International Aegean Conference on Electrical Machines and Power Electronics,
IEEE ACEMP'07 - ELECTROMOTION’11 Joint Meeting
September 8-10, 2011, İstanbul, Turkey
Reviewer :...... Review of Paper No:.....
Paper name:......
Reviewer Familiarity with Subject Matter(Relates to the confidence you have in your review)
□High□ Moderate□ Low
Review IEEE criteria
score: Make your choice bold for each criterion
important subject 6 5 4 3 2 1 0trivial, limited inscope
timely subject 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 obsolete
high reference value6 5 4 3 2 1 0no reference value
Original contribution6 5 4 3 2 1 0previously published
scientifically sound6 5 4 3 2 1 0dubious, obscure
application oriented6 5 4 3 2 1 0irrelevant for industry
experimentally, confirmed6 5 4 3 2 1 0unproven
discussion of past work6 5 4 3 2 1 0poor background
Recommendation:
□ Reject: Content inappropriate to the conference or has little merit
□ Probable Reject: Basic flaws in content or presentation or very poorly written
□ Marginal Tend to Reject: Not as badly flawed; major effort necessary to make acceptable
but content well-covered in literature already
□ Marginal Tend to Accept: Content has merit, but accuracy, clarity, completeness, and/or
writing should and could be improved in time
□ Clear Accept: Content, presentation, and writing meet professional norms;
improvements may be advisable but acceptable as is
□ Must Accept: Candidate for journal publication. Suggested improvements still appropriate
Is this paper a candidate for publication in Electromotion / IEEE?
□ Yes □ No □ Unsure
Comments for the Program Committee: These comments are not seen by the author
Comments for the Author:
Paper Categorization :
Indicate for which session you propose this paper
Place X to the appropriate box please
ACTUATORS / PE-C (Converters)DC motor / PE- I (Inverters)
DI (DIAGNOSTIC) / PE – emc (EMC-Harmonic)
DR-SIM (Drive-Simulation) / PE-SMPS
Education / Photo (Photovoltaic)
E-vehic (Electric Vehicle) / PM-Analysis (Permanent Magnet Brushless)
IM-AN (Analysis Induction Motor) / PM-Control (Permanent Magnet Brushless)
IM-AP (Application Induction Motor) / PM-Design (Permanent Magnet Brushless)
IM-CO (Control Induction Motor) / PO-Q (Power Quality)
IM-DE (Desingn Induction Motor) / SR (Switched Reluctance)
IM-PAR (Parameter Estimation Induction Motor) / SYNCH (Synchronous Machines)
MIS-THEORY (Miscellaneous-Theory) / Trafo (transformers)
other / WIND