Minutes of the 79th meeting of the Committee Constituted for Deciding the Consent under Orange Category, held on 30.09.2008 in the Conference Room of Chairman, DPCC.
The following persons attended the meeting:
1. Sh. J. K Dadoo, Chairman DPCC
2. Sh. Anil Kumar, Member Secretary, DPCC
3. Sh. S.K.Gupta, Head Chemical Engineering Deptt. ,IIT Delhi
4. Sh. B. Kumar, SEE, DPCC
5. Sh. M. Dwarakanth, SSO, Dept. of Env,. GNCTD.
6. EEs of CMC – I, II & III.
7. EE & AEE of PGRC.
8. AEEs and JEE of CMC – I, II & III.
Following decisions were taken in the said meeting:-
Agenda Item No.1- Personal hearings of (i) Vishal Retail Ltd., A-18, B Block, Mihan Co-Operative Society, Mathura Road, New Delhi (ii) Mc-Donold Restaurant, West Punjabi Bagh (iii) TSL Mall /Shopping Mall, Sec-04 Dwarka, New Delhi (iv) TSL Mall /Shopping Mall, Sec-06 Dwarka, New Delhi (v) Bhandari Farm, Kh. No 772, 773, 774, Near Nanda Hospital, Chattarpur, Delhi -74 (vi) R G Complex, Plot no 2, Motia Khan, Paharganj, Delhi (vii) RG City Centre, Plot no 4, Motia Khan, Paharganj, New Delhi (viii) Today Homes and Infrastructure Ltd, Proposed Commercial Complex (North Gate obit plaza) at Gujarawala Town area of Model Town-II, New Delhi (ix) Parsvnath Developers Ltd in construction with M/s OCL Ltd Commercial Complex at Pratap Nagar Metro (x) North Square Mall , F-1,2,3 Netaji Subhash Place, Pitampura, Near T.V. Tower, New Delhi (xi) India Coloniser Pvt. Ltd (const. of Commercial Complex at M-6 Plaza NHCC Jasola)
(i) Vishal Retail Ltd., A-18, B Block, Mohan Co-Operative Society, Mathura Road, New Delhi
The unit did not come for personal hearing. Call for personal hearing on 20.10.2008 at 6.45 PM.
(ii) Mc-Donold Restaurant, West Punjabi Bagh
The unit came for personal hearing today. It argued that it has complied with some of the directions of DPCC and had installed the ETP. The unit was heard and was clearly indicated that in view of the complaint from the RWA and protective correspondence from the unit, it’s plea for leniency cannot be accepted and it has to comply with all the directions of DPCC so far. The unit was asked for its convenience to comply but it did not respond. The Committee, therefore, decided to give time upto 30.10.2008 to comply with all DPCC directions without fail. Call on 30.10.2008.
(iii) TSL Mall /Shopping Mall, Sec-04 Dwarka, New Delhi
The unit came for personal hearing today. The unit will submit Consent to Establish application with all the details on which basis it’s case will be considered on 30.10.2008. Call on 30.10.2008.
(iv) TSL Mall /Shopping Mall, Sec-06 Dwarka, New Delhi
The unit came for personal hearing today. The unit will submit Consent to Establish application with all the details on which basis it’s case will be considered on 30.10.2008. Call on 30.10.2008.
(v) Bhandari Farm, Kh. No 772, 773, 774, Near Nanda Hospital, Chattarpur, Delhi -74
SIT to inspect and report. Call on 30.10.2008.
(vi) R G Complex, Plot no 2, Motia Khan, Paharganj, Delhi
The unit did not come for personal hearing and sought time for 15 days. Call for personal hearing on 20.10.2008 at 5.00 PM without waiting for minutes.
(vii) RG City Centre, Plot no 4, Motia Khan, Paharganj, New Delhi
The unit did not come for personal hearing and sought time for 15 days. Call for personal hearing on 20.10.2008 at 5.15 PM without waiting for minutes.
(viii) Today Homes and Infrastructure Ltd, Proposed Commercial Complex (North Gate obit plaza) at Gujaarawala Town area of Model Town-II, New Delhi
The unit did not come for personal hearing and sought time for 15 days. Call for personal hearing on 20.10.2008 at 5.30 PM without waiting for minutes.
(ix) Parsvnath Developers Ltd in construction with M/s OCL Ltd Commercial Complex at Pratap Nagar Metro
The unit came for personal hearing today. The unit has completed the construction and but yet not started its operation. Unit has to pay damages as a cash penalty of 0.5 % of the project cost and 0.5 % of the project cost as Bank Guarantee valid upto three years by 30.10.2008. Call on 30.10.2008.
(x) North Square Mall , F-1,2,3 Netaji Subhash Place, Pitampura, Near T.V. Tower, New Delhi
The unit did not come for personal hearing. Call for personal hearing on 20.10.2008 at 6.15 PM.
(xi) India Coloniser Pvt. Ltd (const. of Commercial Complex at M-6 Plaza NHCC Jasola)
Unit has not come for personal hearing and asked time for personal hearing after 1st October, 2008. Call for personal hearing on 20.10.2008 at 6.30 PM.
Agenda Item No.2- Withdrawal of the complaint filed, against Royal Automobile under Maily Yamuna case.
Decisions taken with respect to this agenda are tabulated and annexed as Annexure – 1.
Agenda Item No.3- PGRC cases.
Decisions taken with respect to this agenda are tabulated and annexed as Annexure – 2.
Agenda Item No.4- Special reference cases.
Decisions taken with respect to this agenda are tabulated and annexed as Annexure – 3.
Agenda Item No.5- Shopping Mall cases
Decisions w.r.t. 13 cases (Sl. No 1 to 12 & 14) out of 35 taken with respect to this agenda item are tabulated and annexed as Annexure –4. Due to paucity of time, remaining cases of this agenda will be taken up in the next CMC meeting to be held on 07.10.2008.
Agenda Item No.6- Construction Projects cases
Decisions taken with respect to this agenda are tabulated and annexed as Annexure – 5.
Agenda Item No.7- Implementation of Plastic Act / Rules – Hon’ble High Court order reg.
This agenda could not be taken up by the Committee, due to paucity of time, and decided to take up the same in the CMC meeting to be held on 07.10.2008.
Agenda Item No.8- Representation of APIA Association regarding issuance of consent.
This agenda could not be taken up by the Committee, due to paucity of time, and decided to take up the same in the CMC meeting to be held on 07.10.2008.
Table Agenda Item No 01: Indoor monitoring of particulate, less then 2.5 micron
Sr. Scientist (Air), DPCC will speak to Pr. Secretary (Health). If Department of Health, willing to finance one PM2.5 sampler then two machines will be purchased otherwise only one sampler for the purpose of DPCC be purchased.
Table Agenda Item No 02: Ambience Developer Pvt. Ltd, Plot No. 2, Vasant Kunj Mall, Vasant Kunj
The representative of unit appeared before CMC and sought time for a personal hearing claiming that its Chairman is out of station. Call on 20.10.2008 at 5.45 PM.
Meeting ended with thanks to the Chair.
Sl.No / Name of the unit / Activity / Earlier Decision, if any / ATR/Remarks / Decision on 30.09.20081 / Royal Automobiles, RR-4, Miyanwali Ngar, Main Rohtak Road, New Delhi-87 / Bajaj Scooter Service Station (25-30 washing of scooters / motorcycles) / 16.11.2007
If the unit files an affidavit that it will not take up any industrial activity in this residential premises and file a Bank Guarantee of Rs. 3 lakhs, then CMC may consider withdrawal of case In view of the fact that the unit is closed since long and premises is being used as an authorized dealer of Bajaj Auto Ltd. for Two Wheelers for sales only as per recent inspection / • • Unit is engaged in scooter service.
• Unit inspected on 19.04.2000.
• Case filed on 06.06.2000.
• Case is fixed for pre charge evidence
Unit has been inspected on 17.10.2007. The unit in question is an authorized dealer of Bajaj Auto Ltd for sale only (auto wheelers). Washing activity found removed and no industrial activity carried out.
Unit submitted BG for Rs. 3 lakhs on 15.01.08 as decided by CMC on 16.11.07.
Also filed an affidavit on 15.01.2008. / To put up the file administratively and at the same time ATR of last legal review must be submitted administratively on file by 13.10.2008 by ALO without fail.
Sno. / Name / Activity / Facts of The Case / Earlier Decision / Action Taken / Decision on 30-09-08
1 / Complaint against M/s J.S. Designers Pvt. Ltd & others, Plot No. 190, Patparganj Indl. Area. / Mfg. of Readymade Garments with washing / As approved on file Notice u/s 31(A) of the Air Act, u/s 33(A) of the Water Act and u/s 5 of EPA with a copy of DOV were issued on 02.07.08. Unit has submitted reply along with affidavit. Noise monitoring report of two DG Sets and photographs on 27.06.08 and 11.07.08. Unit informed that deficiency has been rectified, Cess amount has been deposited and requested to waive-off the BG. / As approved on file, Issues final reminder for submission of BG. Call on 30.09.08. / Reminder letter issued to the unit for submission of BG. Unit has submitted reply to inform that deficiencies have been rectified and requested to waive off the Bank Guarantee (Bank Guarantee not submitted) / Ask the unit to file effluent analysis report from any of the empanelled laboratories. Call on 30.10.2008.
2 / Complaint against unit operating at Plot no.45, phase II, Badli Indl Area. Received though CMO. / Re-rolling,anneling & pickling / Inspection was carried out by SIT on 07.08.08.During inspection/s Power cone Industries, Plot no.45,Badli Indl area found in operation and engaged in Re-rolling,anneling and pickling. As approved on file notice u/s 33(A) of Water Act was issued on 25.08.08 for correction of all the deficiencies observed by the inspecting team i.e. SIT. As approved notice u/s 33 (a) of water act was issued on 25.08.08. Cases to be put up for ratification by CMC. No reply received. / Decision on 28.08.08: Issue final reminder for reply. Call on 30.09.08. / Reminder notice u/s 33 (a) of water act was issued on 03.09.08
Reply received on 10.09.08, informed that deficiencies have been rectified. / Send file to CMC for putting up on 20.10.2008.
3 / Jai Bhawani Enterprises/ Bhawani Printers, D-21/6, Okhla Indl. Area, Phase II,Delhi / Printing and Binding / The unit was inspected by Trainee Engineer on 08.08.08 w.r.t. public complaint received from M/s ICON Printing Process Pvt. Ltd., D-22/1, Okhla Indl. Area, Ph-II, New Delhi. As decided in CMC on 13.08.08, the case was put up administratively and as approved notice u/s 31 (A) of the Air Act and u/s 5 of EPA were issued on 03.09.08. No reply received from the unit so far. / Decision on 03.09.08: Call on 30.09.08. / Issue final reminder. Call on 30.10.2008.
4 / Complaint against Geniun Photocopier, 111- Jeeven Villa, daryaganj, Delhi. / Trading of phocopier machine / Inspection was carried out by Trainee Engineers on 02.07.08 w.r.t. a public complaint received from Sh. Narender Singhal through E-mail. During inspection, M/s Geninun Photocopier was engaged in trading and repairing of photocopy machine. Waste toner is collected in the container. Soot particle are blow away into the ambient air by blower. Unit has no DG Set. / Decision on 31.07.08: Notice may be issued to the unit to ensure that there are no air emissions and whatever the repairing of cleaning activity is there it must be done in the enclosed area. Copy of the letter may be issued to the complainant. Call on 3.09.08. / Notice under Air Act was issued on 26.08.08. no reply has been received.
One more complaint has been received from the complainant on 17.09.08. / Issue final reminder. Call on 30.10.2008.
5 / Executive Club
439, Village Sahurpur
New Delhi-110074. #26653337 / Farm House / Inspection was carried out by Trainee Engineer on 03-07-08 as per direction of Compitent Authority and following were observed:-
(i) The Club does not have any CTE/CTO
(ii)The Club uses 700-800l/day(in off season) and 3000l/day (in peak season) of Ground water as per the manager without having any consent from CGWA.
(iii) The Club has 3 D.G.Sets of following capacity -
(a) 35 KVA with stack ht.7-8ft and without any acoustic enclosure
(b) 82 KVA with stack ht 10ft with acoustic enclosure but still noisy
(c) 125 KVA with stack ht 11ft without any acoustic enclosure.
(iv) The Club has a septic tank which is cleaned once in a week (as per manager). The tank was found uncovered. / Decision on 13.08.08: Cases of PGRC to be put up administratively. / The file was put up admistratively and as approved, a letter was issued to the unit on 09.09.08 regarding installation of STP, reuse of the treated water, apply for Consent to Establish, submit permission from Central Ground Water Authority for using the ground water and correct all the deficiencies. It was decided that action taken report to be put up in CMC on 30.09.2008. Reply awaited. / Ask the unit to file adequacy report, noise monitoring report of D.G. Sets and CGWA clearance. Call on 30.10.2008
6 / M/s Sabka Bazar,(A unit of Home Stores India Pvt. Ltd.) C-3/10, Ground Floor, Janakpuri, New Delhi-110058. / Retail outlets / The unit was inspected by DPCC official on 09.04.08 w.r.t. public complaint received from the residents of the area. As decided in CMC on 23.04.08, letter was issued to the unit for the correction of all the defficiences. A simmilar complaint was also received through PGC on 29.04.08. Reply sent on 26.05.08. The unit was again inspected by Trainee Engineer on 24.07.08 and as approved, the unit was called for hearing on 20.08.08/ 22.08.08 before MS. On 22.08.08 one Mr. V.K. Singh, Advocate appeared without POA. As approved the unit was called for hearing on 03.09.08 before CMC. / Decision on 03.09.08: No one came for hearing on 03.09.08 and it was decided “issue a letter to the unit to submit its comments on the complaint and the PGRC Inspection Report. Call on 30.09.2008.” / Letter issued to the unit on 22.09.08. Reply awaited / Issue final reminder. Call on 30.10.2008.