- 1 -
2012 / 2013 – ANNEXURE C
368 Judgments / Court Orders
(Only 368 Judgments / Court Orders were received from 1726 Litigation, all other matters are either pending, struck off the roll, legal opinions or letters of demand)
SUBJECT / NATURE OF LITIGATION / JUDGMENT / COURT ORDER1. Mekoro Deste & 4 others / Minister of Home Affairs (12/11856) / Immigration Urgent Application / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
2. Shampenois Lotis / Minister of Home Affairs & 2 others (2012/108850) / Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
3. Birhanu Yossefi / Minister of Home Affairs (12/11997) / Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
4. Ibrahim Kholil / Minister of Home Affairs (1385/2012) / Immigration / Order to release from detention. Matter settled out of court by agreement between the parties
5. Lamoro Fosido / Minister of Home Affairs / Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela following detention exceeding prescribed 120 days and allow him to apply for asylum
6. Kemau Tarakengn / Minister of Home Affairs / Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela following detention exceeding prescribed 120 days and allow him to apply for asylum
7. Terefa Tesfaye / Minister of Home Affairs / Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela following detention exceeding prescribed 120 days and allow him to apply for asylum
8. Aftab Hussain Warraich / Minister of Home Affairs 19385/12 / Immigration Urgent Application / Order to consider application for a permanent residence
9. Degefa Mitiku 13011/12;
10. Zaude Johannes;
11. Sintoyenu Asseya;
12. Gama Tadaga / Minister of Home Affairs; Director-General; Bosasa (pty)ltd / Immigration / Order to release applicants from Lindela to allow them to apply for asylum
13. Teshomo Walamo Gabete / Minister of Home Affairs; Director-General;
14. Selogile Legabe; Minister of Police 551/12 / Immigration Urgent Application / Order to release applicants from Lindela to allow them to apply for asylum
15. John Wondemu / Minister of Home Affairs & 2 others (12668/12) / Immigration Urgent Application / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
16. David Jumba / Minister of Home Affairs & 2 others 12695/12 / Immigration Urgent Application / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
17. Askale Hailu / Minister of Home Affairs & 2 others 12670/12 / Immigration Urgent Application / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
18. Bahiru Dafriro Dersa;
19. Duamo (Dijamo) Abeba Binchamo;
20. Teshela Woldmakele 13174/12;
21. Shifa Kibamo Delacha 13171/12
22. Muhammad Elias 13173/12;
23. Mandesha Mandine;
24. Genamo Gagabo;
25. Eshetu Ashamo (12/15574);
26. Workino Talilo Workene 13172/12
27. Dado Dalelegn / Minister of Home Affairs (2/13281)
28. Lalamo Lobeto Wolso / Minister of Home Affairs (12/13289)
29. Adino Labemi Abtamu / Minister of Home Affairs (12/13285)
30. Jone Wondemui 12/13284)
31. Mamusha Nasir / Minister of Home Affairs (12/13274) + 12/15576
32. Habetamo Arko / Minister of Home Affairs (12/13286) / Immigration Urgent Application / Order to release applicants from Lindela to allow them to apply for asylum
33. Ella Elizabeth Catherine Rautenbach / Minister of Home Affairs; Director-General of Home Affairs; Francois Hammond; Tjaart Johannes Kilian / Change surname / Order to change minor children’s surnames to Applicants marital surname
34. Paschal Eliahs Mwaijulu / Minister of Home Affairs & others 3896/12 / Immigration Urgent Application / Order to deport applicant to his country of origin
35. Eridado Mulegete; Sinjilo Girima; Jafesa Jafara; Chafamo (Fikile) Fikre / Minister of Home Affairs and others 13275/12 / Immigration Urgent Application / Order to release applicants from Lindela to allow them to apply for asylum
36. Rashid Mahmood / Minister of Home Affairs (6953/12) / Immigration / Application for judicial review for asylum dismissed with costs
37. Motonsa Amin & 8 others / Minister of home Affairs & 1 another (620/12) / Immigration / Order to release applicants from Lindela to allow them to apply for asylum
38. Sefonia Kebebe Mengistu / Minister of Home Affairs (646/12) / Immigration / Order to release from detention pending finalization of an appeal in terms of Section 8 of the Immigration Act
39. Junxia Zhao & 2 others/ Minister of Home Affairs (3945/2012) / Immigration Urgent Application / Order to release applicants and give orders to voluntarily depart from the Republic
40. Sultan Bakara / Minister of Home Affairs & 2 others (4296/2012) / Immigration Urgent Application / Order to release from detention – expired permit due for renewal
41. Mbatha Nompulelo Victoria / Department of Home Affairs & 2 others (30802/11) / Customary Marriage / Department abided by the Court Order (customary marriage - unopposed)
42. Samir Ismailbhai Vohra & 6 others / Minister of Home Affairs (21971/12) / Immigration / Order to return applicants passports
43. Derfed Dersan / Minister of Home Affairs (2012/15702)
44. Ibrahim Jemali / Minister of home Affairs (2012/15703)
45. Dareje Tefera Ossamo / Minister of Home Affairs (2012/15708)
46. Ibrahim Hassan / Minister of Home Affairs (2012/15704)
47. Katanga Christian 12/15579
48. Shafa Dagebo Edao / Minister of Home Affairs (12/15633)
49. Woriki Fikedu / Minister of Home Affairs (2012/15631)
50. MD Balal Miah / Minister of Home Affairs (12/15718)
51. Gata Desta / Minister of Home Affairs 12/15627
52. Chamiso Jemirate 12/15622
53. Derfed Dersan 12/15702 &
54. Dersah Bahiru Defriro 12/15701
55. Dilaso Ermias 12/15705
56. Walombo Eridulo 12/15684
57. Adu-Twum Frank Osei 12/15700
58. Lire Mehamed
59. Sharol Dabedi 12/15690
60. Nuri Shahalo 12/15689 / Immigration Urgent Application / Order to release applicants from Lindela to allow them to apply for asylum
61. Abraham Malcalm 12/15697
62. Herico Abraham 12/15711
63. Demeke Erisumu 12/15719
64. Adana Tiror Bereket 12/15723
65. Desalegne Gadebo Degage (Degago) 12/15722
66. Todese Hodseb Lambedo 12/15691
67. Ziaad Coma 12/15693
68. Ibram Awen 12/15707 / Immigration Urgent Application / Order to release applicants from Lindela to allow them to apply for asylum
69. Tedesse Dauit 12/15628
70. Tedesse Dauit 12/13859
71. Tedesse Dauit 12/15714
72. Joseph Sakwe 12/15629
73. Karim Abdul 12/156329
74. Ahmed Mohmed 12/15623
75. Mohammed Zaine 12/15634
76. Manchos Fitebo Wodeyones 12/15686
77. Mohammad Senteke 12/15624
78. Winekile Adisu 12/15692
79. Tigistu Wombago 12/15686
80. Haiko Cabadia 12/15625
81. Taso Fikedu 12/15626
82. Tiroro Mosa 12/15630
83. Alemu Workenih 12/15683
84. Nuradin Salia 12/15578
85. Abdella Mula 15864/12
86. Elya Bosulu Belly 12/15577
87. De Seleni Belech 12/13861
88. Wahidur Rahman;
89. Abdus Samad;
90. Ali Hossain;
91. Rajaul Islam 13863/12
92. Erica Simul 13860/12
93. Enamul Hoque;
94. Saiful Islam Chowdhury;
95. Rabel Ahmed;
96. Alaur Rahman 13862/12 / Immigration Urgent Application / Order to release applicants from Lindela to allow them to apply for asylum
97. Yonos Kiros Mellaku / Minister of Home Affairs; Director-General of Home Affairs; Chief Directorate: Asylum Seeker Management; Director: Deportations; Bosasa; Chairperson Refugee Appeal Board 16232/12 / Immigration / Order to release applicant to apply for temporary residence permit
98. Nwuaabni Stephen;
99. Arko Amothomo 16507/12
100. Nwoke Emmanuel Ifeanyi
101. Bilore Mathwes Lire (2012/16725)
102. Deliso Fikre (12/16506)
103. Wude Hussein (12/16496)
104. Abutoro Safayo (12/16495)
105. Woledo Bahore (16500/12) / Immigration Urgent Application / Order to release applicants from Lindela following detention exceeding prescribed 120 days
106. Daharos Demeke 16447/12
107. Tarekegn Torogo Dangoro 16449/12
108. Tororo Lano 16448/12
109. Marcos Cherinet 16442/12 (23296/12)
110. Satan Anito (16727/2012)
111. Ganamo Gagabo (12/16713)
112. Solimon Heret (2012/16723)
113. Erose Tefese (16726/2012)
114. Wondato Nathaniel Abobe (2012/16721)
115. Abegai Erkato (12/16508)
116. Willy Ndongara (2012/16722)
117. Petros Zalaka (2012/16724)
118. Bafa Getachaw (12/16493)
119. Abeyana Wondemu (12/16503) / Immigration Urgent Application / Order to release applicants from Lindela following detention exceeding prescribed 120 days and allow them to apply for asylum
120. Tefera Adiso (12/16416)
121. Mishiso Dameka Makedo (12/16705)
122. Zenere Chufamo (12/16707)
123. Desta Hanfore Gichamo (12/16706)
124. Kibomo Ashuro (12/16505)
125. Ramato Hussain (2012/16488)
126. Demeke Chato (12/16489)
127. Safayo Kurere Diema (12/16497)
128. Shukuri Gudeta (12/16502)
129. Degago Desalegn (16504/12)
130. Belachu Hotoro (12/16494)
131. Germa Erwaro (12/16492)
132. Eridado Mvlegete (12/16501)
133. Ararso Muleta (12/16491) / Immigration Urgent Application / Order to release applicants from Lindela following detention exceeding prescribed 120 days
134. Usman Muhammad (12/16695)
135. Shekat Ali (12/16697)
136. Anamul Hapue, Abdus Samad (12/16698)
137. Tekete Tekete Seklas (12/16699)
138. Singh Prem Negi, Sing Sarat (12/16700)
139. Hossan Abrar (12/16696) / Immigration / Order to release applicants from Lindela to allow them to apply for asylum
140. Sainet Manja (168/2012) / Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela pending judicial review
141. Dareje Tefera Ossamo / Minister of Home Affairs & 3 others (284198/12) / Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
142. Ida Oosthuizen Immigration Practitioner cc; 199 Others / Minister of Home Affairs; Director-General; Chief Director: Permitting 30100/12 / Immigration / Order by agreement to consider and decide on permits
143. Ntswaki Agnes Morajane / Lungi Magagula; Minister of Home Affairs; Master of High Court 16988/12 / Registration Customary Marriage / Department abided by the Court Order (customary marriage - unopposed)
144. Natasha Van Wyk / Johannes Jurgens Koekemoer; Director-General of Home Affairs (64457/2011) / Civic Services change of surname / Order to change names (amendment). Complied with Court Order
145. Catherine Mokgaetsi Monkwe / Minister of Home Affairs (29212/12) / Deregister Marriage / Department abided by the Court Order (customary marriage - unopposed)
146. Lan ANH Nguyen / Minister of Home Affairs & 3 others (31614/12) / Immigration / Order to release applicant and return her passport
147. Mei Hau Wen and 7 Others 20742/12
148. Kaviwabo Noella 21182/12
149. Juma Issa 21178/12
150. Raguha David 21179/12
151. Mnega Andre 21183/12
152. Mariam Juma 21177/12
153. Abdi Adam 21176/12
154. Elayo Dajaka (21163/12)
155. Shukiri Gudeta & 4 others (21175/12)
156. Riziki Sefu (12/21184)
157. Ayubu Haji (12/21364)
158. Issa Hamiss (12/21364)
159. Jumapili Mwajuma (12/21180)
160. Vincent Kalala (21397/2012)
161. Deku Johannes (21399/2012)
162. David Juma Amuri (21398/2012) / Refugees / Order to release applicants from Lindela following detention exceeding prescribed 120 days
163. Nazim Uddin / Minister of Home Affairs and 2 others (1891/12) / Immigration Urgent Application / Order to release applicant from Lindela following detention exceeding prescribed 120 days
164. MD Mamun Miah / Minister of Home Affairs (1914/12) / Refugee Affairs / Order to release applicant from Lindela following detention exceeding prescribed 120 days
165. Desta Milkebo / Minister of Home Affairs & 3 others (34507/12) / Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela and issue applicant with asylum permit
166. Alemu Chamisa (23297/12)
167. Anshebo Bekele Abiyo; Guguro Wasiro; Dawit Tirago; Germa Erwaro (12/23200)
168. Khalek Abdul; Rahma Jullar (2012/23186)
169. Sarder Mohsin (2012/12/23187)
170. Agnes Kanyana (12/22990)
171. Manik Miah (23256/12)
172. Ndowa Veronique Wembo (23295/12) / Immigration / Order to release applicants from Lindela following detention exceeding prescribed 120 days
173. Jordan Unya Mutwale / Minister of Home Affairs (6796/2012) / Immigration Urgent Application / Order Applicant to be released and issued with an order to depart
174. Khadar Kunju Shajahan / Director-General of Home Affairs (37148/2012) / Immigration / Order to reconsider the applicant’s application for temporary residence
175. Mohammed Irshad Butt / Minister of Home Affairs (3724/2012) / Immigration / Order to make a decision on the permit application
176. Tesfaye Cassa / Minister of Home Affairs (12/24734) / Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
177. Caseko Erbalo & 3 others / Minister of Home Affairs (12/274735) / Immigration / Order to release applicants from Lindela to allow them to apply for asylum
178. Desteri Kabatho / Minister of Home Affairs (12/24736) / Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
179. Jimmy Cornelus / Minister of Home Affairs (12/24737) / Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela following detention exceeding prescribed 120 days
180. Spone Kande Mwaza / Minister of Home Affairs & 3 others (25027/2012) / Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela following detention exceeding prescribed 120 days
181. Pascal Amuri Bisanga / Minister of Home Affairs (25026/12) / Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela following detention exceeding prescribed 120 days
182. Craig Leonard Upton / Director-General of Home Affairs & 2 others (12850/2011) / Immigration / Application for minor child to be registered in his father’s surname and full unabridged birth certificate to reflect that – granted by court
183. Matias Tirraso / Minister of Home Affairs & 3 others (38796/12) / Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
184. Kadero Dilebo Lire / Minister of Home Affairs (25358/12) / Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
185. Muhammed Hussien Ashaf / Minister of Home Affairs (12/25186) / Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
186. Ogu Okechukwukwu / Minister of Home Affairs (12/25326) / Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
187. Tedamo Dewiti & 5 others / Minister of Home Affairs & 3 others (39977/12) / Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
188. Tsedeke Getechew & Anise Teshuma Minister of Home Affairs / Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
189. Mihret Wisenbei & 15 others / Minister of Home Affairs (26161/102) / Immigration / Order to release applicants from Lindela to allow them to apply for asylum
190. Amore Zeleke Dessaleyn / Minister of Home Affairs (39979/12) / Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum
191. Haalo Damka / Minister of Home Affairs (38837/12) / Immigration / Order to release applicant from Lindela to allow him to apply for asylum