MISS AMERICA’S OUTSTANDING TEEN
MECHANICS OF JUDGING FOR 2009LOCAL PAGEANTS
(Revised May1, 2009)
(This document supersedes all previous documents, which should be destroyed)
Competitions and Scoringfor Single-Night/Single-DayLocal Pageants
Local Pageants are given the option of using the previous scoring system or to begin using the current national scoring system.
OPTION 1OPTION 2
Private Interview -35%Private Interview- 35%
On-Stage Question - 5%Talent- 35%
Talent - 35%Evening Wear/Question- 20%
Evening Wear - 15%Lifestyle and Fitness- 10%
Lifestyle and Fitness in Sportswear - 10%
The judges’ panel is being asked to “find” one of the primary representatives for the Local Organization.
Tie Breakers
Tie Breaker for Getting into the Top Five
(using the same procedure as above)
Talent
Private Interview
Evening Wear
Lifestyle and Fitness in Sportswear
On-Stage Question
Ties Into or Within the Top Five of a Local Pageant
Talent (contestant with highest talent points moves on). If still tied:
Private Interview
Evening Wear
Lifestyle and Fitness in Sportswear
On-Stage Question
Head-to-Head Competition -If contestants are still tied after exhausting the previous judging categories for breaking the ties, the names are placed on a Tie Breaker Selection Sheet and handed to the judges and each judge circles his/her choice for placement.
MISS AMERICA’S OUTSTANDING TEEN
APPENDIX A
2009LOCAL PAGEANT TOP FIVE FINAL BALLOT GUIDELINES
(Revised May1, 2009)
Top Five Final Ballot Explanation
Judges should be instructed well ahead of time that once all On-Stage competitions are completed - Talent, Private Interview, Lifestyle and Fitness in Sportswear,On-Stage Question, and Evening Wear - the auditors will identify the Top Five contestants. At this point, all previous points will be discarded and each of the Top Five contestants will have zero points. (Show the judges a sample of the Final Ballotwith fictitious names to review so they are familiar with this ballot before it is handed to them during the final moments of the competition. This sample ballot should be returned to the auditors, before the judges are dismissed.)
During the actual pageant, each judge will then be provided a Final Ballot. Each judge should then list the contestants in the order in which the judge believes the contestants should finish. A 1st place vote will be worth 10 points, a 2nd place vote worth 5 points, a 3rd place vote worth 3 points, a 4th place vote worth 2 points and a 5th place vote worth 1 point. These points will be totaled and these points alone will determine the outcome of the pageant.
Remind judges to vote their conscience and to accurately place the contestants in the order in which they individually believe the contestants should finish without any consideration to any other factors. Typically, any attempts to manipulate the outcome of the pageant can and do result in an outcome unsatisfactory to all parties.
The winner and runners-up will be announced solely from the results of the Final Ballot.
2007 Miss America Organization - All rights reserved -Revised 05-01-2009
C:\Documents and Settings\mhannah\My Documents\Miss America's Outstanding Teen\2008\Forms for Website Resources Page\Local\2008_MAOT_Local_Mechanics_of_Judging.doc Page 1 of 2