September 2010 IEEE P802.15-10-0816-01-0007
IEEE P802.15
Wireless Personal Area Networks
Project / IEEE P802.15.7Task Group Visible Light Communication (TG-VLC)Title / TG-VLCJuly Plenary meeting in HawaiiMeeting Minutes
Date Submitted / 29September 2010
Source / [Taehan Bae]
[Samsung Electronics.Co., Ltd.]
[Suwon, Korea] / Voice:[+82-31-279-7293]
Fax:[+82-31-279-5130]
E-mail:[
Re:
Abstract / Minutes of TG-VLCPlenary inWaikoloa, HI
Purpose / Minutes of TG-VLC sessions
Notice / This document has been prepared to assist the IEEE P802.15. It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the contributing individual(s) or organization(s). The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after further study. The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to add, amend or withdraw material contained herein.
Release / The contributor acknowledges and accepts that this contribution becomes the property of IEEE and may be made publicly available by P802.15.
Hilton Waikoloa Village, Waikoloa, HI
September 12 - 16, 2010
Monday, September 13, 2010 – 4 sessions (AM2, PM1, PM2, Ad hoc)
10:30 ~21:30
Meeting was called to order by Chair Eun Tae Won.
Eun Tae Won remarked on the agenda for TG-VLC (15-10-0659-00-0007-waikoloa-meeting-agenda.xls) and the committee discussed the time schedule.
- Meeting minutes was reviewed and approved (15-10-0600-00-0007-vlc-meeting-minutes-july-plenary-San Diego.doc)
- Checked the schedule in agenda
- Cureent 14 time slot and asked 2 more ad hoc time slot
- Need to time to prepare the resolution contribution during this meeting
- Suggested “Letter ballot committee”
- Between the official meeting, the Letter ballot committee can approve the D3 comment as a official document for letter ballot and submit for letter ballot
- Need to volunteer one person from each company.
- Need to discussion later more.
- Discussion about No vote
- Clint will send mail to no voter asking the opinion about D2 draft and resolution.
* Comment resolution excel file
*15-10-0681-02-0007-lb57-combined-comment-sheet.xls: presented by Rick Roberts (Intel)
* Hearing presentation
* 15-10-0715-00-0007-comment-resolutions-on-the-parameters-for-color-function-support-t-cid-124-and-221: Presented by Sang Kyu Lim (ETRI)
* 15-10-0688-01-0007-assigned-comments-on-d2-draft.pdf: Presented by Sridhar. (Samsung Electronics)
* 15-10-0728-00-0007-editing-csk-constellation-description-a-cid-1-t-cid-100-103: Presented by Jaeseung Son (Samsung)
* 15-10-0728-01-0007-editing-csk-constellation-description-a-cid-1-t-cid-100-103: Presented by Jaeseung Son (Samsung)
* 15-10-0715-01-0007-comment-resolutions-on-the-parameters-for-color-function-support-t-cid-124-and-221.pdf: Presented by Sang Kyu Lim (ETRI)
* 15-10-0729-01-0007-comment-and-proposed-resolution: Presented by Taehan Bae (Samsung Electronics)
* Discussion about mobility structure.
* 15-10-0693-02-0007-vlc-cell-mobility-clarification: Presented by Sridhar Rajagopal
* 15-10-0688-02-0007-assigned-comments-on-d2-draft: Presented by Sridhar Rajagopal
The session recessed until tomorrow session
Recessed by Chair Eun Tae Won.
Recess until session 5
Tuesday, September 14, 2010 – 5 sessions (AM1, AM2, PM1, PM2, Ad hoc)
08:00 ~ 21:30
* Comment resolution excel file
*15-10-0681-02-0007-lb57-combined-comment-sheet.xls: presented by Rick Roberts (Intel)
* Hearing presentation
* 15-10-0751-00-0007-The text for the merger clause 4_4_3_1_5_VPPM dimming and Annex B_VPPM principles: Presented by Sang-Kyu Lim (ETRI)
2. 15-10-0752-01-0007-The new text insertion as per the accepted remedy on CID 348 related to the clause 6_6_13: Presented by Sang-Kyu Lim (ETRI)
The session recessed until tomorrow session
Recessed by Chair Eun Tae Won.
Recess until session 10
======
Wednesday, September 15, 2010– 3 Sessions(AM1, PM1, PM2)
08:00 ~10:00, 13:30~18:00
Meeting was called to order by Chair Eun Tae Won.
* Comment resolution excel file
*15-10-0681-0x-0007-lb57-combined-comment-sheet.xls: presented by Rick Roberts (Intel)
* Hearing presentation related with comment & resolution
* 10-0763-00-0007-modified-text-for-vlc-cell-mobility: presented by Sridhar Rajagopal (Samsung Electronics)
* Discussion about “symbol”issues in the D2 draft.
* 15-10-0660-01-0007-update-of-5-8-4-1-2.doc: presented by Jaeseung Son (Samsung Electronics)
* 15-10-0778-00-0007-some-discussion-for-lb-57-comment-resolution-of-annex-g.pdf: presented by Sang-Kyu Lim (ETRI)
* 15-10-0776-00-0007-the-text-modifications-of-annex-g-for-the-lb-57-comment-resolution.doc : presented by Sang-Kyu Lim (ETRI)
* 15-10-0681-08-0007-lb57-combined-comment-sheet.xls: updated and submitted by Rick Roberts (Intel)
* Review the remained comments and assigned the committee members.
- each committee member prepare and contribute tomorrow.
The session recessed until tomorrow session
Recessed by Chair Eun Tae Won.
Recess until session 13
Thursday, September 16, 2010 – 4 Sessions(AM1, AM2, PM1, PM2)
08:00 ~18:00
Meeting was called to order by Chair Eun Tae Won.
* Comment resolution excel file
*15-10-0681-08-0007-lb57-combined-comment-sheet.xls: presented by Rick Roberts (Intel)
* Hearing presentation based on the contribution from assigned T-CID resolution yesterday
* 15-10-0763-01-0007-modified-text-for-vlc-cell-mobility.docx: presented by Sridhar Rajagopal (Samsung Electronics)
- discussion about mobility related sub-clause
- Need to insert the contents about “the mobility notification commandis for the device to the infrastructure.”
- Need to clarify the notation for cell, for example, cell, sub-cell and etc
- Discussion for CS in detail.
- The committee can have a CC about that if needed.
* 15-10-0781-00-0007-modified-text-for-annex-e-in-d2.docx: presented by Sridhar Rajagopal (Samsung Electronics)
- Annex E, T-76, 396, 144
* 15-10-0688-03-0007-assigned-comments-on-d2-draft.pdf: presented by Sridhar Rajagopal (Samsung Electronics)
- T-CID 51, 383
* resolving several comment based on Sridhar’s e-mail contribution.
* 15-10-0782-00-0007-modified-text-for-t-cid-182.doc: presented by Sridhar Rajagopal (Samsung Electronics)
- T-CID 182, 165
* 15-10-0729-02-0007-comment-and-proposed-resolution.pdf: presented by Taehan Bae (Samsung Electronics)
- T-CID 193, 194, 195
* 15-10-0778-01-0007-some-discussion-for-lb-57-comment-resolution-of-annex-g.pdf: presented by Sang-Kyu Lim (ETRI)
* 15-10-0776-01-0007-the-text-modifications-of-annex-g-for-the-lb-57-comment-resolution.doc
- ETRI: presented by Sang-Kyu Lim (ETRI)
* 15-10-0775-00-0007-standard-body-text-toward-resolution-of-lb57-cid-t-190: Presented by Joachim W. Walewski (Siemens AG, Germany)
* 15-10-0703-02-0007-use-of-the-term-symbol-in-ieee-802-15-7-d2.xls: Presented by Joachim W. Walewski (Siemens AG, Germany)
- discussion about “Symbol”
- T-CID 6, 133, 140, 208, 216, 234, 394,
* 15-10-0784-03-0007-updated-text-based-on-6-6-11-1-and-6-6-11-2.doc: presented by Jaeseung Son (Samsung Electronics)
- T-CID 277, 285
* 15-10-0799-00-0007-suggestion-for-line-scan-led-signboard-issue-of-annex-g.pdf: presented by Sang-Kyu Lim (ETRI)
- T-CID 509
- The committee decided that“ETRI and Intel figure this out this and should be resolve before releasing the D3.
* review the last comment resolution pending yesterday
* Motion
Move that the TG7 approve the comment resolutions in document 10/0681/r11 (15-10-0681-11-0007-lb57-combined-comment-sheet.xls) as the resolution of comments from letter ballot #57
Moved: Clint Chaplin
Second: Sang-Kyu Lim
Motion Passes: unanimously consent
*Motion
Move to authorize Rick Roberts, Sang-Kyu Lim, and Sridhar Rajagopal asthe 802.15.7 Comment Resolution Oversight Committee chaired by Eun TaeWon; said committee to expire at the beginning of the November 2010802 Plenary meeting. The Comment Resolution Oversight Committee isauthorized to approve the resolutions and approve start of the nextrecirculation of the 15.7 draft on behalf of the Working Group.Comment resolution on Recirculations 1(current) and 2 (next) will beconducted via reflector email and via teleconferences announced to thereflector at least 7 days in advance.
Moved: Joachim Walewski
Second: Clint Chaplin
Motion Passes:unanimously consent
Adjourn by Chair Eun Tae Won.
TG-VLC Submission Page 1 Taehan Bae