Result of Voting on DTR - Document 65B/478/DTR

Project: IEC 61131-8 TR Ed.2
IEC 61131-8 TR Ed. 2: Programmable controllers - Part 8: Guidelines for the application and implementation of programming languages
Circulation Date: 2003-01-31Closing Date: 2003-04-04

Country / Status / Received / Vote / Comments
Belgium / P / 2003-03-10 / Y / -
Canada / P / 2003-03-06 / Y / -
China / P / 2003-03-25 / Y / -
Denmark / P / 2003-04-02 / Y / -
Finland / P / 2003-03-27 / Y / Y
France / P / 2003-03-27 / Y / -
Germany / P / 2003-04-04 / Y / -
Italy / P / 2003-04-04 / Y / -
Japan / P / 2003-03-28 / Y / Y
Korea (Rep. of) / P / 2003-04-03 / Y / -
Mexico / P / 2003-04-04 / A / -
Netherlands / P / 2003-04-01 / Y / -
Poland / P / 2003-03-13 / Y / -
Portugal / O / 2003-04-04 / A / -
Russian Fed. / P / 2003-04-04 / Y / -
Spain / P / 2003-04-04 / Y / -
Sweden / P / 2003-04-02 / Y / -
Switzerland / P / 2003-04-03 / Y / -
U.S.A. / P / 2003-04-02 / Y / -
Ukraine / P / 2003-04-01 / Y / -
United Kingdom / P / 2003-04-01 / Y / -
Approval Criteria / Result
P-members voting: 19
P-members in favour: 19 = 100 % / > 50% / APPROVED
Final Decision: / APPROVED

NOTES

1. Vote: Does the National Committee agree to the circulation of the draft as a TR:
Y = In favour; N = Against; A = Abstention.

2. Only votes received before the closing date are counted in determining the decision.
Late Votes: (0).

3. Abstentions are not taken into account when totalizing the votes.

4. P-members not voting: Austria; Hungary; Romania; Turkey; (4).

Annex

Date / Document
2003.03.26 / 65B/478/DTR
National Committee / Clause/ Subclause / Paragraph Figure/ Table / Type of comment (General/ Technical/Editorial) / COMMENTS / Proposed change / OBSERVATIONS OF THE SECRETARIAT
on each comment submitted
FI / We propose that before publishing IEC 61131-8 should be added with similar annex than in IEC 61499-3: Relationships to other standards
The relation with IEC 60848, IEC 61131-3, IEC 61499 and IEC 61804 should be explained.
JP / 3.3 / General / Examples of Type conversion functions are required because “Type conversion function features” of IEC 61131-3 2.5.1.5.1 are complicated.