Voting Record - Attachment to TLR ReportApril 27, 2006

Vote by the Joint Interface Committee on Motion to approve the NERC SAR and NAESB standard request for the development of Version 0 reliability and business practice standards, respectively, as identified by the joint NERC/NAESB task force - August 16, 2004
NERC Members / Company Name / Vote:
Linda Campbell / Florida Reliability Coordinating Council / Approve
Scott Henry / Duke Power / Approve
Mark Fidrych / Western Area Power Admin. / Approve
Sam Jones / Electric Reliability Council of Texas / Approve
Ed Schwerdt / Approve
NAESB Members / Company Name / Vote:
Michael Desselle / American Electric Power / Approve
John Anderson / ELCON / Approve
Syd Berwager / Bonneville Power Administration / Approve
Ed Davis / Entergy / Approve
Barry Green / OPG / Approve
IRC Members / Company Name / Vote:
Karl Tammar / New York ISO / Approve
Ed Riley / California ISO / Approve
Dale McMaster / AESO / Approve
Kent Saatoff / Electric Reliability Council of Texas / Approve
Charles Yeung / Southwest Power Pool / Approve
Vote by the TLR Subcommittee On the Designated Split of the TLR Business Practices From Reliability Standards June 1, 2005
Name: / Organization: / Vote:
Neal Balu / WPS Resources / In support
Jim Busbin / Southern Co / In support
Phil Cox / American Electric Power / In support
Steve Dayney / XCEL Energy / In support
Michael Desselle / American Electric Power / In support
Mark Fidrych / Western Area Power Association / In support
Mark Fowler / Ameren / In support
Larry Kezele / NERC / In support
Sue Mangum-Goins / TennesseeValley Authority / In support
Andy Rodriquez / PJM / In support
Narinder Saini / Entergy / In support
Charles Yeung / Southwest Power Pool / In support
Kathy York / TennesseeValley Authority / In support
Vote by the WEQ Executive Committee to Approve Recommendation R04013ANovember 22, 2005
End User Segment / Company Name / VOTE
John Hughes / Electricity Consumers Resource Council (ELCON) / In support
Lou Ann Westerfield / Idaho Public Utilities Commission, rep. National Association of Regulatory Utility Commissioners / In support
Paul Sorenson / Open Access Technology International, Inc. / In support
Distribution/LSE Segment
Ollie Frazier / Duke Energy / In support
Jack Leonard / Exelon PECO Energy / Support ballot[1]
Robert Williams / Florida Municipal Power Agency / In support
Robert Schwermann Alt. for D. Cooper / Sacramento Municipal Utility District / In support
Syd Berwager / Bonneville Power Administration/Power Business Line / In support
Don Benjamin / North American Electric Reliability Council / Opposition
Generation Segment
Kathy York / TennesseeValley Authority / In support
Louis Oberski / Dominion Resource Services, Inc. / In support
Tony Reed / Southern Company Generation and Energy Marketing / In support
Barry Green / Ontario Power Generation / In support
William J. Gallagher / Vermont Public Power Supply Authority / In support
Marketer/Broker Segment
Valerie Crockett Alt. for C. Harmon / TennesseeValley Authority / In support
Joel Dison / Southern Company Generation and Energy Marketing / In support
Clay A. Norris / North Carolina Municipal Power Agency #1 / In support
Suzanne Calcagno / UBS Energy LLC / In support
Mark Tallman / PacifiCorp / Support ballot[2]
Transmission Segment
Steven C. Cobb / Salt River Project / In support
Jim Hicks Alt. for M. Maher / PacifiCorp / In support
Edward Davis / Entergy Services, Inc. / Opposition
Mary Ellen Paravalos / National Grid USA / Support ballot[3]
Patrick McGovern / Georgia Transmission Corporation / Abstain
Julie Voeck / American Transmission Company / Opposition ballot[4]
Linda Campbell / Florida Reliability Coordinating Council / Opposition
Wholesale Electric Quadrant (WEQ)Ratification Tally for R04013AApril 10, 2006
Seg / Sub
Seg / Company Name / Voting Member (Highlighted) / VOTE
m / iou / American Electric Power Service Corp. / Barbara Radous, Joseph Hartsoe, Phil Cox / In Support
t / iou / American Electric Power Service Corp. / John Stough, Michael Desselle / In Support
d / other / Bonneville Power Administration / Sydney D. Berwager / In Support
g / fed / Bonneville Power Administration / Francis Halpin / In Support
t / fed / Bonneville Power Administration / Barbara Rehman / In Support
g / merc / Constellation Generation Group / Michael Gildea / In Support
g / iou / Dominion Energy Marketing, Inc. / Louis Oberski / In Support
e / reg / New YorkState Dept. of Public Service / William Heinrich / In Support
d / at large / North American Electric Reliability Council (NERC) / Donald M. Benjamin, Larry Kezele, Tom Vandervort, Bill Blevins / In Support
m / muni / North Carolina Electric Municipal Power Agency #1 / Clay A. Norris / In Support
t / iou / Northeast Utilities Service Company / David Boguslawski, Calvin A. Bowie / In Support
d / muni / Sacramento Municipal Utility District / Robert D. Schwermann / In Support
d / other / TennesseeValley Authority / Cindy Herron, CH Asst. (Dawn Arnorld) / In Support
g / fed / TennesseeValley Authority / Kathy York / In Support
m / fed / TennesseeValley Authority / Clyde Harmon / In Support
t / fed / TennesseeValley Authority / Mitchell Needham, W. Terry Boston / In Support
t / itc / TRANS-ELECT, INC. / Paul D. McCoy / In Support
d / iou / We Energies (Wisconsin Electric) / Linda Horn / In Support
g / iou / We Energies (Wisconsin Electric) / James R. Keller / In Support
g / at large / Williams Power Company / Ron Mucci / In Support
Seg / Sub
Seg / Company Name / Voting Member (Highlighted) / VOTE
d / iou / Consumers Energy Company / Andrew C. Dotterweich, Frank Johnson / In Opposition
g / iou / Consumers Energy Company / Steven L. Gaarde, Andrew C. Dotterweich, John J. Dellas / In Opposition
t / iou / Entergy Services, Inc. / Edward J. Davis, John H. Zemanek, Narinder Saini / In Opposition
t / at large / Florida Reliability Coordinating Council / Linda D. Campbell / In Opposition
t / itc / International Transmission Company / Jim D. Cyrulewski / In Opposition

1

[1] Mr. Leonard submitted a notational ballot on December 12, 2005

[2] Mr. Tallman submitted a notational ballot on December 14, 2005

[3] Ms. Paravolos submitted a notational ballot on December 5, 2005

[4] Ms. Voeck submitted a notational ballot on December 12, 2005