) played 3 (only 2 positions before new player) positions below Sandy Burrows(12). AM won 2 sets. Rubbers in which AM played awarded to PSunlight3 6-0 6-0 / CM2: Pinewood2 pen 3pts (2nd time). Result card changed from 9-9 to 7-10
/ PLAYER NOT REGISTERED: Pinewood2 v PSunlight3: Sue Pogson won 1 set. Rubbers in which SP played awarded to Psunligt3 6/0 6/0. / CM2: Pinewood2 pen 2pts. Result card changed from 7-10 to 6-10 (see p58)
MIXED WEEK 15
/ DID NOT FULFIL FIXTURE: Men: WallaseyM2 could not raise team. Match awarded to Alderley3 8-0. / CM2: WallaseyM2 Men pen 4pts