Oral Language for Learning

Teacher Ready Gibbons

ORAL LANGUAGE FOR LEARNING

We have all seen children move through the stages of acquiring their first language- from babbling to one- word utterances, two- word phrases, full sentences, and eventually, complex grammar. Students learning a second language also move through stages. One of the most important things you should know about each of your EAL/D students is which stage of acquisition they are in. Knowing and understanding the stages and their characteristics are critical for effectively differentiating instruction for these students.

Model: Stages of Language Acquisition

The following model lists the six stages of language acquisition, along with the characteristics and teacher prompts.

When you are familiar with the stages of second language acquisition, you will be more attuned to the appropriate types of questions and prompts to use to engage and motivate students. By understanding your students’ levels of linguistic proficiency, you will become more competent at differentiating instruction to promote linguistic and academic achievement. Your students will be able to participate and feel more confident as they successfully respond.

Explanation: Stages of Language Acquisition

The following explanation lists the five stages of language acquisition, along with the characteristics and teacher prompts.

Stage / Characteristic / Prompt
Preproduction
This is sometimes called the ‘silent phase’, when the student takes in the new language, but does not speak it. This period often lasts six weeks or longer, depending on the individual. / ·  Minimal comprehension
·  Does not verbalise
·  Nods ‘yes’ and ‘no’
·  Draws and points / ·  Show me…
·  Circle the…
·  Where is….?
·  Who has…?
Early Production
The individual begins to speak using short words and sentences are longer, but the emphasis is still on listening and absorbing the new language. There will be many errors in the early production phase. / ·  Limited comprehension
·  One or two word responses
·  Participates using keywords and familiar phrases / ·  Yes/ no questions
·  Either/ or questions
·  Lists or labels
·  One or two word answers
Speech Emergent
Speech becomes more frequent, words and sentences are longer, but the individual still relies heavily on context clues and familiar topics. Vocabulary continues to increase and errors begin to decrease, especially in common or repeated interactions. / ·  Has comprehension
·  Can produce simple sentences
·  Makes grammar and pronunciation errors / ·  Why?
·  How?
·  Explain…
·  Phrase or short sentence answers
Beginning Fluency
Speech is fairly fluent in social situations with minimal errors. New contexts and academic language are challenging and the individual will struggle to express themselves due to gaps in vocabulary and appropriate phases. / ·  Has good comprehension
·  Can produce sentences
·  Makes grammar and pronunciation errors / ·  Short sentence answers
·  What?
·  How?
·  Why do you think?
Intermediate Fluency
Communicating in the second language is fluent, especially in social language situations. The individual will be able to speak almost fluently in new situations or in academic areas, but there will be gaps in vocabulary knowledge and some unknown expressions. There are very few errors, and the individual is able to demonstrate higher order thinking skills in the second language such as offering an opinion or analysing a problem. / ·  Has excellent comprehension
·  Makes few grammatical errors / ·  What would happen if…?
·  Why do you think…?
Advanced Fluency
The individual communicates fluently in all contexts and can manoeuvre successfully in new contexts and when exposed to new academic information. As this stage, the individual may still have an accent and use idiomatic expressions incorrectly at time, but the individual is essentially fluent and comfortable communicating in the second language. / ·  Near first-language level of speech / ·  Decide if…
·  Retell…

Developing Spoken Language

Research into language development, including studies in both first and second language acquisition, support the notion of language use as a major principle for language development. Being immersed in language and having access to good language models is of course important, but it is not in itself sufficient to develop language competence. Children who spend a large part of their waking hours in front of the television, for example, may be receiving- depending on the quality of the program- good models of language, but this exposure will not be enough to develop their language. Children also need to use language in interaction with other children and adults. Essential to any learning program for EAL/ D learners is effective instruction in language development. Children need explicit instruction in English vocabulary, as well as opportunities to hear and speak the language throughout the day.

Arrange the classroom in a way that supports each type of instructional activity that will take place, and then keep changes to the physical environment to a minimum. Once EAL/D learners learn which activities take place in various parts of the classroom (e.g., centers, circle), the physical environment will cue them as to what they are to do and how they are to behave in that area. Predictable classroom routines can also provide scaffolding for EAL/D learners by allowing them to anticipate what will happen each day, including the type of language they will need for each activity

What is scaffolding?

Scaffolding – in its more usual sense- is a temporary structure that is often put up in the process of constructing a building. As each bit of the new building is finished, the scaffolding is taken down. In the classroom it portrays the temporary, but essential, nature of the mentor’s assistance in supporting learners to carry out tasks successfully. Scaffolding, however, is not simply another word for ‘help’. It is a special kind of help that assists learners to move toward new skills, concepts, or levels of understanding. Scaffolding is thus the temporary assistance by which a teacher helps a learner know how to do something, so that the learner will later be able to complete a similar task alone. In is future- oriented. As Vygotsky has said, what a child can do with support today, she or he can do alone tomorrow.

Key characteristics of a scaffolded program:

Gibbons outlines the following key characteristics of a scaffolded program-

·  Integration of language with ‘content’

·  Planned opportunities for development of ‘literate spoken language’ development as a bridge to reading and writing

·  Use of scaffolding- gradual release of responsibility

·  Planned use of the first language (Mother Tongue)

·  Message abundance

Meanwhile, Wood, Bruner and Ross (1976) identify six features of effective scaffolding. These were:

·  Creating children’s interest in the task

·  Simplifying the task, for example, breaking it into stages

·  Keeping children on track by reminding them of the goal

·  Pointing out key things to do and/ or showing the child other ways of doing parts of the task

·  Controlling the child’s frustration during the task

·  Demonstrating an idealised way of doing the task

The Role of Talk in Learning

Student- student and student- teacher talk can provide rich contexts for second language development. But just allowing talk to occur is not enough. Productive talk does not just happen – it needs to be deliberately and systematically planned, just as we plan for literacy events. How tasks are designed, how group work is set up, and how teachers respond to students all impact on how effective classroom talk is in supporting language development. Sometimes, even quite small changes in how opportunities for talk are set up can have significant effects on how the discourse is played out. It is not an exaggeration to suggest that classroom talk determines whether or not children learn, and their ultimate feelings of self- worth as students.

It is through talk that much learning occurs. Talk allows children to think aloud, to formulate ideas, to set up and evaluate hypotheses and to reach tentative decisions in a context that is not restricted by the more formal demands of written language.

Integrating Language and Content

Language objectives should be planned for, in teaching teams (bilingually if possible) for explicit language objectives at function level (e.g.-generalising) down to word level. In content areas, what language will students need to access this content and do the activities?

Talk can be just as demanding for Language One learners as it is for EAL/D learners, as language/experiences far removed from the context means the speaker has to re-create the scene for the listener and that requires complex language.

Gibbons gives the example of: ‘Tell others’, which is a strategy where learners have three opportunities to tell/ share with others about the learning experience they undertook (for example:- a science experiment or an excursion). Gibbons suggests that three opportunities are provided because each time, the speaker is micro-scaffolded to the literate language. Once the ‘literate language’ is used, the learner can now write!

Often you will do micro-scaffolding intuitively, but this must be planned for and ‘scripted’ so that any teacher utterances (for example: questioning) are open-ended, allowing for learners to do the extended talk and the teacher to listen and wait patiently (which may be for long periods of time, allowing for translation to occur).

Ideas for Language in the Classroom

English language learners need lots of opportunities to engage in social interactions with other children, but they also need support from adults as they develop the language skills they need to negotiate those interactions. You can use the following strategies to foster social interaction:

·  For group activities, pair EAL/D learners with children who have stronger English language skills.

·  Provide opportunities for self-directed activities so that EAL/ D learner can choose activities that match both their interests and their language abilities.

·  Encourage ‘child talk’ by providing prompts when children need help in expressing themselves (e.g., "Tell Shakira, 'May I have the red crayon now?'").

·  Use open questions, or questions that can have multiple answers, to help EAL/ D learners to expand their own utterances (e.g., "Why do you like this doll best?" instead of "What is this doll's name?").

Here are some more examples that you might like to use in order to set up oral language situations (possibly for older children):

Possible Idea
Giving an opinion or personal response:
·  Responding to a book
·  Responding to a news event
·  Offering a personal opinion about a current event
·  Evaluating events/ behaviour/ characters in a book
Narrating:
·  Recounting a personal experience
·  Retelling a narrative
·  Telling a joke
Describing people and things:
·  Barrier games
·  Maths activities involving position
·  Describing a person to someone else
·  Describing known people
·  Describing a picture or a setting in a story
·  Describing what something looks like
Giving instructions:
·  Telling someone how to make something
·  Telling someone how to play a game
·  Explaining how something works
·  Describing a natural process
·  Describing how something is made
·  Describing how something is done
Giving an explanation:
·  Explaining why something occurs
·  Discussing and explaining reasons
·  Explaining why a particular solution to a problem has been chosen
Presenting and supporting an argument:
·  Small group discussions relating to current issues
·  Formal debates
·  ‘simulation’ computer games which involve group decision making
Hypothesising :
·  Hands- on science experiments and problem solving situations
·  Maths and computer activities which involve problem solving
·  Discussions and games which require projection into the unknown

Here are some examples, using the model stages:

Stage and Ideas
Preproduction:
Students can point to a picture in the book as the teacher says or asks: ‘show me the wolf. Where is the house?’
Early Production:
Students do well with yes/ no questions and one or two word answers: ‘did the brick house fall down? Who blew down the straw house?’
Speech Emergence:
Students can answer ‘why’ and ‘how’ questions with phrases or short- sentence answers, and can also explain their answers: ‘explain why the third pig built his house out of bricks.’
Intermediate Fluency:
Students can answer ‘what would happen if’ and ‘why do you think’ questions: ‘why do you think the pigs were able to outsmart the wolf?’
Advanced Fluency:
Students can retell the story, including the main plot elements leaving out the insignificant details.

See checklist of communicative activities- part 11.

Message Abundance

Students prosper best in an environment of message abundance. That is, as many channels of communication as possible are used to support a variety of learning styles and to give the students plenty of time to practice and hear these messages. It is important to note that these messages should be amplified and not simplified. That is, you should give the messages several times in different forms.

Role of the Mother Tongue

As part of the process of scaffolding, teachers need to make a link between the familiar and the new, and in the case of foreign language learning, a link between the language, which is the shared, ‘text book’ like communication among the children, and the language that is to be learnt. This process of scaffolding from the children’s first or second language (depending on the composition of the class) to a foreign language in a formal classroom context is one which may also promote independent language use. It is, however, also recognised that the strategy of scaffolding from the first or second language to the foreign language is not one that will necessarily be available to every teacher since it does depend on the teacher also understanding the children’s language.

Obviously, support in the first language (L1) makes a huge difference to learning. Research shows that learning literacy skills in first language really sets students up for learning in second language (L2). Gibbons outlines one bilingual model (of which there are many):