Motion Picture Editing, Nancy Forner, A.C.E.
USC School of Cinematic Arts
Summer Program
The Critical Study of the Art of Picture Editing
Instructor: Nancy Forner, A.C.E.
SCA 424
COURSE DESCRIPTION
The Critical Study of the Art of Picture Editing
Picture Editors are story tellers but unlike writers who use text, or lyricists who use words, editors use visual images, dialogue, sound, special effects and music to stir the emotions of the audience and tell our stories. “How” editors use these elements and “why” editors use them is critical to the success of the film, tv show or any form of visual media. Why should I cut at this frame as opposed to this one? Why is it more important to use off-camera dialog as opposed to playing dialog on-camera? Why should a music cue start at this point in a scene as opposed to that point? When to cut when not to cut, when to stylize when not to and why. This class will analyze and deconstruct all the elements of the art of creatively manipulate the images through editing, Learning the this art is useful for all facets of filmmaking, especially if you want to be a writer, director, producer, or even a cinematographer for after the shooting stops it all comes down to the editor to put the pieces together to make a compelling, exciting and emotional story.
Nancy Forner has over 30 years of editing experience. Since the moment Mel Brooks promoted her from Assistant Editor to full Editor on the movieSolar Babies, Nancy has been busy picture editing movies and television series. During her career she has worked on many notable and diverse projects in genres and styles that range from comedy, horror, action/adventure , fantasy, medical and legal procedurals, to high intensity crime dramas and documentaries.
The award-winning Buffy the VampireSlayer, Law&Order:SVU,The Vampire Diaries,Witches of East Endand the cult classicReturn to Horror Highare a few, but not all, of her many and varied credits.
She is currently cutting the Amazon seriesJust Add Magic.
Nancy is also a Professor and Editing Track Head at USC School of Cinematic Arts and holds the Michael Kahn Endowed Chair in Editing.
CLASS FORMAT
Each week will be a mixture of lecture, viewing of film and television example and class discussion/presentations.
WEEKLY COURSE PLAN:
Week 1
Class 1
Lecture:
-Discuss Log Lines and Scene Analysis. Understanding what and who the scene is about, nuances plots, and subtexts and how that understanding affects the editing.
-Watch “The Cutting Edge” a brief introduction, overview and history of film editing.
Assignment:
-Write out a scene analysis for the script provided “500 Days of Summer.”
-Pick a movie you like, write a log line for it. Bring both to class.
Class 2
Lecture:
-Discuss the differences between “Story, Style, Emotion and Character” and how and why a scene is edited to express each.
-Watch movie and tv clips that support those differences with discussion.
-Discuss log lines and scene Analysis homework.
Assignment:
-Pick any scene from a movie or tv show, bring to class and be prepared to discuss
if the scene is cut for “Story, Style, Emotion or Character.”
Week 2
Class 1
-Lecture on Comedy Editing. Comedy is one of the most challenging genres to edit
requiring precision timing. Discussion on the theories on what makes something funny and what does not.
The Romantic comedy vs. Slapstick. The history of comedy editing, how it has changed and how many of the old rules still apply. Multicam vs. Single camera comedies.
-Watch movie and tv clips that support comedy editing theories with discussion.
-Dicscuss “Story, Style, Emotion and Character” Homework
Assignment:
-Pick any comedy scene from a movie or tv show, bring to class and be prepared to discuss.
Class 2
Lecture on Adventure and Action Editing. An action scene is immediate, visceral and needs no interpretation.
It is the most exciting and also the most technical of all editing genres. Discussion on the theories of
action editing: why are some edits more thrilling than others, how does the editor bend the film to get the
best reaction. The role of the hero and the history of action editing and how much modern technology has changed it.
-Watch and discuss movie and tv clips that support Action editing theories with discussion.
-Watch dailies of Gladiator and ER to analyze for action editing.
Assignment:
-Pick any action scene from a movie or tv show, bring to class and be prepared to discuss
Week 3
Class 1
Lecture: Genre Editing, Horror, Fantasy, Suspense and SCI-Fi Film. Horror deals with the monster, death and morality.
Fantasy with our hopes and dreams and scary romantic figures. SCI-Fi with how we imagine the future.
Suspense keeps us riveted to our seats. It all in the pacing.
Genre editing is the most creative and inventive of all editing styles. Discussion on how does the editor
use this inventiveness yet keep true to the story and the emotions of the characters
and how much modern technology has changed genre editing.
-Watch and discuss movie and tv clips that support genre editing theories.
-Watch dailies of Witches of East End to analyze for horror editing.
Assignment:
-Pick any genre scene from a movie or tv show, bring to class and be prepared to discuss
Class 2
Lecture: Sound Effects and Music
Rhythm is primal and therefore music has a strong effect on an audience.
Sound or the lack of it reinforces the emotions and pushes the elements of story.
Discussion on how does the editor use music and sound effects effectively. What is sound design
and how is that different than simple sound effects.
-Watch and discuss examples of Sndfx. and Mx. in feature films or tv shows
Assignment:
-Pick any scene from a movie or tv show, with interesting music or sound effects. bring to class and be prepared to discuss
Week 4
Class 1
Lecture: Visual Effects and Stylistic Editing.
The difference between a play and a movie is that the editor can be a magician with the film.
Discussion on VFX and how they can transport an audience to another world or intensify the one they
are in. The history of VFX and CGI.
Discussion on cutting for Style vs. Formal editing. Cutting with the rules for narrative dialogue scenes
or breaking all the rules to push the emotion.
-Watch and discuss examples of VFX and stylistic editng in feature films or tv shows
Assignment:
-Research any editor or editing style of your choice. Prepare a presentation to the class
about your research with film clips to support your research. Due Week 5, Class one.
Class 2
Demonstartion in AVID LAB
Editing is not only understanding the aesthetics but mastering the technology of the editing software. Demonstration of the AVID from simple dialogue to advanced Sapphire VFX.
Assignment:
Week 5
Class 1
Presentation of research project. Class Discussion.
Assignment:
Class 2
Lecture: The Auteur Editor
Most editing projects start out with a script, but what about projects that are not scripted where the editor is responsible for the images, sounds, pace, rhythm, story and structure?
Discussion on the auteur editors who cut documentaries, clip shows, art films, trailers, promos, sizzle reels, commercials and music videos.
How the editor, without a script or director needs to arrange images to communicate an idea, create an emotion, tell a story, or sell a product.
Assignment:
Week 6
Class 1
Lecture: Guests Lectureres: TV Director and Producer discuss working with an editor.
Class 2
Lecture: The politics of editing
How do you get a job as an editor. How do you keep that job.
Discussion on the rules of behavior between editor and director, producer, writer, studio and network executives.
Suggested READING
The following texts are invaluable knowledge for any editor, aspiring or otherwise.
http://magazine.creativecow.net/article/style-emotion-vamping-on-the-vampire-diaries
(an article I wrote about my experiences editing “The Vampire Diaries”)
Rosenberg, John: The Healthy Edit: Creative Techniques for Perfecting Your Movie.
AESTHETIC
Hollyn, Norman: The Lean Forward Moment: Create Compelling Stories for Film, TV, and The Web.
Murch, Walter: In the Blink of An Eye: A Perspective on Film Editing 2nd Edition
Silman-James Press. AESTHETIC.
Ondaatje, Michael. The Conversations: Walter Murch and the Art of Editing Film. This is an incredible series of interviews with Murch. Far more accessible and interesting than In The
Blink of an Eye, it goes over many of the real world concerns in shaping characters and filmic
story telling. AESTHETIC.
Oldham, Gabriella. First Cut: Conversations with Film Editors. This is the book mentioned
above. An incredible series of interviews with some of the top, most thoughtful, editors around.
THIS IS A HIGHLY RECOMMENDED addition to our handout readings. AESTHETIC
Koppelman, Charles. Behind the Seen: How Walter Murch Edited Cold Mountain Using
Apple's Final Cut Pro and What This Means for Cinema. This is a really great book which
describes what it was really like in the editing room on COLD MOUNTAIN, from the prep work
that Murch typically does before a film is shot, through the later previews. Rather than a book
about Final Cut (though it does talk a lot about that) it is more a look at the real world of editing.
HIGHLY RECOMMENDED. AESTHETIC and PRACTICAL.
Arijon, Daniel. Grammar of The Film Language. A very detailed, thorough and incredibly
tedious (but valuable) look at how to block a scene to create the best shots for editing. If you've
ever tried to plan shots for a group of eight people around a dinner table, you'll appreciate this
book. TECHNICAL
Bayes, Steve The Avid Handbook. This is an excellent reference book for the intermediate
Avid editor, complete with tips and tricks on organizational skills, the Avid program, and the
hardware. TECHNICAL
Boorman, John and Donahue, Walter. PROJECTIONS. This is a periodic book series that
often includes interviews with directors. Some of their discussions are quite amazing in their
description of storytelling. The excerpt from Walter Murchʼs interview about THE ENGLISH
PATIENT that I use in class originally appeared in this series. AESTHETIC.
Cohen, Steve. Avid Agility (2ndEdition). This is a great book that encompasses both basic
and intermediate tips for the Avid Media Composer. Once you're good at the program, this book
will give you a number of "Oh My God! THAT'S how to do that faster/easier" moments.
TECHNICAL. Order directly from Amazon at http://amzn.to/qX8x0y
Crittenden, Roger. Fine Cuts: The Art of European Film Editing. AESTHETIC Dancyger,
Ken. The Technique of Film Editing.
Davis, Richard. Complete Guide To Film Scoring. We will be discussing film editing and
music during one of our classes. This is a good companion for those of you who want to dig
deeper into the topic.
Dmytryk, Edward. On Film Editing. A great discussion of editing, from a personal point of
view. Also valuable from the same author are On Screen Writing, On Screen Directing, and On
Screen Acting and On Film. AESTHETIC.
LoBrutto, Vincent. Selected Takes: Film Editors On Editing. A wonderful series of interviews
with some of the top editors of the past and present. AESTHETIC.
Pepperman, Richard D. The Eye Is Quicker: Film Editing: Making a Good Film Better. A
profusely illustrated discussion of film editing, using frame grabs from well-known movies, to
make general points about different styles of editing. AESTHETIC.
Rabiger, Michael. Directing: Film Techniques and Aesthetics. A very detailed study of the
issues in directing. Its discussion of editing is very valuable for what it reveals about the
storytelling mind, from the directorʼs point of view. AESTHETIC.
Reisz, Karel, and Millar, Gavin. The Technique of Film Editing. One of the seminal texts on
editing. While outdated in terms of some stylistic choices, it remains one of the classic texts on
editing. AESTHETIC
Rosenblum, Ralph. When The Shooting Stops... The Cutting Begins. Rosenblum, a veteran
film editor who cut many of Woody Allen's early films, talks about his experiences both in and
out of the editing room. More raconteurial than instructional, it does give a nice sense of the
style of a colorful editor -- both in terms of editing and politics. AESTHETIC.
Rubin, Michael. Nonlinear - A Field Guide to Digital Video and Film Editing. A description ofthe history and equipment in non-linear digital editing. Pictures of the various editing systems
with descriptions of each one fill up most of the back part of the book. TECHNICAL
Solomons, Tony. The Avid Film Editing Room Handbook. This book is an excellent
introductory work to the Avid. Though it isnʼt a how-to book in the classic sense, it does give the
new Avid user a good sense of how to perform varying levels of tasks. TECHNICAL
Thompson, Roy. The Grammar of the Edit. AESTHETIC.
Truffaut, Francis. Hitchock/Truffaut. A series of interviews done by then-critic Truffaut of the
master director, Alfred Hitchcock. It is here that his incredible theory on surprise vs. suspense is
mentioned. AESTHETIC.
STUDENT SURVEY:
Name______Major______Email______
The following is not graded. My intention is to understand everyone’s capabilities and interests
coming into the semester.
* What kind of editing experience have you had at USC or elsewhere? Please be specific.
* What editing software are you familiar with?
* What is the number one reason you chose this course?
* Name three things you hope to learn in this course.
* List your five favorite films...and why (this doesn’t have to be about editing).
* List your five favorite TV shows...and why (this doesn’t have to be about editing).