Brief 1 Rubric – Private Fitness LLC

Total 50 points

Criteria / Unacceptable / Acceptable / Proficient / Student Score and Comments
Applies the 5-step critical thinking decision making tool (appendix). / Vaguely applies the 5-step critical thinking decision making tool.
(0-3 points) / Applies the 5-step critical thinking decision making tool and, for the most part, fulfills assignment requirements.
(4 points) / Applies the 5-step critical thinking decision making tool and demonstrates solid ability to accomplish the assignment.
(5 points)
Develops an opening paragraph that introduces the case. / Vaguely develops an opening paragraph that introduces the case or does not have an opening paragraph.
(0-3 points) / Develops an opening paragraph that introduces the case and, for the most part, fulfills assignment requirements.
(4 points) / Develops an opening paragraph that introduces the case and demonstrates solid ability to accomplish the assignment.
(5 points)
Identifies the options Rosemary should consider when making a decision about her working relationship with Kate / Vaguely identifies the manufacturing costs essential to produce bottled whiskey or completely off the topic.
(0-7 points) / Identifies the manufacturing costs essential to produce bottled whiskey and, for the most part, fulfills assignment requirements.
(8 points) / Identifies the manufacturing costs essential to produce bottled whiskey and demonstrates solid ability to accomplish the assignment.
(10 points)
Identifies the recommendations to be made to Rosemary / Vaguely discusses the importance of distinguishing inventoriable costs from “Other costs” that are included in the Cost of Goods Sold or completely off the topic.
(0-3 points) / Discusses the importance of distinguishing inventoriable costs from “Other costs” that are included in the Cost of Goods Sold and, for the most part, fulfills assignment requirements.
(4 points) / Discusses the importance of distinguishing inventoriable costs from “Other costs” that are included in the Cost of Goods Sold and demonstrates solid ability to accomplish the assignment.
(5 points)
Integrates established accounting principles into the discussion. / Rarely integrates established accounting principles into the discussion.
(0-3 points) / For the most part, does a good job of integrating established accounting principles into the discussion.
(4 points) / Consistently does a good job of integrating established accounting principles into the discussion.
(5 points)
Synthesizes relevant information and materials to provide evidence of critical thought. / Synthesizes information at a minimal level.
(0-3 points) / For the most part, effectively synthesizes information, which supports main ideas.
(4 points) / Consistently and effectively synthesizes information, which provides strong support to main ideas.
(5 points)
Develops ideas with clarity and logic. / Demonstrates little clarity and logic. Readers have difficulty following the line of reasoning.
(0-3 points) / Develops ideas with clarity and logic. Readers can generally follow the line of reasoning.
(4 points) / Develops ideas with clarity and logic. Ideas flow smoothly from one to another and are clearly linked to each other.
(5 points)
Uses supporting documentation that has been properly references and cited. / Inadequate or minimal use of supporting documentation or not properly referenced or cited.
(0-3 points) / For the most part, uses supporting documentation that is properly referenced and cited.
(4 points) / Consistently uses supporting documentation that is properly referenced and cited.
(5 points)
Considered holistically, demonstrates the ability to write at the graduate level. / Considered holistically, the student demonstrates an inadequate ability to write at the graduate level.
(0-3 points) / Considered holistically, the student demonstrates an acceptable ability to write at the graduate level.
(4 points) / Considered holistically, the student demonstrates a proficient ability to write at the graduate level.
(5 points)
SubTotal Points
Turnitin.com / Did not turn paper into Turnitin.com
Minus 10 points / ---- / ----
Revisions based on the originality Report / Did not revise paper based on the originality report
Minus 10 points / ---- / ----
Grammarly / Did not revise paper based on the recommendations from Grammarly.com.
Minus 10 points / --- / ---
Total Points =