You have been given the front page of a newspaper.
Sample 1a is from The San Francisco Call, San Francisco, California, March 26, 1898
Sample 1b is from The Herald, Los Angeles, California, August 4,1898.
Using the front page that has been provided to you (1a or 1b), analyze and discuss the following:
Break down the newspaper. Highlight interesting phrases. Circle key words that you may (or may not) understand. Comment on the text.
\\
Activity Options:
- Label as many objects as you can in the cartoon. Look for factual information, symbols, and clues.
- List three questions that you have about the cartoon.
- How does this cartoon connect to what we have already learned about imperialism?
- What is the opinion of the cartoonist? Support with evidence from the cartoon.
Source: Austin's Hawaiian Weekly, July 22, 1899
\\
Reading for Detail Challenge – Ask students to read the article, and then offer them a challenge of how many points they can earn. Scaffold the activity as it appropriate to the needs of your students. Some variations can include:
- Allow students to preview the questions in advance (or not);
- Have students take notes on the article that they can use to help answer the questions;
- Allow students to use the article for part or all of the time to answer the questions;
- Create a question and answer period in which students can clarify their understanding before jumping into the game;
- Double the point value for questions answered correctly without the use of the article, then let students work with the article to receive more points;
This challenge be conducted individually or in small cooperative groups.
Instructions: Based on what you read, answer as many questions as you can:
Level 1. Value: 1 point for each correct answer. No partial credit on this section.
1. King Kalukauaruled the Hawaiian Islands for ______years.
2. Kalukauawas ______years old when he took the throne of Hawaii.
3. Kalukaua died because he had _____ disease.
4. King Kalukaua visited England because ______.
5. What was the Queen’s name in the article? Queen ______
6. King Kalakauawas the king of ______.
Level 2: Value: 2 points for each correct answer. Partial credit may be given.
7. Why was Hawaii important to countries such as the United States, China, Japan, and Australia?
8. Which country was most connected with Hawaii? Why are these two countries so closely linked at this time?
9. What was the cause of the reform movement and revolution in Hawaii in 1887?
10. Who was primarily involved in the reform movement?
Level 3: Value: 5 points for each correct answer. Partial credit may be given.
11. Why might some members of the royal family or administration be disliked by the general public? What is an example of this?
12. What were government funds largely used for by the royal Hawaiian family? How did this upset the people of Hawaii as well as Americans and investors?
13. What were the consequences of the King’s journey to the United States? Give three examples.
14. In what ways can you detect a bias in the newspaper article’s author? Use three examples from the text to support your point of view.
15. Do you think the author of this article would support the annexation of Hawaii? Give three pieces of textual evidence to support your point of view.
Source: “The Death of King Kalakhua,” The Sun, January 21, 1891
ANSWER KEY
Level 1. Value: 1 point for each correct answer. No partial credit on this section.
1. King Kalukauaruled the Hawaiian Islands for ___17___ years.
2. Kalukauawas ___38____ years old when he took the throne of Hawaii.
3. Kalukaua died because he had ____Bright’s_ disease.
4. King Kalukaua visited England because ______he was attempting to get better because of his failing health.
5. What was the Queen’s name in the article? Queen ______Kapiolani
6. King Kalakauawas the king of ______the Hawaiian Islands OR Hawaii
Level 2: Value: 2 points for each correct answer. Partial credit may be given.
7. Why was Hawaii important to countries such as the United States, China, Japan, and Australia?
- Hawaii is the only North Pacific stopping point between America, Australia, China, Japan, and Australia
- Hawaii serves as great commercial importance because of its fertile lands with tropical fruits, and banana, rice, and sugar exportations.
8. Which country was most connected with Hawaii? Why are these two countries so closely linked at this time?
- Hawaii is most associated with the United States.
- Connections include:
- commercial ties and trade
- “interests of capitalists”
- United States’ investment in Hawaii after King Kalakaua’s trip to the United States
- Specific interest in banana, sugar, and rice trade.
9. What was the cause of the reform movement and revolution in Hawaii in 1887?
- Misappropriating funds.
- White capitalists wanted control over public spending (that would benefit them)
10. Who was primarily involved in the reform movement?
- “American capitalists and other white residents” interested in fixing the monetary and corruption issues that plagued Hawaiian royalty.
Level 3: Value: 5 points for each correct answer. Partial credit may be given.
11. Why might some members of the royal family or administration be disliked by the general public? What is an example of this?
- excessive use of funds for fancy events and extravagant things for the royal family
- many native Hawaiians and Hawaiian immigrants felt that the Hawaiian government and royal family was incapable of ruling, and wasted government funds (example: when Kalakaua was found to have gambled away almost a quarter million dollars during his time in office as the clerk in the Land Commission Board. )
- use of gold for “useless and immoral objects”
- wasting money
- not accounting for money that was spent
12. What were government funds largely used for by the royal Hawaiian family? How did this upset the people of Hawaii as well as Americans and investors?
- parties, obtaining gold, lavish items, material goods, etc.
- upset the people of Hawaii as well as others because they were seen as not only encouraging Hawaiians to act “barbaric” by “reverting back” to old customs, but also because they were not investing money in the sugar, rice, or fruit business that many people depended on.
13. What were the consequences of the King’s journey to the United States? Give three examples.
- “Enlarged the King’s ideas”
- “Developed his ambition for power”
- “Sharpened his taste for regal display and military parade”
- Extravagant coronation ceremony after his return
- dismissal of missionary advisers
- “reverted to barbaric customs, revive pagan rites and dances, and lets his native subjects relapse into their old habits of vice and sloth”
14. In what ways can you detect a bias in the newspaper article’s author? Use three examples from the text to support your point of view.
- Answers will vary, but must include textual evidence for credit.
15. Do you think the author of this article would support the annexation of Hawaii? Give three pieces of textual evidence to support your point of view.
- Answers will vary, but must include textual evidence for credit.
For this simulation, individual students (or groups of students) will be given one of eight roles. The date is Sunday, April 16, 1899. The basis of the simulation is the article “What Shall We Do with Cuba?” Students will be asked to read their primary source and answer the questions below:
Role 1: T. Estrada Palma, President of the Cuban Junta
Source: “What Shall We do with Cuba?”
The San Francisco Call, April 16, 1899
For this simulation, individual students (or groups of students) will be given one of eight roles. The date is Sunday, April 16, 1899. The basis of the simulation is the article “What Shall We Do with Cuba?” Students will be asked to read their primary source and answer the questions below:
Role 2: Ex-Governor G. H. Grosvenor, Ohio, speaking for Congress
Source: “What Shall We do with Cuba?”
The San Francisco Call, April 16, 1899
For this simulation, individual students (or groups of students) will be given one of eight roles. The date is Sunday, April 16, 1899. The basis of the simulation is the article “What Shall We Do with Cuba?” Students will be asked to read their primary source and answer the questions below:
Role 3: Edward Atkinson, Boston, speaking for the Anti-Imperialists
Source: “What Shall We do with Cuba?”
The San Francisco Call, April 16, 1899
For this simulation, individual students (or groups of students) will be given one of eight roles. The date is Sunday, April 16, 1899. The basis of the simulation is the article “What Shall We Do with Cuba?” Students will be asked to read their primary source and answer the questions below:
Role 4: General M. G. Butler, Cuban Evacuation Committee
Source: “What Shall We do with Cuba?,”The San Francisco Call, April 16, 1899
For this simulation, individual students (or groups of students) will be given one of eight roles. The date is Sunday, April 16, 1899. The basis of the simulation is the article “What Shall We Do with Cuba?” Students will be asked to read their primary source and answer the questions below:
Role 5: Booker T. Washington, speaking for the Southern Negro
Source: “What Shall We do with Cuba?”
The San Francisco Call, April 16, 1899
For this simulation, individual students (or groups of students) will be given one of eight roles. The date is Sunday, April 16, 1899. The basis of the simulation is the article “What Shall We Do with Cuba?” Students will be asked to read their primary source and answer the questions below:
Role 6: Bishop Potter, speaking for the Clergy
Source: “What Shall We do with Cuba?”
The San Francisco Call, April 16, 1899
For this simulation, individual students (or groups of students) will be given one of eight roles. The date is Sunday, April 16, 1899. The basis of the simulation is the article “What Shall We Do with Cuba?” Students will be asked to read their primary source and answer the questions below:
Role 7: William E. Chandler, speaking for Congress
Source: “What Shall We do with Cuba?”
The San Francisco Call, April 16, 1899.
For this simulation, individual students (or groups of students) will be given one of eight roles. The date is Sunday, April 16, 1899. The basis of the simulation is the article “What Shall We Do with Cuba?” Students will be asked to read their primary source and answer the questions below:
Role 8: Henry Clews, speaking for Wall Street
Source: “What Shall We do with Cuba?”
The San Francisco Call, April 16, 1899
Points of View Chart
T. Estrada Palma / Ex-Governor of Ohio, C.H. Grosvenor / Edward Atkinson / General M. C. ButlerWhat is the alleged purpose of continuing the military occupation of Cuba until the Cubans in despair ask for annexation? / He has every faith that the U.S. gov’t will uphold their pledge for Cuban independence / They will carry out their pledge to establish a stable Cuban gov’t in stages: first military gov’t, then mixed gov’t (military/civil), lastly a gov’t Congress can direct / By signing the treaty Cuba became a free and independent state and the U.S. has no right to continue to stay there / The troops are there with consent from the Cubans to help them preserve public order and form a stable and durable government
Is annexation desired by the American people? The Cuban people? / The Cuban people should not and would not consider annexation / Most intelligent Cubans want annexation, something he also favors, as it will be an enormous value to US and benefit the Cuban people / It’s not an open question since Cuba was free from the moment they signed the treaty / It is unclear whether Cubans or Americans want annexation, but given the chance Americans would want it (Cuba has $$). Cubans are divided into 3 classes: Large property owners (pro-annex), middle class, and laboring classes.
Should Cubans be permitted to enjoy recognized independence before the question of annexation is agitated? / Cuban’s should be able to recognize their freedom / unknown / Cuba is already free, it’s just a question of whether they can form a stable government / They’re allowed to have independence if they have a stable Republican government that means no harm to the US
When and how should Cuba be evacuated? / Gradual evacuation of troops even before a stable gov’t is established / unknown / The military could help to cleanse/police cities they have no authority to be there / Troops will simply withdraw when Cubans prove they can properly manage their own affairs
Other notes / Calls for a Constitutional convention with delegates chosen by the Cuban people / The President is overstepping his role by continuing to keep forces there
Points of View Chart
Booker T. Washington / Bishop Potter / Henry Clewes / William E. ChandlerWhat is the alleged purpose of continuing the military occupation of Cuba until the Cubans in despair ask for annexation? / unknown / unknown / Doesn’t put any stock in the rumors that America wants to prolong their stay militarily so Cuba will ask for annexation / It would be a “breach of our plighted faith and wicked” to militarily stay in Cuba and force annexation
Is annexation desired by the American people? The Cuban people? / unknown / It would be hypocritical and dishonest to force them into annexation because of our promise, and our traditions / It’s best for investors if America upholds their promises, as long as a stable gov’t is in place, investors have nothing to fear / No sentiment has been given by either nation if they want annexation
Should Cubans be permitted to enjoy recognized independence before the question of annexation is agitated? / Cubans should self-govern, even if they make mistakes and don’t live up to U.S. standards / We have to keep our promise to help Cuba establish their own form of gov’t - it’s irrelevant if we agree with it or not as long as they aren’t hostile to us / Annexation may come eventually, but Cuba should have a chance at free gov’t first / Cubans should be allowed to enjoy independence
When and how should Cuba be evacuated? / We should offer protection, support, and encouragement, but that’s all / We should use our power to lift Cuba to its feet, teach it to stand alone, and then leave / Evacuation of troops will take place when a stable gov’t is in place, no sooner than that. / Cuba will soon be evacuated by the troops simply leaving
Other notes / Cuba has already solved their race issues, it would be unfair to bring them into America and revive those issues for them
Prompts for Discussion and Further Exploration:
- There are two men who “Speak for Congress” within this article - split up and look at the similarities and differences of the two. Who do you agree with more? Why?
- The two men who are in Cuba also have differing views. Compare and contrast the President of Cuba Junte, T. Estrada Palma and General M.C. Butler of the Cuban Evacuation Committee.
- Let’s get creative - Take a look at Booker T. Washington’s views on Cuban annexation and think about what a white southerner might say. Would it be the same or different?
- How would an ordinary Cuban citizen respond? Write his or her response.
- Imagine you are a citizen reading this newspaper. Write to your member of Congress and express your opinion on U.S. actions in Cuba.
- Compare and contrast the opinion of an American farmer in Iowa versus an immigrant factory worker in New York City. How would they feel about the annexation of Cuba?
Newspapers do a great job to help students understand historical context. In this activity, students are given one page of a newspaper and asked some “buzz-worthy” questions to get them thinking.
“Helen Gould Closely Guarded”
- Describe some of the ways Helen stays anonymous even in such a high profile place such as a World’s Fair.
- Do you think that those tactics work in today’s world, especially considering the internet?
- Do you think this amount of precautions would have been taken if Gould were a man?
“Papillions Becoming Happy”
- Take a look at the admission to the show. For 25 cents you saw a theater performance, and enter the garden, cafes, and roof gardens! What can you get for 25 cents today?
- How was the performance “sold” to readers?
“Patagonians Becoming Happy”
- The article describes Sioux visitors being disgusted over something, what was it?
- What was the women’s work that Old Yellow Hair saw the Pawnee men doing?
- Do you think white Americans would have considered that women’s work in 1904? Do you think we consider that women’s work today?
Looking at the page as a whole:
- Take a look at what the articles are generally written about, are they hard hitting news stories? How does this compare to what is published today?
- What was your favorite story on the page?
- What does this page tell us about life in 1904?
Source:The St. Louis Republic, May 10, 1904
DISCUSSION QUESTIONS:
1. Before even reading the advertisement, what is different, and what is the same from advertisements today?