Minutes of the 134th meeting of the Committee Constituted for Deciding the Consent under Orange Category, held on 25.01.2010 in the Conference Room of Chairman, DPCC.

The following persons attended the meeting:

Sh. Dharmendra, Chairman, DPCC

Dr. A.K.Ambasht, Member Secretary, DPCC

Prof. S. K. Gupta, IIT-Delhi.

Sh. M. Dwarakanth, SSO, Dept. of Env,. GNCTD

Sh. B. Kumar, SEE, DPCC

EEs of CMC – I, II, III & IV.

AEEs of CMC – I, II, III & IV.

Following decisions were taken in the said meeting:-

Agenda Item No. 1- Review of ATR of decisions taken w.r.t. Consent to Establish cases (w.e.f. 01.09.2009) considered in the CMC meeting dated 05.10.2009 which are still to be disposed of : reviewed by Scrutinizing Committee on 07.01.2010 / 08.01.2010.

The CMC officials during the meeting confirmed that in all the cases under this category, wherever the grant of consent to establish was decided in CMC meeting dated 05.10.2009, the consents have been issued.

Decisions taken with respect to this agenda are tabulated and annexed as Annexure – 1.

Agenda Item No. 2- Review of ATR of decisions taken w.r.t. Consent to Operate / Renewal cases (w.e.f. 01.09.2009) considered in the CMC meeting dated 07.10.2009 which are still to be disposed of : reviewed by Scrutinizing Committee on 07.01.2010 / 08.01.2010.

The CMC officials during the meeting confirmed that in all the cases under this category, wherever the grant of consent to operate / renewal was decided in CMC meeting dated 07.10.2009, the consents have been issued.

Decisions taken with respect to this agenda are tabulated and annexed as Annexure – 2.

Agenda Item No. 3- Fresh Consent to Establish cases w.e.f. 01.12.2009.

Decisions taken with respect to this agenda are tabulated and annexed as Annexure – 3.

Agenda Item No. 4- Fresh Consent to Operate / Renewal cases w.e.f. 01.12.2009.

Decisions taken with respect to this agenda are tabulated and annexed as Annexure – 4.

It has been observed by the Committee that certain units are applying for consents during the pendency of their earlier application which could not come up in the chronology being considered w.e.f. 12.08.2009. It was decided that such applications in the new chronology are to be entertained only if the period of three years from the date of applications of these units is going to expire within four months from the date of new application being made. The copy of these minutes be also be forwarded to Enquiry Counter with the instructions not to accept the new application from the unit if they are not fulfilling the aforesaid criteria. The cases considered in today meeting, if not covered in the aforesaid criteria should be linked to their old files figuring in the old chronology. All CMC officials may check carefully while implementing the decision taken in today’s meeting.

Meeting ended with thanks to the chair.

Sl. No / ID No / appl_dt / firm_name / firm_address / area_name / Proposed Activity/ Product / Earlier CMC Decisions / ATR / Remarks / Recommendations of Scrutinizing Committee on 29.09.2009 & 30.09.2009 / Decision on 05.10.2009 / ATR / Remarks / Recommendations of Scrutinizing Committee on 07.01.2010 / 08.01.2010 / Decision on 25.01.2010
1 / 31282 / 01-09-2009 / SHAKTI METALS / D-174, PHASE-II / MAYAPURI INDUSTRIAL AREA / Mfg. of metal scraps and ingots / GW : NIL
DG Set :NIL
Applied afresh. Unit proposed to install pit furnace for mfg. of ingots. / Recommended for grant of Consent to Establish. / Inspection be conducted before decision on consent application. / Inspection conducted. Case was considered in CMC dated 21.12.09 and it was decided to Issue consent to operate and consent to establish. / Implement the earlier CMC's decision dated 21.12.2009. / Issue Consent to Operate and consent to estabish in pursuance of CMC decision dated 21.12.2009
2 / 31304 / 02-09-2009 / RIVERIA COMMERCIAL DEVELOPERS LIMITED / YASHWANT PLACE COMMUNITY CENTRE, CHANAKYAPURI / NC-ND / commercial complex-cum multiplex / newly proposed case
Ground water reported as Nil. / Ask the unit to submit environmental clearance. / Case be considered after implementation of decision of Scrutinizing Committee. / Letter issued.
No reply received. / Put up in next meeting. / Issue final reminder.
3 / 31305 / 02-09-2009 / RAJINDER MOTOR WORKSHOP / 46, ZAMRUDPUR AUTO COMPLEX, NEAR N BLOCK, GREATER KAILASH-I / NC-S / workshop for servicing & repairing of automobile without washing / Unit is operating since 1986 as per CTE application. Applied for consent to establish now
Ground water reported as Nil. / Details of this unit is not available. Further it involves the conformity issue. File is required to be submitted administratively. / Call the details from the unit to substantiate the proof of conformity, / Letter issued on 28.10.09
Reply received on 23.11.09, they have submitted the DDA prespective plan, licence review receipt and trade license issued by MCD. / Inspection be conducted. / Inspection be cnducted to know the washing activity and conformity.
4 / 31313 / 02-09-2009 / SUNBEAM ELECTRICAL INDUSTRIES (REGD) / B-68/4 / WAZIRPUR INDUSTRIAL AREA / Mfg of PVC compound, PVC filters & non-adhesive tapes / Ground Water-300l/day / Recommended for grant of Consent to Establish. Subsequently, inspection be conducted. / Issue Consent to Establish. Subsequently, inspection be conducted. / CTE issued. Also inspection report to be discussed. / Inspection be expedited. / Issue SCN u/s 31 (A) for closure in view of the findings of the inspection.
5 / 31321 / 02-09-2009 / INTIMATE SERVICE STATION / PANCH SHILA PARK / NC-S / petrol pump cum service station / Ground Water : Nil in current file. In old file ground water shown 300 Lt/day.
CTO granted earlier valid upto 29.05.2006. CTE applied.
Applied for CTO (R) vide I.D. No. 19160 & 31294. / Recommended for grant of Consent to Establish. Subsequently, inspection be conducted. / Issue Consent to Establish. Subsequently, inspection be conducted. / Case has been considerd on CMC 21.12.09 as Special Ref.
Recommendation of scrutinizing Committee
Issue SCN u/s 33(A) of the Water Act.
Decision of 21.12.09
Issue closure direction. / Implement the earlier CMC's decision dated 21.12.2009 / Implement the earlier CMC's decision dated 21.12.2009
6 / 31323 / 03-09-2009 / CHINTAMANI COMMODITIES / A-20, / JHILMIL INDUSTRIAL AREA / Mfg of copper rods / Applied afresh. Copper scrap material is melted and alloyed in melting furnace at 1200 degree centigrade is transferred via laulder to holding furnace, after that passes through 8 stands fitted with different dies. The rod is converted into coils and is ready as final material. / Recommended for grant of Consent to Establish. / Issue Consent to Establish. / CTE issued.
However, CMC orange in its meeting held on 21.12.09/22.12.09 has decided that the cases of such type of activity to be reexamined by srcutinizing committee. / A Committee for 4 EEs CMC and Sh. Ramesh Chandra, AEE & Sh. N.K. Joshi, AEE may examined the matter expeditiously. / Final outcome be apprised to CMC.
7 / 31327 / 03-09-2009 / DEVYANI INTERNATIONAL LIMITED / 12, COMMUNITY CENTRE, SAKET / NC-S / restaurant / Unit is operating since 2003 as per CTE application. Applied for consent to establish now
Ground water reported as Nil. / Recommended for grant of Consent to Establish. Subsequently, inspection be conducted. / Issue Consent to Establish. Subsequently, inspection be conducted. / CTE issued. Also inspection conducted / Inspection report is to be considered with consent to operate. / Ask the unit to provide proper channelization system through CTO file.
8 / 31332 / 04-09-2009 / VARDHMAN INDUSTRIES / J-32 / UDYOG NAGAR INDUSTRIAL AREA / Mfg. of all kinds of footwears including leather footwear without tanning / G.W:-NIL
D.G Set of 125 KVA (proposed)
However, earlier application for renewal of consent was refused on 10.11.06 vide refusal no. 1501 / Inspection be conducted. / Case be considered after implementation of decision of Scrutinizing Committee. / Inspection report to be discussed. / Recommended for grant of Consent to Establish. / Issue consent to establish.
9 / 31350 / 04-09-2009 / SUCAM ENTERPRISES / 1/536, D-7, GALI NO 5 / FRIENDS COLONY INDUSTRIAL AREA / Mfg of plastic moulded products & PVC wires / 17.06.09
Ask the unit to file full compliance by 30.06.2009. Issue letter without waiting for minutes. Call on 19.08.2009 / letter issued on 15.07.09 reply received and mentioned that channelisation with exhaust fan has been provided. Applied for CTE using fresh raw material
GW-Nil / Recommended for grant of Consent to Establish. Subsequently, inspection be conducted. / Issue Consent to Establish. Subsequently, inspection be conducted. / CTE issued on 07.10.2009.
Inspeection done and inspection report to be discussed. / Inspection report is to be considered with consent to operate. / Ask the unit to provide proper channelization system through CTO file.
10 / 31361 / 07-09-2009 / CAVANDISH INC / D-4 / UDYOG NAGAR INDUSTRIAL AREA / Banquet Hall / G.W:-NIL
D.G Set of 160 KVA
Applied afresh. / CMC has confirmed that it is already operating. Inspection be conducted w.r.t. date of operation and other pollution control measures. / Case be considered after implementation of decision of Scrutinizing Committee. / Inspection conducted. Case was considered in CMC dated 21.12.09 w.r.t CTO application and it was decided to Ask the unit to submit valid health licence from MCD & eating house licence from Delhi Police. / Recommended for grant of Consent to Establish and further unit may be asked to submit valid health licence from MCD & eating house licence from Delhi Police to decide application for consent to operate. / Issue Consent to Establish and ask the unit to submit valid health licence from MCD & eating house licence from Delhi Police.
11 / 31425 / 14-09-2009 / MGS HOSPITALITY PLOOF RESTAURANT / 13, MAIN MARKET, LODHI ROAD / NC-ND / Eating House / Seating Capacity-72, Appliied for CTO on 17/7/06 & 17/9/09, GW-Nil, DG-Nil, Hood & Suction and Oil & Grease trap installed as per information submitted / Recommended for grant of Consent to Establish. Subsequently, inspection be conducted to know the present status. / Issue Consent to Establish. Subsequently, inspection be conducted to know the present status. / CTE issued. Also inspection report to be discussed. / Inspection report is to be considered with consent to operate. / Decision taken w.r.t Consent to Operae listed in the other agenda of this meeting.
12 / 31437 / 14-09-2009 / S.M.S. EXPORTS / W-7, PHASE-II / OKHLA INDUSTRIAL AREA / mgf of garment with washing if required / Transferred from Green due to washing activity found during inspection., ETP not installed yet. GW-nil, DG-nil ,opearting since-2004 as per information given in application / Issue SCN for refusal of consent and SCN u/s 33(A) of Water Act as no ETP installed / Case be considered after implementation of decision of Scrutinizing Committee. / SCN issued.
Reply received on 17.11.09 stating that
i)by mistake information regarding ETP plant, generator and boiler was omitted.
ii)And they have submitted an adequacy report on 12.10.09 and they have applied for NMR and report of boiler.
iii)water for washing is purchased from outside from tankers, borewell is not used.
File was submitted administratively and it was desired to submit whether any environmental damages can be leived. / Ask the unit to submit Bank Guarantee of Rs. 1 Lakh each under Air Act, Water Act & HWM Rules valid for one year, failing which, court case will be filed. / Case be considered after implementation of decision of Scrutinizing Committee.
13 / 31447 / 15-09-2009 / SYNERGY NATURAL CARES / J-6 / UDYOG NAGAR INDUSTRIAL AREA / Mfg. of plastic additive compounding system (additive compound in powder, beads & granules) / Applied a fresh. / Inspection be conducted to ascertain the mfg. of plasticisers. / Case be considered after implementation of decision of Scrutinizing Committee. / Inspection report to be discussed. / Recommended for grant of Consent to Establish without plasticizer.
Issue SCN u/s 21/22 of the Air Act and u/s 25/26 of the Water Act to another unit namely M/s Organo Vinyl Pvt. Ltd. / Issue Consent to Establish without plasticizer.
Issue SCN u/s 21/22 of the Air Act and u/s 25/26 of the Water Act to another unit namely M/s Organo Vinyl Pvt. Ltd.
14 / 31465 / 16-09-2009 / HYUNDAI MOTOR INDIA LTD. / A-29, / MOHAN CO-OPERATIVE INDUSTRIAL AREA / Servicing with washing of cars / Fresh Case, DG-62.5(Proposed), GW-nil as per information given in application / Recommended for grant of Consent to Establish. / Issue Consent to Establish. Subsequently, inspection be conducted. / CTE issued. Also inspection report to be discussed.
Case has been considerd on CMC 21.12.09 as Special Ref.
Recommendation of scrutinizing Committee
Issue SCN u/s 33(A) of the Water Act.
Decision of 21.12.09
Issue closure direction. / Implement the earlier CMC's decision dated 21.12.2009 / Implement the earlier CMC's decision dated 21.12.2009
15 / 31487 / 18-09-2009 / ASHOK TOURIST SERVICE STATION (A UNIT OF ITDC LTD.) / NITI MARG, CHANAKYA PURI / NC-ND / Repairing & servicing of automobiles. / Fresh application. ITDC proposed to establish service station on the back portion of the IOC Petrol pump at Niti Marg.On the project report they mentioned that after getting NOC /CTE from SPCB, they may give it on outsourcing with or without installing the machinery/ equipments.Sanctioned plan, valid dealership agreement, documents regarding transfer of land to ITDC are not furnished. / Issue letter seeking the deficient information/documents and Enquiry Counter may be asked to clarify for accepting the incomplete application. / Case be considered after implementation of decision of Scrutinizing Committee. / Letter issued.