AGENDA ITEM 9
BOROUGH OF POOLE
PLANNING COMMITTEE – AUGUST 2008
REPORT OF HEAD OF PLANNING DESIGN AND CONTROL SERVICES
APPEAL DECISIONS RECEIVED - FOR INFORMATION ONLY
1.Matters for Consideration
To report on appeal decisions received from the Secretary of State for the Department of Communities and Local Government.
- Details of Applications
NO. / SITE ADDRESS / DESCRIPTION / APPEAL DECISION / DATE / APPEAL OFFICER
1 / 77 Harbour Close / T1 Cedar - fell. TPO ref: 41 ind 1999 / Dismissed / 13/02/08 / Gwydion Howells
2 / 59-61 Panorama road / T20 Maritime pine - fell. TPO ref: 58 ind 1999 / Dismissed / 15/02/08 / Gwydion Howells
3 / Broadstone United Reformed Church / T1 Lawson Cypress - crown clean, crown lift over drive, remove subsiding branch. T2, T3, T4, T6, T7 Western Red Cedar - fell. T5 Beech - crown reduce by 2m and shape. TPO ref: 9 area 1955 / Dismissed / 14/02/08 / Steve Chamberlain
4 / 8 Tower Road / T1 Pine - fell. TPO ref: 51 Ind 1998 ***THE AVENUE CONSERVATION AREA*** / Dismissed / 20/02/08 / Steve Chamberlain
5 / 65 Blackbird close / T1 Red Oak. Fell. TPO Ref 112 Group 2001. / Dismissed / 27/02/08 / Steve Chamberlain
6 / 2 Western Avenue / T14 Cypress: fell. ***BRANKSOME PARK CONSERVATION AREA*** / Dismissed / 27/02/08 / Steve Chamberlain
7 / 22 Erpingham Road / T1 - T2 Western Red Cedar - Crown reduce by 3-4m / Dismissed / 06/05/08 / Russ Fisher
8 / 21 Forest Road / T1, T2 - Sycamore - Fell, T3 - Sweet Chestnut - Fell / Split / 14/05/08 / Gwydion Howell
NO. / SITE ADDRESS / DESCRIPTION / APPEAL DECISION / DATE / APPEAL OFFICER
9 / 3 Elmstead Road / Sever land and erect two storey detached dwelling with integral garage as amended by plan received 14/12/07. / Dismissed / 03/07/08 / Eleanor Godesar
10 / 3 Elmstead Road / Demolish existing dwelling and erect two new detached two storey dwellings with access and parking. / Dismissed / 03/07/08 / Eleanor Godesar
11 / 1B Mount Grace Drive / T2 (Oak) Fell. TPO Ref: 5 Area 1989 / Dismissed / 02/07/08 / Gwydion Howell
12 / 325 Sandbanks Road / Demolish existing and erect a block of 7 flats with associated parking, cycle and bin store. Accessed from Lilliput Road. / Dismissed / 04/07/08 / Darryl Howell
13 / 36 Seliot Close / T1 Oak: reduce by 3 metres the long lateral branch reaching toward building. Crown thin by 20%. Crown clean. TPO 94 area 1977. / Approved / 04/07/08 / Gwydion Howell
14 / 37 Nelson Road / T1 Scots Pine: remove two large limbs overhanging boundary. T2 Sycamore: remove overhanging branches to stem/to clear boundary. T3 Sycamore: remove limbs overhanging neighbouring property. T4 Sycamore: pollard/50% reduction. T5 Sycamore: remove lowest limb. T6 Beech: reduce crown by 30-50%. TPO 28 area 1965. / Approved / 17/07/08 / Steve Chamberlain
15 / 6 Flaghead Road / T1 Holm Oak: remove 3 branches. Trees at rear of property: T1 - T4 Cypress: fell. T5 Holly: reshape. Trees at front of property: T4 Holm Oak: fell. T5 Cherry: fell. T6 Holly: reshape. T7 Leyland Cypress: fell. Tree numbering as per applicant's description. TPO 35 Area 1966. / Dismissed / 17/07/08 / Russ Fisher
NO. / SITE ADDRESS / DESCRIPTION / APPEAL DECISION / DATE / APPEAL OFFICER
16 / 3 Ravine Road, Canford Cliffs / Demolish existing dwelling and erect 3 storey block of 3 flats with parking to front (Revised Scheme) (As amended by plans received 22/08/07) / Allowed / 17/07/08 / Eleanor Godesar
17 / 89 Laurel Gardens, Broadstone, Dorset, BH18 8LT / Erect porch. Erect single storey extension to side/rear. / Split / 9/07/08 / Laura Archer
18 / 3 Durrant Road, Poole, Dorset, BH14 8TP / Form new roof with raised and extended ridge line, with dormer on front elevation to provide first floor accommodation (as amended plans received 27th September 2007). / Allowed / 9/07/08 / Rebecca Landman
19 / Eagle International School, Wayne Road, Poole, Dorset, / Erect a pair of houses with covered parking at ground floor level with access from Cranbrook Road. / Dismissed / 14/07/08 / Kevin Chilvers
20 / 55A Elms Avenue Poole BH14 8EE / Retrospective application to carry out excavations to garden and form retaining walls. / Dismissed / 15/07/08 / James Gilfillan
21 / Wessex Gate Retail Park, Broadstone Way, Poole, Dorset, BH15 3TE / Erect new restaurant with drive-through accessed from Broadstone Way. / Dismissed / 17/07/08 / David Mansell
22 / 147 Banks Road, Poole, Dorset, BH13 7QJ / Erect three storey detached dwelling with integral garage. Access from Panorama Road. (Amended plans received 23/08/07). / Dismissed / 24/07/08 / Clare Dick
23 / 21 Dorset Lake Avenue, Poole, Dorset, BH14 8JD / T4 Pine: remove branch overhanging balcony of penthouse. TPO 5 area 1989. / Dismissed / 24/07/2008 / Gwydion Howell
24 / 14 Inverclyde Road Poole BH14 8PB / T1 – T2 Pine: fell. T3 Pine: remove large, lower branch. T4 Pine: remove bottom two branches. TPO 7 area 1991. / Dismissed / 05/08/2008 / Gwydion Howell
25 / 10 Water Tower Road Broadstone BH18 8LL / T1 Beech: remove 3 lowest branches overhanging shed roof. TPO 11 Wood 1959 / Dismissed / 24/07/08 / Gwydion Howell
NO. / SITE ADDRESS / DESCRIPTION / APPEAL DECISION / DATE / APPEAL OFFICER
26 / 2A Branksea Avenue, Poole, Dorset, BH15 4DW / T1 Holm Oak: fell. T3 Hom Oak: fell. T2 Monterey Pine: remove three lowest overhanging branches interfering with crown of retained Oak. TPO 95 area 1977. / Split / 04/07/08 / Gwydion Howell
27 / 172 Blandford Road Poole BH15 4BH / Erect free standing internally illuminated advert display unit. / Dismissed / 07/08/08 / Mark Fewster
28 / 587 Blandford Road Poole BH16 5EB / Erect free-standing internally illumniated advert display case. / Dismissed / 07/08/08 / Mark Fewster
29 / Compton Acres Canford Cliffs Road Poole BH13 7ES / Fell 19 trees and remove specific branches from 8 others. COMPTON ACRES CONSERVATION AREA TPO 17 AREA 1962 / Dismissed / 08/08/08 / Gwydion Howell
PETER WATSONHEAD OF PLANNING DESIGN AND CONTROL SERVICES
1