Comment Report: All Comments
Project: Ft Gillem, Enclave Force Protection Requirements
Review: 65% Review - Package B
Displaying 90 comments for the criteria specified in this report.
2422 ms to run this page
Id / Discipline / DocType / Spec / Sheet / Detail2962453 / Mechanical / Plans / n/a' / M-3 / n/a
Coordinating Discipline(s): Mechanical
On Drawing M-3 EF-2 is left off the equipment schedule.
Submitted By: Ivan Sheall (404-469-7168). Submitted On: 04-Jan-10
1-0 / Evaluation Concurred
This item has been added to the drawing.
Submitted By: Michael Reeves (2510990-5778) Submitted On: 05-Jan-10
1-1 / Backcheck Recommendation Close Comment
Closed without comment.
Submitted By: Ivan Sheall (404-469-7168) Submitted On: 05-Jan-10
2-0 / Evaluation Concurred
The revised drawing pdf has been included with the items added to the drawing
Submitted By: Michael Reeves (2510990-5778) Submitted On: 06-Jan-10 (Attachment: M-FGVCC_M-3_(1).pdf)
2-1 / Backcheck Recommendation Close Comment
Closed without comment.
Submitted By: Ivan Sheall (404-469-7168) Submitted On: 06-Jan-10
Current Comment Status: Comment Closed
2962458 / Mechanical / Plans / n/a' / M-1,M-2,M-5, M-6 / n/a
Coordinating Discipline(s): Mechanical
On Drawing M-5 there is a note calling for 2 lines to be installed on the north interior wall, down through the floor slab, pass beneath the foundation and go out the building to HPU-1. On Drawing M-6 Detail 5 the lines are shown going under the foundation and continuing further inside the building beneath the slab. The differences need to be resolved. The same comment applies for M-1 and M-2.
Submitted By: Ivan Sheall (404-469-7168). Submitted On: 04-Jan-10
1-0 / Evaluation Concurred
These comments have been addressed and updated drawings are included.
Submitted By: Michael Reeves (2510990-5778) Submitted On: 06-Jan-10 (Attachment: M-FGVCC_M-1_(1).pdf)
1-1 / Backcheck Recommendation Close Comment
Closed without comment.
Submitted By: Ivan Sheall (404-469-7168) Submitted On: 06-Jan-10
2-0 / Evaluation Concurred
This comment includes a second updated drawing.
Submitted By: Michael Reeves (2510990-5778) Submitted On: 06-Jan-10 (Attachment: M-FGVCC_M-2_(1).pdf)
Backcheck not conducted
3-0 / Evaluation Concurred
This is the third updated drawing concerning this comment.
Submitted By: Michael Reeves (2510990-5778) Submitted On: 06-Jan-10 (Attachment: M-FGGH_M-5_(1).pdf)
Backcheck not conducted
4-0 / Evaluation Concurred
This is the final updated drawing referenced in this comment.
Submitted By: Michael Reeves (2510990-5778) Submitted On: 06-Jan-10 (Attachment: M-FGGH_M-6_(1).pdf)
Backcheck not conducted
Current Comment Status: Comment Closed
2962460 / Mechanical / Plans / n/a' / M-4,M-8 / n/a
Coordinating Discipline(s): Mechanical
Can M-4 and M-8 be combined into one sheet to cover the VCC and the gate house?
Submitted By: Ivan Sheall (404-469-7168). Submitted On: 04-Jan-10
1-0 / Evaluation Concurred
This was done this way to allow the contractor to combine individual sets of drawings for each building, thereby having the notes available for each building. This was previously discussed and agreed upon.
Submitted By: Michael Reeves (2510990-5778) Submitted On: 05-Jan-10
1-1 / Backcheck Recommendation Close Comment
Closed without comment.
Submitted By: Ivan Sheall (404-469-7168) Submitted On: 05-Jan-10
Current Comment Status: Comment Closed
2962463 / Plumbing / Plans / n/a' / P-1, CU-101 / n/a
Coordinating Discipline(s): Utilities Engineering
On Drawing P-1 the Sanitary Sewer line is leaving the wrong side of the Visitor Control Center. According to CU-101 the sanitary sewer line should leave the VCC on the north side.
Submitted By: Ivan Sheall (404-469-7168). Submitted On: 04-Jan-10
1-0 / Evaluation Concurred
This item was corrected on the drawings.
Submitted By: Michael Reeves (2510990-5778) Submitted On: 05-Jan-10 (Attachment: P-FGVCC_P1_(1).pdf)
1-1 / Backcheck Recommendation Close Comment
Closed without comment.
Submitted By: Ivan Sheall (404-469-7168) Submitted On: 05-Jan-10
Current Comment Status: Comment Closed
2962465 / Mechanical / Plans / n/a' / n/a / n/a
Coordinating Discipline(s): Mechanical
The HVAC units for the guard booths at the ID Check Points are not in any mechanical schedule.
Submitted By: Ivan Sheall (404-469-7168). Submitted On: 04-Jan-10
1-0 / Evaluation Concurred
These gurad booths are premanufactured units with HVAC included.
Submitted By: Michael Reeves (2510990-5778) Submitted On: 05-Jan-10
1-1 / Backcheck Recommendation Close Comment
Closed without comment.
Submitted By: Ivan Sheall (404-469-7168) Submitted On: 05-Jan-10
Current Comment Status: Comment Closed
2962472 / Electrical / Plans / n/a' / E-0 / n/a
Coordinating Discipline(s): Utilities Engineering
Is the power for the rest of the site coming out of the Gate House or from the transformer next to the Gate House?
Submitted By: Ivan Sheall (404-469-7168). Submitted On: 04-Jan-10
1-0 / Evaluation Concurred
The power to the rest of the site including the VCC building is coming from the Gatehouse. This item is included in the 100% electrical drawings included in the civil submittal.
Submitted By: Michael Reeves (2510990-5778) Submitted On: 06-Jan-10
1-1 / Backcheck Recommendation Close Comment
Closed without comment.
Submitted By: Ivan Sheall (404-469-7168) Submitted On: 06-Jan-10
Current Comment Status: Comment Closed
2962475 / Electrical / Plans / n/a' / E-0 / n/a
Coordinating Discipline(s): Utilities Engineering
On Drawing E-0 move the power pole near the Chapel site away from the communication conduit.
Submitted By: Ivan Sheall (404-469-7168). Submitted On: 04-Jan-10
1-0 / Evaluation Concurred
The communication duct bank has been rerouted and no longer is in conflict with the power pole near the chapel. This item is included in the 100% electrical drawings included in the civil submittal.
Submitted By: Michael Reeves (2510990-5778) Submitted On: 06-Jan-10
1-1 / Backcheck Recommendation Close Comment
Closed without comment.
Submitted By: Ivan Sheall (404-469-7168) Submitted On: 06-Jan-10
Current Comment Status: Comment Closed
2962479 / Security / Plans / n/a' / E-3 / n/a
Coordinating Discipline(s): Security
On Drawing E-3 remove the notes "Power by Others" and "Traffic Poles by Others" What is NSS?
Submitted By: Ivan Sheall (404-469-7168). Submitted On: 04-Jan-10
1-0 / Evaluation Concurred
These notes will be removed as well as NSS which is a company name abbreviation.
Submitted By: Michael Reeves (2510990-5778) Submitted On: 05-Jan-10
1-1 / Backcheck Recommendation Close Comment
Closed without comment.
Submitted By: Ivan Sheall (404-469-7168) Submitted On: 05-Jan-10
Current Comment Status: Comment Closed
2962483 / Security / Plans / n/a' / E-8 / n/a
Coordinating Discipline(s): Security
On Drawing E-8 is there a requirement for 2 cameras inside in the VCC? The way they are positioned right now it seems the second camera is redundant.
Submitted By: Ivan Sheall (404-469-7168). Submitted On: 04-Jan-10
1-0 / Evaluation Concurred
RFP Section 3.10.2.2 VCC directs that the parking lot, waiting area and the ID counter areas be monitored. We agree one camera can be removed. The extra camera will be removed from the appropriate sheet and be submitted with next review submission.
Submitted By: Michael Reeves (2510990-5778) Submitted On: 06-Jan-10
1-1 / Backcheck Recommendation Close Comment
Closed without comment.
Submitted By: Ivan Sheall (404-469-7168) Submitted On: 06-Jan-10
Current Comment Status: Comment Closed
2962486 / Electrical / Plans / n/a' / E-9 / n/a
Coordinating Discipline(s): Electrical
On Drawing E-9 how is power going to be supplied to the guard booths?
Submitted By: Ivan Sheall (404-469-7168). Submitted On: 04-Jan-10
1-0 / Evaluation Concurred
RFP Section 3.1.2.4 Guard Booths directs that the Guard Booths are required to have 100 amp 120/208 load centers with main breakers. These panels will be fed from the Gatehouse. This item is included in the 100% electrical drawings included in the civil submittal.
Submitted By: Michael Reeves (2510990-5778) Submitted On: 06-Jan-10
1-1 / Backcheck Recommendation Close Comment
Closed without comment.
Submitted By: Ivan Sheall (404-469-7168) Submitted On: 06-Jan-10
Current Comment Status: Comment Closed
2962492 / Architectural / Other / n/a' / n/a / n/a
(Document Reference: SID/CID)
Coordinating Discipline(s): Architectural
On the SID/CID AW-2 and AW-3 should be replaced with something related to the Army, not the Marines. Also one of the brick colors was missing.
Submitted By: Ivan Sheall (404-469-7168). Submitted On: 04-Jan-10
1-0 / Evaluation Check and Resolve
The two brick colors are being coordinated with the designer and samples of each will be provided at the upcoming review meeting. The interior designer is not clear as to what the first comment indicates. Is the question whether the selected interiolr colors provided are more oriented to Marine colors as opposed to Army colors?
Submitted By: Michael Reeves (2510990-5778) Submitted On: 06-Jan-10
1-1 / Backcheck Recommendation Open Comment
I was referring to the actual content of the art work. This is an Army installation and the artwork chosen is the Marine Corps Seal and the Marines raising the flag on Mt Sarabaci on Iwo Jima in WWII. Something more appropriate to the Army would be the Army Seal and something about the Army.
Submitted By: Ivan Sheall (404-469-7168) Submitted On: 07-Jan-10
2-0 / Evaluation Concurred
The display graphics shown in these two items will be replaced with army related graphics. This will be incorporated into the final submissions.
Submitted By: Michael Reeves (2510990-5778) Submitted On: 07-Jan-10
2-1 / Backcheck Recommendation Close Comment
Closed without comment.
Submitted By: Ivan Sheall (404-469-7168) Submitted On: 12-Jan-10
Current Comment Status: Comment Closed
2962496 / Project Management / Specifications / 01 33 00 1.4.1, page 6 / n/a / n/a
Coordinating Discipline(s): Project Management
In Specification 01 33 00, paragraph 1.4.1, page 6 delete the words from "(Commander, NAVFAC ...... -Engineer: (_____),]" and substitute "Contracting Officer Representative" for the deletion. Also delete the last sentence of the first paragraph and the entire second paragraph.
Submitted By: Ivan Sheall (404-469-7168). Submitted On: 04-Jan-10
1-0 / Evaluation Concurred
This specification section will be corrected per comments.
Submitted By: Michael Reeves (2510990-5778) Submitted On: 05-Jan-10
1-1 / Backcheck Recommendation Close Comment
Closed without comment.
Submitted By: Ivan Sheall (404-469-7168) Submitted On: 05-Jan-10
Current Comment Status: Comment Closed
2962499 / Project Management / Specifications / 01 33 00 1.4.1.1, page 6 / n/a / n/a
Coordinating Discipline(s): Project Management,Project Management
In Specification 01 33 00, paragraph 1.4.1.1, page 6 delete "Architect-Engineer for the project NAVFAC Atlantic]" and substitute "Contracting Officer". In same line delete "for the Contracting Officer".
Submitted By: Ivan Sheall (404-469-7168). Submitted On: 04-Jan-10
Revised 04-Jan-10.
1-0 / Evaluation Concurred
This will be corrected in this spec section per comments.
Submitted By: Michael Reeves (2510990-5778) Submitted On: 05-Jan-10
1-1 / Backcheck Recommendation Close Comment
Closed without comment.
Submitted By: Ivan Sheall (404-469-7168) Submitted On: 05-Jan-10
Current Comment Status: Comment Closed
2962505 / Project Management / Specifications / 01 33 00 1.4.1.2 and 1.4.1.3, pages 6 and 7 / n/a / n/a
Coordinating Discipline(s): Project Management
In Specification 01 33 00, paragraph 1.4.1.2 and 1.4.1.3, page 6 and 7 delete these paragraphs in their entirety.
Submitted By: Ivan Sheall (404-469-7168). Submitted On: 04-Jan-10
1-0 / Evaluation Concurred
This will be corrected in this spec section per comments.
Submitted By: Michael Reeves (2510990-5778) Submitted On: 05-Jan-10
1-1 / Backcheck Recommendation Close Comment
Closed without comment.
Submitted By: Ivan Sheall (404-469-7168) Submitted On: 05-Jan-10
Current Comment Status: Comment Closed
2962509 / Project Management / Specifications / 01 33 00 1.11.1 page 19 / n/a / n/a
Coordinating Discipline(s): Project Management
In Specification 01 33 00, paragraph 1.11.1, page 19 substitute "30" for blank space.
Submitted By: Ivan Sheall (404-469-7168). Submitted On: 04-Jan-10
1-0 / Evaluation Concurred
This will be corrected in this spec section per comments.
Submitted By: Michael Reeves (2510990-5778) Submitted On: 05-Jan-10
1-1 / Backcheck Recommendation Close Comment
Closed without comment.
Submitted By: Ivan Sheall (404-469-7168) Submitted On: 05-Jan-10
Current Comment Status: Comment Closed
2962514 / Project Management / Specifications / 05 12 00 1.7.2.1 page 6 / n/a / n/a
Coordinating Discipline(s): Project Management
In Specification 05 12 00, paragraph 1.7.2.1, page 6 delete the entire paragraph.
Submitted By: Ivan Sheall (404-469-7168). Submitted On: 04-Jan-10
1-0 / Evaluation Concurred
This will be corrected in this spec section per comments.
Submitted By: Michael Reeves (2510990-5778) Submitted On: 05-Jan-10
1-1 / Backcheck Recommendation Close Comment
Closed without comment.
Submitted By: Ivan Sheall (404-469-7168) Submitted On: 05-Jan-10
Current Comment Status: Comment Closed
2962518 / Project Management / Specifications / 05 12 00 2.6 page 10 / n/a / n/a
Coordinating Discipline(s): Project Management
In Specification 05 12 00, paragraph 2.6, page 10 delete the entire paragraph.
Submitted By: Ivan Sheall (404-469-7168). Submitted On: 04-Jan-10
1-0 / Evaluation Concurred
This will be corrected in this spec section per comments.
Submitted By: Michael Reeves (2510990-5778) Submitted On: 05-Jan-10
1-1 / Backcheck Recommendation Close Comment
Closed without comment.
Submitted By: Ivan Sheall (404-469-7168) Submitted On: 05-Jan-10
Current Comment Status: Comment Closed
2962519 / Project Management / Specifications / 05 12 00 3.2.1 pages 11 and 12 / n/a / n/a
Coordinating Discipline(s): Project Management
In Specification 05 12 00, paragraph 3.2.1, page 11 and 12 delete the entire paragraph.
Submitted By: Ivan Sheall (404-469-7168). Submitted On: 04-Jan-10
1-0 / Evaluation Concurred
This will be corrected in this spec section per comments.
Submitted By: Michael Reeves (2510990-5778) Submitted On: 05-Jan-10
1-1 / Backcheck Recommendation Close Comment
Closed without comment.
Submitted By: Ivan Sheall (404-469-7168) Submitted On: 05-Jan-10
Current Comment Status: Comment Closed
2962524 / Project Management / Specifications / 05 12 00 3.9.3 page 15 / n/a / n/a
Coordinating Discipline(s): Project Management
In Specification 05 12 00, paragraph 3.9.3, page 15 delete the entire paragraph.
Submitted By: Ivan Sheall (404-469-7168). Submitted On: 04-Jan-10
1-0 / Evaluation Concurred
This will be corrected in this spec section per comments.
Submitted By: Michael Reeves (2510990-5778) Submitted On: 05-Jan-10
1-1 / Backcheck Recommendation Close Comment
Closed without comment.
Submitted By: Ivan Sheall (404-469-7168) Submitted On: 05-Jan-10
Current Comment Status: Comment Closed
2962528 / Project Management / Specifications / Table of Contents / n/a / n/a
Coordinating Discipline(s): Project Management
Table of Contents in specifications missing Divisions 22 and 23.
Submitted By: Ivan Sheall (404-469-7168). Submitted On: 04-Jan-10
1-0 / Evaluation Concurred
These divisions will be completed and added to the specifications.
Submitted By: Michael Reeves (2510990-5778) Submitted On: 05-Jan-10
1-1 / Backcheck Recommendation Close Comment
Closed without comment.
Submitted By: Ivan Sheall (404-469-7168) Submitted On: 05-Jan-10
Current Comment Status: Comment Closed
2962530 / Project Management / Specifications / 23 08 00, 23 09 23, 27 54 00, 28 16 00 / n/a / n/a
Coordinating Discipline(s): Project Management
Specifications missing sections 23 08 00 – Commissioning of HVAC Systems, 23 09 23 –Direct Digital Control for HVAC and other Local Building Systems, 27 54 00 – Community Antenna Television (CATV) System, and 28 16 00 Intrusion Detection System.
Submitted By: Ivan Sheall (404-469-7168). Submitted On: 04-Jan-10
1-0 / Evaluation Concurred
These specification sections will be completed and added to the specifications.
Submitted By: Michael Reeves (2510990-5778) Submitted On: 05-Jan-10
1-1 / Backcheck Recommendation Close Comment
Closed without comment.
Submitted By: Ivan Sheall (404-469-7168) Submitted On: 05-Jan-10
Current Comment Status: Comment Closed
2980949 / Electrical / Plans / n/a' / n/a / n/a
E2. Note 2 indicates that the power circuit/conductors for the cameras are NIC. If the cameras will be connected to 120V, 20A circuit, would it be best to go ahead and include it in the contract?
Submitted By: Renard Davis (912-652-5601). Submitted On: 11-Jan-10
1-0 / Evaluation Concurred
Amendment No. 0001, Section 6.9.5 (Security Systems) states. " Security systems to include CCV, intrusion detections systems and duress alarm shall be designed and installed in the project. However, only the mounting poles, conduit, pathways, duct banks, cabinets, racks and junction boxes are to be provided. The actual devices such as CCTV cameras, DVR's, balanced magnetic switches, duress buttons and associated control panels are to be installed in the future by others.
Submitted By: Michael Reeves (2510990-5778) Submitted On: 12-Jan-10
Backcheck not conducted
Current Comment Status: Comment Open
2980955 / Electrical / Plans / n/a' / n/a / n/a
E5. The receptacle in the Bathroom (Rm 101) should be GFI, in accordance with NEC 210.8(B)(1).
Submitted By: Renard Davis (912-652-5601). Submitted On: 11-Jan-10
1-0 / Evaluation Concurred
The receptacle in room 101 shall be made GFI per NEC 210.8(B)(1)
Submitted By: Michael Reeves (2510990-5778) Submitted On: 12-Jan-10
Backcheck not conducted
Current Comment Status: Comment Open
2980961 / Electrical / Plans / n/a' / n/a / n/a
E5. The downlights in the Storage room do not match the 2x4 light fixture shown on the RCP on A8. Resolve conflict. Also, the type GE downlight in the Storage room does not appear to be centered in the ACT.
Submitted By: Renard Davis (912-652-5601). Submitted On: 11-Jan-10
1-0 / Evaluation Concurred
The downlights in the storage room shall be adjusted to the ceiling grid. The RCP on sheet A8 shall be revised to comply with sheet E5.
Submitted By: Michael Reeves (2510990-5778) Submitted On: 12-Jan-10
Backcheck not conducted
Current Comment Status: Comment Open
2980985 / Electrical / Plans / n/a' / n/a / n/a
E7. The light fixtures in room 100, 101, 102, & 106 do not match the light fixtures and/or placement of light fixtures shown on the RCP on sheet A1.
Submitted By: Renard Davis (912-652-5601). Submitted On: 11-Jan-10
1-0 / Evaluation Concurred
The light fixtures shown on the RCP sheet A1 shall be revised to comply with sheet E7.
Submitted By: Michael Reeves (2510990-5778) Submitted On: 12-Jan-10
Backcheck not conducted
Current Comment Status: Comment Open
2981086 / Electrical / Plans / n/a' / n/a / n/a
E19. See I3A, Figure B-5 for Comm Room layout for a small facility. Consider removing the "MDF Field" and "Voice Field" in the "Voice Schematic" diagram to match the voice layout in Figure B-5. Verify the layout with the Ft. Gillem DOIM.
Submitted By: Renard Davis (912-652-5601). Submitted On: 11-Jan-10
1-0 / Evaluation Concurred
Figure B-5 shall be added to sheet E-19.
Submitted By: Michael Reeves (2510990-5778) Submitted On: 12-Jan-10
Backcheck not conducted
Current Comment Status: Comment Open
2981136 / Electrical / Plans / n/a' / n/a / n/a
E5, E7, E19. Clarify the term "multimedia" outlet in the building legends. Does this device consist of 1 voice outlet and 1 data outlet (based on the usage in both the "Data Schematic" and "Voice Schematic" diagrams) or 1 data outlet only (based on the number of multimedia outlets provided, i.e.- 4 outlets provided in the processing room in the VCC).
Submitted By: Renard Davis (912-652-5601). Submitted On: 11-Jan-10
1-0 / Evaluation Concurred
The device consists of 1 voice and data outlet. The legend has been clarified.
Submitted By: Michael Reeves (2510990-5778) Submitted On: 12-Jan-10
Backcheck not conducted
Current Comment Status: Comment Open
2981293 / Electrical / Plans / n/a' / n/a / n/a
E8. Consider placing a mass notification speaker in the Processing Room. The speaker in the Waiting Room may not provide intelligible coverage for both rooms.
Submitted By: Renard Davis (912-652-5601). Submitted On: 11-Jan-10
1-0 / Evaluation Concurred
A mass notification speaker shall be added to the processing room.
Submitted By: Michael Reeves (2510990-5778) Submitted On: 12-Jan-10
Backcheck not conducted
Current Comment Status: Comment Open
2981310 / Electrical / Plans / n/a' / n/a / n/a
E8. Show the ACU and LOC on the fire alarm/mass notification plan.
Submitted By: Renard Davis (912-652-5601). Submitted On: 11-Jan-10
1-0 / Evaluation Concurred
The ACU and LOC shall be shown on the plans.
Submitted By: Michael Reeves (2510990-5778) Submitted On: 12-Jan-10
Backcheck not conducted
Current Comment Status: Comment Open
2981319 / Architectural / Plans / n/a' / Cover sheet / n/a
Revise the renderings to better match the drawings by adding the soldier courses, and eliminating the brick at the corners on the front elevation (should be aluminum) and deleting the brick indicated between the door jamb and the window jambs.
Submitted By: Gaylin Bergers (402-995-2165). Submitted On: 11-Jan-10
1-0 / Evaluation Concurred
Upon completion of the review and color selections, the renderings can be revised to show the proposed conditions.