Peer Review Worksheet

Your name______

Peer Review partner’s name______

URL of peer review partner’s website______

Peer Review partner’s email address______

Home page ('index.html')

Paste the text here:

1. Does it include a thesis statement claiming that the chosen multimedia document or text X is (or is not) a well designed example of its Y genre?

2. Does it adequately explain and summarize the X?

3. Does it explain the Y genre adequately enough, perhaps with examples other than the X, that you are convinced that the Y genre exists and has more multimedia documents or texts in it than just the X? Does the genre seem too broad for the X?

4. Given the way the X and Y are explained, do they seem like a good fit? Can you think of a more appropriate Y for that X?

5. Are the criteria comprehensible without reading the criteria pages? Do they seem like reasonable criteria for judging the design of multimedia documents or texts in the Y genre? Are they too general? In other words, does it seem that the criteria would also apply to multimedia documents or texts in other genres? Are they too specific? In other words, do the criteria seem to be derived from that particular X without consideration of other multimedia documents or texts in that genre?

6. Is the image well chosen as an introduction to the X?

Criteria Page One:

Paste the text here:

1. Does it clearly describe the criterion?

2. Does it justify why the criterion is vital for evaluating the design of Y?

3. Does it include an example of how the X satisfies or fails to satisfy the criterion?

4. Does it cite a source supporting the choice of criterion with regard to the Y genre or discussing the criterion in relation to the X?

5. Is the image appropriate for the criterion or help explain why the X meets or fails to meet that criterion?

Criteria Page Two:

Paste the text here:

1. Does it clearly describe the criterion?

2. Does it justify why the criterion is vital for evaluating the design of Y?

3. Does it include an example of how the X satisfies or fails to satisfy the criterion?

4. Does it cite a source supporting the choice of criterion with regard to the Y genre or discussing the criterion in relation to the X?

5. Is the image appropriate for the criterion or help explain why the X meets or fails to meet that criterion?

Criteria Page Three:

Paste the text here:

1. Does it clearly describe the criterion?

2. Does it justify why the criterion is vital for evaluating the design of Y?

3. Does it include an example of how the X satisfies or fails to satisfy the criterion?

4. Does it cite a source supporting the choice of criterion with regard to the Y genre or discussing the criterion in relation to the X?

5. Is the image appropriate for the criterion or help explain why the X meets or fails to meet that criterion?

Works Cited Page

Paste the text here:

1. Do the sources seem appropriate? Is the X documented? Are there at least three sources other than the X? Are the sources of the images listed?

Website Specifications

List any specifications that still need to be addressed, fixed, etc.