Guidelines for Isa Technical Papers and Presentations

2017 ISA Water/Wastewater
and Automatic Controls Symposium
August 8 to10, 2017●Wyndham Lake Buena Vista Disney Springs Resort ●Orlando, Florida, USA
Presented by the ISA Water/Wastewater Industries Division –
Technical co-sponsors: Florida AWWA Section, the WEF Automation and Info Tech Committee ,
Florida Water Environment Association, Instrumentation Testing Association, and ISA Tampa Bay Section

WWAC2017_Papers-PowerPoint-ReviewFormPage 1 of 2

2017 ISA Water/Wastewater and Automatic Controls Symposium
Aug 8-10,2017●Wyndham Lake Buena Vista Disney Springs Resort●Orlando, Florida, USA
Review Comment Form - Paper, Presentation and Poster /

Review Comment Form – Paper, PowerPoint, Poster

Instructions: Complete this form for each of your assigned authors – then email it to the program chair.

Save completed form as “WWAC2016_AuthorLastName_1st-or-2nd-draft_Review_YYYY-MM-DD.doc”

Reviewer
Name
Date
What you are reviewing
Title
Authors
What they submitted / ___ PowerPoint Presentation
___ Paper
___ Poster
Version / ___ 1st draft, / ___ 2nd draft, / ___ Other:
Where you got it from / ___ Dropbox (enter date retrieved: ______)
___ Email (enter date: ______, from who______)
Recommendation
Recommendation / ___ Revise and resubmit as Draft 1
___ Make requested changes, and submit as Draft 2
___ Revise and resubmit as Draft 2
___ Make requested changes, and submit as Final
___ Accepted as FINAL version, not changes required.
General Comments
comments

PowerPoint Review Comments (applicable Y/N:____)

PowerPoint– General Checks / Yes/No
Was able to open the PPT file
PowerPoint does not include any embedded video. (no video is permitted)
Slides formatted as per template provided (see author kit)?
First slide includes title and authors
Second slide includes author bios, company names, and photos
Abides by Non-Commercialism Policy (see author kit)
Abides by General Guidelines (see author kit)
Slides look consistent from slide to slide
Spelling/Grammar
PowerPoint - Comments

Slide X – comment
Slide Y - comment
Etc.

Paper Review Comments (applicable Y/N:____)

Paper – General Checks / Yes/No
Was able to open the Word file
Paper formatted as per template provided (see author kit)?
First page includes author contact information as per template
All acronyms are defined in the list of acronyms at the end as per template
Includes Bios at the end for main author and any co-authors as per template
Abides by Non-Commercialism Policy (see author kit)
Abides by General Guidelines (see author kit)
Spelling/Grammar
Paper - Comments

Page 1 – comment
Page 2 –comment
Etc.

Poster Review Comments (applicable Y/N:____)

Poster– General Checks / Yes/No
Poster was supplied as a PDF file
Was able to open PDF file
Poster size is 3 feet wide x 4 feet high
Abides by Poster Guidelines (see author kit)
Author name is display near the top or near the bottom corner
If company logo is displayed, it is only beside the author name
Abides by Non-Commercialism Policy (see author kit)
Abides by General Guidelines (see author kit)
Spelling/Grammar
Poster- Comments

Comment 1
Comment 2
Etc.

WWAC2017_Papers-PowerPoint-ReviewFormPage 1 of 2